Been there a few times now. VERY inconspicuous from the outside, BUT absolutely amazing inside! Feels like a small pizza supper club. First time we went, the waitress made us feel like we were regulars. Have always gotten the home style crust, which is the "middle" choice of thickness, but it's not thick in the middle, so don't be turned off thin crust lovers. The buttery end crust is like garlic bread. "Pro" tip...get a side of marinara on the side to dip your crust in...you're welcome . Cheese is high quality and gives you those squeaky chews! Sausage & pepperonis are also higher quality, and vegetables are plentiful. Give Paddy's a try, I bet it you'll put it on your dining out rotation! read more

Service, so wonderful and friendly. Ambiance, the perfect family pub. Cozy, welcoming, peaceful, relaxed. Food, SO terrific!!! We had the spaghetti and the teriyaki salmon bowl, from any awesome menu. Both were perfectly cooked, excellent flavors. Nothing to say except come here and enjoy a lovely meal at a local spot. read more

Paddy's is classic. The pizza is amazing and the ambiance is absolutely unique. If you're looking for a neat experience I strongly recommend this restaurant! @teamjesbon read more

Good Pizza , friendly staff but service is ridiculously slow. It took over an hour for a pepperoni pizza and an order of mozzarella sticks. But the prices are very reasonable , so they have that going for them. read more

Paddy's Pizza Pub'n'restaurant - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eden, Wisconsin

See all

Love their pizzas. We always go for their home style pan crust. Buttery garlic goodness no matter what toppings you put on them. The pizzas are even half priced on Saturdays for dine in! Cozy interior. For takeouts, we usually call ahead about 45 minutes or so. The pizzas don't come out fast, but it is worth it. The 16in pizzas will fill up a average sized family no problem. Servers have always been friendly and accommodating. read more

You gotta eat the pizza there, it is literally the best pizza ever, they even delivered my $69.57 order at 9:30pm so if you have nothing to eat, I highly recommend this place. read more

How I'd describe Paddy's to someone who wants to eat there for the first time: uninviting exterior, dimly-lit, and enough garlic in their pizza sauce to kill a vampire from a 1,000 miles away. On the plus side, the prices are pretty darn reasonable and they certainly don't skimp on the cheese when you ask for extra cheese. read more

Great food and friendly service.... like your favorite neighborhood spot! Pizza is excellent - recommend thin crust or Chicago style - and the Deluxe and chicken bacon ranch are particularly good. Drinks are stiff and staff is super friendly. Don't overlook the apps (mozzarella sticks, loaded pub chips, fried pickles) or the hoed spaghetti. read more

Worst pizza I ever had! We went at about 5, we were told it would be 45 min. to an hour. Thought we would try it anyway. My girlfriend got her salad in a reasonable time. When they brought out her mac & cheese, they said my pizza would be right out, so I took my insulin. Ten minutes later, the waitress said the cook was putting the finishing touches on it. Another ten minutes went by and I finally got my pizza. I had ordered a 10 inch bacon cheeseburger pizza. All that was on the outside inch or so of the pizza was the sauce. If there was 6 pieces of hamburger and even less bacon I would have been lucky. Not even one piece on each slice, Middle was a glob of undercooked cheese and the pizza was not even cut, had to try to separate with a knife. The cashier did not even ask how our meal was. I was charged $9.50 for something I could not eat. I had to go home and make a sandwich. I will never go back there and will not ever recommend this place. All in all the most disappointing pizza ever. Jeff A. (920) 923-5691 read more

Pizza is really good depending on who is in the kitchen. Garlicky crust baked on cornmeal with loads of fresh toppings. Nice strong drinks and great cheese curds. Yes, they are incredibly slow. Even our cheese curds took 20 minutes. In the end, the wait is worth it. We've been there about six or seven times and twice it was bad, due to burnt pizza or forgotten orders, but they always apologized and made it right. A nice drive and a nice date night. read more

Ordered pizza while at the Breezy Hill campsite. Pizza was fantastic! Price was average, will definitely order from again. Delivery time was within an hour, right to our campsite. read more

If I could I would give -3 stars. What a total joke! We ordered Truffle fries and there was no truffle oil and they made us sick. Then after sitting there for an hour we ask where is our Pizza and the waitress tells us it is burnt. Please don't waste an hour of your life on this place believe me STAY AWAY! When we got there it was 3pm And there were two people in the restaurant apparently more Than the two waitresses could Handle as the place was a total mess with several tables not cleaned. Total waste of time! read more

One of the best pizza places around. Kind of out there but we'll worth it.. Yum I drive 45mins for Darn good pizza and the atmosphere is also very laid back. Bring cash no Cards are affected. read more

We had a very nice experience at Paddy's. The pizza was very good and the crust was fantastic. I am from Chicago, where of course,pizza is an inherited by geographical art. It was nice that they offered a "take and bake" pizza for people who are too impatient to wait for their delivery. By the way, I live in Lomira, and they deliver here. Way to go! read more

Tried Paddy's twice, both times they were understaffed and the staff that was there was rude and inattentive! Waited over an hour the first time for one pizza with no apology, and the pizza was mediocre. The second time we called in an order to go and when we arrived we were told the person who took the order was wrong about the time it would be ready. They asked the chef how long it would take for an order of wings and the salad we ordered 30 minutes earlier and he was incredibly rude and could have cared less, he said "well I have no idea, I guess I could get it ready in 15 or 20 minutes!?!" We will NEVER go back! Don't waste your time or money! read more

Really good pizza at a very reasonable price. Today's order was a large 14" cheese sausage and onion pizza along with two orders of cheese garlic bread. All for only $21.10 read more

I grew up on California cheese, and by extension, pizza made with California cheese. California has nothing on Wisconsin when it comes to cheese -- and Paddy's is truly excellent. It has a small town atmosphere, high quality pizza, and reasonable prices. I went with a relative that is local to the area and the owner came out and chatted up a storm. Very friendly place. Paddy's is on my list of "must see" places when I'm in Wisconsin. read more

Friday night.... slow service. Ordered a side salad and did not get it even after 35 mins. Cancel salad. waited for fish fry 40 minutes.

Ordered burgers and waited 1:45 for our food! Also, I watched a table of 7 order 4 pizzas, and the pies all came out 20 minutes apart! I was completely amazed at the lack of promptness from anyone at this place. My wife asked for another can of soda and it took us asking the waitress 2 more times before she actually brought it out,as we were finishing our food. Everything was very reasonably priced and the food was actually very good. The waitress did apologize for the insane wait on everything. Probably won't return for second chance. read more

We went last night for first time with friends who had been there and recommended it. The pizza was wonderful and the price even better! They also have double bubble before 6, DAILY! and they do have mixed drinks in addition to beer and wine. We were all blown away by what we received for the money spent and actually felt guilty! We will definitely be back. Oh, and split one extra large pizza for 2 couples and still had leftovers! Frozen and take and bakes are an even better bargain. We were going somewhere after or would have taken some along. read more

I live close. That said I enjoy a good pizza. This place has a great pie. Dining in is always a pleasure as the staff is very friendly and take good care of you. Dogfish 90 minute ale on tap when i was there tonight was a pleasant surprise. give it a shot. read more