When I went In I didn't even get a chance to order before walking out because the 2 guys behind the counter were arguing, one of them tossing things and cussing. Both completely ignoring the 2 people in-front's of me also trying to order. read more

Besides having the BEST variety options of PIZZA, Sal's in FDL has, hands down, the MOST DELICIOUS chicken Caesar salad!!!!! Every time... never Seize to amaze with the TOP NOTCH quality freshness!!! read more

Sal's Pizza - CHICKEN CESAR SALAD - Pizza Near Me - Fond du Lac, Wisconsin

Service was one of the worst I've experienced from the pizza place. I was ignored at the counter and had to endure two employees arguing. Product was average. read more

I had called to place and order the guy that answered tried to change my order twice. I ordered a cheeseburger and fries and the guy tried to put it down as a mushroom swiss burger. Once I corrected him and said no I want a cheeseburger with tomatoes, lettuce.... Then he told me I would have to order fries sperate. Then when I ordered a spinach pizza add chicken he told me that he couldn't do that then started listing other things I could add. I stopped him and I told him I read the menu and it said chicken was an add on then he finally got my order right. After I got the food the cheeseburger was rubber and the pizza tasted like chemicals. Never will I be ordering from sals every again read more

One of the best pizza restaurants in uptown. Authentic New York style pizza serve by New Yorkers. Great prices, great food. They are moving locations but it's obviously going to be much better because they're moving into a much larger location. I have never had a bad experience at Sal's. Absolutely recommend. Great people, great ambiance and great prices. read more

Great old time real pizza place staff are great bunch of guys pizza well it was excellent

Pros- good pizza by the slice, variety of sides apps to eat one of my go to places for pizza with the kids Cons- pizza sometimes is very greasy but STILL GOOD read more

Food is always delicious and cooked by people who you can tell enjoy it. The building is old and they make it a cozy date spot.

I ordered food from here a few times, I eat at the Milwaukee location but when I'm in the area this is the spot for me, easy communication and fast delivery! read more

I ordered the roast beef grinder withonions,peppers and cheese. EXCELLENT! the fries and onion rings were just grand. This is a secret, go there now, or as I did have it delivered. All good. read more

Pizza was pretty good.... But the customer service was terrible. Some of the worst I've seen. Employees were talking about poor business practices by owner too. read more

If you look through my reviews you will see a lot of pizza restaurants from New York to California. In short, I love pizza. Having said that, fast food chains seem to give me heartburn and I'm not sure why. Probably added preservatives and excess spices do make up for all the time that stuff was frozen, but I digress. Sal's pizza is good, hot and fresh with good ingredients that don't upset my stomach. For me, the stomach test is always my "check" for fresh ingredients and Sal's passes with flying colors. The wings, cheese bread and rolls are very good too. When I'm in town this has been my go to for pizza! Enjoy! read more

Excellent customer service. Extremely friendly staff. Clean environment. Looking for help. Will most definitely will be back

The pizza was huge and it tasted ok But the hot wings were horrible omg. Just a tip from the hot wing town native of Atlanta Ga. Your not supposed to bread Hot Wings. read more

Love the Gyros here so much. Pizza is great but especially love the dinner roll that comes with the pizza. Easy in and out when you order. I just wish they would update a little for dining I. read more

Best pizza ever... I just wish the salads were better with more veggies. I always ask to cook it just 5 minutes extra... Its delicious when you reheat it in the oven for 5 minutes at 350* read more

Best pizza in town, love this place! Pizza by the slice is amazing, cheesy, hot and flavorful. Lunch special is perfect huge slice of pizza, galic knot and can of soda for $4.75. The owners hospitality is unbeatable, today I saw a customer come in with a baby to pick up a pizza order and he carried the pizzas out to her car for her. read more

Sal's Pizza - Lunch special $4.75 - Pizza Near Me - Fond du Lac, Wisconsin

See all

Asked coworkers what the best pizza was in Fond du Lac. Sal's was the second choice as first choice was not open for lunch. Not sure if they were playing a practical joke or what. Probably the worst pizza I have had. I was hoping for a great pizza with fresh ingredients. What I recieved was a pizza that tasted like the dough came in frozen along with the nasty pre-cooked sausage. Your best bet is to actually buy a frozen pizza at Kroger's or go somewhere that they are able to make them fresh like Rocky's. read more

so disappointing!! we have loved Sals for years, especially the special chicken salad. the last several times we've ordered it, it's been hit or miss so we don't order much anymore but we decided to try again tonight. well, we are definitely done with it - don't know what happened but it has gone DOWNHILL! the garlic knots were burnt, inedible - the salad was completely wrong and not what the menu described - and the pizza was cold and bland. man I miss the Sals of years ago! read more

Slice of sausage and old school coke in the bottle for $6.70 at lunch. Good pizza but it was light on the sauce and heavy cheese. I personally like it the other way around. If I were in the area I'd go back. read more

Sal's Pizza - the outside of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Fond du Lac, Wisconsin

Working in town and was looking for a good pizza. This definitely wasn't it. Greasy, floppy and tasteless. No thanks. I couldn't even do a 2nd piece... read more

Sal's is our "go-to" when it comes to pizza delivery. Their pie beats out everyone else in town. This is classic New York style with a thinner, really chewy crust, cut into huge slices. The sauce is good and they are skimpy with the toppings. As another plus they use only fresh mushrooms. So many places around Fond du Lac, use those nasty canned mushrooms which drives me nuts. I'll admit, their delivery isn't the fastest around, and it can sometimes be a pain to place an order as the guys answering the phone don't have the greatest grasp of English, but it is well worth these few, small hassles. read more

Guys!!! I am from NY and also NJ suburbs. We moved here in November 2017. I was so sad every pizza place was just terrible. The Italian food here is just terrible. I opted to buy Dominos pizza because at least the quality is the same everywhere. But I'm in quarantine and I decided on a whim today I would try to see if I could possible find a good pizza place here in WI to make me feel slightly closer to home. After many searches, and looking at food pics I opted for Sal's. Guys!!! This place is so good!!!! It's not like 100% the same as NY pizza but I would honestly feel comfortable bringing a pie back home and having my friends try it, and them saying "yes!! This can pass!!!" This is my go to place now!!! I was soooo happy today I could cry!!!! the crust was thin and slightly crunchy, it may have been slightly chewier than I would prefer but it's good!!! And the cheese to sauce ratio was great!! Though I may next time ask for 1/2 more cheese. Guys!! I am so happy, you have no idea!! Us New Yorkers and New Jersians are super friggen picky when it comes to pizza!!! I LOVE this place!!!! Finallllllllyyyy!!! Good bye crappy Domino's, I hate you!! Hello Sal's, a customer for as long as I live here, I LOVE you!!!! I will try some of their other things too but really, I'm just going for this pizza!!!! read more

Ordered the calzones and they were much larger than expected. Had leftovers for the day after. I had the supreme and it was tasty. Freshly made and delivered to table. Only downfall was that the soda machine wasn't working. But other than that good food and experience. Will go back. read more

I'm sorry to see folks have had bad experiences at Sal's. I've been there several times and only had great pizza. I've never had delivery so I can't comment on new well they deliver but every time I've been there for lunch it's been great. read more

Was not good tonight. Ordered a pizza with some rolls. The rolls were soggy & they forgot my marinara sauce and they said they were too busy to bring me some. Not impressed this time. read more

Being new in town and a pizza lover, I asked where to find the best pizza in town. Immediately was told I had to go to Sal's. All I have to say is I don't have to look no further, and Sal's got themselves a new customer and fan read more

Ordered two pizzas for deliver at 4:30pm on a Friday night. Was told 45 minutes. Pizza arrived at 5:35pm. Only one of which was correct. Instead of a Margarita pizza we got Mac & Cheese. Called and it was determined that they couldn't read the writing of the order taker. Also delivered Pepsi instead of Diet Pepsi. Said they would send another one right over. Called at 6:45pm wondering where our pizza was. They hadn't even started making it. In the meantime a Diet Pepsi did arrive. Now at 7:20pm the final pizza arrived. No refund. No nothing. DO NOT ORDER FROM Sal's! read more

Best NY style pizza you'll get in this area! I love the fact that you can buy pizza by the slice. So if no one wants to split a pizza with you, then you don't have to worry! Definitely recommend for those who love thin pizza you can fold in half and shove into your mouth. Yum. read more

Usually have great experience until I ordered the philly tonight. It had mayo on it......mayo on a philly=gross super disappointed

Hands down the best pizza I have ever had!!! Pizza comes with garlic rolls, absolutely awesome! Decent pricing, the only complaint I would have is the slices are huge! :) I highly recommend!!! read more

Ordered a pizza last week via eatstreet. Two hours later, nothing. Called, they said it would be here in minutes. Ok, everyone makes mistakes right?! 30 min later still nothing, called again. We had an appointment to get to, canceled, they said we would get a refund. Week later, called manager raised his voice at me and said there is nothing he can do. Great customer service right?! Way to go eatstreet, great customer service on their part. I hope they cut ties with these horrible business owners. Xxo read more

Great pizza delivered warm couldn't possibly have a complaint it was a good experience

Great New York style pizza and garlic knots. Love spinach and feta pizza. Fast and friendly service.

Great food and drinks! the draw back is they dont accept savings account debit cards. they DO accept visa and master card! i figure, if it was made in america, we should be able to pay with it! (seriously, this trump thing is in shambles!) read more

Well first of all, my friend asked for a pizza with just sauce and sausage, no cheese, because she's lactose intolerant. The guy behind the counter then went on to say that they don't make pizzas without cheese (even though she has been here 2 other times and has gotten a pizza without cheese,) and he then stated "I'm from Europe and we don't make pizzas that way," and gave us no other reasons as to why he couldn't make the pizza. Then, they dropped my other friend's pizza on the ground, and instead of coming to inform us that it'll take a little longer, they quickly threw a pizza together, and now we've been waiting 30 minutes for a medium size pizza and have still yet to get it. We usually love this place, but the service was really crappy and rude today. read more

Great variety of pizzas and other italian specialties. Great place to go just to pick up a slice or two. Another great option is to get a whole bunch of individual slices for a family dinner instead of everyone eating the same thing. Slices are large enough to cut in half and still be a good size. Staff is friendly. We have never had the pizza delivered-always picked up or ate in. read more

Coming from a New Yorker, born and raised, this is one of my guilty pleasures in FDL. Nothing better than just a simple cheese pie from here! read more

Ordered a pizza for delivery. It took one hour and thirty two minutes to get my pizza that was cold. The driver didn't have a receipt for my credit card purchase and didn't care that the delivery took forever or that the pizza was cold. When I tried to eat it I realized that the two extra toppings that I paid for weren't on the pizza. I called the store and the first guy argued with what I was trying to explain, he put another guy on that wouldn't identify himself other than he was a pizza guy. I explained the long delivery wait, the cold pizza and the missing toppings that I paid $3.50 extra for. I actually outright told me "I don't care" and that he wouldn't do anything. He then hung up. The food might be ok when hot but the customer service alone would make me NEVER go back. My advice, skip the pizza here and have a burger at 11:11 down the street. read more

So, looking at Yelp I was going between here, Joe's Fox Hut, and Ang and Eddie's. Ang and Eddie's wasn't open on Mondays and Joe's didn't have online ordering so I went with Sal's. I have to say I was pretty disappointed. The pizza was just extremely blah. There were plenty of toppings and a good amount of cheese, but there just didn't seem to be a lot of flavor. Included in the pizza box were a couple of big puffy dinner rolls that looked really good, but again were just really blah. The big floppy pieces of pizza were also really hard to eat... they'd flop over when you picked up a slice and all the toppings would fall off. That being said, delivery was about 10 minutes faster than estimated, my order was accurate, and delivery guy was friendly. read more