The first time I went in here - to Stash Cafe' in Old Montreal - I was fairly wowed. Part of it was that this spontaneous conversation with the people at an adjacent table began and I forgot to take photos, thus I forgot what I had ordered. It was very good, though, albeit a little bit pricey, given that country-style Polish food can be had in diners in any U.S. community with a larger Polish population. Add to that service that was excellent.
Fast forward to this last visit to Stash. It was a little crowded at night, but it was crowded last time, too. I looked at the menu and decided on a sampler platter. It had four items on it. I asked the host what he recommended and he recommended the beef stroganoff, which I did not go with. Everything on the platter was somewhat ordinary, the soup was more of a broth, and the small dessert that came with the table d'hote that evening was a little flat. The beverage was drip coffee, which was fairly good. Prices have risen in line with how they've risen elsewhere, so that's moot. As for the service, there was no checking back. (Again, it was crowded, but that wasn't an excuse, eliciting the appropriate "entry level" tip.) If I needed something, which was nothing out of the ordinary, I just intercepted another employee walking by and it was provided.
I later looked at other people's Yelp photos. The presence of something dark red colored (the red cabbage) rang a bell. That's what accompanied the beef stroganoff ... and that's why a dinner there several years ago turned out to be good. It was the beef stroganoff platter that I had had in the past!
It seems there's a lot of halo effect and groupthink when it comes to reviewing Stash. This is down home Polish country cooking. It's not haute cuisine. (In a similar vein, arancini - stuffed Italian rice croquettes - which are ubiquitous in southern Italy and reasonably priced, are trendy items on this side of the Atlantic that cost quite a bit more, are not as filling, and are not as good.)
Stash can evaluate their menu items across the board. They can also be more attentive to the patrons in the restaurant, which might be challenging in a crowded restaurant in Vieux-Montreal during the peak color wave. Ratcheting up the uneven spots on the menu could easily take Stash to 4 stars. read more