We've stayed at this hotel a couple times. It is a decent and safe place, given it is across from…read morethe state police. The rooms are clean and comfortable. This isn't your fancy Hilton, but it's not your Motel 6 either. Breakfast was a variety of foods, including delicious bagel toppers. They need to serve this more often! The front desk made check in a breeze and the rooms were clean, so we had a confortable stay for a halfway mark for driving both up and down on our trip.

The staff was very accommodating and our room was spotless. Breakfast didn't disappoint either. We…read morecouldn't find a room in Columbus and drove on hopeful we could get a room. So glad we found this property. It will be our "stop" from now on this route. Highly recommend this property.

I really wanted to like this place as the grounds are beautiful…read more On the positive side, the staff was great and did what they could. The person working the front desk was friendly and looked like she was doing 3 jobs at once. The bartender was fast efficient and made great cocktails. Some of our concerns go to more managerial issues. As an example, the heat in our room did not work and our room was as cold as the outside. Being middle of January we were literally sitting in our rooms in hats, gloves and coats. The staff did bring up some space heaters to help raise the temperature, which eventually worked. The wine pairing dinner we attended was just ok, but at 70 dollars a person I would expect more than using small plastic cups for the pairings. The food itself was really good, so my compliments to the chef. If the room price was more reasonable and not 450 per night I would be less critical. The cost just didn't match the expectation

So I saw this on Hotel Hell many years ago and always wanted to come here. I booked a surprise…read moretrip for the guy I like and picked my castle room based on reviews. When we arrived we saw a beautiful property, had exceptional customer service and check in, the room was unique and huge, and also very clean. The on site amenities were great, the landscaping and theming was emasculate, and the on site restaurant had delicious food for each meal. Several weddings happened on site while we were there and all of that looked very intimate and special for them. The pool complex was very nice and clean. I loved my experience and highly recommend this property to anyone who wants a unique experience in Ohio! Thank you for the memories!

Well this is truly a 3 star hotel even with the ongoing renovation. I have been fortunate to get…read morethe updated rooms as the other rooms feel tired. Unfortunately the renovation team must had been the lowest contract as much of the room is unorganized and many fixtures still not working. More importantly, the towels that were replaced are worst then the ones they had. Talk about small and rough, does not fit around your waist and I am not a large person. The shower gets warm but not hot. Was told this is due to the way the shower was installed and they need someone to fix the renovations. Finally the breakfast is lackluster, and most of the time the coffee is empty. They have lots of room for improvements.

I have stayed at Fairfield Inns and been impressed...not here. I immediately noticed the elevator…read morewas dingy. As I walked to my room the carpet was dirty. My room was OK, but the bathroom was dim and the floor didn't look all that clean. There was a wire hanging down from the microwave to the floor, unplugged. The TV was small and old. They never did come make up my room and there was no notice to request service. Breakfast was pretty good and the beds were comfortable. Still, finding a different place next time in town.

Weary travelers listen up : this Mount Gilead. Best western…read morewas amazing for two weary travelers.. we came in late approximately 10:30 PM and was met with a happy smiling face a quick check in with a reasonable price, the room was, very comfortable it smelt clean the water pressure was amazing in the shower. They had blow dryers tissues, coffee all in the room with the refrigerator that was clean. Every single thing was clean., the bed was very comfortable... the other hotels we stopped along the way on our road trip were at best OK but when we woke up and had eggs sausage potatoes, waffles, cereal, yogurt, fruit toppings, a clean area to eat our breakfast gluten-free options. making one less stop on our road trip from Ohio that would cost us a fortune for breakfast was a happy surprise. it was easy check out as well. the next time we come this way the best Western in at this location in Ohio will be where we are staying...

Avoid Best Western Mt. Gilead - Family Turned Away at 2am, Forced to Sleep in Parking Lot…read moreBooked a room with 2 beds last-minute (11:50pm) through Hotels.com for a late arrival while driving as the only adult/parent with my four young kids (ages 7-12) from Nashville. Arrived exhausted at 2am. Front desk refused us the room, citing occupancy limits. Solo parent with small children -- splitting rooms wasn't safe or realistic. We had no choice but to sleep in their parking lot which the front desk manager knew and let happen. I understand policies exist and even understand why we were ultimately turned away. What I don't understand is the complete lack of flexibility, compassion, or basic problem-solving for a family in a tough spot at 2 in the morning. No alternatives offered (despite what they might say happened as no additional room or discount was available or offered as an alternative option). No goodwill. Just "policy." Worse, the hotel and corporate continue to refuse any refund even though we received nothing for the booking. Paid for a room we were denied and no alternative options were available or offered. We booked at 11:50pm same night so we know we didn't displace or keep anyone else from booking this room. Best Western claims to cater to travelers and families -- this experience proves otherwise. Cold, rigid, and indifferent when it mattered most. This seems to be the common review when it comes to people's interactions with this staff and management. Hospitality is not just about enforcing policies. It is also about how guests are treated when something goes wrong. In this situation, the management showed no compassion, judgment, or willingness to help a family in a difficult position. I would not recommend this property to families or anyone arriving late at night. I hope people read these reviews and warnings and don't make the same mistake I made.

Starting with a last minute accommodation and check in with Emma to a "go way beyond service"…read moreexperience from Brie. We ere impressed. Note, this property needs some live and care, but the people made the difference. I left a personal item at the hotel. Brie hunted it down, kept me informed and made sure my item was ready for a FedEx pick up. The ownership of this property should know their folks take care of their guests well. Thanks Brie for making my day! Much appreciated.

If you like cold showers, stained towels and a little mold hiding under the sink, then this is the…read moreplace for you! Bad smells, dirty floors and missing furniture also come along with your room with no extra charge! Clogged sink, tv that won't connect and no WiFi will give you a chance to really unwind! It's almost embarrassing that a company paid for my room here and I actually stayed.

Looking for a place to stay for the night, this place was 2/3 of the way to our destination. Make…read morethe turn by Bob Evans and then there is a road that leads to the hotel. Our room was clean and spacious. There was sufficient outlets to charge devices. Microwave and refrigerator (large one by hotel standards) present. Coffee and tea bar available 24 hours. Good hot breakfast and on this day crispy bacon which was appreciated. Nice touch having sealed cups by the water fountain near the elevator on the first floor. There is a small business center as well as fitness center. Service was friendly.

Terrible service with front desk lady's, my sentences were cut off, they were extremely rude to me…read moreand my party, one person in my party also in a meeting and they failed to accommodate to that. Very little to no effort to do their job and that's where the landscaping people stepped in and did it for them. They shouldn't have had to do 2 jobs at once but unfortunately with this staff they had to. No appreciation for military members I guess..

Positive: Conveniently located off I-71 close to a few fast food places and a country style buffet,…read morehotel has standard American breakfast spread, and onsite what looks like a fun pool/water park for kiddos.. Staff was pleasant and accommodating. Negative: If you have animal allergies AVOID this place, the smell of dog dander is very overwhelming. Rooms especially the carpet needs completely remodeled, the carpet was musty and felt sticky under shoes with socks it was filthy. One of our queen beds had a used lottery ticket in between the sheets. The shower head is very low, Im 5'4" and it was barely above my head. The bathroom sink was very slow draining . You can hear TV/neighbors conversations in the rooms (kids yelling etc.) Its not the worst place to stay but at 139.00 a night, Ive stayed at much cleaner for far less. Update your property.

I was a little nervous to visit after seeing some of the pictures and reviews- even brought my own…read moresheets and towels- but we had a great time. We were able to pay $35 and check in at 1pm, the room was clean. The pool was clean and a comfortable temperature it is a little bit old but everything worked fine and the kids had a blast. The free breakfast was great - warning it was a lot of food with dyes and sugar but I think that's the norm everywhere. They do charge $75 for any late check out - even 15 min which seems absurd considering the room was $67. If you get a room facing the harbor (indoor pool) it is very loud until 10pm if you have young kids with bedtimes I'd request a room that faces the parking lot. The train resturaunt on the top of the hill was very cute and my son Loves trains - closes at 4! The taco restaurant has a good happy hour and strong margarita.

When we arrived we were told to give them a few minutes to check in we walked the hall to check…read morepool, in the meantime we received some news and we should head back home, I asked to cancel and the front desk girl says why would you do that, and said it's to late, I called 800# and they called to ask to cancel our room, they would not, we we ended up staying in the OLD Hotel, very old needs some updates sooner than later, when we went to our room there was garbage in the hallway, that same garbage was still there the next day, the pillows are like having empty pillow cases, they are so worn out you sink right through, We had someone else's hair tie on our floor & wrapper, the shower could use a good cleaning. The friendliest person there was the lady who does breakfast, but then even Miss grabby came and got her. I would recommend not staying here, if they just would have realized there is a reason this person is trying to cancel the room so hard and canceled, it would have saved them and us a headache.

Amazing staff, clean rooms, breakfast was good. Shout out to Manager Pam! We were there for Tiffin…read moreGraduation and she went above and beyond to steam my sons and other graduates gowns the day before! I say they are an A+ service

I visited from Las Vegas, Nevada over the weekend. This hotel is beautiful, well maintained and…read morequiet. Cameron at the front desk was kind, professional and accommodating. This is the first time I have stayed at this hotel, but I will definitely stay here again.

Friendly staff, clean room, nice Continental breakfast, and decent pool. It's a little off the…read morebeaten path, but worth staying here.