Friendly staff and a great sub. Plenty of meat and good sub roll. Have had their cheesesteak in the past and wasn't impressed but this in was very good. read more

Steve & Irene's Hoagies - Super club - Sandwiches Near Me - Mayfield, Pennsylvania

Ordered a 12 inch cheese steak hoagie and when I got home, there was VERY little steak and cheese on it. For $11.25 I expected a STEAK and CHEESE hoagie. It had very little meat and cheese on it, I wish that I took a picture of it. DON'T waste your money going to this place, you will be VERY SORRY!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Steve & Irene's Hoagies - Receipt - Sandwiches Near Me - Mayfield, Pennsylvania

Steve & Irene's Hoagies (Mayfield, PA). Nov, 2024. My husband and I were visiting family in northeastern Pennsylvania over Thanksgiving, and were looking to eat something different after a few days of homemade turkey and sides. The "locals" suggested ordering take-out from this restaurant -- their favorite hoagie shop. Steve and Irene's is a mom and pop shop that has been in business for more than 40 years, and has been voted "best hoagie" in the valley for 10+ years. Nonetheless, I hesitated because they're located a few towns over, and would require someone to drive to go to pick them up. We reviewed their menu on-line, and called in an order for four 12" hoagies for four adults. The restaurant offers both 12" and 24" hoagies; they don't sell our usual smaller 6" ones. My husband ordered the Cheesesteak Special ($11.50), which includes green peppers, fried onions, mushrooms, and marinara sauce, while I chose an Eggplant Parmesan ($10.75). Others ordered a Corned Beef Reuben ($12.00), with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and thousand island dressing, and a regular cheesesteak ($10.95). In retrospect, my husband and I should've ordered only one hoagie as the quantities were large and we ending up splitting one for dinner and ate the other one the next day. Of the two, we enjoyed the Cheesesteak Special more than the Eggplant Parmesan, largely because we prefer a hoagie with A-LOT of fillings and toppings and the cheesesteak had more. That said, while the taste was good, we still would've preferred more fillings and toppings on both. Our friends enjoyed both of their hoagies. We easily called in our order, and the girl who took our order apologized that it would take 55 minutes. However, it was actually ready in only about 35 minutes. Parking was easy. Staff were friendly. We would order from this hoagie shop again. read more

See all

Disappointed Yet Again Tried giving Steve and Irene's another shot, hoping things had improved since our last visit -- unfortunately, it's only gotten worse. The sub we ordered was all bread with barely any meat. What little meat there was could only be described as pathetic. It's incredibly disappointing to pay for a hoagie and end up with a glorified loaf of bread. You'd expect a decent meat-to-bread ratio, especially from a place with a reputation for subs, but this was unacceptable. Steve and Irene's really needs to reevaluate their portions if they want repeat customers. Sadly, this was our last visit. read more

Steve & Irene's Hoagies - The lack of meat - Sandwiches Near Me - Mayfield, Pennsylvania

See all

I just had a Cheesesteak hoagie with onions & mushrooms & I think it's the BEST I've ever had, Thank You for your Delesious food's, looking forward to ordering again very soon, read more

Place has really gone down hill, soggy sandwiches with really poor quality ingredients, bread is mush and just sucks most of the time and in my opinion they are expensive. Mid at best. There are better options literally everywhere. So disappointing. Not to mention you need 4wd to get into the crumbling parking lot to pick up you overrated overpriced slop... read more

Steve & Irene's brings back the nostalgia of your childhood. This was our Friday night dinner before family camping trips. Somehow, the food tastes just like I remember it from 30 years ago. Nothing has changed. Well, except the owners, but the new owners haven't changed a thing. The place, the food, the service is all top notch. Now, when I travel back to PA and get the same hoagie I did when I was 10, every bite unlocks an old memory. Thank you for being a positive impact on my childhood and now adulthood. read more

The best needless to say more I really don't price Hoagies I just eat them and these are very good

This is a sad day, I started getting cheesesteaks from here over 40 years ago, they were the best. Coming home to the area for thanksgiving, I figured I would get one for nostalgic memories, what a disappointment. The roll was not even half filled with meat, and the price was outrageous. There are definitely better places to eat in the area. Actually, disappointed is an understatement. read more

So disappointed. Two stars...one because the bread is good and one because I did recieve the correct food in a timely manner. Thats the only good things about my experience. The guy at the front counter was pretty much a jerk. Having never been there before I had questions about the menu. The guy at the front counter seemed big seemed very annoyed that I was asking questions and really only gave 1 or 2 word answers. I felt like I was annoying him by coming in to order. All that aside this is a restaurant and I felt I should reserve judgment until I got the food. I love a good cheesesteak and sadly this was not one. The bread is soft and pillowy and pretty delightful. The problem comes that there is so little meat to bread ratio. The steak was bland and again there wasn't much of it. The hot peppers are just banana peppers. How can you call yourself a hoagie shop and not have hoagie hot pepper relish? My husband was so excited that I was stopping at this place that I had even brought an insulated carrier to bring him a 24" sub home which is 4 hours away. Unfortunately not only am I not bringing him a sub, because it's not worth it, I threw 3/4 of mine away. read more

Amazing sandwich shop. Huge selection of hot and cold sandwich's. Definitely a takeout place. They only have 3 high top tables to sit at while you wait for the food. If you didn't order ahead it's worth waiting for!! read more

Good service and an impressive variety of foods on the menu. A bit of a drive for me but I really enjoyed my lunch!

I recommend the Italian hoagie it's delicious me and my husband try and get food from here once a month

We use to order from here when I worked for a local manufacturer. The food was good and had a decent price. There hoagies are great. You can't go wrong read more

Sandwiches are good Bread is fresh wish there just more meat added . Staff is nice and helpful read more

Got a few italian hoagies from here. Very good and good price. Also got a burger. Very good and great price.

Very delicious sandwiches tailor made for your preferences. Katy was very personable welcoming us and taking our orders. Sandwiches were prepared quickly and exactly to order. Their cheese steak selection has something for everyone. read more

Don't advertise that you're open until 8pm if you stop taking orders at 745. If you're open until 8, you don't start cleaning until 8. Or if you take a chance, you might get burned. You have one mightily pissed off customer now. But you probably don't care. The workers in the store didn't read more

Went to this place or ordered from quite a bit. Got a steak and cheese today, 24", had barely any steak on it. Paid $20 for mostly bread. Even my wife asked where all the meat was. Maybe it was the cook today or something else. I know prices are up, but the amount of meat on a $20 sandwich was ridiculous read more

Ok have been giving them the benefit of the doubt. But this is the last straw. I have been hearing a lot around town that this place is going downhill. The last few times it was not that great. But last night I got a cheesesteak I asked for extra cheese. Did not get extra cheese the meat was so dry it was like beef jerky definitely the worst cheesesteak I've ever had. It's a shame this place used to be good. I would no longer recommend going here. Unless they have a sign out that says under new management!!!!! Also don't water the chicken fingers they are more like chicken nuggets now all breading they suck!!!! read more

Horrible to their employees , and they have the same frozen crap Sheetz does but they just upcharge . Last time I ate here , I spent triple what I would spend at Sheetz for the same junk and last time my daughter went there , there was barely any meat on her cheesesteak. read more

This place used to have the best hoagies, but now, I'm not so sure...Just got a 12 inch Italian and a pizza. Ordered extra sauce on the pizza but it was dry. And take a look at this pic, a few slices of ham on my Italian, and not much else... read more

Steve & Irene's Hoagies - Dry pizza and a ham and bread sandwich. $22 for this? Booo - Sandwiches Near Me - Mayfield, Pennsylvania

See all

I grew up eating Steve and Irene's hoagies and they have never let me down. I have yet to find another hoagie shop that beats this place. I have tried many of their hoagies throughout the years and I have always been impressed. My family's favorite has been the Steak and Cheese Special. Two of my favorites are the Italian and the California Steak and Cheese. The menu features a very wide selection of hoagies, so you are bound to find something to fulfill your cravings. The wings are also very good, my favorite is the honey mustard! I have never once in all the years I have been ordering from here eaten at the shop, it is definitely more of a place to get take out. The building is very small with not much space to eat inside. They now have online ordering, which helps to make the whole take out process a breeze. The prices are great especially for the amount of food you get. A large hoagie is 2 feet long and priced between $10 - $15. I'm always sure to make a stop here when I come to NEPA. I highly recommend you give it a try! PS: To all my Philly friends, yes, in NEPA it is called a steak and cheese, not a cheesesteak! read more

Steve & Irene's Hoagies - California Steak and Cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Mayfield, Pennsylvania

Steve and Irene's is terrific! We have tried a number of things on the menu and we have yet to be disappointed. These guys really think outside the box when it comes to their specials. Idk who thought to put cranberry mayo on a steak sandwich (don't hate) but I appreciate your ingenuity! And The Gobbler is one of my hubby's favorite hot subs ever. read more

The hoagies are always delicious here. You can get 2 foot subs and the monthly specials are really creative. This business is a community staple. read more

There's subs are bussin i live poop fart caca ye ye ye ye ahahahahgaahhahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahah

Top 3 cheesesteaks ever! "hole in the wall" for sure but dang the food is good. Fantastic buns/ rolls for the sandwiches.

Their hoagies were outstanding a few years ago but have gone downhill. - a slice or two of meat & a slice of cheese. They need to realize that the onions, lettice and tomatoes go on top, not on the bottom of a hoagie. They are many other places that make a better hoagie. read more

Always the best service. The Hoagies are by far and wide the best in the area! The place hasn't changed their recipes in years, I have been ordering here since I was a child and you always know what to expect when it comes from Steve & Irenes! read more

For takeout they definitely provide some excellent options. I love the Kate's Special so much I will sometimes make my own version with hummus I get from from Mediterranean in downtown Scranton. Cheesesteaks are pretty good too with some cool and original variations. read more

Great hoagies and the absolute best hot wings. Check Facebook for daily soup specials

After Grace's Hoagies closed, I thought I'd never find a good steak and cheese hoagie again. Then I discovered this place (and I have no idea how I missed it before). The hoagies are HUGE (just like Grace's were) - a large is two feet long. The prices are really decent and the food itself is high quality and delicious. I love the California steak and cheese! I've had a few variations of the turkey hoagies as well, and I've always been impressed. Even though the main draw is the hoagies, the appetizers are good, too, but not nearly as amazing as the hoagies. I love that you can order online - it makes life so much easier. You definitely can't stop by and eat in, since the inside is so small, and there's not a lot of waiting room if you don't order ahead. However, this is probably the best hoagie shop in NEPA. Try it at least once! read more

This is an absolute gem in a remote location. Foot long or 24" size heroes. They call them hoagies, but other than that, everything else is fine. I ordered the foot long chicken cheesesteak with onions and peppers and wanted to order a second one before I finished the first. Value here is through the roof. read more

Ever since the roof issue a few years ago it has gone hill BADLY.. Take out orders are often incorrect, meat sliced so thin that when its heated it turns to shredded cardboard, and veggies dont seem fresh. Its sad because it used to be sooo good but after at least a dozen tries since then I now give up read more

I ordered takeout from here this evening. I Got a steak & cheese and an order of cheddar bacon ranch fries. The steak and cheese was pretty good. The bun was very fresh and it tasted like a bun from National Bakery. The fries were very soggy. This may have been because they were in a Styrofoam box and there was condensation. It ruined the fries, I think if I ate them their or if I lived closer, they would have been fine. Also, the ranch seasoning was a bit overpowering. Next time, I'll only get ranch dressing on the side. Overall, I'd say the food was pretty good and prices were fair. I'll come back eventually, but being in Mayfield, it is kind of far for hoagies. read more

Two employees behind the counter had their masks under their chin. The kitchen had a black curtain hiding it from view, so hopefully they were wearing their masks. I heard a lot of good things about this place, so I ordered an Italian hoagie. What a disappointment! The hoagie was very generic tasting as if made by a novice. Save yourself the disappointment and go elsewhere. read more

This was a pleasant surprise! We happened to be in the area and wanted lunch from a local place and not a fast food chain. We ordered a cheesesteak and some Cajun fries. All we can say is it was great! A huge amount of meat in the hoagie and fries were way more than we could eat. Everything tased so good, wished we lived closer to get this more often. read more

Best hoagies ever. Never had a bad sandwich or side. Would definitely recommend the cheesesteak. Kind of weird hours some nights but I'm willing to work around them! Yum! read more

I'm a regular customer but the last 2 times I ordered was disappointing. Tonight they forgot to add an item I paid for and the buns were huge... over came the meats inside. I was not satisfied at all. Especially when you pay for items you don't get in your order. I've heard the same from friends . Seems likee they are slacking a bit. read more

The large hoagies are seriously LARGE! One large is about the size of 4, six inch hoagies. But their prices are still average to anywhere else. Such a great deal! They have so many interesting combinations to choose from, and it's less than 50 cents to add additional toppings like peppers, mushrooms, etc. read more