What a cute little reto ice cream stop! It was SO hard to pick what to order but the kind employees showed us the special they had at the moment: an apple cider ice cream donut, so our hands were tied , we had to get it! Wow - this was a melt in your mouth donut with the perfect amount of sugar topping to add a fun texture without being too sweet. My friends and I enjoyed our treats at the table seating. We had no problem finding spots in the late evening and were so happy we made this spot. Would come here again! read more

Sawyer Ice Cream - Apple Cider Donut - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saugerties, New York

The aesthetic is such an authentic and vintage vibe. The ice cream is delicious. The price is reasonable.

What a cute old school ice cream spot! Plenty of parking and plenty of seating. Came here on July 4th before the fireworks and waited less than 10 minutes. I really enjoyed the fluffer nutter ice cream, thick, creamy, and perfect for a peanut butter lover. Can't wait to come back next time I'm in the area. read more

Sawyer Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saugerties, New York

Two words - Almond. Joy. This flavor was hard ice cream heaven Went to this place while visiting Saugerties and it did not disappoint. They have an amazing menu & selection of ice cream and a good amount of flavors. read more

Great ice cream spot. A lot of seating outside. The portions are pretty generous. I got the chocolate milkshake and it was delicious. Very chocolaty but not too sweet. The servers are very kind and make your orders very quickly. read more

See all

This place was cute and right around the block from where we were staying. Service was good and ice cream was good. We just picked up so can't say much else :P read more

Sawyer Ice Cream - the outside of the restaurant - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saugerties, New York

Quick lil update: I got lunch! 2 hot dogs, chips and a shake. Not a bad deal, it was everything I wanted from a summer lunch at an ice cream joint. The service was great - I really don't know how they found folks presumably happy to be there! Also, they offer ice cream samples. I HAD to try the oat based chai latte ice cream and it's friggin great. Big thumbs up from me! read more

Sawyer Ice Cream - 2 hot dogs with Sawyer Sauce, and a milkshake! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saugerties, New York

We stopped by on a hot summer afternoon and got a cup of fluffer nutter and a waffle cone with cappuccino caplosiom. The fluffer nutter was creamy and had a peanut butter flavor with plenty of marshmallow swirled in. The cappuccino caplosiom also tasted good and had a hint of cappuccino, which was good because sometimes it's overpowering. We also got a pup cup, which is some soft vanilla ice cream with a dog bone on top, which is free. Plenty of parking and summer hours are posted on a sign by the street daily. read more

See all

My dear friend and co-great grandmother went to your ice cream shop (me for the first time) a few weeks ago, I had a chocolate ice cream and promptly rated it the best ice cream I've ever had, pure heaven and it was like chocolate mousse!! I never finish my ice cream but I ate every spoonful!! we also felt transported to a beautiful time when girls on skates brought your order, th ambiance took me back to the six and it was wonderful!! I hop to go back soon , can't get enough of that creamy delight read more

Excellent house made ice cream. Hard and soft serve and sooo many flavors to choose from.

Amazing and creative menu. Our choices tasted great. Friendly efficient service. We'd be back too often if we lived close by.

The best ice cream i have ever had in Saugerties. High quality ingredients, middle size looks like a giant one) Highly recommended!!! read more

Incredible. Service is good, ice. Ream is great, ambiance is retro. It's cute, try the deconstructed ice cream. It's like an ice cream lunchable with little waffle cone chips and toppings. Yummmm Sundays rock too. read more

I LOVE ICE CREAM!! And this place did not disappoint. It's squeaky clean, fun atmosphere, and lots of flavors to choose from. Definitely stop by or make the trip from wherever you are. I had pumpkin pie hard ice cream...pieces of pie crust in it. I also had salted caramel. What a tasty pairing! Will definitely be back. read more

Sawyer Ice Cream - Exterior - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Saugerties, New York

Nice old-school vibe, fair prices, and good ice cream. Everything was very clean and service was good.

If you are familiar with who Bob Siracusano is and his love for Ice cream then that's really all you need to know about this place. While I don't think it's the perfect Ice cream spot just yet historically he is the type to continually tweak and fine tune whatever he is involved with. I am excited to see the place only get better as the years go on. Not much happens on this side of town in the late afternoon and evenings so it's nice to have a family friendly place to go to and enjoy great ice cream. read more

Sawyer Ice Cream does it right! I love the throwback 50's decor. Fast friendly service with a sense of humor. Family atmosphere. Easy to get to. Have a good summer and enjoy your ice cream! read more

See all

Friendly service, delicious ice cream, reasonable prices, ice cream for all dietary needs, great family place--A true gem

I love their ice cream but feel I've been ripped off twice this year. The first time I ordered and paid for 12 ice cream sandwiches when I got in the car and looked in the bag there were only 6, maybe an honest mistake. Yesterday I bought a hot fudge sundae $5.95 and was charged $7.02. That doesn't add up. read more

Just came from there, great hot dogs with chili best ice cream around. I would recommend this place to any and everyone

We checked out Sawyer Ice Cream a few months ago. The coffee soft serve wasn't impressive - the texture was fine, but the taste was more like coffee diluted with too much milk. The scoops of strawberry and vanilla had a very gummy texture and an unpleasant, artificial taste - we tossed both scoops after a couple of bites. When I threw something else out, I noticed that the scoops we disposed of about 30 minutes earlier had barely melted; one has to wonder how much preservatives and stabilizers have been added to the "ice cream". Very disappointed. read more

I love this places milkshakes and also the hot dogs with sawyer sauce are delicious!!!

So happy to have our own ice cream place nearby! The newly constructed building is adorable too!

Great icecream. It's way to expensive. I thought they would have descent prices but they are the highest everywhere. I compared price.

A fun little nostalgic treat! Very clean establishment. Old time stand feel, with great music playing in the background. Loved the Sawyer hot dog sauce. Shakes and ice cream are awesome too. Excellent prices. Now one of my new local favorites. read more