I booked them for a surprise birthday for my sister and we had a fantastic time! Captain Shari and…read moreher crew were great and so knowledgeable about the area! They played fabulous music and created such a festive environment for us. The boat was really clean too!

We had Shari and Janine as co-captains for our 4-person outing, and they were awesome! So friendly…read moreand knowledgable about the area. They answered all of our questions and gave us great history and recommendations for places, both in the Hamptons and in the city! A beautiful day out on the water. Highly recommended; we would definitely do it again, and ask for Janine and Shari!

Hands down the best thing to do on the North Fork. Erick, Hannah and Christian took 8 of us out…read moresailing for several hours on the schooner Bonnie Lynn, and it made for the most memorable, vibrant and relaxing time. Bonnie Lynn is an incredible boat, with Erick and Hannah the perfect hosts. I can't think of a better way to introduce people to, and share with them, the beauty of the North Fork. We cannot wait for next time, and neither should you.

Great experience. We had fun, very enjoyable sail. Our hosts were very kind and welcoming. Will go…read moreagain.

This was a highlight of our bougie Bachelorette party in Montauk! We rented our own private…read morecatamaran for six people for three hours. It was about $700+ after fees, tip, etc, and it was totally worth it. Our captain, Mason, was super cool. He was friendly, knowledgeable, and we felt comfortable being really annoying and weird in front of him. The sail itself was just a short ride in the bay, where we anchored close to a beach. We loved dancing on the boat, trying out the SUP board (included), basically chugging our BYOB drinks (no hard liquor allowed on board), taking pics lounging in the net, gawking at the yachts, and pretending the pool noodles were seahorses that we were riding. Bachelorette stuff! I think we had the Mon Mini boat, probably the smallest option. Included: one SUP board, bluetooth speaker, cooler, two pool noodles, the captain.

I booked the 26' catamaran for a Friday sunset cruise from 5-7pm. The catamaran was larger than I…read moreexpected. Also, the bean bag chairs were very comfortable compared to other boats. They provided two Yeti coolers and a Bluetooth speaker for music which was nice. The staff were very friendly and helpful. They helped take pictures for our group and the sailing was very smooth. I would definitely book again, probably earlier in the summer for the 3 hour cruise to be able to do the paddleboarding.

They cancelled our charter with 15 minutes notice to arrival time as we were already about to…read morearrive with a party of 15. "Mechanical issues on the charter prior." I bet. This was my plan for my 25th birthday. I had a party of 14 about to be there, and we all already paid. Beyond disappointed as this last minute cancellation has ruined my birthday and left a party of 14 in sag harbor with no backup plan since we received a final confirmation the night before. Thanks American Beauty. Not feeling beautiful.

Very nice boat ride around sag harbor with great views. David did.an excellent job telling and…read moreshowing us all the history around the area

Jon is very nice and answers texts and calls rapidly. Got a great Naish SUP board! My only…read morecomplaint was the delivery charge was $200. I got Furntiure from the city for $300 so it seemed expensive but we had no option.

Do not rent from them! -Boat started sinking the minute it…read morehit the water. -Rudder broke 100 yards off shore. -Pulley system to main sail did not work. Owner's response, "Well, she's an old boat" I gave him several opportunities to do the right thing. ie reimburse, take accountability, etc.. After 3 months he offered 10% on future rental. There's not a star rating low enough to give this review justice.

Such a great hidden gem! If you love yoga like I do, and you love the water, what a amazing…read morepairing. The water is in the bay so its calm and beautiful with lots of birds and wildlife. Cameron is the best, so helpful and made sure everyone got onto and off of their paddle boards safely. Cheryl is the teacher and owner. You can tell she loves what she does and cares about everyone. She showed us what to do ahead of time and explained just how to get ourselves ready for a fabulous class. She asked if there was anyone who was new to Paddleboarding and/or yoga and helped those who were new to the practice. We all had a very good time. Afterwards, she was helpful for those who wanted to paddle more or do additional poses. Some did headstand- on the board- wow! Just wow. Great time! Highly recommend this fabulous experience to everyone. If you are in the Hamptons (near Dockers) its a must do for you and your friends and family.

An awesome experience ! Great location to kayak and paddle board. The owner was terrific to work…read morewith.

We went out boating with Jessica (the owner of True East) and her crew for the past three summers…read more No better way to "undo" the city's chaotic living. The crew is always so accommodating and the Azimuth boat with it's three motors is a state of the art "Bentley" on the water. Can't wait to see you guys again soon

Exactly what I needed. This was one of the simplest and best charters we've ever booked. The…read moreowner was very flexible and let us switch from a half-day to a full-day with short notice. We will definitely be using them again. Great boat, great service. Thank you!

Everything, great captain and great mate. Most of the fishermen were regulars and for good reason.read more

Owner is very rude. The owner who is also the captain of the boat does not pay attention to the…read moresurrounding boats. Today 7/7/19 the boat would have hit our boat if we did not move and when we said something to the captain about him not moving the boat he was very nasty to us in front of his passengers. i do not recommend using the Shinnecock star.

SO MUCH FUN!!! I've…read morebeen Jetskiing before but I decided to surprise my cousins because they both have never been. Kevin was an AMAZING guide! He helped my cousins learn how to operate a Jet Ski properly and he was incredibly helpful out on the water as well. The Jet Ski's were Yamaha Waverunners and for a 30 minute rental the price is not bad at all. Overall I'd definitely recommend and I can't wait to get out on the water again with Peconic Water Sports!!!

We hired two boats for two hours, and we had a blast. The staff were former professional wake…read moreboarders, and the boats were brand new (literally a week old) specialized water sport boats that generate extra wake for better tubing, wake surfing, wake boarding, etc. The two staff members on each boat were patient, encouraging and polite. They gave great tips and instruction on how to wake board. Our group of 6 (aged 6 to adult) will be back!

Beautiful evening on the Bella Sophia with Captain Paul. What a relaxing cruise on a beautiful 43'…read moremotor yacht. I definitely will be doing this again.

We chartered Paul's boat for a friend's birthday and it was so much fun! Paul and Bella were great…read moreas hosts and provided snacks and sodas for the trip. They also had a speaker for us to hook up to our playlists. Overall great experience definitely recommend