I just had the Thursday cheeseburger special for dinner and it was fantastic! its not the thin uniformly thin burger joint burger, either. It's thicker in the middle and my suspicions were confirmed because I asked..they make the burgers by hand on site. There's a huge taste difference compared to other places . I'll add that there was a nice roll of equal proportion to the burger, not a 90% bread 10% burger combo. I know the Friday fish is great too. I had it but didn't write a review. I thought she was joking when she gave me the bill and I don't mean it was too much. read more

Lovely breakfast spot and diner. Extremely cost effective. Tasty food. Welcoming staff. I'd definitely come back here. It is small so come early before the rush. I didn't get a sticky bun but it looked really good from a distance. read more

See all

Solid food all around - but the sticky bun French toast is perfection. Whatever you do, get at least a side of that to go with whatever else. Service was good, but they were pretty slammed while we were there. read more

Sticky Bun Cafe - Grand Slam! With sticky bun French toast. - American Near Me - Yeagertown, Pennsylvania

See all

My wife and I decided to go here on a Sunday morning for a quick breakfast. This is a no frills small diner in rural Pennsylvania. First the positives: the staff were friendly and responsive, prices extremely reasonable, and the food was tasty and of good portion - especially the pancakes that my wife had but are not pictured. The not so positives: our order was missing requested items (staff did immediately address), the rye "toast" was under done (more bread than toast), the entire place is in need of TLC, especially the carpet which is so soiled that it should be replaced. The bathroom was clean but rundown. Overall, a mom and pop location that offer good food and that is in need of some TLC. The decor and aesthetic condition has not changed since the pandemic. The current owners are approaching their 2nd anniversary in February 2026. With some refreshing this could be a go to top choice. One final note, I asked for hot sauce for my eggs and stated the hotter the better. Nice tasting, but what a kick. I was warned read more

See all

Love the food here. Small place, big flavor! Food is delicious and dining area is clean. Service is fast and servers are friendly. Here's what we ordered: - Mess: 3 eggs, ham, bell peppers, onions, and home fries, cooked together and topped with American cheese, served with toast. - Grand Slam: 3 eggs, home fries, sausage, and Sticky Bun French Toast - oatmeal - (not pictured) Scrapple Highly recommend. read more

See all

I made the mistake of skipping the free breakfast at the local Super8 motel for this. I fear that was a clear step down. The eggs over easy came out scrambled. Neither cook nor waitress seemed to have noticed. With only 2 customers, I can't even say they were under much pressure. None of the food had seen a grain of salt in its making. The sticky bun, for which the place is named, even though it was swimming in syrup, was dry and stale. There's no way it had been made that day. It's clear there's no competition here or this place would not have survived. read more

My 3 friends and I came here for breakfast. Simple, no frills. Great friendly service. Fantastic coffee, wonderful breakfast. Everyone loved it. If you just want good food and coffee, come here. read more

We had breakfast here this am. The place is a great little diner. It's not fancy but the food is good hot and fast. The customer service is great and it's a friendly environment and lots of locals!! I would totally come here again. I forgot to take pictures but the sticky bun is deff not small! read more

Sticky Bun Cafe - Sticky bun. - American Near Me - Yeagertown, Pennsylvania

Local old school breakfast place. Food was okay but pretty bland. Seems to be a local favorite. But not for me.

12/2025 Ate at the Sticky Bun Cafe for the first time in a couple of years - since they got a new owner. Their soups of the day were Taco soup or Chicken Rice. I ordered Chicken Rice and was surprised that it contained cumin. Not a normal ingredient for Chicken Rice soup. I am wondering if a busy kitchen worker threw cumin in the Chicken Rice rather than the Taco soup. I just ate the crap and didn't say anything as I was with someone else. Either way, IF I go there again and something is that messed up, I will send it back. read more

This is my absolute favorite breakfast place! You can't beat the price and the food is high quality! I love getting their eggs Benedict for only $7.00 and the sticky bun French toast is to die for! read more

Love the people and the service. They are all like family. The prices are great and the food is great. Im there just about every day.

the food was incredible. I recommend the grand slam. plenty of food for the great price, almost too much food. the ambience was cozy and warm. the staff was very kind and the service was outstanding. highly recommend as it's a great place to go for a cozy morning meal. read more

The staff were friendly and super accommodating. The food was delicious especially the sticky bun french toast. Great prices overall. A nice little mom and pop cafe! read more

The food was good. Do NOT go for service. The ladies were not kind and we didn't even get greeted when we came in. It was our first time and we didn't know to wait or just seat ourselves. read more

This place gave such a cute, cozy diner feel. ABSOLUTELY one of the All-day best breakfast places in the area. The servers are so nice and friendly and the overall service was wonderful. read more

One of the best places one can go for a great good quality breakfast! Staff are very nice and food is always fresh and tasty! This nice eatery is one you should definitely come to to eat. There are many options to choose from on the menu and each is a good portion size and very filling. Prices are very good and the food quality is exceptional! The dish to try is for sure the Sticky bun, which is very tasty and sweet. The meals and other options are very good as well Come to this place whenever you are in the area. It is a great place with god food and amazing service. read more

See all

Service was the worst part of my visit. Half of our meal was not prepared the way we ordered it. Server could of cared less. It wasn't anything special. Everything came out hot and in good time. Flavor was good on some and bland on others. Everything is made from scratch. This is a small little place. Menu is really selection is fair. It more set up for breakfast.i would come back. Un fortunately i was not in a good mood when i came in. I wasn't any happier when i left. Lol read more

Sticky Bun Cafe - Inside dinning area - American Near Me - Yeagertown, Pennsylvania

Good breakfast, coffee in hand immediately upon arrival. Great local atmosphere, almost a "Cheers!" feel to it ("everybody knows your name!"). Sticky Buns very tasty. read more

First things first: the sticky buns are excellent. In fact, I put them in the top five that I've ever had. Large, soft, gooey but not disgustingly sugary...mmm. Get them with nuts. The menu is standard diner/country breakfast grub, but they make it taste good without excess grease. I didn't care for the toast, which was thick and light which made it seem too dry, even stale. The orange juice has an artificial taste to it. The service is satisfactory, and the interior is a quaint, pleasant country theme. read more

I found this little place while traveling and seeking coffee. Glad I found it. Great sticky buns. Great coffee. Nice people. read more

Sticky Bun Cafe...who goes to a place with such a name and not order the sticky bun? I do BUT I made sure my husband did :) thank God that I didn't because truly these buns ARE by far the BEST sticky buns I have ever had. I wanted to stop eating it but I couldn't...sooo good but so bad for you with all that yummy syrup and delicious flavor from top to bottom. I won't even review anything else because who cares???? This place is amazing! read more

Oh ma! I love this place. I really have nothing bad to say about it. Here is what to expect along with a tip or two. Great service. Great ownership. Food is perfectly cooked and reasonably priced. This is diner style food as it is cooked. But it is in a homestyle fashion meaning not as greasy. The atmosphere is small and homey. At 36, I am typically the youngest person at a table. The real treat are the desserts. This place has the best sticky buns and whoopie pies in town. I also recommend the breakfasts but it is fairly hard to screw up a breakfast. I love this restaurant for everything it is and is not. It is a great local small town country restaurant and while many people swear by the Honey Creek Inn, I favor this one for its variety and baked goods. read more

Great breakfasts, I haven't tried anything else. The sticky buns are a meal unto themselves so be prepared to take one home if ordered on the side. Good, friendly service. Small place with lots of parking. read more

Stopped into the Sticky Bun today for lunch. I really enjoyed this place. It's small, but homey and the waitress was super nice and did a great job. The patty melt was the special for the day so I decided to have that. While it was a lot like any patty melt you get anywhere, I really enjoyed it and I really liked seeing the interaction with the customers and the waitress. It was clear they were regulars and always happy with their food. Although I usually don't get dessert, I couldn't resist at this place. I ended up taking some to go. Yes more than one! Everything looked so good and made in house so I loaded up the fridge. They had cream puffs. I've not seen homemade cream puffs anywhere forever so I had to get two. The were HUGE. I didn't realize else one would have been more than enough. I'll be eating on those for a few days. I also got a piece of sugar cookie cake that was amaze balls . I finished it up with a piece of chocolate layer cake with peanut butter icing. All are so good. I can't wait to go back and try more things! read more

I really like this place, but I like diner/country comfort food. I loved the homemade wheat toast that came with my eggs, homefries and scrapple platter, which was $5.35. And you can get breakfast all day, which I love. The coconut cake was awesome, and you can get homemade whoopie pies and cookies as big as your head. The chicken and waffle special is pretty good on Wednesdays, the waffles have a nice light, fluffy texture. read more

Typical small town hick. I walked in for the first time and the person behind the counter just stared at me. No greeting, just awkward silence. The few customers there just kept staring. I stated it was my first visit and was looking at the menu. No response. This place didn't seem very clean to me as I looked around. The person behind the counter seemed a bit unkempt and sloppy. No customer service, I turned around and walked out. read more

This is a local favorite with many items on the menu that are common in Mifflin county. What stands them apart from other country restaurants in the area are their homemade sticky buns, breads, and desserts. If you like homemade bread, their homemade wheat toast is a really good! They are not open Sundays. Also, they have daily specials that the locals enjoy such as ham pot pie, chicken and waffles and fried haddock. That type of food is not to my liking, but very popular around here. read more

Very good soups and great sticky buns. The wheat bread, toasted and slathered with butter, is tasty read more

Best patty melt I've ever had. Went there with family. Staff was very friendly. My husband had a cheese burger. He said it was excellent. Shared cheese fries which were amazing. And great portions uncle in law had chicken fingers and a bacon cheese burger, was very good. Great portions and great prices! We went home very satisfied. They are very accommodating The wait staff is awesome. the cook was a sweetheart. Her name is sandy. She was very nice and by far the best employee there. We see her often, there at this restaurant, and always has a smile on her face. I always tip this cook just because of how nice and such a great cook she is. Would recommend if you go there and see her to talk to her. She will brighten your day. And will do her best to make your order as perfect as you want it ! Always remember when you go to tip the waitress to remember the cook:) Would recommend to anyone. Will be back over and over again with family. Overall one of the best restaurants in the area. read more

Great soup, delicious fish sandwiches and homemade whoopie pies and bread! Good find near State College! The coconut cream pie is amazing!

Local cafe with very friendly service. Western omelet was great with fresh homemade toast. Ruben sandwich with fresh bread was more than filling. A good "off the road" stop. read more

They are known for their sticky buns which I recommend ordering. They make a ot of their own baked goods. Even the toast that was served with breakfast was homemade. read more

Literally the best sticky buns I've ever had... Even better than grandma's. You will never feel as valued by a restaurant owner and staff as you will at this place. Food is amazing, service is great, atmosphere is warm and inviting. Best breakfast place in town, hands down. read more

Wow, all I can say. Bad. Really bad. The waitress was very cold and unfriendly, the atmosphere was horrible. I felt like all the locals were looking at us like we were diseased. We ordered the sticky buns thinking this should be good because that is their speciality. They were completely dry and served cold and I think it was drenched in table syrup. I could have made it better from a frozen package. The coffee was average. Would not recommend this hole to anyone. read more

The other place I like to go for breakfast. Famous for, you guessed it, home made sticky buns and other baked goods. Solid breakfast menu. Lunch and dinner about as good as anything else in the area, but that's not much of a compliment. Owner is super nice and staff is also friendly. Showed up an hour before they opened once to see if they were open, and owner spotted us and I invited us in. read more

Glad we stopped. coming back from penn state. Great owner. Exceptional sticky buns and the best patty melt ever. They make their own bread and it made the sandwich taste even better read more

Got two eggs over medium with home fries, bacon and wheat toast. Split a sticky bun. One of the better breakfasts that I've had in a while! Surprisingly good potatoes and homemade bread. Still-warm sticky bun was sublime. Prices were very reasonable. highly recommended! read more

I have only eaten breakfast here, but it was very good and reasonably priced. I had the omelette and a bite of my husbands sticky bun-yummy! There wasn't much room a large group would not work. read more

This place was awful. We had to wait a good 10 minutes before anyone brought menus or offered coffee because the waiter was too busy gabbing with other patrons or wait staff. When we finally got our food my daughters eggs had a big black hair on them so we sent them back. The old biddy behind the counter asked the waiter why they were going back and when he told her there was a hair on them she said it was probably one of ours! Nice move stupid bitch because we both have blonde hair. The hashbrowns were burnt and so salty I couldn't eat them. Thought I was going to have to tackle the waiter to get a refill on the coffee. Gave them another chance when they had the Mifflintown restaurant and it was awful as well though the staff was much nicer. Still, there's a reason they didn't even last 3 months. read more