The Bodega is a trendy, upscale market in downtown Greencastle just off the Square. They sell some…read morelocal produce and other specialty items such as herbs. The shop is somewhat sparse. There is a wall of cookbooks. The clerk is super friendly and gave us the background on the various farms that the featured gourds and pumpkins were grown. I purchased a French blue gourd. Prices were on the high side. They sell breakfast and lunch sandwiches (daily specials). Cold assorted salads are in a fridge for take out.

I'm writing in reference to Lindsey L.'s insipid one-star review of the Bodega…read more She states that she "should have been paying closer attention to the menu because [she] didn't recall it saying mayonnaise was on the breakfast sandwich." Well, "mayonnaise" wasn't on the sandwich, nor on the menu. "Dijonaise" and aioli were on both, however. All Lindsey and company had to do, which is all that anyone has to do at any business establishment, was go to the counter and ask for either a refund or a custom modification to the sandwich. And yeah... reading the menu--written in big letters and hanging on the wall--helps too. As someone who doesn't have to drive "about 40 minutes" to go to the Bodega, I'm super thankful that it's here. It's a blessing for those of us who have been thankful for ALL the businesses who have brought a new bit of life to our community. At the end of the day, people like Lindsey should be taken with the half-grain of salt they're worth. She wants you to think that the folks at the Bodega went out of their way to ruin her day. What we actually think is that she opted to announce to everyone on Yelp that she's petty and selfish. She didn't bother to read the menu, didn't ask questions, and didn't take her grievances to the store. Instead, she fired off her editorial opus and punched "one-star" because, in her world, if she's inconvenienced or made angry, then something has to burned to the ground. The Bodega is wonderful. Five-stars. People such as Lindsey are why Yelp can be awful.

I have ordered delivery from the Downtown location before but this was my first time visiting any…read morelocation in person. It's very cool on the inside with vintage and Indiana-themed decor, tin ceilings, and, of course, a potbelly stove. The staff were friendly. But brother and I were very confused about the ordering process. There wasn't a lot of directional signage showing where to start and each step of the process. I watched a few other customers go through and they didn't seem like they had a problem so maybe it was just us. Next time I would probably just order online and pick it up so I could avoid the in-person ordering process altogether. I had the turkey sandwich and it was pretty good. I would say definitely a step up from your typical sub sandwich chain in terms of flavor and toppings options. I tried the chili mac as well. The chili is definitely à la Wendy's but I enjoyed it. The mac and cheese was good as well. I'd probably get either on its own but not together again. I also tried the Potbelly/Zapp's collab chips, the Hot Pepper flavor. They were good but are definitely not for everyone. When I visited, most of their fountain soda options were out of order so I settled on a no sugar added Pineapple Passionfruit juice/soda which was actually pretty good. We'll definitely be back - especially to try out their milkshakes!

So excited to have a Potbelly on the south side of Indianapolis! They are one of the better chain…read moresandwich shops in my opinion and when I went in, the person working behind the counter took the time to talk to me about the menu and asked me what I liked. I had the meatball, which was really good and the meatballs tasted homemade - they actually ran out after me so I got the last batch!

This was our first stop at the Sandwich Shop. We were planning to go next door but upon exiting…read morethe car, we saw their sign "Dinner for 2" in honor of Valentines Day. 2 double bacon cheeseburgers, fries and 2 drinks for $22. SOLD! What a cute place! I don't know if they always hac the red and white checked table cloths and candles or if that was special for Valentines Day but it was adorable and made our Valentines meal a little more special. Our waitress was super sweet and attentive. Our cheeseburgers were some of the best we have ever had. We even considered driving back up there the next day for more! And the fries! By far the best fries! We couldn't stop eating them! We are sold. We will definitely be coming back here. There were other sandwiches I wanted to try but that cheeseburger will be hard to beat!

I went here while on a work site visit! It's super cute! They have a classic lunch counter. We sat…read moreat the counter since it was super busy and seating was limited. Service was super fast. The food was mouthwatering! The fries alone were amazing! They were golden crispy perfection! I got the double cheeseburger with tomato, lettuce, and pickles on top. The bun was perfectly buttered and browned from the grill too! I'd come back if I ever go out that direction again!

Great service and good prices. Not very many places do you see the owner serving. He is a great guy…read moreand he is the local mayor

Just do it the food is great!! We had breakfast this morning. Wish they were closer to home!read more

I will never give my money to this place ever again they cancel my order. They took the money off…read moremy card. I went by the store and asked why did I get my delivery? The manager was rude to me called the general manager today and she said she was gonna threaten to have me arrested because I came up there beat on their window. That's a lie. I asked the guy where was my food, and he said that he bought my order and tried to call me, which was a lie so managers that don't do right and food business they don't need to be in that spot. i've never had such a bad experience with a food place and I've bandaged food places before and that's not how you treat your customers. It says you're open to a certain time you place your order they take your order and they don't want to deliver it and then they take your money acceptable manager should be fired

We visited Jimmy John's today with my college basketball team and our bus driver. They were…read moreincredibly nice, quick to serve us, and made all of our sandwiches really well. I know it seems simple, but rarely will restaurants welcome 16 people and they did so with ease. Thank you!

5pm on a Friday at Eddie's is an unusual time to dine. Food is always good. The server/cook/all…read morepurpose utility guy was casual and friendly. The bar is old time and cool. The bench seats are good....! Always good place. Try it out if you never have.

Not anything like I was used to as a kid, but the food was close to the same! I would visit every…read moreonce in awhile just for the old school taste!

Charming little cafe with good midwestern breakfast items. Excellent prices and 99 cent coffee!…read moreLunch menu looked good too. The staff were hardworking, friendly and attentive. I had the breakfast platter with a bowl of gravy on the side and ended up ordering extra biscuits - worth every carb! Room for groups of 4-10. Pet friendly with street side dining available and definitely kid friendly. True gluten free and vegan folks might struggle a bit but vegetarians would be ok. The fried potatoes were excellent. We will add this to our places to return in this area.

This is a cute eclectic place. A great place to meet and chat with friends. The food is good and…read morethe atmosphere very friendly!

Joe's Butcher shop has a counter that makes sandwiches and salads and provides seating "next door"…read more We had lunch today with friends. The menu has a few unique sandwiches that make good use of the butcher's meat. Prices are reasonable. My husband had the Debris Po' Boy Sandwich, served hot. He loved his sandwich with a generous portion of beef, lettuce and tomato. I had the Grand Palace Salad, which was huge. The chicken was marinated in a Thai sauce and was a tad dry. The rest of the salad was fresh with snow peas, cherry tomatoes and mandarins orange. My friend had the meatball sandwich, which looked awesome. The sandwich was huge and shareable. (I'm getting that next time.) The clerks were friendly and helpful. The dining area is roomy and great for conversation. Restrooms were available. There is a dedicated parking lot behind the building or street parking in front.

Food was fresh and delicious!! Definitely get the IPA beef brisket sandwich and the house BLT! Will…read morebe back to try more of other sandwiches. The space is dining is great for lunch!