Fresh sashimi and sushi rolls. Ordered at 11am to pick up for 5:30pm. It was ready for me when I arrived. When ordering, the person picking up was not familiar with the menu. It was a little frustrating and when picking up, I wasn't optimistic. I had to keep repeating Ufo roll probably 10x. Our actual order: yellowtail sashimi (10 pieces), 5 tuna & 5 salmon sashimi, tamago sashimi, Ufo roll, and spicy tuna inari. What we got- everything with exception of the spicy tuna inari. On the paper, it said spicy tuna nori. There isn't such an item by that name. They made us spicy tuna roll instead. Not terrible, but wish they had a separate number from the market. In terms of the freshness, quality is definitely on point. It's as fresh as you expect, I would compare it to Chelsea market. The only confusion is the Ufo roll. Suppose to have eel. Was eel mushed up with spicy tuna on top? Very confused. I think it was missing the eel. Overall, I am interested in ordering their large platters for parties. Too bad they don't have more exotic options like baby Hamachi, ikura, Toro, uni etc. Lastly, the market smelled clean. Would be very interested in purchase lobsters and some clam chowder next time. Maybe this will the fish monger I have been looking for close to home... read more

See all

Fantastic quality . Great people, great value for your money. Highly recommend. Been going here for years.

I've been coming to this place for 20+ years and I love it, I bought some shrimp that I thought did not taste good. I am a foodie who loves to cook and has been cooking for over 45 years. I purchased 5 pounds of frozen shrimp, and there was a distinct aftertaste that tasted like something processed never tasted anything like it before, but we could not eat it, my wife and my son agreed, and this all happened on Christmas Eve and I was preparing for 17 people. We had to go to a different seafood store in BAYVILLE fish market . And they were fantastic.Thanks Rick! Gus, the owner was not available today when I was accosted by the manager, insisting that he had no issues with any shrimp that he sold for the holiday. I was treated like a second rate citizen he just ignored me and walked away, instead of being professional, apologizing or coming to some reasonable solution. Like I said, I never had an issue the syosset seafood, Gus the owner is fantastic. Just had this one problem. I wish you handle it better read more

DELICIOSO! Fabulous fresh fish and seafood! Also premade dishes ! Counter help knows their product! read more

I try their sushi platter yesterday. It was terrible. The rice was way too sticky and the portion was very small. Anyway we couldn't finish the platter. Half of platter was left. And i just throw it away. I will never come back. read more

i purchased lobsters for christmas. When i picked them up they were dead. It was then that i realized why i never got lobsters from them on christmas. read more

Had Pre cooked 3 lb lobsters they could not have been better Not our first lobsters from here was Perfect before as well Saved a trip to Island Park read more

For my son's virtual graduation day we ordered from Syosset Seafood (Joe's Sushi). Their Sushi is freakin fresh and delicious as well as their variety of fish! This place is one of the few seafood markets I trust for quality. Reasonably price too! read more

See all

I ordered the lobster bake for 4 people yesterday. It was a lot of food and tasted amazing. Great value and top notch quality. It was a great birthday meal! Looking forward to doing this again. read more

Seafood is priced on the higher end but the establishment is super clean with helpful and welcoming employees. They give you a little bit of a seafood market with a nice area offering cooked food that they can warm up for you as well. A large variety of seafood and veggie options. Very delicious. Definitely worth it! read more

Syosset Seafood - Seafood Markets Near Me - Syosset, New York

See all

This is my go to seafood place. My girlfriend and I got 24 oysters for our anniversary and they were delicious did not disappoint. The sushi is out of this world even though slightly overpriced. Worth it for the great quality fish read more

Extremely fresh flaky fish bites. HEALTHY! City price. Grilled veggies are so sweet! Love them. read more

See all

Find this place on yelp so I went there to try .everything looks so fresh .i bought the salmon crab cake ,lobster salad and clam chowder soup everything was really good and fresh !! read more

Re: Joes Sushi-Ordered platter with specific rolls to be included and received less expensive rolls NOT ordered (California rolls and avocado rolls instead of salmon). Spoke to Joe and he argued the number of pieces was correct. They do what they want here. Ended up with a small credit & disappointed guests. Never buying Joe's Sushi again. read more

Ordered 3 3lb. Steamed and cracked lobsters. Each one was delicious and seemed to me bigger than 3 lbs. second time ordering lobsters from them and looking forward to the third time! read more

Syosset seafood is always fresh and had the best fish around. Not only is the fist great but Joe's Sushi is great as well and everything is fresh. Highly recommend both Syosset seafood and Joes Sushi. read more

Discover this place 2 mounts ago. Very fresh fish. Excellent, but pricey. Rather pay more money and enjoy the food.

This is a high end fish market. Only come here if you are rich or have extra money to burn, the prices are extremely high. But the quality is high too. The place doesnt smell like fish, it smells like brine, which shows you how fresh the fish is. There is a lot of variety in a small space, a lot of prepared dishes, and a few relevant grocery items. It's a high quality place but pricey. read more

I have been going here since it has opened. I have never had a bad piece of fish and never disappointed. It is the only place I buy fish. I moved 15 miles away and still only come here. Great people great fish read more

Poor customer service! Called 3x about my order and never got a call back. I went in the night before Christmas Eve and I didn't have my order number - they insisted I got one then said I maybe didn't have an order. Upon finding my order, I told them I didn't know if I would order next year and the owner SCREAMED IN MY FACE, in front of staff and customers - he wouldn't sell me my order and told me to get out because he didn't need to hear me say I might not be back!! Never again!! read more

Not the cheapest prices, but you're paying for quality. Fish I've gotten from SS is not just fresh, but quality flesh. Not all flecked up and weird looking. And not that much more expensive than the supermarkets, some of which have pretty good seafood (Key Food), some are, meh (Stop & Shop). Syosset Seafood is never "meh", so if you need good fish and don't have the time to mess around, go to Syosset Seafood, they'll hook you up. If the prices were a tad cheaper, and there were more selection, I'd give a fifth star. But hey, 4/5 ain't bad! read more

Just visited to try out new sushi counter & they didn't disappoint! Had tuna, salmon, veggie roll & all were exceptionally good! Highly recommend you pick up sushi when you stop in for fresh seafood! read more

While driving down Robbins Lane was telling my husband my mom and her friend would always get the halibut salad. This was like 40 years ago. He surprised me today and it was just as wonderful as I remembered. Looking forward to the lobster bisque for dinner and more halibut salad in the future! read more

You get what you pay for. It costs, but you can count on high quality, fresh fish. Owners are low key and helpful. Halibut salad is delicious and hard to go back to plain old tuna salad once you've had it. Dry scallops a treat and yes, price to match but there is no waste and still cheaper than eating out. Healthy low fat meals pay off in long run. read more

The owner is just the nicest man around! The quality here is fresh. The staff is so helpful in not only helping plan your meal but giving the best suggestions on how to prepare the food!! INCREDIBLE!! read more