Came here during pie day and ordered the Rusty's special with anchovies and added jalapeños on a thin crust! It's actually pretty tasty! The service was friendly and it looks like a great place to eat. The interior reminds me of the old school Pizza Huts back in the 90s. I would love to try their Diablo pizza next! read more

I had a terrible experience here due to a major mistake by the manager/staff member in charge, Omer. While waiting, I asked Omer if I could add a beer to my order. He told me I had gone over the time limit to order drinks. Frustrated by the wait and the service, I told him, "Fine, then cancel my order," pointing to the pizzas coming out of the oven. Omer immediately canceled that pizza order without checking if it actually belonged to me. A moment later, the actual owners of those pizzas walked up, confused about why their food was being canceled. Omer had wiped out another customer's order without verifying their identity first. It was completely unprofessional, and I felt terrible for the innocent customers who lost their food because of his carelessness. read more

It was convenient since it is close to the beach and freeway. But for the price of what we had, it wasnt worth it. We had pepperoni pizza and the rusty special pizza. It was alright. But the wings, omgg it was the smallest one we had in the world. read more

Food and service was subpar, Been coming here since I was a kid why are they charging seven dollars extra for it to go salad, was quite literally forced to eat my salad in the store while I waited for my pizza to go, do better read more

Ordered online, couldn't get through all the prompts, hung up. One of thier representative called me back and took my order and made sure I had the address and gave me an order number. The pizza was ready safe as I ordered. The reason for the low score is their pricing puts them in the league with Italian pizza restaurants but the pizza was in the league with the fast food chains I've Dominos. Little Cesar's, Pizza Hut. read more

Amazing Excellent pizza I have been going for years mmmmm Yum Yum Yum you will not be disappointed

They go so far as to offer a vegan pizza (limited availability) the customer care person said because it's popular it's not always in stock. That's the first issue... if it's popular you make sure it's available. Oh but wait.... They don't offer a vegan cheese option like some of the competitors serving UCSB. This place will never get any money from me. Epic fail. read more

Food clapped my cheeks Service. Ambiance. read more

The service at this Rusty's and the taste of pizza is way better than their location in Sb. The staff was friendly and accommodating. The pizza was tasty very cheesy and had a crunchy crust. The pizza came out fast. The salad bar was decent and wings were ok. There is a lot of options of seating inside, the decor is dated but I liked the nostalgia of it. I would come back to this one instead of the one in sb. read more

Some of my favorite pizza in the WORLD. my bf and I live a couple hours up the coast but every time we drive down to SoCal for trips we always stop here. It's our favorite pizza and on of our favorite traditions! read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - Pan pizza. Pepperoni and pineapple - Pizza Near Me - Goleta, California

Pizza is amazing I was born and raised on Rustys I almost think the negative reviews are bots or something frozen pizza or comparing to Costco both of wish suck badly This pizza crust is very unique and delicious never gets old always taste amazing both thick and thin The toppings are great too with their speciality pizzas ranch is great soda great everything is great here read more

The positives for this location are there is plenty of parking in the lot and ample seating in the dining room. This is a walk in, order at the counter, and find your seat kind of place. Easy breezy. They have an average looking salad bar, but we did not order. They also have some beers on tap but we did not order, so I am not sure of the variety. The negatives about the space is for kids there are only about 4 or 5 really dated video games and for adults only one small TV. I found it odd that the NFL playoff game was not on, but they were showing UFC prelims. There is nothing great to say about the food. The pizza honestly tasted like a high quality frozen pizza. We opted for the thin crust so I am not sure if we would have had a better opinion if we ordered thick crust. We also ordered the garlic cheese bread which is made on their thick crust. This was average but it is really hard to disappoint me with bread and cheese. We would not return and probably would have been just as happy getting something out of the Target freezer section (same parking lot). read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - Garlic cheese bread (small order) - Pizza Near Me - Goleta, California

See all

Hola yelpers: Hoy en días de nunca estamos a dieta, tocó pizza bbq, con coca de dieta por qué equilibra la grasa . De Rusty's creo es mi favorito lo que es el Sauce ranch, ya que es el sabor de cualquier cosa que pidas. Mi invitado quedó fascinado con la pizza y más su delicioso Ranch. Así que sin más por el momento yelpers. Pidan sus deliciosas pizzas ... Saludos read more

See all

I always love there Pizza here I grow up in this areas eating this delicious Pizzas. And this place is always packed with people Everytime my siblings go here. Thanks for the good service in front. read more

100% sure they forgot to make my pizza. Ordered online and waited 50 minutes for a small pizza

Sorely disappointed... Husbands favorite pizza... but??? not like this....Deep DishMeat Mania .... I Really appreciate how the mishap was rectified! We definitely will be back! read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - Burnt Meatlovers pizza... also got a sausage pizza not so burnt but spending 33.98 for 2 medium burnt pizzas... not ok - Pizza Near Me - Goleta, California

See all

Dropped by This Rusty's for a 5 year olds b day party. The ambiance was casual & Pizza Pies are PREEMO! There's a reason why all Rusty's are Santa Barbara locals favorites. We shall return. read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - The Girls. - Pizza Near Me - Goleta, California

See all

I went here on Tuesday and the food was good. I've never been to Rusty's before so I was a bit curious. I had a pepperoni and pineapple pizza and a pepperoni pizza as well. Also the guy that took our order was nice. I don't remember his name though. read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Goleta, California

See all

This pizza place is really really good! In our group we got two pizzas, two orders of wings, and a garlic cheese bread. The crust was so good, we got thin crust and we were impressed! The wings had good flavor (both the Hot and Mango Habanero) and a good kick of heat which we were happy about. The interior is cute, there is information up by the entrance about how it used to be a bank. Overall a really good experience and great pizza and wings! read more

See all

Food was delicious 10/10 we you got it simple pan pepperoni pizza we loved it in our kids did as well. Service was friendly and prompt! 10/10 As for the Ambiance it looks like they're going to some renovations.. and it is a bit dated. The bathroom was a little dark although that doesn't matter much. read more

Not sure why this place has so low stars, but my second experience here were excellent!!! I have ordered 2 top pizzas with thin and thick crust, mushroom with bell peppers (the yammiest) and thin chorizo w onions. OMG, even I am not really big pizza person, but they made me addicted!! So fresh and delicious, mouthwatering. My order was ready in 10-12 min. The place also looks clean, neat and organised. Keep it up, guys! Great place!!My favourite pizza place!! read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - two boxes of pizza and a bottle of coke - Pizza Near Me - Goleta, California

i love rusty's pizza! i've never been disappointed by it. it's thin crust which i love and always tastes so yummy. there wings and cheesy bread are also delicious. the service is always friendly and kind and they work fast as well. i love the old school pizza parlor vibes. read more

Pretty good pizza shop. They go a little heavy on their sauce so you may want to ask for light sauce. We had half pepperoni and half pineapple/Canadian bacon and some garlic cheese sticks. It's a basic pizza place, but good for a quick bite for the family. read more

I ordered a small pizza and the cashier rung me up for a large. They didn't include the side of ranches in my order but made sure to charge me for them read more

Delicious pizza - casual environment. Salad bar was super fresh. Pizza came out hot and yummy. Service was friendly.

I have had my order ruined for the fourth time by their AI system and now when you as for a representative it goes to some outsourced call center. The service in the pizza parlor is great with great local people. They have apologized for the system and recommended we as for a representative. That worked till they then outsourced the call center. The owners raised prices and outsourced and use faulty AI for their ordering system. To bad. read more

We don't live in the area but it's a tradition to order Rusty's at least once when we visit grandpa. The kids insist. We like a saucy pizza so we asked for pan crust pizzas with extra sauce. Everything was very tasty and ordering through the app made it easy to place our order and ready for pick up within 15 minutes. read more

I waited to long to post this but what I remember is I enjoyed the pizza and wings that I dined in for.

We were in town for a baseball tournament. We had 2 dogs with us. We Called ahead of time to ask if they had a patio because we had a large group of people and we had dogs. They assured us they had a patio. I asked to confirm several times "the location is on Storke Ave, right?" Showed up. No patio! Not sure where the communication was lost. Super irritating. read more

Not much to write home about. It's like Dominos. Some people may like it but this isn't real pizza in my opinion.

Sooo good! We loved this place! The pizza and salad was perfect! Will definitely be back!

"Rusty's pizza is as classic as a talking trans am. Probably not as fast, but still gets the job done." - KITT read more

Rusty's is not better than Costco pizza and definitely not cheaper either. The dough was a flop for me and the pizza sauce wasn't zesty but a simple tomato sauce. Seems this is a go-to for many but I think it's because it's the nearest for lunch in the area. I say try it out, maybe you aren't as picky as me when it comes to pizza. If they were to offer me this anywhere for free I'll still take it but wouldn't pay for it again. read more

The pizza and wings were great. Beer was cold, but mugs were warm. It had been years since we had visited and I don't think they have upgraded or maintained the interior since our last visit. No changing tables in the restrooms for infants (and a family restuarant). One family changing baby on bathroom counter and one on the seat of a booth. Air conditioning not working or they don't have. Ordered second pitcher of beer and they had no clean pitchers, mugs came from been cleaned so were hot. So maybe order for delivery or take out. read more

As of 2/6/21 Rusty's has made the worst decision and had the nerve to deliver a paper thin crust to my house. Even in this pandemic I will drive to Toppers Pizza in Ventura or even order Domino's before I give your cheating a$% another dime shame on you!!! read more

Rusty's Pizza Parlor - Paper thin. Never have I ever seen this at rusty's "Damn shame what they did to that pizza" - Pizza Near Me - Goleta, California

See all

I had not been here for awhile Ordered a large 3 topping. The crust was thin and undercooked and very skimpy on yhe toppings. ​made a second mistake and went to the salad bar. Not much to choose frome there either. Will not be back. It totally was a waste of.money. read more

Delicious pizza and quality service. I hadn't tried them before but will recommend them.

High price, so a rarer pizza event. They do have the best informal seating for pizza around though - at any one of their locations

Its ok. The thin crust felt a bit like I was eating a frozen pizza at home. I stole soda from them witha water cup though so its all good i guess read more

I honestly will never come here again I've given it too many chances and every time I go there they are EXTREMELY rude! Today I ordered even put the plates napkins and Parmesan and pepper and additional ranches on my order online and while confirming at the front when i picked up just so i wouldn't additionally have to ask. She said "only 3 ranches" I'm aware it is 3 i was confirming. I said oh and can you make sure the Parmesan and peppers are also in there. And she showed me the rubber banded Parmesan and peppers and threw them in the bag with a crappy look on her face. She threw my order onto the counter and honestly i had some choice things to say but i thought i would call and speak to the manager directly who completely dismissed me on the phone. Saying "yah, I sorry" like 2 times, then was just quiet. I'm over spending $35 on a mediocre pizza for GARBAGE ATTITUDES AND CRAPPY SERVICE. IF YOU GOING TO GIVE CRAP SERVICE DINT MAKE YOUR PRICES SO EXPENSIVE. read more