What I liked best about this wonderful restaurant was that it was the Stone Mill Cafe. Not Meek Mill. Not Millie Bobby Brown. Not Milly Adcock. Not Ted DiBiase " the Million Dollar Man". It wasn't even the Millenium Falcon. The Stone Mill Cafe knows what it wants to be. Great food! Fantastic service! A great vibe! All of that and it's still the Stone Mill Cafe! Honestly, what more could you ask for? A++++++ Two thumbs way up!! read more

Grabbed lunch here Friday. Friendly and fast service. Had the Rueben bread is amazing!

This is our last time eating here! My wife and I come here for lunch pretty regularly. It was easily once per week to every other week. We just found out that the "owner" , as blamed by employees, has decided it's an a la carte menu now and only includes the sandwich and not the chips and cookie anymore. Now, their cookie was total dry trash and never worth eating but that's beside the point. Today, for a total of $42, we got 2 sandwiches, 2 drinks and 1 bag of chips. Really Their foods not that good and the "owner" can suck it. We're not coming here anymore and for the price, I encourage the rest of you to find another mediocre restaurant for lunch. read more

Stone Mill Cafe - That's a $42 lunch. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

Customer service was excellent! The food was fresh, filling and satisfying. The Restaurant is clean and that helps to make the atmosphere is relaxing. Great place to eat or take it to go. read more

Outdoor seating in the front and back so you can bring your . The sandwich was good. The bread was fantastic!

Not the same as the Stonemill in Fayetteville. The chicken and dumpling soup was horrible and I love the chicken and dumpling soup at the Fayetteville location. The chicken salad sandwich was also awful. Will not be back. So sad it's not the same quality food. read more

Sandwich was great! Bread tasted very fresh. I wish I would've gotten it toasted but I forgot to ask. Chicken and dumplings were lacking salt but I'd rather it be that way. I added a little bit of salt and they were amazing! Service was great, all the staff were very kind. read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Cup Monday Chicken & Dumplings and build your own Half Sandwich (turkey, Swiss, ramolade, onion, and lettuce) - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

Stone Mill is a delicious sandwich shop in NWA. I love the West Coast Special. Order a half sandwich as the whole is humongous!!Service is fast and you even get a cookie and pickle plus chips with your meal. Also love the scones and muffins if you are looking for sweet treat in the morning. read more

Very rude to customers. I have thought this several times but yesterday I decided never going back. They have a bible verse on their counter since covid and asking folks to be nice to their staff. I think their staff needs to practice what they preach. Manager listen to complaint walk away and never heard or all her after. It's seems odd that a sandwich/ bakery would have to put up a sign asking unless they have some unhappy customers, again who could be so angry a sandwich shop right? They have a staff issue! read more

Always looking for a good sandwich shop but this place was very generic. Best part was shady seating outside since we had our dog with us. Sandwiches were bland - nothing to brag about. Ample seating inside for large groups. read more

Service here is always top notch and I've tried multiple times to put a tip into the register and they skip it. When I protest they always tell me not to worry about it with a smile. They still provide the best service! The food is always amazing too. If you're looking for an amazing chicken and dumpling this is the place. I make it a point to visit in the days they offer them and always get the half sandwich and soup (ALWAYS dumplings) and the. Take home some (if they have any left to sell!). They also offer bread and baked goods to take home if you want-- recommend the jalapeño cheese bread. Highly recommend this place! read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Chicken dumplings - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

I've dropped in here before to buy loaves of bread. The selection of breakfast sandwiches always look and taste good. Their display case and a quick lunch menu is diverse and delicious read more

See all

Food was tasty but ticket time was slow. Maybe because they appeared to be prepping a TON of bagged lunches. I'll come back when there's no way they are distracted and see what's up! Breakfast burrito was fire!! read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Breakfast burrito with added Avocado - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

Definitely middle of the road.......went there for breakfast the other day and ordered the scramble. As you can see in the pictures, the cheese was partially melted, partially not. Biscuits and gravy were not good or bad, just relatively boring. read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Ham and egg scramble - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

Food is good and bread is fresh but the service is so slow in the mornings. If you're trying to order takeout, I recommend calling ahead for 15-20 mins later. A simple breakfast burrito took me 20 mins to get, and I was literally the only customer in the store. I saw another guy come in to place his order, then drive off in his car, and come back 15 mins later to pick up so clearly he knew the drill. read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

For a delicious and quick lunch option, order the BLAT with a cup of the soup of the day. I come here often to pick up fresh bread, which comes pre-sliced. Their cookies are also delicious. Grab and go items are available near the counter. read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Chicken and Dumplings. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

Good homemade comfort food. Staff is very pleasant and accommodating. Baked goods are especially good

Very kind people and comfortable atmosphere. Excellent bread as well! I really enjoyed my visit and definitely recommend the Stone Mill Cafe! read more

This quaint, tablecloth-topped bakery and lunch spot is perfectly healthy and satisfying. Their chicken salad on cranberry pecan bread is available in whole and half sizes and comes with chips and a homemade oatmeal cookie. The chicken salad was perfectly seasoned. The bread had a tender bite and a was a perfect sandwich bread. read more

This was okay. Cook seemed overwhelmed. You can seat yourself & order at the counter. By the time we ordered the cook shouted "It'll be a while I have a lot in front" it felt like we she was telling me to turn around and go somewhere else. We ordered anyway because on a Saturday there is always a wait. The food was precooked bacon, sausage & ham. Nothing special. It tasted fine. Now I know what I can make at home! I was with my husband and boys. The company was nice so overall we enjoyed our time. read more

I have been in love with Stone Mill bread since the early 2000s. You can basically put anything between their bread and it is yum. The country white, spinach feta or tomato basil are my favorite. My kids eat the pumpkin bread( it weighs at least 10#s) as soon as we get it. And the oatmeal chocolate chip cookies- no good- leave all those for me. They are delicious! read more

On our way through town and stopped here for lunch with 4 kiddos. I got the French dip - which was actually delicious. My husband got the chicken salad sandwich and the kids got BALT's and pb&j, and a grilled cheese. Based on their plates the BALT's were a winner. Nice little lunch spot if you're passing through. Good service, I'd stop here again. read more

Had the French dip and it was outstanding! Both the sandwich and au jus were delicious! Staff was also very friendly

Ate lunch here on a Friday. Service was friendly and helpful. Seating area is fully open now. Got the cajun sandwich which came with chips and cookie. Overall good experience read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Cajun sandwich - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

A quick, fast casual and excellent lunch spot! Creative made sandwiches and soups! All served with chips and a fresh baked cookie! Ordered a grilled BALT (Bacon Avocado Lettuce Tomato) with cheese, yep outstanding! Bread grilled just right, golden not burnt, tasty ingredients! Also added a cup of homemade cream of chicken soup - creamy base with wide noodles and chunks of chicken and veggies, great combo with my sandwich. This is a place that might go unnoticed, but you should check it out; and if you like fresh loaves of bread, get a loaf to go. Enjoy! read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Tasty cream of Chicken soup and grilled BALT! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

Hands down one of the new BLT sandwiches I've ever had! The home made bread was delicious, the tomatoes tasted home grown and the bacon was still warm off the grill. I was tempted with the chicken salad I saw coming out of the kitchen but held firm with the BLT and was very glad. read more

Today I called off and on for 30mins to place an order. I never got through so I called while driving over to place an order. No one ever answered and the phone was ringing when I arrived. When I placed my order at the counter, I asked if they were answering the phone today and they said no, it was too busy. I asked to speak to a manger and she repeated the same. I asked in these instances do you offer an apology and I finally received one. It's unacceptable to not answer the phone at a restaurant and to simply state to customers it's too busy to address their needs. This used to be a place I would frequent for lunch but today will unfortunately be the last. Good customer service and an apology go a long way. read more

We went 5 minutes before they close on a Saturday, we knew they closed in 5 minutes but we were only getting a gelato to go. NOPE, "sorry we are closing". I thought you closed at 5? "We do but we are closing up". Oh ok.. I guess they have enough business with out mine. read more

Challah bread = the best bread if you love bread like Oprah Doordash meal to my desk = so convenient and so fast TASTE = the only place that I am willing to pay for someone to make me a sandwich and not just make one myself PRICE =‍ a but pricey for a post-grad student but all and all #WORTHIT read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Pick 2 meal! Perfect lunch portion - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

See all

I love sandwiches so this may be biased. Quick, hearty, clean and consistent and I love when I have them warm my club sandwich...hmmm hmmm hmmmm-so good. Great lunch date and:or quick brunch catchup read more

Drove up to the to go window to order my mom a simple turkey sandwich and this is how it went - "Did you call in an order because we don't take orders at this window" no I didn't it was a last minute decision and all she wanted was a turkey and mayo sandwich -"well I will have to go see how long before we can get to that" never mind and no thanks - it was 2pm on a Wednesday - the young man at the window was sooooo rude I won't be returning - THANKS read more

Spinach feta bread was divine! The cafe was clean and received good service. We had the chicken and dumpling soup and it was rich and creamy. The oatmeal cookie was soft and chewy. Far superior to other chain sandwich places...I'm looking at you Panera. read more

Customer service was great and the food was really good. Price point was pretty good as well!

Ive been to this cafe several time and I've never been disappointed with the quality of food. I do find it a bit pricey but not above the top limit just close. I was just there today and inquired about hot coffee and was told they would brew me a fresh pot. Another lady then said that they were not brewing fresh coffee in the afternoon however thanks to Drina K she insisted that they would certainly brew me a fresh pot. I'm from a place where if you have cafe and coffee shop then coffee is always available. I understand that hot coffee isn't always popular here but with the invention of single coffee pods it certainly shouldn't be unavailable. I did get my coffee but it felt like the owners were just trying to save because they only served the coffee in large brewing pots. Therefore I really can't say that it rates any higher than a 3 star. read more

Incredible sandwiches!! My favorite is the stuffed jalapeño popper!! Second favorite is the Euro Veggie and I'm not even a vegetarian

No stars. Food is I spent $17.00 for 1/2 sandwich and an old looking salad. Nasty coffee. No plans to go back.

What a great lunch today! Had a Cajun Special sandwich and a cup of Broccoli Cheese soup. The sandwich came with chips a freshly baked oatmeal cookie. The sandwich itself came on freshly baked jalapeño corn bread and it was super delicious. The cafe was super clean and the service was spot on. Can't wait to go back. That Cajun Special sandwich is my new favorite. Get over here and try this place!! read more

Stone Mill Cafe - Cajun Special and Broccoli Cheese soup - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Bentonville, Arkansas

That chicken salad supreme was SUPREME! The cranberry bread is wonderful! I'm so lucky to pick out this place! Cobb salads! Reuben sandwich, cookie soup, etc . are all amazing! I'm so glad I decided to try something new. The service is great and very helpful. I feel ! read more

One of my favorite places in Bentonville! The food is simple, delicious, made locally, and inexpensive. My favorite meal is easily the Heartwarmer, which consists of a grilled cheese sandwich (I have no idea what they put in it but it is AMAZING) and a cup of tomato soup (which is also delicious). Also a big fan of the West Coast Special sandwich, the BALT (bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato), and their Chicken and Dumplings! Their meals come with chips and a cookie, or you can order a half and half (similar to Panera). For desserts they have brownies and scones (chocolate chip and raspberry/white chocolate are my faves), and they just added gelato! Ahh! Stone Mill also bakes their own bread and it is available for purchase. Their cranberry pecan is WHERE IT'S AT. All in all, huge fan! So glad they're here! read more

See all

I got a sausage skillet. I asked for over-medium eggs and I got over hard eggs. The skillet was supposed to have cheese on it and only had a little sprinkled on the eggs, none in the potatoes, which were undercooked and bland. Very little sausage in skillet. Toast with soggy and cold. I got cinnamon rolls and they were cold and hard. Coffee was bland and lukewarm. One of the worst meals I've had in years. Response to managers comments below: I'm surprised at the defensive tone of your reply. When I put my order in on the app, it gave me the option for 8:00 AM which I chose, but when I submitted it, I got a reply that stated my food be ready at 8:30 am. I assume that's an automated response and it's due to the fact that you guys don't open till 8 am, so you wouldn't be able to have food ready at 8:00 AM? The application also asked for my phone number, which I gave, so a phone call or a text message stating the food was ready would have been helpful. I showed up at 8:31, not 8:35 am for an 8:30 am order. I have no doubt that you have competent staff, but I believe it is the processes, procedures, and leadership that are suspect. Normally I would take this up the chain of command to the corporate office, but this experience, and specifically your reply, has shown me that Stone Mill Café is not worth the effort. read more