I got a sausage skillet. I asked for over-medium eggs and I got over hard eggs. The skillet was supposed to have cheese on it and only had a little sprinkled on the eggs, none in the potatoes, which were undercooked and bland. Very little sausage in skillet. Toast with soggy and cold. I got cinnamon rolls and they were cold and hard. Coffee was bland and lukewarm. One of the worst meals I've had in years. Response to managers comments below: I'm surprised at the defensive tone of your reply. When I put my order in on the app, it gave me the option for 8:00 AM which I chose, but when I submitted it, I got a reply that stated my food be ready at 8:30 am. I assume that's an automated response and it's due to the fact that you guys don't open till 8 am, so you wouldn't be able to have food ready at 8:00 AM? The application also asked for my phone number, which I gave, so a phone call or a text message stating the food was ready would have been helpful. I showed up at 8:31, not 8:35 am for an 8:30 am order. I have no doubt that you have competent staff, but I believe it is the processes, procedures, and leadership that are suspect. Normally I would take this up the chain of command to the corporate office, but this experience, and specifically your reply, has shown me that Stone Mill Café is not worth the effort. read more

Love this local restaurant. Amazing food and fresh. James is an amazing worker and his care and interaction with customers is amazing! #jalapeñochips read more

What an amazing place. Truly loved this and the service. Awesome menu. Very friendly people

This place is order at the counter and take a seat. Which is fine. But...1st order: biscuits and gravy, 1 scrambled egg and bacon. 2nd order : breakfast burrito. The biscuits and gravy came out within 5 minutes but the egg and bacon and burrito came out 10-15 minutes later. The egg and the bacon were cold. The burrito was at least warm but now utensils were provided to eat the burrito with. The staggered food delivery was not just us, it happened at other tables as well. Will not be back. read more

I really wanted to rate this place higher and if this was solely a sandwich shop, then it could be a 4-star. But based off overall items ordered, the 3-star is justified. My wife and I ordered the chicken salad sandwich, BALT (bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato) sandwich, along with a kolache, and cinnamon toast. The sandwiches were fair, though at the price point, they should provide more filling for a more boutique sandwich shop. However their non-sandwich items leave much to be desired. The kolache was a pigs in a blanket and for a more higher end shop, I expected it be elevated, but falls in line to something you would receive from a random house party. The sausage didn't have that burst of flavor or snap you would expect and the bread used to wrap it was bland. According to the menu, their cinnamon toast comes with their sprinkled streusel. According to google, a streusel is: "a crumbly topping of flour, butter, and sugar that is baked on top of muffins, breads, pies, and cakes." That's what I know to be a streusel but literally all you got was a cinnamon dust sprinkled on top of toast. Saying that there is streusel is very misleading and I was thoroughly disappointed. Overall if you stick to the sandwiches and stop in to purchase their bread, which can also be purchased from some local wal marts, you should be fine. But in the Bentonville area, there are other establishments that could better satisfy you. read more

Awful experience. After ordering at 10:14, food was finally delivered to my table at 10:48. We each ordered a BLT with no alterations. After walking up to the ticket counter to inquire about the 30 minute wait at that time, I was told ours was being made right then and still had to wait 5 more minutes for two simple sandwiches. No manager talk, no apology, no attempt to right the wrong of the longest wait for a sandwich known to mankind. I wish I could give customer service as a zero star. It's also unnerving that a tip is on the register as you pay before you get your food. Mind you I gave 10% for the delivery to the table but that service deserved no more than a quarter. Be aware. read more

Yummy gelato and sandwiches! Service was friendly as well. Their lunch combo comes with a fresh baked cookie as well.

I try not to eat a ton of bread but when I do and decide to eat at this place, I always get the Basil Pesto Sandwich. It is so good. You can get a sandwich, chips, and cookie for under $10. I've only eaten here for lunch and it's usually pretty crowded. The lunch crowd can be a lot and can slow down your food if you're ordering to-go. The only thing I'd like to see is if we can get to choose from the kind of chips and cookie that comes with the sandwich. Other than that, everything else is good and worth a visit. read more

Never one to leave a review like this, but came for the first time on my lunch break. It was like pulling teeth to have the worker check the ingredients in the bread for me (which she also got wrong) She gave me the wrong chips and my sandwich was completely wrong. My sandwich came out with 2 slices of deli meat and a piece of bacon, disorganized and missing every vegetable that was listed in the menu. The ingredient I couldn't eat was in the soup I ordered, which was never disclosed as well. I realized after opening the soup lid and having to call the cafe. The cinnamon roll was dry also. Very disappointed and upset that I wasted 30 minutes here, had to call and go in twice to have something fixed. The worker also had an attitude. read more

My girlfriend and I ate here for breakfast. She got biscuits and gravy, I got the cinnamon rolls. A fight soon ensued as we fought over the cinnamon rolls with our forks. I thank god every day she only had a plastic knife. Seriously, eat here, but get plenty of cinnamon rolls. Phenomenal!! Quick service, clean, friendly staff, and plenty of seating. read more

When I crave a Reuben, I choose Stone Mill. The rye bread is always great, they don't skimp on the sandwich meat, and the thousand island is sensational. The thousand island dressing and bread is what really sets this sandwich apart from other competitors. My fiancé and I have started to add it into or biweekly rotation when possible. I recommend Stone Mill Bread & Cafe! read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Saturday Picnic Reuben - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

So based on the reviews we decided to give it a try. Parking is a bit of a challenge as there are only a half dozen or so spots in the front of the building and the rest are around back. The prices are not clear on the menu so when you order you do not have all the information needed to make the decision. I paid almost $10 for a cold club sandwich which was not all that great. The light wheat bread was very dense and nothing special. The bacon on the club was a few very thin strips of what appeared to be Oscar Meyer microwave bacon and did not have a presence with the 2 slices of cheese 1 cheddar and 1 Swiss. They turkey and ham were tasty. They give you a cookie with the sandwich. And for being a bakery I truly had higher expectations of the cookie. I was pleased with the drink selection. They serve Pepsi products which I love. And they had a nice assortment of sweetened and non-sweetened teas and lemonade. The Yelp app offers you a free 20oz fountain soda but I did not discover u til after we had already paid. And unfortunately will not return to redeem it. read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

See all

Delicious fresh food made with in house bread. There was a low gluten bread option and the staff was very friendly and helpful. We will be back soon. read more

I don't know if I got the full experience or not with COVID-19 and all but here is my review I ordered takeout a few days ago A Reuben sandwich and the tomato soup The Reuben sandwich was delicious but a little light on product it could really use some more meat and sauerkraut i've never been a huge fan of tomato soup but the fire roasted tomato soup here was delicious. I gave it a couple days and came back and got the French dip and chicken and dumpling soup I really enjoyed the French dip sauce but the French dip itself just wasn't for me I did not like the flavor at all but the chicken and dumplings was delicious I will be going back read more

Chicken salad sandwich on cranberry bread is where it's at!! My brother is moving to town and this is one of the Resturant suggestions I put on a list for lunch's. read more

I was having a mother daughter day with my mom and we thought we'd try Stone Mill Cafe for the first time. We both ordered a sandwich and soup combo. I customize my sandwich and had chicken and dumplings. They were both great. The surprise cookie that came with the meal was delicious too. My mom ordered the chicken supreme sandwich ( I think that's what it's called) and was not impressed. It did not come with lettuce or tomato, at least it wasn't offered. So it looked like a chicken pate on bread ( not appealing to the eye). Maybe we'll come back to try something else and ask more questions when ordering. read more

Usually this place is delicious but today my bread and cookie were very stale. Kind of a letdown.

First time eating here. Staff was super friendly and very covid safe. The food was good. Will definitely be back

They're flats of eggs are excellent and the yolks are a burnt orange beautiful worth purchasing

Hair in food!! Got the cobb salad and it had HAIR on the egg slices. Disgusting and gross. I dont't think i can ever eat there again. Its a shame because the first few times i ordered delivery the food was great. read more

I was so excited when this opened up because I love a good sandwich place! When I first moved to NWA almost 3 years ago there were truly no good sandwich places (jimmy johns and subway don't count, I'm talking high-quality non-chain restaurants). Bentonville has a few good places now, woohoo! I have only been here for lunch and have loved everything I have tried. The ingredients taste so fresh and of high quality. Also - the cookies are delicious!! Customer service has been great. I went during a super busy lunch hour, so it took a while for the line to move, but it was worth the wait. There is plenty of seating inside and some outside in the front and back. I definitely recommend Stone Mill Cafe! read more

Great lunch spot. The food is simple and wholesome. Friendly and fast service as well as a rustic atmosphere make it an enjoyable find. read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Chicken salad supreme - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

Stopped in on a Saturday at noon. Not many people there, so ordered and were served very quickly. Very kind and attentive staff. We really wanted to love it. If I could give half scores, I'd give a 3.5. All four of us ate every last crumb. But y'all. It's just another sandwich place. We are pretty adventurous eaters and were underwhelmed by the flavors of our food, and it seemed a little pricey for what you get. We ordered... Cajun Special sandwich Cup of Chicken & Dumplings with a Small Spring Greens Salad Two Turkey & Cheddar Sandwiches (kids meals) It doesn't seem like anything is actually baked here. No fresh bread smell when you walk in. They told us the cookies are baked somewhere else. In short, we could've gone to Jason's Deli and spent less money and had the same sort of experience. It's not a bad place to eat--don't get me wrong--but we wish we would have tried another place we bookmarked for the trip. read more

Love this place, I bring guest that are new to the area here for lunch, it's a for sure pleaser! Fresh food, excellent staff and location, easy in and out! read more

Incredibly disappointing. Tried again after a descent experience. Whom ever made my sandwich grabbed some bread, slopped some turkey and avocado chunks on it and wrapped it. Forget the 5 seconds it would take to cut it. Tastes like something a child made. For the price this is ridiculous. Made 9/5 approximately 7pm. So I guess close to closing who cares right? Won't be back read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

See all

I had heard excellent things about Stone Mill Cafe, and had been wanting to check it out since they opened. I finally got a chance. It was Saturday, right at noon. They did not disappoint. The staff were super friendly. The General Mgr was very helpful in helping us decide what to order. The owner introduced himself, and was very hospitable. The restaurant was impeccably clean, and the overall atmosphere was great. I ordered a cup of fire roasted tomato soup, and half a sandwich... bacon, lettuce, tomato and, sliced avocado. Hands down the best sandwich I've ever ate. Although it was a half sandwich, it was as big as most full sandwiches. The tomato soup was...well, amazing! And the prices are great as well. An all around wonderful experience! I think I've found a new "regular" place. Good work, Stone Mill Cafe! read more

I stopped by for a chicken salad sandwich today and loved it!! I called my order in and went through the convenient drive through pick up.....it was great! I will definitely go back!! read more

Picked up order at the Bentonville location. Simple sandwich, but the bread was stale and one (1) slice of turkey. I ordered turkey on cranberry walnut bread with lettuce, tomato and mayo. The 1 slice of turkey at best covered half of the bread and no lettuce or tomato. A terrible value for $10.33! Also was told by a guy to cover my face before picking up my sandwich which was on the phone WITHOUT A MASK!!! read more

So, you would think a place that's a bakery would have great bread but the cranberry bread used for my sandwich was dry. The chicken salad was puréed with no noticeable chunks. When the bag of Ruffles is the best part of lunch----no need to return. Happy I only ordered a half sandwich!! read more

I was excited that we were getting one up in Bentonville. It made me nervous to never see a bunch of cars for breakfast. I went in and the menu was very limited. Service was great, everyone is nice and helpful. The food and drink bar made it feel very "Continental Breakfast" from a hotel. We really need some more sit down breakfast places in town. With one that opened and has a consistent 2 hour wait, Stone Mill needs to expand their menu like Fayetteville. Food was nothing special, omelette was just folded over eggs with ingredients in it. Toast was chewy and ketchup packets didn't help for the overall feel of a sit down meal. read more

Love the Fayetteville location and was excited to see they were opening a cafe in Bentonville. Stopped in for lunch hoping for the best. Their fresh bread was the draw, but unfortunately the sandwich was meh. For the price I expected a great sandwich, but got a couple thin slices of turkey, a minuscule amount of avocado, meager amounts of veggies and some cream cheese. Bread was great! I'll be back for the bread but not for a sandwich. Very disappointing. Update: removing stars because I stopped in to get a fresh loaf of bread and was handed a pre-bagged, dated loaf that was expiring in less than 5 days. Seriously? If I want that I'll pick up a loaf at the local market. Won't ever be back. read more

My daughter and I were in the area and went here for breakfast. Employees were very friendly and it was very clean. We both had a breakfast sandwich to our specifications and it was delicious. Would definitely recommend stopping by. read more

They got the best b.l.t sandwich ever and there great sweet tea. The gelato is super amazing .

These guys are great to work with. My wife orders through Bite Squad a lot and has some dietary restrictions and Stone Mill always obliges. The veggie sandwich is our go-to, guilt free, mid-day bite. Great spot in Bentonville for a sandwich and soup. Fresh bread, baked daily, and good prices. read more

Cajun spicy sandwich and turkey chili was delicious. Fast service friendly people and great atmosphere. Will be coming back soon

Came in from out of town and looked for somewhere light for lunch. I was not disappointed! The food here is great and the portions were actually much the larger than I'd hoped for. (But that's ok ;) ) Tried the gelato also and it was very good! The place was very clean and had great ambiance. The staff were very friendly!! read more

Viisited the Bentonville location a few tImes when it first opened and was somewhat satisfied. Had been to the Fayetteville location recently and it was very good, so tried the Bentonville store again the other day. Not the friendliest bunch, but we got our orders in and eventually received our meals. I had specifically ordered my AVOCADO BLT sandwich on the jalapeño cheese bread. Where was the jalapeño in that cheese bread? Zero flavor. Won't be taking loaves home after all. The sandwich was flat and thin. There was a piece of tomato sliced so thin I could read through it, and a teaspoon of avocado under a tiny mound of lettuce. The bacon was fit for a Barbie doll. With this $11 sandwich I got a pasty oatmeal flavored flour cookie and a bag of chips. -- skip the cookie, skip the chips--give me some veggies in my sandwich. Kudos for the variety at the beverage bar, and extra points for the diet Dr. Pepper. The whole concept of your store is great. I'll give it another try in a few months. read more

So, we ate here Friday for lunch and the food was good, service ok. On Saturday, we decided to return. We arrived at 4:30, they close at 5. We were going to get gelato to go...nope. After standing there, for a good 10 minutes, waiting to be acknowledged, and getting annoyed looks from 2 of the 4 workers, we were told they already put the gelato up. If you are going to run a business, honor your hours. If you want to close earlier than the stated closing time, then change your hours. We will not be returning and definitely won't recommend. read more

I love this place but beware if you want coffee after 4:00 pm, you can't get it! They "pull" all coffee at 4 and won't serve it! Yikes! Anyone else out there need coffee in the late afternoon?? read more

My husband and I decided to try someplace new for lunch and we were very dissatisfied with the food. I ordered the West Coast sandwich combo with bean and ham soup. The sandwich had approximately 1 1/2 slices of turkey, served on soggy bread. The ham and bean soup had zero flavor, and the oatmeal cookie tasted just like plain oatmeal. My husband ordered the Cajun sandwich which tasted much better than mine but still greatly lacked in the protein department. We also felt the menu was overpriced. We do not plan on going back to Stonemill Cafe. read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas