I ordered 2 dozen reg size bagels and 1 dozen mini for my church and they were super fresh super soft and absolutely delicious. Ive had bagels all over Port Washington but Schmear is beyond delicious soft fresh and great service. My church loved them!!! Thank you!!!!!! Ill be back!!!! read more

3.5 My friend and I ordered the breakfast burritos and the bacon egg and cheese. I'd give the breakfast burrito 4.5. It was large and filled with eggs and sausage for $14.07. My friend's bacon egg and cheese was a little messy and all over the place. Maybe they were just too busy. The cashier unfortunately did mess my name up with another common Asian name, even though I spelled it out for her. read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - Breakfast burrito - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Black and White cookie review. Both frosting sides had the right consistency, but the wrong frosting/cake ratio. The black half and white half were overpowered by the thick cookie, the black side more so. Bad presentation of my B&W, especially once you remove it from the paper bag, which pulls off some of the frosting. Perhaps use wax paper or thin plastic bags that don't have this issue, like Orwashers. read more

See all

I used to come to this place for many years . Order my omelette the same way. theres a new kid behind the counter who gave me a hard time while I was placing the order. (We don't have this, we don't do it like this) The kid told me to "go fuc myself" when I told the new owner , he didnt seem bothered at all. that's the level of customer service they have in this place now. Never again! I hope they leave Port Washington soon! read more

Tried to give them a second chance and well, I should've left them alone after the first time. Went in and ordered a sandwich and got some puddings for my sweet tooth afterward. Wasn't until I got back to work that I noticed that there was mold growing on them. So not only are the puddings not fresh but they've been sitting there long enough to grow mold? Smdh. Contacted the store about this and still haven't heard back, that was 3 days ago. Clearly they couldn't care less. That's fine, they just won't be getting my business again. Don't give them yours either. read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - Moldy pudding. - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

See all

Such a cute place to have a bagel or a parfait. The staff is very friendly there. Parfait had a good amount of granola and strawberry which I enjoyed. Cream cheese lox was ok. Bagel was good read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - Parfait was yummy. About $6 - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

See all

Delicious!! My husband and I love this spot! We usually get an egg and cheese on a croissant or a number 5, everything bagel, cream cheese, pesto, tomato, balsamic glaze! The best, fresh, and filling! Staff very filling! read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - #5 - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Come on guys, is the $5.50 price tag just for the labor of making the flagel? Because the scallion cream cheese is barely a schmear.... read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - Where's the scallion cream cheese?! - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

See all

Stopped in for bagel with cream cheese and coffee. Eat in store. Bagel wasn't cut all the way through and coffee was filled to the top and spilled when top taken off. This might not sound like a major issue but WTF. staff needs better/more training read more

Great local deli with fantastic sandwiches, good selection of snacks and drinks, and lovely staff. Highly recommend.

Huge portions, excellent food. Highly recommend, we did takeout but the interior looked very cute.

Terrific product line and friendly service at its best. A special shout-out to Gigi at the counter. Always pleasant with a smile to start the day off right. read more

This is a pretty cute and cozy place. I liked hanging out here during the morning. You wait on line, order on the righthand side, then pay on the left side. First glance, it seems the prices are a bit higher than average. I got an everything bagel with cream cheese and tomato, toasted. It tasted fine, but it was much smaller than what I am used to. It was also not as covered with toppings than others I've had in the area. They also have a long menu of avocado toast, which I would return for. read more

Very disorganized. It's difficult to determine what's on offer as they have a bakery case in one place, a cooler with unmarked concoctions in another place, and then you have to read a menu screen behind the counter that keeps changing before you can absorb one page. Then the food came out long before our coffees came out. I guess when you're the only place open you don't have to worry about good service. read more

Perfect find for a quick Saturday morning breakfast. Hot and toasted Everything Bagels - 1 Buttered and 1 with Cream Cheese. Add 2 bottles of water and 2 Lattes served by friendly staff in a clean and welcoming environment = no reason to complain. Popular with the local crowd, multi-generational clientele; who lingered while dining. Was really an enjoyable way to start the weekend. Great selection of juices, pastries and other breakfast items. Sandwiches and salads available for the lunch/brunch crowd too. read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - Everything Bagel and Latte - look at that cute - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Both bagels snd cream cheeses we got were great, latte and mocha were very good. Service was quick, lots of tables inside. A little on the expensive side but the quality is there. read more

I came here to grab a cuppa coffee and a bagel and a shmear of cream cheese while waiting for my mix of Himalayan Trek paint to be ready from the paint store around the corner. Wiw what a discovery. Fabulous bagels and confections I dare not touch but still admire for their mouth watering effect. Service is pronto and delightfully delivered with a smile. When in Port Washington skip the massive chain coffee franchise across the street and give yourself a welcome treat. I did not mean to wax poetic there but the place inspirers that. Large enough to not feel crowded even when filled with millennials, book readers and moms after pilates. Will def return here. read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - My latte just right - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Schmear is a local gem!! They have so many breakfast and lunch options, including freshly baked bakery items & bagels! I love coming for the coffee and I try to order something different every time I come! If you have a hard time deciding which deli to go to then look no further! On this trip I had the #5 but I swapped out the ham for turkey! They did not disappoint I also ordered an oat-milk latte with hazelnut syrup read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - #5 but with turkey and tomatoes - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Gorgeous place! I love the atmosphere of it and very clean! The staff isn't that friendly but the coffee was really good! read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - tables and chairs - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Bad tasting food. There was also an extremely hard unidentified foreign object in my food. read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - Create Your Own Egg Sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Nice aesthetics and popular with parents and kids. But too bad that utensils are mostly single use plastic. The clientele would appreciate something more environmentally friendly options ( biodegradable/plant). Was a shame to throw out plastic fork and plastic knife, Kraft maple syrup pack etc. read more

Out of this world with these spectacular sandwich creations! I will be definitely coming back!

Order on door dash. An hour and half later had to cancel as food never arrived. Terrible service.

I ordered a bagel with butter and this is how much butter came on it. Now I am stuck at work eating a dry bagel for lunch and can't leave to get food that is actually acceptable. Ruined my lunch today. read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - Bagel "with butter"..who expects a bagel with butter to come like this when they order it? - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Talk about a lovely coffee shop! I came here unexpectedly as i was in the area and i am not disappointed. The service was fast and its quite big in here ! My iced mocha didn't come with too much ice but i actually loved that because i get more coffee. It tastes great. read more

See all

Schmear is a wonderful addition to Main Street in Port Wash. their bagels are fresh, the shop is sparkling clean, and the staff are courteous and helpful. This is in far contrast to other Bagel establishments in the neighborhood, which seem to have deteriorated in recent years due to issues around quality and cleanliness. Last weekend, I ordered an everything bagel and an egg sandwich on a croissant. The bagel was chewy and the sandwich was also met with rave reviews. I also love their beet cured salmon and egg cups. I hope they continue to add to the menu and introduce new varieties of bagel sandwiches in the future read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - Excellent collection of parfaits and reasonably priced. - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

Friendly service, good iced tea and fair priced! The amount of toppings is good too, but I wasn't impressed by the croissants. Both didn't seem fresh at all and not like made in house! read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

See all

Called to order pickup for a sausage egg & cheese plus an avocado toast with smoked salmon on top. Both came out to $18. 12$ for the toast and 5$ for the bagel. There was a good amount of avocado and salmon on the toast. I was very content. I ate it before I could take a photo. There were some seats (but tiny) outside for outdoor dining due to Covid. The inside looked cozy and the gentlemen that helped me was very kind. What would make this visit better was if there was an option to order online or be able to do contactless ApplePay. read more

Great bagel shop in town! Staff is super friendly and super fast with our order! Decently priced!

Discovered this place off of Yelp and I am so glad I found it! The atmosphere is beautiful and everything is very clean. I love their iced coffee and their assortment of milk options as I am a fan of oat milk and it can be difficult to find sometimes! They also have a great variety of sugar free syrups which is a plus! I have had their egg and cheese bagels and they are so tasty and so reasonably priced. Their baked goods are so fresh and also very reasonably priced. Love this place and can't wait to come back soon read more

See all

I was in Port Washington for the first time, and an employee recommended that I check out this place. As I walked towards it, I was completely thrown off by the appearance. Schmear Market is surprisingly large with a very modern/hipster appearance. As I walked in, I could smell some baked good which is always a good thing. Their menu isn't overwhelming. In fact, it's on the smaller side. They have a few basic sandwich options, but they do have a variety of fresh baked items. I ordered a no.7 on a baguette. The sandwich was hearty, and the baguette wasn't the soft inside that I expected but still good. I definitely got my money's worth in roast beef. I also bought a slice carrot cake. The icing was very sweet, but the inside was well balanced. Schema Market is definitely a place I would visit again. It's the type of place where I would bring a book or my laptop and do some work. It makes a good hang out spot, and the staff is friendly. read more

I've been here a few times and every time I'm here the food quality is amazing! Today I got lox, veggie cream and tomato on a whole wheat everything bagel and it was DELICIOUS - probably the best I've ever had. A few days ago I got the avocado toast with smoked salmon and I was in heavennnnnn. I've had their açaí bowls a few times but I don't really like them here as much I think they're more known for their bakery and breads so I'm going to stick to that!! One star off bc their prices are pretty steep. read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

See all

Just had a wonderful experience with Schmear and highly recommend them! I had to order a last minute delivery as a condolence gift and I couldn't have been more impressed with their customer service. Thank you, Bill. read more

Bagels, shmagels! Visiting a friend in his neck of the woods recently got me craving a NY bagel. Growing up in Brooklyn and living in the West, one misses the basics. This place really hit the spot! Onion bagel (toasted twice), whitefish spread, tomatoes! DELISH! Coffee was good as well! A nice, clean and cozy spot! read more

Schmear Bagel & Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Port Washington, New York

My daughter came home from abroad and I wanted to hear all about her trip so I thought it would be a great spot to visit today. *This is a great trendy addition to Port and the location is right on the $! You order in the back and pay upfront and they call you when the order is ready -I customed my omelet...not on the menu. $5+ add ons -My daughter chose to make her own salad...seems to be the popular option. $8+ add ons My omelet was cooked perfectly and my daughter's salad was refreshing! The service was fast and the staff was friendly and smiling The cashier helped us navigate since it was our first time and wasn't at all annoyed by our questions The layout is open and inviting Overall: Definitely a great spot to grab a salad, pastry, light lunch or fresh brewed coffee(good and strong btw)/tea and get some work done or catch up with friend(s). **All Summer Seventeen** read more

See all

Great bagels! The smoked salmon was delicious. They had great coffee, too, and a nice place to sit and enjoy your breakfast. Weird ordering/paying process but would definitely recommend. read more

Nothing special bagel place in a good PW location. Nice Aesthetics, clean and bright. I don't eat bagels but tried a few other things. Rolls and baked goods were a step towards stale. Order taker was not knowledgeable on baked good, ingredients, etc. Terrible dry scone. Coffee was nothing special and was not made to my liking/ as I ordered I.e. light. Overall disappointing read more

It's my go to for breakfast every morning. Sometimes the sandwiches can be burnt but overall, it's good breakfast/salad place! Love the bagels. read more

Everyone is exceptional and friendly always service with a smile. The food is always delicious. I cannot recall the name of the young man with dark black hair that is always working the front taking orders. He made my day last week when I mentioned my dad passed away last year. He was genuine and kind. Thank you read more

Schmear is Port Washingtons newest bagel shop. Gorgeous interior, wooden lays, light wood tables and a nice open space in the front for waiting & eating. The staff is extremely friendly, I've been here twice and each time I've been helped everyone has been very nice and helpful. However it saddens me to say, the bagels which should be the star, are just mediocre. They aren't crispy, but somewhat chewy and a little over doughy. The spreads are just OK, and their beet cured lox which I was so excited to try it but it was hardly anything special. It was very mild in flavor and a bit of a rip off for the extra money. This place however, is not overpriced, and a few of their items are okay. I haven't had much on the menu so I don't want to completely undermine this spot, and I will change my review if I go back and try something else that ends up being yummy and worth a star upgrade. But for now, I'd stick to manhasset bagels or even any other bagel spot in port! read more

See all