Great service. They had someone outside taking orders. It's ice cream!! If you can write a bad review about getting ice cream, you need help! I had the strawberry and Oreo shake! It was different and I wondered if I'd like it, I loved it!! It made me smile!! read more

I remember when this was in Overland Park, KS in the early 2000's. To this day, I still remember what I got, the Elvis Presley concrete. Vanilla frozen custard with bananas, peanut butter, rice crispy cereal, and marshmallow fluff. So amazing and tasty! I wish I could go here now in my 30's and show my daughter your concretes! She loves frozen custard! read more

My wife and I were over on Hwy 291 a few nights ago and made a spontaneous stop. We found the menu very limited and their large concretes not so much. We both had the key lime concrete and found it creamy but it got kinda slushy in fairly short order. It also wasn't colored an appropriate green (not a big deal, just a nice touch), and it kinda lost it's key lime flavor towards the last third. However, the window service was wonderful, being staffed by a very personable young lady. I won't rule out another visit to try a different flavor but based on our experience, I do think you can do better (I'm looking at you, Andy's). Pro tip: they don't take Apple Pay read more

The best ice cream in the world! Or frozen custard, or concrete, or whatever it is. I last had a Razzle Dazzle from Sheridan's at another location about 14 years before and had remembered it. When I started to travel to Missouri again, I asked about that Sheridan's and it was closed, so my boyfriend drove me to Liberty to this Sheridan's to get my Razzle Dazzle. You know how they say you can never go back in time? This magical bowl of perfect frozen deliciousness was exactly as I remembered it. As I sat there in the parking lot on the back of my guy's pick up truck as we were eating our ice cream, I felt like we were on our first date. We watched families and couples come and go getting their ice cream, doggies at their heels wagging their tails, you couldn't help but smile. Americana is alive and well at Sheridan's. I cannot describe how different the ice cream is to those you get in Los Angeles. It's just different. Thick and creamy.. quality. The hot fudge is so good too. There is something about that Razzle Dazzle... I'm dazzled and have visions of ice cream in my eyes all the way from Downtown Los Angeles. I cannot wait to go back and get another! read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - a hand holding a cup of chocolate and raspberry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Liberty, Missouri

One of the best chain ice cream restaurants I've ever been to! I absolutely love frozen custard. It's so creamy! Just had their salted caramel brownie sundae! If you ask, they will add whipped cream for you which makes it extra delicious! They have several amazing concretes not advertised like the choco nut joy and my personal favorite the lemon lush! If you haven't had it yet, next summer you certainly must!!! read more

See all

I just ordered a turtle Sunday. I was charged over 6.00 dollars and they gave me a teaspoon of Carmel and chocolate.i won't be coming here again. They have really gone down hill. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - a bowl of ice cream and pecans - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Liberty, Missouri

Not recommended for anybody who cares about their/other's health during the COVID-19 pandemic. Drove by and could see that Covidiot staff were exposing everything by not wearing masks. Per the CDC and Clay County Public Health Center guidance, "Customers should wear face masks/coverings [and] Maintain six-foot distance between customer groups. Staff must wear protective gear such as masks and gloves." Not here though! It's really too bad because we were really craving frozen custards. read more

You guys are awesome! Had the special and it was amazing. One of the best ice cream places in the city.

Meh. Not what I expected but maybe it was what I ordered. This place isn't a type of sit and eat being there was nowhere to sit. It's a small joint where you just order and go. PARKING: small and limited APPEARANCE: simple and small nothing fancy CUSTOMER SERVICE: can't quite saying considering I didn't pay however their service was fast. We ordered and received our order quickly. FOOD: we ordered the salted caramel brownie. it was waaaay too sweet. I have a sweet tooth and I love everything sweet so if something is too sweet for me than it must really be too sweet. PRICES: I can't tell ya, because I didn't pay Overall I wouldn't come here again. It was nice to try okay, maybe I'd come here again but def try something different. I rate this a 3 star because it's nothing too hoot and holler over but it's also nothing to complain about. read more

Sheridan's Frozen Custard - First check in - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Liberty, Missouri

Ok, So here's the skinny, not really because i'm sure this dessert was close to 1000 cals. but anyway Wifey wanted a "concrete" for lunch today 8/1, so of course I oblige, because, remember......a happy wife makes for a happy life. She orders the 'Brownie Bling' a mix of delicious frozen custard, peanut butter, chocolate, brownie bites and a hole in the middle filled with FUDGE. Did you just read that????? Yes, she shared a little with me and the two kids. She shared a "little" I said. She had the entire concrete devoured in less than our 4 minute drive home. Sheridans is not the least expensive but DAMN that Sh*& is good. read more

Yummy treats, some are on the super sweet side but it was nice to try the mix in and the dirt cup is a throw back to my adolescences. One of the few places that's open late in the area. read more

Pretty much the standard by which frozen custard is served in the metro. Sheridans is my family's go to for this tasty treat. This specific location is kinda like the last hold out in terms of modernization. The drive through is narrow and doesn't have a speaker, so you give your order at the same window that you get your food from. I wish they had more pre-thought-up concoctions, but it's still damn good. Go ahead and skip Culvers and Freddy's and head straight to Sheridan's. read more

Crappy, slow service. We were the only people in line & it took the 3 people working almost 10 minutes to make our order. Too busy talking to each other . Once we got our order it was good read more

While they offer a wide-array of toppings and some unique mixtures, the custard texture is light and melts very quickly, leaving something to be desired. It is rich and creamy, but becomes soupy after a minute or two. I do enjoy the smore combo with graham cracker crumbs, marshmallow cream and chocolate bits. They also switch it up with seasonal flavors, we recently had a lemon custard one that had a whole piece of lemon bar in it. Quite yummy and a good way to welcome in Spring. read more

I've been coming to this location ever since I've had my license. So, about 7 years! My bestfriend and I always come here and get chocolate chip cookie dough concretes; and they're HEAVENLY. Staff is friendly. They work quickly, too! read more

this yelp review is more geared towards jacob & less towards sheridans, this is because twitter (jessica) requested i write a yelp review over his promposal. i chose sheridans as the location for this review because it's where jacob took me for our first date. so on the actual subject of sheridans custard: it's very good, highly recommend this location. on the subject of this promposal & jacob in general: not only was it adorable because it incorporated the usage of this app, but i just genuinely feel blessed to have him in my life. i have never met a sweeter or more caring individual, i couldn't feel luckier, i love him very much. happy prom season y'all. read more

I've tried their pumpkin pie custard and it has too much sugar, wondering if their other custards have too much sugar.

We went for ice cream this past gorgeous Saturday and sat in one of two benches in front of the shop. Most customers took advantage of the drive-thru. My son did not finish his one scoop of chocolate ice cream but I easily finished my one scoop of vanilla within minutes. Both ice cream cost less than $2.50. While we were enjoying our ice cream, we were watching the cars driving on 291 hwy. It is difficult to get in and out of the parking lot because there is always heavy traffic and fast cars. read more

not a very clean establishment & my custard was very runny and also tasted old. not sure how that happens. older woman taking orders was quite rude and smelled of cigarettes. will not be returning, andys has a much better product. read more

All I can say is delish! I stopped on the way to our hotel with my wife and kids and my mom. Everyone got something different and it was all great, not good. read more

I haven't had a bad sundae yet! I love the fact that their pecans are roasted and salted, those little details are what makes the difference in that extra star! Also - perfect ratio between ice cream and topping. read more

Just about as good as frozen custard can get. It has that local feel, and everything I have tried has been exceptional. My favorite is the Mango Dango. If you're in the mood for ice cream or a sundae don't go anywhere else. read more

Tried Sheridan's strawberry shortcake and was completely disappointed. Their commercial shows fresh strawberries but they use frozen. It's not cheap either at $5.40. I wrote to the corporate office and did not even get the courtesy of a response. I'm sticking with Culver's around the corner - cleaner store and better quality! read more

This place gets 5 stars just for the wedding cake concrete. Please build one of these in California.

My favorite "ice cream" in Kansas city. Creamy, delicious, and addicting! My go-to order is the coconut joy concrete. I usually get a mini and that is the perfect size for me. If we ever leave Kansas city I know that I will crave this place and miss it! read more

Made a day trip to KC from Des Moines. A stop to Sheridans is always a must!! Great frozen custard and service with a smile!!

always friendly faces and delicious custard! within price range and you get fairly large portions. my favorite is wedding cake concrete!

This place was great! The milkshakes and malts are creamy and delicious, as well as mildly addicting!! Full, wonderful, and rich flavours. I would highly recommend them! read more

This is a super good ice cream place to go to. I highly recommend it. They come in a big cup and it is super good. Try the new Pumpkin Pie Concrete. yum yum yum read more