WHYYY DOES THIS PLACE HAVE TO BE IN INDIANA??…read more We live in Minnesota. We were on a trip when I saw a billboard for this place. I was hungry for something not greasy fast food, and was drawn to the idea of snagging a deli sandwich while here. I did not expect the sheer incredible variety of food goods available here. Every aisle we browsed was like an exclamation of pointing and going "ooh!" I wanted to buy SO MUCH absolutely delicious looking stuff (especially the fruit-topped cheesecakes, pastries, and cookies... drool), as well as the various ingredients and spices and sauces and pickled veg. They had a huge pop-it-yourself popcorn selection, for example. Tons of pasta shapes. Even milk of many flavors in reusable glass (if only the world could go back to that sustainable model!). The worst part is, I only got a couple things, fully intending to stop again on our way back to Minnesota. But we left for home Sunday, when it wasn't open. It was a foolish error on my part indeed, one which I will likely never live down (until we come back out this way, and you can bet your ass I'll drop at least a hundo in here, maybe two!). The sandwich, which I did get, was quite large and I ate half then, half later. It was cool and yummy, and I appreciated the many options of bread and meats to choose from. I also grabbed a fancy bottled soda. They have an indoor seating area so you can munch inside, or there's tons of outdoor seating as well, because they have lots of their pieces on display for you to custom order! I legit wanted to buy one of their loveseat swings (complete with a fold-out cupholder in the center). They had a lot of color options available, many quite vibrant! Besides many varieties of furniture (made of reclaimed plastics in tons of fun colors), they also sell whole-ass sheds and barns and stuff. Genuinely cool. I can't lie, I'm pretty tempted to somehow get one of their loveseat style porch swings (they even come with a fold-down cupholder). Fun decor on the inside like taxidermy, with a high ceiling and wall art. The bathroom is in the back (it was a bit difficult for me to locate at first) and was clean. All the employees were friendly and helpful. I'd probably shop here weekly if I lived nearby, so it's a real shame it's nearly nine hours away!

Adorable Amish grocery store and deli plus ice cream place. Homemade breads, cinnamon rolls,…read morecookies. The deli counter makes affordable sandwiches.

been going here since i was a little kid! the food is always great, as well as the service. way…read moreback when we used to go inside and eat, not sure if they still do that? anyway i just order at the drive thru! gyro plate is the best!

Always stop by here when I am driving through for work or personal, best gyro in the Midwest hands…read moredown! The owner is very nice as well as the staff. Definitely worth going out of the way for if you not driving by. Give them a try! You won't regret it

Stopped by for lunch as I was passing through from Kentucky to Michigan. Really glad I did!…read more The sandwich was great. I did the Sandwich of the Day. You just answer a few questions about your preferences and they make something based on what is on hand. I ended up with a spicy onion and ham sandwich. Very tasty! They also had a bunch of cheese samples. I liked what I tried so much that I simply had to grab a few things. The staff was super friendly and accommodating. Several regulars came in while I ate and I can see why. I only wish I lived closer!

Food was absolutely amazing! The flavors were so good! Kind of off the beaten path, but well worth…read morethe visit! Will definitely visit again!

Great service, great food! Nice atmosphere also. Friendly staff. My hubby and myself both give it…read more5 stars, will definitely return and recommend!

Food was great however the atmosphere was not great... a gentleman with a mancino's shirt was…read moresitting with 2 other guys and talking so loudly that we couldn't hear each other.

This was our first stop at the Sandwich Shop. We were planning to go next door but upon exiting…read morethe car, we saw their sign "Dinner for 2" in honor of Valentines Day. 2 double bacon cheeseburgers, fries and 2 drinks for $22. SOLD! What a cute place! I don't know if they always hac the red and white checked table cloths and candles or if that was special for Valentines Day but it was adorable and made our Valentines meal a little more special. Our waitress was super sweet and attentive. Our cheeseburgers were some of the best we have ever had. We even considered driving back up there the next day for more! And the fries! By far the best fries! We couldn't stop eating them! We are sold. We will definitely be coming back here. There were other sandwiches I wanted to try but that cheeseburger will be hard to beat!

I went here while on a work site visit! It's super cute! They have a classic lunch counter. We sat…read moreat the counter since it was super busy and seating was limited. Service was super fast. The food was mouthwatering! The fries alone were amazing! They were golden crispy perfection! I got the double cheeseburger with tomato, lettuce, and pickles on top. The bun was perfectly buttered and browned from the grill too! I'd come back if I ever go out that direction again!

Had a good experience over, but I wish whoever decided to load up the potato soup with garlic would…read morereconsider that choice. It used to be the best soup out there, but now it's just got too much garlic in it.

Today I went to Jarrett's I was better to door and seated by a nice young lady name, Brandy. She…read moreescorted me to my table. One thing I noticed was how clean the restaurant was the tables floors even the walls ceiling was clean. As for the service, my waitresses name was Amber. Reminded me of waitresses that waited on me many years ago. She had old-time friendly professional air about her. I will want her for my waitress every time I come in here. I ordered the spinach salad with bacon on the side with extra salad dressing. It was very good. I will order it again.

Ordered a pick up in the app but also ordered an additional sandwich when I got there. Employees…read morewere friendly but I was surprised I didn't get a notification that my mobile order was ready. My main complaint is the lack of meat on the turkey tom. For $7 bucks you would expect meat to at least cover the sandwich.

A really nice experience here today…read more I ordered two #6 sandwiches, each with several customizations. I was happy to see that they had labeled the sandwich wrappers so we didn't have to guess. Both sandwiches were perfectly made. Mine was the best JJ's sandwich I hive had for some time, and I visit many different locations when traveling. The employee at the drive thru window was super friendly. A nice experience!

We stopped in for breakfast during the July 4th weekend. I had the lox bagel with 1 lox slice, my…read morekiddo had a cream cheese bagel, and my husband had some bacon egg and cheese bagel. I really enjoyed my lox bagel and thought it was one of the best I've had!! The flavors were nicely balanced with the onion, capers, cream cheese and lox. I was able to eat it easily and get a little piece of everything in each bite. The bagels seem smaller than average, but who needs giant bagels anyway? I found these to be reasonably sized. Big overstuffed bagels that fall apart while you eat them - lox sliding all over the place - are really annoying. These were satisfying without making you feel gross after. The coffee selection exceeded our expectations. We shared a chemex for 2. They had a few single origin coffees to choose from and we had their pink bourbon Columbian. We enjoyed our coffee and bagels outside in their seating area and this was once of my favorite parts of our trip! We didn't have to wait too long, but as we were finishing, a long line was forming down the block. Consider getting there a little early!

This was the place on a Monday morning right when they opened at 7:30am. There was a good mix of…read morepeople dining in versus carrying out. The New Orleans iced coffee was so good! I had a plain bagel with cream cheese as well. It's a little tight inside but there's plenty of seating. We also loved all the quirky decor and art for sale.