If you are looking for a little piece of New York where you can buy a slice, this is it! These guys are cranking out all sorts of pies all the time. We loved the variety. I visited this place a few times and sampled several pies. My favorite was the Soppressata Hot Honey. Yum! And, if you are gluten free, they have this incredible dough they offer which my wife says tastes fantastic! But, you will need to order a whole personal pie. And don't forget the dessert. I tried one of their bombolone and it was fantastic! All of this great food was found in a quaint, but lively, little shop at the end of an alley. And the guys behind the counter were always friendly and ready to guide you through your pizza journey. So go ahead and venture off the beaten path and you will not be disappointed. read more

Genius Concept A pizza by the slice shop is honestly brilliant when you just want something quick without committing to a whole pie. The variety here is incredible, from simple classics to fully loaded, ingredient-packed slices. Pricing Plain slices feel a little pricey, but the specialty, loaded slices are definitely worth it. Considering it's on Fifth Avenue South, the prices make sense. You're not walking out feeling ripped off. Fresh and Fast Service Slices are constantly fresh, and they bring your food right to your table. Hot, fresh, and ready to enjoy. Plus, they have seasonings on the side so you can customize. Marketing and Vibes The pink theme is amazing and makes the place feel fun and super Instagram-worthy. Temperature and AC Situation It gets very hot inside. I love the open-air seating concept, but in the summer it's brutal. AC vents don't seem to do much, and there aren't fans running, so brace yourself. Customer Service Not the friendliest vibe when I asked a couple questions. I get it, it's a quick-stop spot, not a fancy restaurant, but a friendly smile never hurts. With the heat, it kinda makes sense why staff might be a little rushed. Cleanliness Bathrooms are super clean, which is always a huge plus. Overall Rating Fun, unique, quick slice spot with tons of options. Fresh, hot slices, cute marketing, minor heat and AC issue, and slightly rushed service balance out to four stars. read more

See all

I only had a pizza slice- pepperoni -- but I was absolutely delicious. there were too many options -- a great problem read more

Slice Shop - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

I thought this place was pretty good. It's nice to have a good slice shop in the area. Definitely on the higher price point. But I will say you're getting a very large slice for that price. So that made it a little bit more palatable. The dough was good. Close to New York style, but still not being in New York. I think I'm over the hot honey on pizza idea. Overplayed. The service is nice. The place is clean. The decoration is good. Lots of seating. The Cesar chicken pizza was good and special out of NY but too much dressing read more

See all

Great Pizza. Tons of options Will be back before we leave. Having Lunch and will be coming back for Dinner read more

Always delicious and the people working there are so kind. Every time we come to Naples we eat here every day that we are in town. Keep doing a great job. read more

See all

Incredible pizza! I've eaten here twice and the first time was better than the last. This is one of the defining qualities of a good restaurant. I highly recommend the Sicilian Slice, the Jam, and the Booch but I'm sure all of their pizza is incredible. I look forward to my next visit. Don't miss it! read more

Slice Shop - Sicilian Slice - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

The Slice Shop Pizzeria has officially opened its doors in Downtown Naples, Florida. I had the opportunity to sample their offerings, and I must say, it comes remarkably close to authentic NY Style Pizza. In fact, the owner hails from Long Island. They provide a wide array of handcrafted and specialty pizzas, ranging from the classic NY Style Slice to the Truffle Mushroom Slice, along with many others... The establishment is conveniently located just behind 5th Ave. The Shop features both indoor and outdoor seating options. This is a must-visit for those seeking NY Style Pizza. Parking can be somewhat challenging, particularly in the downtown area, but patience is advised. read more

See all

Super cute pizza shop with a huge selection in the heart of downtown Naples. The only reason I'm not giving it a five stars is because I was absolutely floored when my total was over $8 for a slice of pizza. The staff is extremely friendly and welcoming, decor is adorable, and the selection can't be beat. I just don't know if I'd return at these prices. I can't imagine what a whole pie would cost! read more

Slice Shop - Decor - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

Absolutely loved going to slice shop! The chicken Caesar salad pizza was my number one pick and I was thoroughly impressed. The crust still kept crunchy even with the sauce and salad on top. I also got the Burrata pizza which had a great deep dish crust. Some of my family members got some other ones like sesame Thai chicken and vodka pizza which were all equally delicious. There were seats when we went midday on a Sunday and the patio is such a nice place to sit. The service was quick and efficient. I highly highly recommend this place. read more

See all

My grandson told me about the place we checked it out after one of our fishing trips and I'd say possibly the best pizza in Southwest Florida. Very good and great service I would be a repeat customer. read more

Slice Shop - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

Great addition to 5th Avenue! Line was out the door at this cute trendy pizza shop with lots of fun offerings! Mac and cheese pizza, Buffalo chicken, deep dish, flatbread and more! Ample seating and an efficient process made the experience go smoothly. You order at the counter either to go or sit at a table and the food is brought to you. The pizza was good and the garlic knots were amazing. Naples prices but a good alternative to a sit down meal especially for bigger groups or with kids. read more

See all

Literally dining next to Papa John's - the pizza has to be good, right?! We had cheese and the white pizza. The garlic knots were amazing! Actually preferred over the pizza but would like to try some other flavors next time. The only thing that made it not a 5 star experience besides the expensive prices was the fact that you don't know what types they have until you get let in (there's a pink rope you have to wait to be let in by staff) since they don't list them on their menu (just non pizza items - not sure if that's a good marketing strategy or not) and then by the time you get to the counter you feel rushed to pick something (hence why we went with the cheese and white pizza). Also, there are not many large tables. Lots of seating for 2. So we were left pulling a chair over and eating in the walkway to the exit. Cute shop. Very instagram-worthy. And the staff were helpful. We'd come back and hopefully try something new! read more

See all

I really love this place. We got a few different options and everything was delicious. The special when we went was the chicken roll and it was delicious! It's a great pizza to just get a slice. They have so many different flavors to choose from - very different flavor combos too like teriyaki pizza. It's a cool place to visit after the beach for sure. We got the chicken Cesear pizza and it was yummy. The service is pretty fast. You pick your pizza and they warm it up for you and it takes about 5 minutes. The ambiance is nice and chill, a great place for the family. read more

Slice Shop - Chicken Cesear pizza , regular cheese pizza , chicken roll - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

I am a New Yorker raised in Little Italy Manhattan NY, growing up in a real Italian community of course had a great Pizzeria, so I am not that easy to say any Pizza is good. My daughter told me about it she lives in Naples Florida and me and my Fiance came to see for ourselves, and yes it's worth it to stop by here, the quality is good.. read more

See all

Great pizza served by the slice you won't be disappointed at all eating at the slice shop

Delicious and efficient service. Very casual, seat yourself and they bring g to table. Small bar on the back. read more

Slice Shop - Delicious sausage slice & grandma! - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

Being born Italy and having lived in both Chicago and New York this place is amazing! The NY slice rivals any NY places like original Joe's in the Village and the Grandma pie is as good as King Umberto's in Elmont NY or Umberto's in New Hyde Park Long Island. The Nutella Bomboloni (Italian donut for the non-speaking Italians) was great. Highly recommend this place if you are in Naples, Florida. read more

See all

Great pizza shop off of 5th Avenue. Had the truffle slice and it was awesome. Loads of fresh, quality ingredients, mushrooms, truffle oil and wonderful parmesean cheese. Large slice with thin crust. I also had an order of the garlic knots, 2 knots. They were tender, and loaded with garlic and parmesean. They have so many choices of pre-made slices to choose from. They heat it up right away and it is hot and delicious. I can't wait to choose another slice. Fast service andbox up to go orders. It is not cheap, but neither are the ingredients or location. Great outdoor seating and inside. Nice atmosphere. read more

I got the New York pepperoni and the square grandmas vodka. Curly pepperonis are always a plus in my book, first bite was a tad soggy, the more I got into it, it got crispier. Second pizza , grandmas vodka the sauce was good the base of pizza was soggy, crust very crispy which I liked. I originally went in for their eggplant pizza but was told they didn't make it today, if it's one your menu, it should be out. Now we have to talk about price.... My bill was a tad over 17$ which I think that is outrageous for just two SLICES of pizza. I was pretty disappointed with price and hoping pizza would be worth it, but sad to say it wasn't. read more

Shop is really cute and inviting. The service was awesome and everyone worked well as a team to take orders, grab slices, check out, and clean up. We tried two daily specials - hot honey bbq and meat lovers as well as the Booch. We added in the garlic knots last minute and they were amazing. Awesome spot! read more

Slice shop's pizzas are the best! Booch pizza slice was delicious --mixed with honey. The pizza is fresh, delicious, and never disappoints. Highly recommend this place! read more

Amazing!!!!! Went in today expecting that the facebook hype might be overstated but it was just soooooo good! One slice was so filling! the combo of the pepperoni, creamy cheese and hot honey was just perfection. The crispy buttery crust was the cherry on top! I will be back!!!! read more

Slice Shop - The Booch!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

So many slices to choose from ! The person in line with me suggested anything with the vodka sauce on it so I tried one of those a regular New York thin slice the hot honey chicken and the macaroni and cheese, and they were all wonderful read more

See all

Yeah!!!! Born and raised in NY and transplanted to Naples a few years ago. After years of searching, finally a real NY pizza place in Naples. Social media called our name and we fell for it, glad we did. We have already returned for a second helping. The pizza is delicious, the real cane sugar Coca-Cola can't be beat and the atmosphere is lovely. Whether you want to sit inside or outside, you will be in a comfortable spot. We tried the Portnoy. Chicken Parm Pizza and classic NY Pizza, all were wonderful. Thanks for finally bringing real NY Pizza to Naples Florida. read more

Tasted good but mouth hurt later so maybe it's spice used. Hope this helps. Sorry, I wish it were all good. read more

Slice Shop - Pizza that tastes ok on the way down but later mouth was burning :-( - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

We stopped here with our four kids on a busy Friday night. We were able to get a seat and wow did we enjoy it! Our kids loved it as much as we did. We had the kale Caesar with chicken, tried a variety of slices of pizza and the meatball starter was incredibly delicious. My daughters especially loved the truffle pizza. The had a fluid line of people ordering and the staff was kind. We will absolutely be back! read more

overall, I think their pizza is pretty good. I've been here three times. The sauce is a little rich for me and as a result, one slice is always more than enough for me. That being said I had no other options today as I was running fast so I decided to stop in and got a regular New York slice of Margherita I just felt that $9.01 is a little expensive for a slice of regular margarita . You be the judge. read more

Slice Shop - $9.01 Slice. Very good but not for the $$. - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

Heard and read many comments about the Slice Shop so I decided to stop there today for a slice. It did not disappoint! Slice Shop offers an incredible assortment of pizzas, both triangle and square, with just about any topping you might desire. I'm a simple guy and really prefer just pepperoni and cheese. Slices uses cup 'n char pepperoni, my absolute favorite. Ordered a slice (about $8, but remember this is Naples and it's 5th Avenue. Because the shop was so nice looking (and incredibly clean) I decided to eat it there. They give you a number when you pay and they bring it out to you when it's heated. It was one of, possibly the best slices I've had in Florida. It's a little bit expensive (remember: Naples, 5th Ave) but still represented a good value. I'll definitely be back. read more

This cute hidden gem pizza shop located in Naples was absolutely fabulous. We were greeted by the owner Rob, who was very attentive and nice. I informed him it was our first time here! My husband ordered a buffalo pizza and I ordered a margarita slice in which both were so fresh and delicious. The pizza's were just right not too crispy nor not too soft. Great pizza sauce and cheese flavor taste. There are a variety of different kinds to choose from. The inside colors and decor is very elegant. Definitely will come back again! And Thank you Rob for the experience and keep up the amazing work you guys are doing! read more

Finally made it to Slice Shop off 5th south. I'll preface my review by saying I was more than skeptical about $9 slices. I know it's Naples, but $9 a slice is still pushing the envelope (unless you have a captive audience- i.e. entertainment venue). The selection was huge. It wasn't just different toppings, but tons of completely different styles of pies. For a guy that loves different styles, it was right up my alley. It doesn't matter if it's a greek style, neapolitan, Sicilian, Detroit or Chicago etc. If it's done well with quality ingredients, I'm gonna enjoy it. That said, I generally gravitate towards thicker, lighter crusts being my favorite. I had to try at least least two different kinds. I ended up going with the burrata and the chicken vodka. I did order them to go. But in fairness, I didn't want them sitting in the box long. So like the fat bastartd I am, I ended up scarfing them down in my car within a minute of them coming out of the oven. I had the burrata first. It was excellent. The flavors were all on point. I'm a big burrata fan. Generally whenever I see it offered on a menu, especially on pizza, I get it. I honestly don't think it could have tasted any better. The only thing that could have been improved upon was the temp. It was really just a hair above room temperature. I watched her put it in the oven. It came out in about 2 minutes. It honestly wasn't hot at all. And this was eating it within a minute of it coming out of the oven. I'm guessing it prob needed 2-3 more mins in the oven. Next was the Chicken vodka. While this one also looked appealing in the display case, I probably wouldn't normally have been one of my top choices cause I'm not a huge vodka sauce guy. But I saw the guy put a whole pie out fresh right in front of me. So I decided I wanted to try it at it's freshest. Knowing that I might be a little bias against this one, I was ready to be a little underwhelmed. But it also was excellent! This slice was enormous. Not only was it a large slice, I've never eatin a heartier slice of pizza in all my life than this chicken vodka slice. I sh*t you not, the slice I had contained at least an entire chicken breast worth of meat! I enjoyed the panko breading. You would think that it was too much chicken. But the flavors all worked together excellently. It was well balanced. For not being a vodka sauce guy, it was the best vodka slice I have ever had. Again, the only thing that was lacking was the temp. It obviously was in the oven the same length of time as the first slice. It only took me a few mins to eat the burrata slice, so this one was right at room temperature when I ate it. That said, it was delicious enough that it didn't even need to be hot for me to thoroughly enjoy it. Sure, if it was actually hotter it would've been even better. But I was seriously blown away with the flavor and quality of ingredients in both of these pies. All this said, I have to eat some humble pie when it comes to the criticism of the $9/slice price point. I wholeheartedly believe these slices are worth nine dollars each. The chicken vodka pizza was plentiful enough to be a full meal in and of itself. I am a guy that can eat four slices of a large pie relatively easily. It had been seven hours since I had lunch. I was pretty hungry. But these two slices completely stuffed me! Although we're generally only in Naples 6 months of the year (Nov-April) I had to come back for a few days this week for a quick work trip. So I was looking forward to trying out the new places that opened up in town since we left this past May. These guys pies are so good I may be back every day this week though! One thing is for sure, I'm gonna need to exercise a lot for more this winter to compensate for all the pizza I'm going to be consuming at Slice Shop! This is a great additon to downtown Naples! Only thing keeping it from 5 starts was the temp. Next time I'll ask for it to heated up an extra couple minutes and it should be perfection. read more

See all

Yes oh yes. This place has incredible food. Pizza to be exact. So many wonderful choices to choose from. Just incredible. Enjoy!

It's not worth it So manny great pizza places around the area Don't waste you money and time on this !!! 11$for a slice!!!that's insane (and ven living in nyc for a long time never had slice of pizza as expensive as this !!!!) Don't waste you money read more

Slice Shop - No prices anywhere!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

Slice was just barely warm when served. Asked for it to be heated up. Instead they gave us two new slices. By the time they brought them back out they were burnt on the bottom and basically inedible. At $10. a slice I expected better than that. read more

The food was amazing, and love their choices of pizza. I'm sorry I have to add this, but to the comment below.. just because you can't afford good pizza. You shouldn't comment, and it's for sure not heated up buddy! But back to business, been here 2 times and it only gets better. I'll be coming back today for another round read more

Slice Shop - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

Environment is awesome! Food amazing, the owner , even better!!!!! Fresh and fast service ! read more

Slice Shop - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

ayyeee get the BOOCHHHH lots of randoms from new jersey don't know how a line works but other than that staff is lit read more

Great slice for SW Florida! Im NYC born and raised ,so Ive had alot of slices in my life. But something is off with the cheese . Its "plasticky" ,slightly squeaky especially when reheated. This could be due to poor quality cheese or they are using a good quality cheese but its not "whole milk Mozzarella"and is "pre-shredded "which hurts the melting consistency. Also not sure if temperature of ovens are hot enough as there is limited "char" to the undercarriage. This could also be due to dough fermentation techniques.The upside down slice was good as well. Not sure if they are using different sauces but this is common and all pizza sauce shouldn't be sweet,depends on the slice. I live local and would love to help them improve as I would love to see this place become a Naples institution! Would love if owner reaches out to me. read more

Lots of pizza varieties, something for everyone. Had the buffalo chicken pizza and it was really good. Reason for the rating....... HOW can you justify $5.50 for a bottle of Diet Coke!! Insane. Sorry but you lost me, don't think I will be back. read more

Great restaurant! The food is delicious. We loved the pizza, garlic knots, sub and both pasta dishes. Excellent service. Great ambiance. Also, very reasonably priced. read more

Slice Shop - Patio dining - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all