This restaurant came highly recommended by a great friend, so when I was thinking of a place to…read moretake my amazing daughter for her birthday, this was my first choice and I'm happy to report it did not disappoint. Service was tied with the food for first place! Starting with the friendly and helpful hostess, every single employee offered a greeting and a smile. Our server was Elijah, he was wonderful! Warm, friendly and professional. He was attentive and perceptive. He didn't hover but anytime we needed he re-appeared. We were greeted by two out of the three managers, 10 out of 10. Now for the food! We ordered the rice balls, maple wings a Pepper pig pizza and for my cocktail I had the blue Hawaiian. Every thing was delicious hot and freshly made. The outside and inside are visually appealing. I would describe it as modern meets industrial with a nice dose or rustic, very nice.

I would never return…read more The service was terrible from start to finish. They brought out the appetizers and entrées at the same time, leaving our table completely overcrowded with plates. To make matters worse, a server took away one of the pizza trays while my dad was still actively eating from it--I'm not exaggerating. It was only 9:04 PM, and we were simply finishing our meal before leaving. On top of that, I ordered the Bucatini, and it was severely overcooked. My mom ordered another pasta that also wasn't good. Overall, a very disappointing dining experience with poor service and subpar food.

great friendly service and fantastic food. wish i had a pizza place like this by home. hope to stop…read moreby again soon

Our experience here for a post- commencement lunch was so fantastic. Friendly service, and all the…read morefood- particularly the pizza- was made with love! Our favorite was the diavolo pie and grandma pie- we love a crispy crust! But everything we ordered was hot, fresh, and delicious. They also easily accommodated a dairy allergy. Highly highly recommend! Thank you !!!

I had a vegetable slice, upside down Sicilian, and margarita. The vegetable slice was decent, the…read moreother two pizzas were terrible. The sauce was bland, and there was barely any cheese on any of them. My husband had a sausage and a regular slice, and he didn't care for his either. Go somewhere else if you'd looking for good pizza!

Cute little hole in the wall place we wanted to check out because my husband saw the barstool pizza…read moreguy's video. We stopped in for a slice and it was great! Quick and friendly service, and great pizza for the price. We chatted with the guy at the register while we waited and he was very nice. Learned he was helping out his family and he's from Dallas (we're from OKC, so it was nice to chat with him). I love thin crust and we got classic cheese. It was delicious! Definitely recommend for a late night bite or any pizza night with the fam.

Sorry to say,I just got take out,and the meal tasted like perfume. The sauce was tasteless, except…read morefor the perfume and the spaghetti was overcooked.

Such good food. I liked the baked ziti. Pizza looked good too. Mozzarella sticks were good…read more Everything is awesome. This is real jersey pizza with yumminess. If you are in Metuchen you should come here.

The food, service, and atmosphere were definitely a vibe! Everything about the experience was…read moreenjoyable from start to finish. I had the Salmon and the Gnocchi Al Pesto, and both dishes were delicious, savory, and full of flavor. The staff was attentive, the ambiance was great, and the overall experience made me want to come back again. Highly recommend!

This place is absolutely fantastic…read more The octopus is some of the best I've ever had. So delicious. They got it crispy on the outside without overcooking the inside. The bread they bring you before meal was fresh out of the oven. I was like oh no. I don't want to fill up on this but it is amazing. Warm and fluffy and cut into fingers. We got a Cesar salad as a starter to share too. That was very good. For my meal I got the tuna steak medium rare. They cooked it perfectly. The orange sauce they put over it too was amazing. I don't know how to describe it. Some sort of tomato base. Which I wouldn't think of for tuna. Then I finished the night with a cappuccino. I was too full for desert but we weren't in a rush. That hit the spot. This was a business meeting and they moved us to a larger table to give us more space which was super cool of them. We got to sit in the tented area where it was easy to talk to one another without yelling.

Love coming here for their pizzas. Not sure what it is, I think it's their red sauce I really…read moreenjoy. My favorite to get is the bacon pizza. However, there was one time I had called to order for pickup and asked for a bacon pizza pie. A female had picked up the phone and told me they can't make it for me. Super weird and suspicious as my man bought a bacon pizza pie the week prior and no one refused him. To make sure I wasn't going crazy, I had my bf go back to order a few days later and the guys there did not blink & made us the most delicious bacon pie. Not sure why I was refused but Antonio's should train their employees a bit better. Lost a star because of that BUT the pizza makes up for it.

We've been on a mission looking for a great pizza. Antonio's brick oven pizza hit the spot. The…read morecrust was perfectly browned and crunchy. The sauce had great flavor. Pizza had the perfect amount of cheese. We ordered a side of meatballs. They were very good, too. The staff was friendly and provided great service. We will definitely come back.

This is my favorite pizzeria to go to whenever I'm in the area! The food is always fresh and…read moreabsolutely delicious. The staff is very friendly and welcoming, and the place is always clean which makes the experience even better. My favorite is their margherita pizza -- it's perfectly cheesy with just the right amount of sauce. I also love that the crust is thin and holds up nicely with no flop. Highly recommend if you're looking for a great slice!

I hate to say it but I didn't love Brooklyn Boys. If we are talking service- they were great. The…read moreperson who took the order over the phone was patient, the girl who gave us our food and checked us out was friendly and offered us plates and seasonings. Two of my friends were in from out of state and of course, when in Jersey you have to get PIZZA! I'm not unfamiliar with this area but all my favorite pizzerias are at least 15 mins away, so I wanted to get them something closer to their hotel. I saw the good rating and heard from a friend that it was good so I landed on Brooklyn Boys. We order garlic knots, white pizza, & vodka margherita. The garlic knots were so dry they were stored in a pizza box. I felt these were more like garlic dinner rolls. The garlic knots I know are soaked in a buttery garlicky oil, these weren't that. The white pizza was good but again, a bit dry. I would have liked more ricotta all over under the mozzarella. It also just didn't have much oil, which I understand is a preference. I know some people who blot their pizza to get some grease off, I'm not one of those people. In fact, I once went to a pizzeria where they give you flavored oil with your pizza to enhance it, those are my people. I saved the best for last- the vodka margherita. The vodka sauce had a good flavor and there was a good amount, the fresh mozzarella paired nicely. Overall, I didn't feel like this was a good representation of Jersey pizza, or Brooklyn for that matter. For what it's worth my guests thought it was generally tasty and were happy, they said it was better than what they had in their respective states, although they too were very disappointed with the dinner rolls, ahem, "garlic knots".

I'm from California and I never had this kind of pizza in California…read more Very good customer service and super friendly staff.

I love their specialty slices! I had their bruschetta slice and their chicken Caesar salad slice…read moreboth were so DELICIOUS! It was the first time I ever had a chicken Caesar salad slice, and I was surprised how good it was! The chicken was moist and well seasoned, and the salad on dressing on top was so tasty! I also tried a plain margarita slice which I didn't like. There wasn't enough cheese or sauce on it, and I didn't like the taste on the margarita either. My husband also tried a plain slice and a sausage slice, and he thought they were just ok. They had a big selection of all different specialty slices that all looked great. I'd like to try their bbq chicken slice next time. I'd skip their regular slices, but I highly recommend coming here for their delicious specialty slices!

There is no food here! Just a dive bar and mostly deserted! Scary place!!…read more Do not go here looking for pizza or food!!!

I tried the CHICKEN PARM for the first time. It was okay. If I could change anything I'd ask for…read morethinner noodles and the sauce could be a little less watery. Perhaps the noodles needed to be drained longer.

Stopped by this ice cream spot after dinner for a sweet treat, and it was the perfect way to end…read morethe night! My daughter and I got chocolate ice cream, and my mom tried the almond joy flavor. Both were absolutely delicious. The flavors were rich and hit the spot. There was plenty of seating inside, but since the weather was so nice, we decided to enjoy our ice cream outside, which made it even better. Such a simple but great experience. The staff were knowledgeable and helped. They didn't seem like they were in a rush which was great! 10/10 ice cream!

I always visit this ice-cream shop with my family almost every weekend. There's so many unique &…read moreinteresting flavors. It's a small family business which makes the experience more personal and the workers are always helpful with their flavor combo suggestions and they have so much patience with my 3 year old. It's a small quiet shop but you won't be disappointed with the experience!