This place has the most affordable and tasteful Italian sub i have had in a while. Obviously it is…read moreno Italian sub from a salamaria but it is similar to blimpee very quality sandwich. The service is fast and kind and the store gives you that retro bodega feel! Definitely a sleeper and must try! Leaves me full everytime.

From the owner: Cole’s Fairfield Market has become a community cornerstone that its customers rely upon and…read morepatronize enthusiastically. Please try us – you will not be disappointed.

Stop & Shop Till You Drop!! hopefully it doesn't ever come to that but just in case it does and…read moreanyone's looking for me, I'll probably be over in the Meat Department. Seriously though anyone who really knows me would've already figured that one out in like three seconds, LOL!! This is a pretty solid store where the positives definitely outweigh the negatives and most of the employees here seem genuinely helpful plus shelves are well stocked. I'm always able to get whatever I'm looking for plus some other stuff I didn't even know I needed but bought anyway. As someone who's not from this area it isn't my regular go-to grocery store but with reasonable prices on most things thanks to their "Rewards Points" program, I could definitely see myself Stopping & Shopping here whenever I'm in this part of the neighborhood. Come And Get Your Shopping On!!

Store is mostly great just be sure to avoid the old woman at the customer service counter.... She's…read morejust there to talk with her friends asking a question will prompt her to tell you you need to wait even if you aren't rushing her.

What a letdown. I've been shopping at the Caldwell Shoprite for over twenty years, and I was…read morelooking forward to the new location. As much as I liked the convenience and quick "in and out" quality of the smaller original location, the idea of a new, larger store with more inventory and variety was exciting, but sadly, all the negative qualities of this new store have discouraged me from shopping there, and frankly after shopping there just twice I don't plan to return. There are very few handicapped parking spaces, and they only exist at one of the two entrances. Although for reasons passing understanding, there's a solitary handicapped spot out in the farthest corner of the parking lot. What's that about? The main entrance to the parking lot is also at the exact spot where the main entrance and exit to the store is located, which causes an almost omnipresent bottleneck of cars waiting to get into the parking lot, while customers are entering or existing the store with their carts. The inside of the store is impressive at first glance, but that only lasts until you start actually shopping. The produce department somehow feels smaller than the old store with less inventory. The small produce bins are for the most part are equally sized, with no apparent thought given to what they would contain. For example, bananas are in the same size bin as the plantains. Which do you think they sell more of in Caldwell? So, the bins with the popular/everyday items need to constantly be refilled and are consequently frequently empty. Why they didn't make larger bins for bulk items like tomatoes, potatoes and onions is baffling. The deli counter is also smaller than the older store. It's now a small counter where both the customers and the deli people battle for space. In addition, the store has created yet another crowded bottleneck there. Customers who are waiting at the deli counter act as a human barrier to all the other foot traffic that can't get past them. Again, poor planning. The bread counter. Again, smaller than the old store. I've included pictures. The new store has a large dining area with tables that divides the produce area. It's nice idea in concept, since the store does have an upgraded hot foods counter and more prepared foods, but the reality is that the area seems mostly unused aside from the few Shoprite employees I saw eating there, and it acts as a sort dead zone right in the middle of the produce area. The Morristown Shoprite and Livingston Shoprite have similar dining areas, but are wisely located outside of the main shopping area. The aisles are another frustrating design choice. They are loooong. Why they did not make some sort pass-thru at the midpoint, just like the Morristown Shoprite did and Wegman's did with their long aisles is a question. There also seems to be an issue with where the store places it's products. Every supermarket in the country puts the ice cream cones with the ice cream (and Caldwell used to). Now the ice cream cones are at the opposite end of the store in the aisle with the crackers or cookies. It took three employees to find them. This counterintuitive placement of products seems to be a running theme of which that is just one example. On the plus side, the store does sell liquor and beer now, but again, they have chosen to place that section right at the entrance to the store, bisecting the food aisles, which is simply odd to me. The bottom line is the store is new and it is beautiful, but the planning and execution for real, everyday shopping is sorely lacking. Choosing style over substance was a bad choice. Hopefully it's one they can correct. Until then I'm driving to Parsippany, Livingston, or Little Falls (heck, even West Orange).

I come here every so often, there is a great time to go which is around 4:30pm. Other than that…read more That place is a zoo. Between the crazy mom and dads with their little kids and stuffing their cart to the brim and the seniors with nothing else to do during the day so there isn't a rush to get thru the aisle. It's hectic. I actually would pay more to avoid the parking lot area and that mess of people in there. I did however, ordered catering since a lot of people do rave about it. And it was amazing. Their finger sandwiches were a hit at the party. Fresh deli meat and Martin bread, you can't beat that. The platter I ordered served 8, which was way enough for people to take home. Love the decor and i hope they're taking it to the new ShopRite.

Excellent thin chicken cutlets and really not a bad price! Will be back to try other things! I…read morelooked around and saw really nice Italian specialties and the staff were friendly!

The absolute best! They have been our butchers since the day they took over the business, anything…read moreI need, special cuts and they bring my order out to the parking lot! Second to none for quality meats!

I have been driving by this place for years. Finally stopped there today. Poorly stocked by…read moreconvenience store standards. I picked up a bag of Paqui corn chips and two bottles of Pure Leaf iced tea. Simple enough. No quite. As I was driving I opened up the chips and they tasted very stale. I looked at the expiration date only to find that they expired six months ago. Additionally, one of the bottles of iced tea was also past the best by date. This doesn't bode well for management. This is a place for lottery tickets and cigarettes. Nothing else.

VERY RUDE!!! Poor customer service. The owner could not complete a simple transaction on his own…read morecomputer. Brushed me off and waived his hand at me to leave because he did not know what he was doing. I will NEVER return!

Great store but no one is ever there to check out. Be prepared to check yourself out . I'll…read morecontinue to shop at the bjs on 10

I always love to shop here. It is clean, organized,and never a total madhouse like the competition…read more There are usually a few manned registers opened which I prefer. The savings are pretty substantial on certain items.

Came to this Convenient Dollar Tree store when looking for something quick decor / gift wrapping or…read moredisposable baking foil tins. They have variety of items and seasonal items depending on what one is looking for. Good for small crafts as well or party items. Check out is quick. Friendly staff and can help if one has questions. Easy peasy, one, two, three. Ample parking.

My favorite Dollar Tree. It is clean and fast. Has tons of stuff that is very cheap. I got these…read morePremium Protein for 1.25 USD, which are twice my price anywhere else for the unit. I also like their brand of diet soda, which is great price for the quantity.

Extremely casual fish market w/comfy seafood restaurant in back. Definitely BYOB. Interesting menu…read morefeaturing many varieties of primarily grilled, extremely fresh local fish, including some you don't often find in these parts, including Grouper, Red Snapper, Sea Bass, Swordfish, Halibut, etc. While the "somewhat pricey" menu doesn't necessarily reflect the laid back, extremely casual atmosphere, the extensive fish & seafood options, along with innumerable different sauces & preparation options; plus the accompanying fresh veggie & potatoes (or rice) sides, assures customers of a satisfying dinner - albeit not exactly a "fine dining" experience. My lovely wife, who is perpetually on the lookout for "healthy" restaurant options, definitely enjoyed our dinner. We look forward to returning soon, hopefully next time with friends.

Superb seafood. I was very impressed with the freshness of the fish as well as the cleanliness of…read morethe establishment. You literally cannot detect the smell of fish when you are in this place. I ordered the baked whole branzino. Lightly seasoned and brushed with olive oil. Served with garlic broccoli rabe and mashed potatoes. The branzino was cooked to perfection and broccoli rabe was on point. The only minor stumble was the mashed potatoes. They were over whipped which gave them a thick, pasty texture. Not a big deal, but room for improvement. The prices are on the high side but I can live with that given the quality of the product. The service was excellent. Ken, the manager was very friendly and accommodating. He found us a table on a busy Friday night even though we didn't make reservations in advance. I will definitely add Caldwell Seafood into our regular rotation.