Everything is made from scratch and you can tell! They're constantly showcasing new recipes and flavors and you know there's no cake mix or shortening to be found! I absolutely love their buttercream frosting. It's not overly sweet. The Key lime pie is to die for, the cookies and bars are really tasty and portions are huge! They've added bagels and croissants for sandwiches, etc. And though I never really had bagel sandwiches before, the roast beef is fantastic and filling. Also, they are truly some of the nicest people I've ever met so it's nice to see them doing well at something they clearly love to do! Check them out and don't forget the iced coffee!! read more

Sugah Hill Bakery continues to set the bar for what a local bakery should be. Beyond their exceptional everyday pastries, this is a place that truly shines when it comes to beautiful custom-order cakes and outstanding pies. Their custom cakes are not only visually stunning--clearly made with precision and pride--but they also deliver where it matters most: flavor, texture, and balance. These are celebration-worthy cakes that look as good as they taste. The pies deserve special mention as well. Perfectly baked crusts, generous fillings, and flavors that feel classic yet elevated. Whether fruit-based or cream, they strike that rare balance between homemade comfort and professional execution. Across the board, everything here reflects care and craftsmanship. Cakes are moist and well-balanced, cupcakes are indulgent without being overly sweet, cookies hit that ideal texture, and specialty desserts never feel mass-produced or rushed. There's a clear understanding of restraint and technique--nothing gimmicky, just excellent baking. Consistency is another standout. Whether you're grabbing a quick treat or placing a custom order for a special occasion, the quality never wavers. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely proud of their work, and the shop itself is warm, clean, and welcoming. Sugah Hill Bakery isn't just a Hanover favorite--it's one of the standout bakeries on the South Shore. The kind of place you recommend confidently and return to often. read more

Finally stopped into this bakery, I pass it often. It's clean bright and so inviting. Friendly welcome by girl behind the register. All the desserts looked incredible, but this time I opted for the vanilla waffle cookies and the sweet chipotle peanuts. The cookies were so yummy, and the nuts delicious! I love all kinds of nuts and trying new ones. This was the perfect blog sweet and spicy , not too spicy at all, just right. Will definitely go back when I've depleted them and will also try the other baked goods. read more

See all

I first found this bakery two days ago and LOVED their breakfast blueberry cake and apple nut bar. I went back today and was greeted by Mama B, one of the owners. She was so friendly and nice. So today I selected the lemon poppy and blueberry muffins along with another apple nut bar...all were absolutely delicious! I will definitely be a returning customer there. If there were more than a five-star review, I would totally choose it! This place is worth the trip! read more

Heard some good things about Shugah Hill Bakery and thought we would try it. Stopped into the store and right away there was a not so pleasant odor instead the store rather than the usual expected freshly baked goods smell. The store is nicely decorated. Not many selections to choose from on display. Chose a blueberry cake, a mini chocolate Bundt cake, oatmeal cookie and almond biscotti. The oatmeal cookie was a bit mushy and fell apart as I ate it and the flavor was a bit too sweet for my taste. The rest of the pastries were either tasteless or not enough of something. The texture of the Bundt cake was like a flourless cake, dry, dense and stale. The blueberry cake was also dry and stale. Will not be going back again. read more

See all

Walked in for a pecan pie. Folks were friendly and helpful. Ambience was bright and open. The pecan pie was mostly custard with some pecans on top. Not what I was expecting and not worth the $42.80 i paid for it. read more

Shugah Hill Bakery - 'Pecan' Pie - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Hanover, Massachusetts

This bakery has a beautiful interior. The staff are friendly and helpful. I tried several items while I was there. I got the Blueberry Cake ,Pumpkin Sheet Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting,Mini Key Lime Pie,Raspberry Almond Bar,Italian Anisette Cookie, Italian Lemon Cookie, Brownie, Americano and Almond shortbread. You can tell the attention to detail on these items. The Key Lime Pie was Sweet and tasty . Pumpkin Sheet Cake had a hint of Spice and sweetness. Brownie was delicious. They also have fresh ground coffee. Definitely worth a shot read more

See all

I am writing due to a surprisingly unprofessional experience. I have been using shugah hill bakery for the last year for all of my celebrations and have always highly recommended this to anyone I knew. I called this morning. Was asked to be put on hold. No problem. I waited on hold for approx 5 minutes and hung up when no one came back to the phone. I tried to call again multiple times and the phone service was offline with a recording of " the party is not available try again". I asked my mother who works in town to go in person to order a cake I need 5 days from now. She was met with what seemed like a frazzled employee complaining that they aren't taking any more orders til May 7 due to a large order volume of cupcakes they have to get done. I feel overall this was presented in an unprofessional manner and continually not answering the phone when open seems to be a bad business move. My order was taken elsewhere. I will no longer be recommending this business. read more

I stopped by Sugah Hill for a treat while I was running errands. Everything looked really good. I was hoping to buy some vanilla cupcakes. There were only chocolate in the front case, so I asked if they had any. Turns out they were in the process of frosting some freshly baked cupcakes in the kitchen, so I was in luck! The cupcakes were absolutely delicious and a real hit at home. read more

It would have been enough just to converse with the amazing owners of this bakery, but then there is food. OMG I don't know if I have eaten muffin than the Glorious Morning. Loaded with apples and raisins it didn't need a lot more to sweeten it. Loads of flavor without a load of sugar. Just perfect. The Key Lime ‍ pie is the best that I've had north of Florida. The chocolate cream pie is amazing. Next visit I'm going for the scones! Treat yourself and grab a pastry and an amazing cup of coffee . You will return. read more

I have been waiting to try this bakery out. It is finally open and there are many things to choose from. I picked up a key lime pie for a party and it was a hit. I also tried the gingerbread cookie and the almond cookies. Both were tasty and fresh. Although it was busy the service went quickly. It's a cute bakery and I'm looking forward to going back. read more

See all

This is a great bakery and a cute bakery. The blueberry muffin and Sour Cream Coffee cake and muffin is delicious. All the ingredients are the best. Thank you for having so many delicious items. read more

Absolutely amazing ladies , everything about this place as incredible . The owners are the nicest sweetest people I have ever met and this is the cutest bakery I've ever been to . So comfortable and they just make you feel at home . Go sit and drink coffee and a snack and have a chat . read more

Shugah Hill Bakery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Hanover, Massachusetts

I was surprised for my birthday with a Shugah Hill custom cake and it was the most spectacular cake I have ever had. On top of the cake being beautifully decorated - the taste was out of this world. The frosting and layers of cake were to die for, and everyone was quick to ask for seconds. I will only be buying my special occasion desserts from Shugah Hill from now on! read more

Shugah Hill Bakery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Hanover, Massachusetts

Totally pumped for Shagah Hill Bakery to open! MamaB and Marie's baked goods are killer! The Pies, Cakes, Italian Cookies, Brownies are all out of this world! Once you taste their stuff, you won't want to go anywhere else! CHOWIN!! read more

See all

Shugah Hill Bakery has AMAZING cakes! I used Shugah Hill Bakery for my wedding cakes that served 225 people and everyone raved about the quality and taste. I highly recommend Shugah Hill bakery for all dessert needs but especially wedding cakes. THE BEST AROUND! read more

Shugah Hill Bakery - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Hanover, Massachusetts

See all

Shugah Hill Bakery is the best! I've been tasting MamaB's baked goods for several months. Her biscotti, and Italian anisette cookies remind me of my moms, who is straight from the old country! And her cinnamon rolls are decadent. For me it's almost a one hour drive - it's that good! read more

This new bakery is AMAZING! Get your baked goodies, coffee, and more. The two bakers, Mama B and Marie, are incredible at what they do, and the vibes are warm, welcoming, and relaxing. Check them out in Hanover! Highly recommend. read more

See all

If you live within a 500 mile radius, you should make the pilgrimage to this bakery. The blend of different baking styles means there will be something for everyone; the atmosphere is calm and warm, making you feel comfortable staying and reading a book for a while, or grabbing a mid day pickup and running out. Many years of baking expertise went into the menu and service, making sure the product is consistent and unforgettable. Do yourself a favor and visit Shugah Hill. read more

got a slice of chocolate cheesecake for eat in. the body of the cheesecake was chewy and not very flavorful, the crust was nice and the layer of chocolate ganache on the top was nice. service was fine, teen service jobs. sat and read on my kindle while i ate, tables are nice. read more

Shugah Hill Bakery - chocolate cheesecake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Hanover, Massachusetts

See all

Cute new bakery in town. I went in and was greeted by 2 really sweet girls that helped me pick out a couple cookies brownies and a delicious key lime pie! I recommend you swing by and pick up a sweet treat!!!!! Shugah Hill is a 10/10 for me. read more

Once again I had the opportunity to be in this beautiful bakery. Again, I was thrilled! The quality, the atmosphere, the staff, are all AMAZING! If you haven't come in, you are missing out! Just WOW! Try the 7 layer bars...or the brownies...wait maybe the new Breakfast sandwiches on the weekends. But...don't forget to get a latte too! read more

They made a cake for my friends wedding and it was absolutely stunning. One of the layers was Carrot Cake & it was the best slice of Carrot Cake I have ever had. Since then I have been a frequent customer and have never been disappointed. You won't be either if you give Shugah Hill a try! read more

Such a cute spot to sit down and enjoy a nice coffee and dessert! Everything I've had here is delicious!!!

I live in Franklin, MA and Shugah Hill Bakery is worth the drive. Everything I've sampled there has been fabulous, From the biscotti to the Raspberry Almond Bars, which are always a big hit with the kiddos! And the staff is friendly, helpful and very sweet (pun totally intended!) read more

What an absolutely delightful find! The coffee is superb and the pastries are divine. Very attentive staff... friendly, polite, courteous and professional. They even went to extra effort to bring our order to our table and warmed our slice of cake! The ambiance is warm, inviting and relaxed. It's our first of many visits! Come early, come often! read more

These guys are the best bakery in the Northeast, the key lime pie is to die for. But don't stop there! Everything is delicious. Do yourself a favor and stop by. read more

So excited that there's a authentic bakery this side of the South Shore! We had the carrot cake and it maybe the best I've ever had.