This was our first stop at the Sandwich Shop. We were planning to go next door but upon exiting the car, we saw their sign "Dinner for 2" in honor of Valentines Day. 2 double bacon cheeseburgers, fries and 2 drinks for $22. SOLD! What a cute place! I don't know if they always hac the red and white checked table cloths and candles or if that was special for Valentines Day but it was adorable and made our Valentines meal a little more special. Our waitress was super sweet and attentive. Our cheeseburgers were some of the best we have ever had. We even considered driving back up there the next day for more! And the fries! By far the best fries! We couldn't stop eating them! We are sold. We will definitely be coming back here. There were other sandwiches I wanted to try but that cheeseburger will be hard to beat! read more

Sandwich Shop - Valentine's Special - 2 Double Bacon Cheeseburgers - Sandwiches Near Me - Delphi, Indiana

I went here while on a work site visit! It's super cute! They have a classic lunch counter. We sat at the counter since it was super busy and seating was limited. Service was super fast. The food was mouthwatering! The fries alone were amazing! They were golden crispy perfection! I got the double cheeseburger with tomato, lettuce, and pickles on top. The bun was perfectly buttered and browned from the grill too! I'd come back if I ever go out that direction again! read more

Another delicious lunch today. Consistently a great meal. Service is outstanding. Clean. Many more menu choices but I love their burgers and fries! read more

Sandwich Shop - Double cheeseburger with onion, pickles, tomato and a large order of hand cut fries. - Sandwiches Near Me - Delphi, Indiana

Just passing through on way to Indy-great little diner! Food was amazing- burgers very tasty, fries fresh cut, fried a little darker but very good with just right amount of salt. The pork tenderloin sandwich was the real winner! Homemade fresh coleslaw- yum- with 2 iced teas total bill was about $20. In Chi-town it would have been $40- make this a definite stop even if you have to go out of your way a bit. We will be back! read more

This small town diner has the absolute best sandwiches and fries in Indiana. I kid you not. Local friends highly recommended this spot so we stopped for a quick lunch. The place is cute with black and white tiled floors and brick walls located just off the square in Delphi. And it was packed for lunch. We took seats are the counter and watched the chef prepare the hand cut fries. The thin cut potatoes are popped into the fryer right before your eyes. And they are perfectly delicious. Everything is made fresh. The burgers are amazing. I had the shrimp po boy which was immense packed with fried Buffalo shrimp that packed a punch. The rotator and lettuce tamed the heat. The toasted bun was beyond delicious. I want to try every sandwich on the menu as I looked at what the regulars order. The staff is friendly and hustles. They were fun to watch. Amanda, our server, was attentive and kept glasses full. They have a couple tables outside on the sidewalk. There is plenty of free street parking. Simply amazing. I recommend sitting at the counter where you watch the magic happen. read more

See all

From the greeting to the last fry this place rocks. Consistently great food and you can't beat the special BD/CB WITH FRIES AND A DRINK!! I had a Kaoto Melt and it was delicious. read more

My wife stopped at this restaurant last month as she traveled from our home in Chicago to central Indiana. She told me the hand-breaded pork tenderloins were amazing. Today I took her advice as I was passing through Delphi, and my wife was right! The breaded tenderloin is the best I've ever had anywhere. It was beyond amazing! And the service was incredible as well. I am already trying to think of an excuse to visit central Indiana again just so I can eat here. read more

Found my new favorite burger. Fun environment at a typical sandwich shop. Great and friendly service. Can't wait to come back. read more

See all

Today I found myself in Delphi for lunch and I reached out to a friend on a place for a quick bite. He recommended two places, and I decided to visit The Sandwich Shop. This was the correct choice and I immediately know I was in for a treat. The place was hopping, even at 3pm and the smells were amazing. I ordered the double cheeseburger and a small fries (with cheese and bacon). The burger was one of the best I've had. Simply amazing! The "small" fries were the size of a mountain so needless to say, I couldn't finish them and now I'll have a snack for later. Definitely a place to try the next time you find yourself in Delphi! read more

Food was amazing and the service was top notch. Depending on time of day could be busy and seating is limited. read more

See all

The place was full, even outside seating so we took a seat at the counter. It was surprisingly comfortable. A lovely young girl waited on us and she was excellent. She Refilled my husband's tea without us asking and brought extra napkins. She was very young but very good even with the crowd. The food was fine. Correctly cooked and tasty. The one problem and I don't know what they could do about it, it was very hot inside. Between the grill and the weather, we are having. They serve a good burger and very good fries much better than some drive-through. read more

See all

What a wonderful place for a tasty lunch! We spent the afternoon exploring the adorable downtown of Delphi, and when it was time for lunch went with The Sandwich Shop as it seemed to be hopping. Being lucky enough to grab two counter seats, we were able to watch all the action. Even short a server, the service was friendly and quick. Prices were excellent as was the food. I enjoyed a mushroom swiss made fresh on the grill in front of me, and my husband had the double bacon cheeseburger. We split a small order of chili cheese fries. Everything was fresh, perfectly prepared and tasted delicious. We didn't leave a bite behind! I'll be suggesting this spot to anyone headed to or through Delphi! read more

See all

We moved to Delphi a little over a year ago and Wednesday 9/25/2024 was the first time my wife and I made it into the Sandwich Shop. It was busy at lunch time with practically every seat of the small dining room filled, but we were able to grab a table as someone else was leaving. The staff was quick to get the table cleaned and reset for us to sit down and enjoy our lunch. My wife ordered the double mushroom and Swiss burger and I ordered a grilled cheese and a chocolate shake, we shared a 1/2 order of the fries loaded with nacho cheese and bacon. The 1/2 order was more than enough for two of us to share so it was definitely worth the price. The milkshake was served in the ice cold metal mixing cup which only added to it's deliciousness. It's definitely got that diner vibe with the counter seating and the grill in the middle of the room. The menu is a nice collection of burgers and sandwiches and the prices are more than reasonable in today's economy. The staff was pleasant and helpful even though they were busy with the lunch rush and the food was delicious. read more

We stopped here on our way to Profitstown . The service was great and quick. The owner was on the grill and came over to talk with us after we got our food. He was great and super friendly! The food was 10/10! Hand cut fries were a hit for sure. We will definitely be back anytime we are headed to Purdue. read more

We stopped into the Sandwich Shop on a road trip. The special was a bacon double cheeseburger with hand cut fries. Yes, please! Delicious! Clean, friendly, great service. Great prices. read more

This is a great local diner in Delphi. We had hamburgers and fries. Burgers were really good. Fries were excellent. If you are looking for an inexpensive restaurant with lots of local history, you won't go wrong here! read more

For a small town place it was big town incredible. Has pork tenderloin and cheeseburger and the fresh cut fries. Everything cooked to order. Dessert pie loved it peanut butter pie. read more

It can get busy but the sandwiches and fries and tasty and quick. Real cheese would be a great addition

Stopped by for a quick lunch and was very impressed with my meal, the vibe and the place was packed.

Some one needs to tell Guy Fieri about this place. Best burger ive had. Cant wait to try the rest of the menu. Simply excellent!!! read more

Great food! Fast service. I had a BLT and coleslaw. Very friendly people. Asked if I wanted a to go cup. If I were to come back to Delphi I would go here over any fastfood Prices good too. With drink sandwich, coleslaw and tip. $15.27 read more

I came here to get a sandwich and I got to tell you it was amazing! I ordered a cheeseburger and loaded fries. We ordered our drinks and got them super quick and then we ordered our food, came out super quick. The place had a fair amount of people which is always a good sign. I highly recommend this place always a good choice! read more

This is a great sandwich shop in Delphi. Delicious cheeseburgers and fries. Definitely recommend when traveling through.

The Special is always great! We've enjoyed the Sandwich Shop for the past year we've lived in Delphi as our favorite family burger stop! - Sarah was a great waitress! I'm slightly biased though. read more

I have been coming here since I was a kid. The people are friendly staff is great with accommodating you with anything on or off your sandwich you want. This restaurant gives you a "back in the old days" feeling when you sit in there to eat. The prices are reasonable and the food is great! You should check it out. I recommend the breaded tenderloin read more

We have ordered from here several times esp. when family is in town. Everyone has loved all their food. I can't remember what everyone ordered but thought it was great that everyone loved what they had ordered! Great cheeseburgers for sure! read more

HIDDEN GEM. First, the photos of the interior and exterior are outdated. The place has undergone a redo and the interior is absolutely adorable. Second- the food was OMG . Best fries in the state of Indiana since we moved here 5 years ago. Excellent hand formed non frozen burgers. This place is a FIND. Worth the drive to Delphi from Indy. I will be back! read more

Food and service was great. The homemade fries are the best. The only negative about this place is the parking.

The Sandwich Shop in Delphi, Indiana serves a Texas BLT that is truly memorable. I can't believe I'm saying that, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, bread, sounds pretty ordinary but theirs is not. Best BLT I have every had! They offer a different fruit pie daily so if you enjoy sweets to finish your meal, they have that covered. Be sure to look around their quaint shop because there is history to be found. Sure enjoyed my first visit. Will be back soon! read more

Every time we go here it never disappoints! The Sandwich Shop has been a local tradition for years, and it lives up to it every time. The fresh, homemade, hand cut fries that they are famous for are a must try, and the hand breaded tenderloin is a classic. It is nice sitting outside and watching the sunset down Main Street or seeing the cars go by. read more

Sandwich Shop - The outside - Sandwiches Near Me - Delphi, Indiana

Pretty good. I ordered online, and they said it would be ready in 15 minutes, and it was! It tasted amazing and the store was nice and clean. read more

Had lunch here today outstanding and very tender breaded tenderloin will go back and wife had wrap ham turkey and bacon also

Having grown up in Indiana, I find myself occasionally reminiscing of days gone by. Well, lately I've been craving an Indiana staple that is incredibly, yet surprisingly, difficult to find outside of my home state. The fried tenderloin sandwich. This sandwich is as distinctly Indiana as is the Old Oaken Bucket rivalry between Purdue and IU. It is a simple sandwich that Hoosiers have made their own since it was introduced to them by German settlers. My weekend back home in Indiana required that I get a tenderloin sandwich. My buddy mentioned The Sandwich Shop and I figured they'd be able to scratch the itch. Oh boy did they ever. I am used to a tenderloin that is hugely bigger than the bun, yet thin. This one was thicker, but with less diameter. Fried to a golden brown, it was juicy and delicious. My first bite put me into a brief trancelike state with an audible mmmmmmm being uttered from my full mouth. My airline ticket cost $300, but this sandwich provided me a free trip down memory lane. Thank you to the delightful people at The Sandwich Shop. You made my trip home complete. read more

So this is one of my favorite places for hamburgers. We have always had good service and food. But today. I will say they dropped the ball. We pulled up to the curbside and ordered curbside service. The girl taking order was not at all into Taking the order. She said it would take 30 minutes for a double cheese burger and fries. Ok Friday nights r busy. But I told her we r already outside waiting. 35 minutes from call I decide to go in since they haven't come out yet and check on order. The girl who took order ( in a Kettering college sweatshirt) asked if I had an order. I said yes. I ordered 30 minutes ago. She looked over at a bag and grabbed it. I said how long as this been sitting here? She said Maybe five minutes. I asked why didn't U bring it out? I got no answer. Then got to car and fries were cold. When I told her she said "ya they get cold fast". She could care less. I hope she doesn't treat everyone like she did me. Manager needs to know. They did Make fresh fries for me and food ended up good. read more

Awesome place, great food! With an amazing small town feel!!. I have been trying countless breaded pork tenderloins since I moved here from Chicago. This place is so far the best one! I am from Chicago, so I know what good food is. Sorry, but not. Sorry, 85% of the food that I have had since I moved here is garbage!. read more

Delicious!! Burgers are the best around... and the hand cut fries are awesome too. Can't beat the prices either. I eat here as much as possible lol. read more

Stopped in with some friends before going to a concert at the Opera House. My wife and I both ordered the tenderloin sandwiches and got an order of onion rings to share. The tenderloins were slightly larger than the buns were pretty good size. They were also thicker than normal and coated in a delicious coating. There was an ample amount of onion rings of various sizes. We both enjoyed our food and Josiah was a great server. We have talked about going back just to try something else. read more

Good food, affordable prices. Only reason for 4 stars is because they were out of shrimp and fish. Also beware the space is not suitable for large groups. Sitting our party of 6 was a challenge. The chicken and burgers were good though. read more

You ever met a burger you can never say good bye to but instead " see ya later" Well for me its the Mushroom burger... I am always going to see it later in my dreams, my fantasy or craving for a juicy delicious burger. Fries are the freshest next to home made Be a rebel and order the Big Basket !!! Love the people there. Always friendly and awesome service always !!! read more

See all

Our first visit here! Can't believe we've not come here before! The food was excellent!! The service was great and prices very reasonable. Burgers were very good especially the Western Burger. My daughter had the chef salad which was a good size and loaded with meat and veggies. The hand cut fries are some of the best we've had! Chocolate malt shake - delicious!! I can go on and on - really everything was just awesome!! Highly recommend!!!! read more

Sandwich Shop - Exterior of The Sandwich Shop. - Sandwiches Near Me - Delphi, Indiana