We were given an incorrect room key & were locked out of our room for an extended period of time…read morelate at night. The host(s) would not answer our calls & the email address was kicking back as undeliverable. We had to search the entire place to find the master keys. She clearly watched us on camera because she knew we located them but provided us no assistance at the time. Not even an apology. Very disappointing. Never again! There are many places far better than this one in the area. I recommend you look into those.

Diane and Jack treat guests like family or friends…read more 10 Guest rooms are tastefully decorated, small with private bath, individual window A/C, and queen-size bed. Other rooms may be larger. Comfortable outdoor furniture on wrap-around front and side porch (pic uploaded) Breakfast is European-style buffet with assorted breads, juices, yogurt, lox, ham, and fresh fruit. Served 8:30-10:00. Many coffee places within walking distance if you want your coffee at other hours. Tasty quiche was made from scratch by Diane and ingredients changed the next day. $450 for 2 nites with breakfast, June weekend, including tax. WiFi included. Fun and easy town to walk around. Ideal choice if interested in the local wineries. Unsuitable for young children due to some fragile items in the open areas. Tip: you can also get to Greenport from NYC via bus or LIRR train (three trains a day from Penn Station, $25 one-way, peak fare, 3 hour trip) or take the Cross Sound Ferry from New London CT, which we used to avoid bridge and LIE congestion, for about $67 with car and two adults.

This was our initial experience at the Mill House Inn located in East Hampton. We visited for the…read moreHampton Classic, and the location proved to be extremely convenient. Our accommodation was situated on the third floor, which was ideal, featuring a king-sized bed, a television, and a bathroom equipped with a spacious soaking tub. Each morning, we enjoyed a complimentary breakfast that included eggs, yogurt, fruit, pancakes, coffee, tea, and more. This meal was available in a cozy dining area or could be served in our room. Additionally, there is a small snack area accessible throughout the day. The Inn itself exudes the charm of a bygone era and is well-maintained. The staff consistently demonstrated friendliness and attentiveness. The Inn is conveniently positioned within walking distance to downtown and other attractions. Overall, it was a delightful stay.

The place is amazing, very well kept. Very clean and quiet. rooms are beautiful and breakfast is…read moredelicious It is highly recommend and we can't wait to came back during the summer.

Love this place! The location is perfect and the home had such character. I really loved the…read moreattention to detail in every room. It was beautifully decorated as well as high end fixtures made it quite luxurious. It was a perfect get away. I especially loved that it was only a few minutes from all the restaurants and shops. It is also close to wineries and ferry to Shelter Island. Don't miss out on this cute home.

An Absolutely Exceptional Stay -- Silver Sands Is Something Special…read more My wife and I spent three days at Silver Sands celebrating our 31st wedding anniversary, and although this was our first visit, it certainly will not be our last. From the moment we arrived until the moment we left, the experience was exceptional. The entire staff went above and beyond to make our stay memorable. What impressed us most was how incredibly organized, attentive, and welcoming everyone was without ever being intrusive. It was almost as if the staff had mastered the art of being there exactly when you needed something, while somehow remaining nearly invisible the rest of the time. That level of service is very difficult to achieve, and Silver Sands does it beautifully. The property itself is immaculate. The grounds are meticulously maintained while still allowing the natural beauty of the surroundings to remain part of the experience. The private beach was spotless, peaceful, and beautifully organized. Throughout the day, we would notice staff quietly moving through, straightening and maintaining everything, yet they were so unobtrusive you could barely tell it was happening. The attention to detail throughout Silver Sands is remarkable. From the design and atmosphere of the property to the pour-over coffee in the room, the thoughtfully selected shampoos and conditioners, linens, amenities, and overall cleanliness -- everything feels intentional. Our room was absolutely impeccable. Silver Sands somehow manages to capture the nostalgia and charm of the classic American motel while feeling modern, sophisticated, and luxurious at the same time. Calling it a "motel" almost doesn't do it justice. It is a truly unique property that can easily rival some of the best hotels and resorts we've stayed at. And then there are Eddie's and Nookie's! Both onsite restaurants were fantastic. The staff and service were wonderful, and everything we ate was top-notch. We left already talking about coming back so we can try more of the menu. Over our 31 years together, my wife and I have been fortunate enough to travel to many beautiful and far-off destinations. Yet there were moments during our stay at Silver Sands when we genuinely felt transported somewhere else entirely -- certainly not like we were still on Long Island, and at times not even like we were anywhere in the United States. It has a special atmosphere that is difficult to describe until you experience it yourself. Thank you to the entire Silver Sands team, as well as everyone at Eddie's and Nookie's, for making our 31st anniversary one of our most memorable, relaxing, and enjoyable staycations. You helped make an already special occasion even more special. We arrived as first-time guests and left knowing we'll be back and bringing others to experience what we had. Thank you again, Silver Sands. See you all soon!

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows is the only place I'll ever stay again in Greenport. This…read moremotel feels like something out of a dream. The service is unbeatable, the grounds are beautiful, and every single detail feels thoughtfully and meticulously curated. I could not have been happier staying here. It's a true oasis of relaxation and the kind of place you never want to leave. Do yourself a favor and book a stay here.

My stay from July 2-3 fell short of that standard. We arrived between 6:00 and 8:00 p.m., and with…read morecheck-in listed until 9:00 p.m., staff availability should have been ensured. Prior to arrival, we made multiple attempts to contact the office to report our delay due to traffic, but received no response. Upon arrival, the office was locked, calls went unanswered, and I was forced to seek assistance from another guest to locate staff. The initial interaction with THE OWNER! --whose name I did not obtain- she dismissive and unprofessional. Although she gave an apology during check out, it did not mitigate the inconvenience and stress caused by the lack of communication and preparedness. I had arranged for a friend to stay with me, but due to the uncomfortable experience, she chose to stay elsewhere that night. This experience reflects a significant lapse in service standards. Professionalism, clear communication, and respect are fundamental expectations for any guest, and these were not met. As a result, I would not consider returning.

We stayed at the Colonial Shores Cottage for the weekend and wasn't super impressed. When we came…read moreto check in, our keys were just siting there in the office and no one was there. So, we grabbed them and went to our room. Strange check in. For the price you pay for this place, you'd think it would be more comfortable. The living room couch is old and uncomfortable, the WiFi isn't great, the ice bucket had bugs in it, but the kitchen was clean enough. The bedroom only has 1 side table, the bed was super bouncy and high off the floor, pillows were horrible, the bathroom has no sink space and no electrical outlet or fan. I had to sit on the floor in the bedroom to blow dry my hair. At least they had a hairdryer. The ironing board was so old we could hardly use it without damaging our clothes. The AC works ok - it's pretty cool in the living room but the vent in the bedroom is small and doesn't cool well. Needless to say, we won't be back.

I had read a couple of reviews of this hotel that were negative post my booking there. My…read morereservation was nonrefundable and as a result I was not sure what to expect. I was pleasantly surprised how lovely this property was and how helpful James who runs the property was as well. I would highly recommend staying here and I hope to visit again sometime soon. The location was great to be able walk around Greenport and enjoy the restaurants and shops.

We loved our stay at Zey Hotel! It's quirky in the best way. Retro shared spaces, a friendly and…read morewelcoming staff, and the perfect location for exploring Greenport on foot. The sweetest resident kitten was an unexpected highlight. Our room was small for the price, but the atmosphere, charm, and location made it worth it. We share more photos and stories from our Greenport trip at https://ourownpathtravel.com and on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@OurOwnPath

This is a fantastic place. The home, rooms, food, everything was perfect!…read more Clean, lovely, large rooms. Host was extremely friendly and warm Walking distance to town with great restaurants. Breakfast was delicious. Very happy and can't wait to return.

We were very last minute arrivals and the host/proprietor Vince could not have been more gracious…read moreand welcoming. This is a quite high-end accommodation. Everything is beautiful. It reminded me of those historic houses that one can tour except you get to stay here. Breakfast was amazing. I highly recommend Wells House especially if its an occasion. Because it feels like one, not just a hotel stay.

This is a lovely spot to eat in outdoors. The food is good as well as the nice staff. You can dress…read moreup or come casual. I think this is a must try.

What a beautiful venue, food is top notch and the staff has always been fabulous!!! Love this…read morespot!!!