Best pizza around. Awesome cheese steaks too . Haven't had a chance to try anything else yet read more

Food is so good. I pickup on my way home from work. Give them a call. People eating in store too. ! read more

The big draw for this place is that the child of the owner is on the show "Stranger Things" on Netflix. The Suns are really good. We got the Veal Parmesan, the Chicken Philly and a meatball sub. They were all fabulous. The meats were flavorful, hot and tasty. The bread... omg, the bread is spot on! Crispy on the outside nice and fluffy on the inside. They are large and filling and worth every Penny. We also had gotten an all meat pizza. This was not as amazing. It was very salty. It would be nice if they had some meats that weren't salted for the winter. The crust was just ok. The sauce not very memorable. So, while others may like their pizza, I will be sticking with the subs. They are certainly worth the drive. Also, the woman who took our order screwed it up. I had said several times that I wanted the chicken cheesesteak and she ordered a regular cheesesteak. This simple mistake meant that one person in our family had nothing to eat because she has diabetes and can not eat anything else. Considering that I said, specifically FOUR times that I wanted the chicken cheesesteak it is frustrating to not be heard. They did offer to drive us out a replacement sub, but we live 30 minutes away and my sister didn't want to wait that long. They did give her a free Sun the next time we came in so she was VERY happy about that. One last criticism, my sister ALWAYS asks for well done fried onions and they have yet to do it. Even when the owner says "burn the onions" they won't. Aside from that though, this place is very good. read more

For 50$ it really is not what was expected!! Ordered a grandmas 1/2 pepperoni. Very, very greasy and bland. Also ordered hot wings with extra ranch and blue cheese, the order only had 7-8 very small wings for 12$ also did not get the extra ranch and blue cheese that I paid for. Trial and error process for eating pizza in this area, better luck next time. Thank You! read more

I've only had the pizza so far; we live 20 mins away and drive past 4-5 local pizza places just to get this pizza. Finally, a pizza in the area with FLAVOR!! my husband literally said when we tried our first pizza "this is what I remember pizza being" because when we moved to Mays Landing we have not been fully satisfied by pizza in 5 years! Thank you Matarazzos for filling our pizza void!! read more

From the first bite, I was in heaven. First evening trying our town's new Italian restaurant and each dish was truly delicious! They even sent a NICE treat along with it. Not to mention the delivery driver was kind and awesome. We can't wait to have their food again. Now the question is, how is their pizza? Coming from an Italian/scottish/American household over here. read more

Average pizza, cooked nice crispy. Little on the greasy side. Cannolis we're pretty good

My first time here. The pizza was good. Nice sauce. But I do have some complaints. They were very skimpy with the toppings. At least that's how my two pizzas were. The sausage was placed sporadically and sparingly. Not worth the extra $$. Also ordered a cheesesteak.....they do not put a lot of meat between the bread. They need to do a better job chopping up the meat as well. It was very tough to chew. To the owner: You have good crust & sauce. Need to be a little more generous on the toppings. Especially the sausage. read more

Got the chicken cutlet Neapolitan style sandwich and it was insanely good. Highly recommend ordering it when you try this place.

AMAZING CANNOLIS! I tried this place after searching for a good calzone in the area, and I am so glad I did. The calzones, pizza, sandwiches, and CANNOLIS are fresh and yummy. I recently ordered delivery and they included an incorrect item, I called and they had no problem replacing it at my convenience. Would recommend. read more

2nd time we've ordered from slice of Naples egg harbor city location. 2nd time disappointed. 1st time ordered a sausage pizza. very little sausage on it and way over cooked. figured we'd try again. this time got a pepperoni calzone and requested extra pepperoni. barely got the normal amount that you would get. also it was cold and so much crust and hardly any filling. my grandson got a burger which he didn't care for. so I feel like I wasted $12 on a burger and $24 on a calzone which I think is an outrageous price. but not all bad. my wife did enjoy her Italian sub. read more

Very good pizza and they made it they way we like it; thin crust and dark. Nice distribution and taste of sauce and cheese. The crust was nice and crunchy. Had a pie with 1/2 anchovies and 1/2 mushroom. Only minor compliant would be a better cut, we had some really small slices and really large. read more

This place is AMAZING! The family is quite pleasant & friendly (take notes, Jo Jo's-Galloway). It's imperative to support family-owned businesses. Tasty, thin crust pizza & wings. read more

Slice Of Naples - Pizza Near Me - Egg Harbor City, New Jersey

We just finished another amazing meal here. We are laws greater as soon as we walk in byy the friendly staff or the owner. We started with fried mushrooms and jalapeño poppers, both came out hot and delicious with an incredible red sauce on the side. For entrees, I got the eggplant Parmesan and was so impressed. It's clearly homemade and the eggplant is sliced thInly, breaded and fried onsite. My family got a Stromboli, pepperoni, ham, sweet peppers and a ton of cheese and a sausage, peppers and onion sandwich, both so delicious! The pizza is also fantastic here! read more

Pizza is great 9/10 times, although sometimes undercooked, and not the best chicken. The pepperoni pinwheels are amazing and they have great lasagna (when they have it). Would've been 4 stars except for the fact they sometimes don't answer their phone- makes it hard to order food read more

Im my opinion Matarazzo's has the best pizza around! Delicious! & super friendly owners/employees. Great prices too! Can't wait to go back.

Came in for the weekday lunch special. I had the very tasty meatballs, sauce and pasta. It came with bread as well. The specials are$5.50 and worth a visit. customer service was great. read more

I wish I could leave negative stars. Probably the worst pizza I've eaten in a long time (should have stuck to south end) horrible customer service (girl didn't put me on hold when I called about the sauce less wings so I heard what the owner manager or whomever she was talking to said) her attitude and the fact that they wanted to pick up the wings is disgusting especially with the fact of what's going around right now... they did refund us for the 60 wings we ordered but by not returning the $$ to the CC used but in the form of cash sent by the only apologetic person, the delivery guy which had nothing to do with anything at all.. (he was tipped accordingly) won't ever order there again it was our first and last and I would have given them another try if they had any type of remorse for shitty food. Also next time don't ask me if I'd like my buffalo chicken pizza crispy if you don't know what crispy even means... so that's about the food so here's the kicker we get the order and there isn't an itemized bill we went over $100 in food and when I questioned that she said "oh we never give out an itemized bill" sooo my assumption is they are charging more then normal bc try to even find a menu for this place good luck bc their website is crap. Anyway good luck there's a better pizza place right down the pike that knows how to cook a real pizza and wings oh and they're actually nice. Good luck. Even their plain pizza is gross. read more

Slice Of Naples - Horrible wings no sauce yuck - Pizza Near Me - Egg Harbor City, New Jersey

I've ordered delivery from this place a few times and have enjoyed their salads, fries, and garlic knots. The calamari wasn't so hot and the special sandwich is good when not drowned in balsamic. BUT tonight I ordered wings and they are quite possibly the WORST wings I have ever had in my life, rubbery, burnt, if they are breaded it is mush on the outside, just terrible. They had to know when they sent them they were inedible, yet they delivered them anyway. What a disgrace. Never again. I would have told them all of this on the phone, but they didn't answer. read more

I give them zero stars! Place is a joke and food is way over priced for the quality, or lack of I should say. The staff openly complained cus I didn't order exactly off the crappy menu, then when I contacted the owner, he made it very clear he approved of their behavior and basically said get over it, well they can kiss my money and all my family's good bye and sence it was usually always empty, I'd say they needed the business. read more

Glad to have a good pizza place (that delivers!) in the neighborhood. We have tried the calzones, Stromboli, and pizza from here and it was all very good. Our new favorite spot! read more

The food is amazing, not to mention it's so close to my house. Found my new pizza joint. Very nice and family owned.

Super yummy. Some people in the reviews say it can be undercooked but I disagree. I think they sometimes overcook it but it's rare. They're normally pretty swamped with food going out for delivery. Ice cream station doesn't seem to be opening this year which stinks. Super friendly people. read more

tasted ok but made my mother very sick and I was sick also would not recommend wasting your time stopping here. maybe I ate some spit or something. had meatball sub a pizza with two toppings. NOT WORTH YOUR HEALTH EATING AND GETTING SICK read more

Fantastic! Great food and reasonable prices. Conveniently located, clean and very comfortable. Wonderful staff!

It's a hidden gem that no one really knows about. Amazing pizza, cheesesteaks are also giant and amazing. Even there homemade soups are great. Overall this place is a hidden gem in galloway and it's probably my favorite pizzeria in all of south jersey. read more

Like their New York style pizza a lot! Customer service was very nice. Pick up was fast and convenient. However, it's a bit salty for us. Maybe cut down on the salt? read more

Matarazzo's has become our new favorite pizza and takeout Italian in the area. The owner and staff are always attentive and friendly and the product is consistently great! read more

After a few more visits id like to give an update. Definetly better not worth another star though. Pizza can be on and off its usually a bit too crunchy for my liking some people may like it like that i understand i like my pizza a little on the doughy side but well cooked i want to taste the dough not just crunchy like a stale pizza but decent pizza for an area with limited restaurant especially pizza i will take it. But my gosh the cheesteaks here are amazing i mean some of the best ive had in a WHILE and ive been eating them in the philly area a lot and they habe nothing on these. The bread is amazing the cheesteak actually tastes like a cheesteak sandwich not just a plop of greasy meat on tastlesss bread with cheeze whiz. I usually dont eat a lot of cheesteaks because in this area there not very good but my gosh they know how to do a good cheesteak. Everything else ive tried like i said has been good above average but nothing to go crazy about. Great place for this area though very friendly as well. My go to spot now for sure. Also this place mazzaratos is signifugant in their menu isnt just put together like any other spot they have personality in seafood clams mussels caprese salad like what pizza joint serves that thats awesome. Totally like this place and hope they stick around for a long time. Definetly what egg harbor needs a good pizza joint/ italian that serves good food but is unique in their own way not just like any old pizza spot thats what we want good job mazzaratos. read more

Very unfriendly when I called. Won't deliver 3 miles down the road. Don't know how a pizza joint is gonna make it if they can't deliver less than 5 minutes away. Tried to support a local spot that just opened up but I guess that won't be happening now. read more

I have only ordered form here once, so this may not be typical. The delivery took half an hour longer than originally quoted, and when it got here one of the sandwiches was wrong. Everything was good, it just wasn't what I ordered and it was late. read more