1. Stuart R Winthrop, MD

    1. Stuart R Winthrop, MD

    0

    Santa Barbara, CA

    Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Stuart R Winthrop, MD

    4.5 (124 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Services - Stuart R Winthrop, MD

    Laser vision correction

    Eye surgery

    Stuart R Winthrop, MD Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Stuart R Winthrop, MD

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Recommended eye drops
    Sydney C.

    If you're debating whether or not you should move forward here with LASIK, my short answer is yes. I wanted to wait a few months after recovery before I review, so here it goes! I had been wearing contacts for 13 years. My eye sight was stable for about two years. However, I developed an intolerance to my contacts. I tried switching brands, but, still, the irritation continued and worsened. So I looked into LASIK since I do not enjoy wearing classes. I have an active life (exercise, military, security). Glasses just were a bother most of the time. I had two of my friends in the military recommend Dr. Winthrop, saying it was a really simple procedure and they were right! The office does an excellent job providing you with all the information you would need to understand the procedure itself and the recovery process. There are no surprises. After I got the surgery, I woke up four hours later and saw just perfectly... like I was wearing my contacts. For the surgery, it was overwhelming discussing the steps beforehand. Hearing about the process really made me nervous, but the medication they offer eased all of that. I hardly remember what happened. The laser is only on the eye for a few seconds. So don't be nervous! For the recovery, you will endure very dry eye irritations most likely. I did for sure. I purchased two bottles of the Theratears Eye drops (see picture). I recommend you purchase this beforehand, so you can have it ready! Dr. Winthrop will give you some of these drops after the surgery too, but they will only last a few days. Throughout recovery, I experienced some "ups and downs" with sight. It's not a worry; only part of the recovery. Sometimes it will be blurry, but I continuously used the eye drops and it helped almost immediately. I see perfectly now. Dr. Winthrop is very knowledgeable so you have every reason to trust this! Make sure you read through the information packets so you know what to expect. My life has improved a lot in every aspect. From working long hours, traveling easier, hiking with family and friends, and military trainings. I don't have to worry about the eyeglasses/contacts like I used to. I am very happy with these results.

    Eyeglasses

    See all

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - Stuart R Winthrop, MD

    Review Highlights - Stuart R Winthrop, MD

    It was always easy to get in touch with Peggy or Claudia for scheduling and questions where other offices took much longer.

    Mentioned in 14 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Douglas Katsev, MD - Santa Barbara Eyecare

    Douglas Katsev, MD - Santa Barbara Eyecare

    3.6
    (46 reviews)
    1.5 mi

    Dr. Doug Katsev offers exceptional care. When I called his office recently for an urgent eye…read morecondition, his staff scheduled me for an appointment the next day --which was very helpful! Everyone in his office is attentive, professional and pleasant. Five stars!

    I had eyelid surgery performed by Dr. Katsev in December 2025, and unfortunately my experience has…read morebeen very disappointing. Since the procedure, my left eye does not fully close, and I was told that too much skin may have been removed. This has caused ongoing issues with dryness, light sensitivity, and discomfort--especially in the mornings when I often cannot open my eyes for 10-15 minutes due to sensitivity. Time and time and time again he kept telling me it'll get better they will get better. I had shared once that I wish I had never done the surgery and he replied well if I knew this was gonna happen I wouldn't have done it either. Over time, my vision has continued to change, and I have not been able to get stable corrective lenses. I also experience difficulty reading fine print and using a computer, which has impacted my daily life and schoolwork. Despite these ongoing concerns, I repeatedly felt that my symptoms were not taken seriously and was often reassured that things would "get better," but they have not improved. Additionally, I was encouraged to try a different type of lens approach which was another surgery that did not work, and I was charged $350 per eye each time. Being on disability, this has been a significant financial burden, and I do not feel these additional costs were justified given the outcome. This experience has been both physically and emotionally difficult. I am currently seeking corrective care with another doctor in hopes of resolving these issues. I believe patients deserve to feel heard, taken seriously, and fully informed about potential outcomes. Unfortunately, that was not my experience here. So all in all I had to have a fourth surgery to correct the mistake that he had made. Also, I never felt like I was heard or an apology or anything. It was like I didn't care at all about me.

    Photos
    Office location- Sansum clinic
    Office location- Sansum clinic
    Douglas Katsev, MD - Santa Barbara Eyecare
    Douglas Katsev, MD - Santa Barbara Eyecare

    See all

    California Retina Consultants

    California Retina Consultants

    3.8
    (19 reviews)
    0.0 mi

    I had an excellent experience with Alessandro Castellarin at California Retina Consultants. From…read morethe moment I walked in, the entire team was professional, kind, and attentive. The supporting staff made the check-in and pre-exam process smooth and comfortable, and they were all very friendly and efficient. Dr. Castellarin was incredibly thorough and took the time to clearly explain my diagnosis and treatment options in a way that was easy to understand. I never felt rushed, and he made sure all of my questions were answered. His calm, reassuring approach made a stressful situation much easier to navigate. The procedure itself was handled with great care and precision, and the staff continued to check in and ensure I was comfortable throughout the visit. It's clear that everyone in the office works together as a team and truly prioritizes patient care. I'm very grateful for the level of expertise, professionalism, and compassion I received from both Dr. Castellarin and his team, and I would highly recommend California Retina Consultants to anyone in need of retina care.

    The doctors seem to be good, BUT, and this is a huge BUT, you are in a huge queue and it takes…read moreabout 90 minutes, up to two hours, for a simple appointment. They expect the patients to be respectful of their time, but they do not respect patients in return. The actual time with the doctor is super short, and for that they charge my insurance thousands of dollars each month!!!

    Photos
    Nathan C. Steinle, M.D.
    Nathan C. Steinle, M.D.
    Robert F. See, M.D.
    Robert F. See, M.D.
    Alessandro A. Castellarin, M.D.

    See all

    Alessandro A. Castellarin, M.D.
    Santa Barbara Eyecare

    Santa Barbara Eyecare

    4.5
    (8 reviews)
    5.0 mi

    By far the most enjoyable experience I've ever had at an optometrist. The staff and doctor made…read moreeverything from scheduling to picking up glasses a super enjoyable experience. The office is very clean and the doctor went above and beyond by recommending supplements that would support eye health and possibly reduce migraines. They delivered pleasant, convenient, and high-quality care, I'm glad they're here in Goleta.

    Well, went in for a much needed eye exam. I was able to book probably the last available slot in…read morethe day. As soon as I got there the girl had the questionnaire ready to be filled up. Which I did. And right away I was walked into exam room. The optometrist started the exam and asked some questions, since I hadn't had an exam since I had my lasik surgery years ago, he suggested to get the extra check ups, eye pressure... but he didn't push he just suggested and I did decide to do it. Great customer service, knowledgeable. We tried different contact lenses until the third pair was tried, and that was the best one. Very patient and not rushing the exam, answered questions I had. And he gave me prescriptions for both eyeglasses and contacts, without me having to ask or him pushing me to buy glasses there. Will definitely use this as my future exam place!!

    Photos
    Make an appointment with Dr. Amanda Beaudry for your next eye exam!
    Make an appointment with Dr. Amanda Beaudry for your next eye exam!
    Kristen and Dr. Amanda Beaudry
    Kristen and Dr. Amanda Beaudry
    Kristen, our wonderful office manager

    See all

    Kristen, our wonderful office manager

    Stuart R Winthrop, MD - laserlasikeyes - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...