I stopped in Two Cousins Fish Market for the first time this past weekend and was rather surprised how bustling it was (as there aren't any windows giving any indication, other than those on the front door). We bought 2lbs of fresh wild shrimp for $20, paid conveniently via apple pay. They have a ton of fish, of all sorts, so I'll definitely be back for my next mediterranean night! Fun fact: When buying fish, they'll clean and cut them up for you for free, you just have to bring them to their filet station, which is located outside towards the back patio. read more

I stopped here for some salmon. I was amazed at this place. Inside they have bins of whole fresh caught fish. There are tongs and plastic bags for you to pick what you want. After picking, you can go around back and they will clean it for you. The salmon was delicious, nice, fresh and delicious. I've had their shrimp and flounder as well and they too were delicious. The staff is friendly and helpful. I love this place. This is now the fish market I go to. read more

Been buying my fish there for years and I am never disappointed with the freshness of the fish, the cordial and helpful staff. Good sale prices on larger amounts. Fish is cleaned in the back of the store for convenience. A nice respectful place to get your fish. read more

I have come here for many years. Always fresh and delicious. Kevin is the best - always makes recommendations and tells me to remember my herbs for the best taste! Love their fish and always is fresh. From clams to tuna, flounder for holidays and shrimp to make multiple dishes it's my go to. Highly recommend! read more

Two Cousins Fish Market - Seafood Markets Near Me - Freeport, New York

See all

Freshest fish, nicest guys, great selection of fish and seafood. THE place to go for seafood on the south shore!

Two Cousins provides great service. The staff is knowledgeable and friendly. They have the best procduct in the area! read more

I'd like to put a warning for those that are paying with credit card. While I was paying, I saw that I was overcharged, and so I asked the worker to weigh the fish again, and he too noticed i was overcharged by 24 dollars. I was given a receipt saying I would be refunded but I never received it. They do not respond to phone calls either. read more

I ordered 6 dz little neck clams with clams and juice on the side, well they were not little but big clams, and they were so tough my guests had to spit them out, I was so embarrased , this was the first time this ever happened . I've been making baked clams for a long time. never again ! read more

I was reeling to try the location for fresh fish since moving to LI. I went here on a Sunday afternoon and hour before it closed so unfortunately I didn't get to fillet anything but my experience was still worth the while. I picked up a variety of fish for the Lent season and it lasted me a pretty long time. Staff is friendly and it can get crowded, so I would suggest going earlier before closing to get fillets outside and more variety. There are several on the strip but I stopped at this one first. Great choice. read more

The best fresh fish ever. Amazing assortment and great prices. You pick out your fish and they filet it for you in the back. Not much atmosphere but plenty of good stuff. Worth the trip. read more

See all

I have been shopping at Two Cousins for over 20 years and I have always been extremely pleased with the assortment and quality for the sea food they have. Always fresh. It is the only place I purchase my sea food. Highly recommended. read more

Disappointed! The guys in the back that filet/clean the fish wouldn't let me stay in the waiting area while they did their work. Went back 10 minutes later as they asked... $5 tip instead of the $10 I usually give them. Bad attitude penalty! The filets were all in one bag. Usually each type of fish is in a different bag. I bought three types. To top it off..... I bought 5 whole fish....ended up with 8 fillets. Do the math! Should have been 10. I won't be going there again. Something fishy going on!!! I smell a rat!!!! Watch your purchase while they clean it! read more

My new favorite fish market ! I heard about this place from one of my friends and I'm happy that I decided to pop in. The place is small but gets the job done . The fish was very fresh and a decent price . They have a shipment everyday and a nice selection to choose from. There's plenty of street parking and a little parking lot for customers in front . There is option to buy a whole fish or buy pieces ... Cleaning of the whole fish and cutting is free with purchase . read more

See all

The customer service at this place is trash. Cashier/ Owner went ballistic on my elderly mother because she asked for a cash discount to be honored (which was advertised in store). Disgusting behavior. read more

I just wanted to say how much I enjoyed my visit to the two cousins fish market and how much I found the fish to be delicious. I highly recommend it. Also, great nautical atmosphere! read more

Love the fresh seafood they have there. We have bought a ton of fish and shrimp from them. I also love their scallops. It's a small place but well stocked. read more

Two Cousins Fish Market - Whole Salmon - Seafood Markets Near Me - Freeport, New York

If you want some of the freshest seafood, this is your spot hands down. While their prices have increased a little it's still cheaper to come here buy what you need and freeze. Staff of friendly and the the guys in the back cleaning the fish for you. Even friendlier. And the ambiance of the place, it's a fish market, don't where a suit to come here because your not gonna come out smelling like roses. Overall yes 1000% recommend this place. Love it. read more

While stopping in Freeport in May, my daughter thought I would get a kick out of seeing this fresh fish market located along the Nautical Mile. (A) because it was so many kinds of fish.... and..... (B) because it was fresh. Even though I live in Los Angeles and can get to the beach with ease, the truth is, L.A. is not known for fresh fish markets, restaurants or otherwise. Sure, they exist, but it's not a common thing nor a commodity like other ocean-based cities, such as San Francisco, Seattle, Boston or anywhere else along the Eastern seaboard, so she brought me in here. As evidenced by all the photos I took, you can see I was impressed by all that fish and seafood. Wow !! I don't have a point of comparison to know how this store is priced, but I wasn't going to buy any fish either. I was just being a tourist and enjoying it all. To be honest, if it's really good quality, not to mention, FRESH.....I don't mind paying more for that. It's nice to know there are places peppered throughout our country that can deliver on fresh, quality fish.......and a great selection at that !! read more

See all

Service outstanding along with the quality of seafood. The guys who clean the fish are spectacular

I stopped in on Saturday and the line was out the door. Forget social distancing, people are on top of each other. I asked for jumbo crabs and the worker points me to the crabs at $8.99 a pound. They were tiny, anything but jumbo. I asked him where the Jumbos were and he said those are the jumbos. The smallest crabs I ever saw.,salmon selling at $22 a pound, scallops were even more expensive. Lobsters at 1 1/4 pounds selling 3 for $69. What a bunch of thieves. Save your money and stay away read more

Two Cousins Fish Market - a pile of blue crabs - Seafood Markets Near Me - Freeport, New York

If you want fresh fish you have to check out Two Cousins Fish Market. The staff is friendly and efficient. The market always smells like the ocean and they have all types of fish as well as some prepared stuff like fresh calamari salad. Kevin in the front is the sweetest man. The guys in the back cleaning your fish (if you need them to) are also fantastic. Tip them well because it's a tough job, but someone has to do it. You can enjoy the music while you wait for them to clean your fish...they are always super fast and super friendly. I have been buying my fish from them for 10 years...I have 2 fish markets less than 5 minutes from my home in Oceanside...but I will travel a little further to the Nautical Mile to get my fish from Kevin and the guys. Pop by for all your seafood needs you will not be disappointed. read more

The selection here is INSANE. Yes, it's pricey but you are paying for QUALITY. Nothing frozen, nothing from Indonesia, always so fresh. You can pick up a whole fish and next door they can clean & filet it for you. Everything from shrimp, to swordfish to whole grouper. This place NEVER disappoints. read more

I was highly recommended to patronize this establishment by a friend I traveled all the way from Brooklyn to be treated rudely by the guys who cleaned the fish. I purchased nearly $200 dollars worth of fish the nice gentlemen carried it to the back to be cleaned and the guy saw that I had money in my hand which was only $5 so I gave it to him as a tip, he says that was not enough because he's cleaning a lot of fish, there's a clear sign that states tips are accepted not obligated !!! I complained to the owner and he tells me they work independently and they are not affiliated with them are you kidding me !! That's bad for his business I will not be going back and I'm telling everyone I know don't waste there time I hate that this was a bad experience because the fish was fresh and the market has great customer service I hope they get find better fish cleaners there rude behavior is not good for business. read more

I've been going to Two Cousins for years since Fiore Brothers closed after Sandy. All was well then all of a sudden they wouldn't let anyone wait in the fish cleaning area. I used to spend on average $100. A visit. My last visit I bought 2 Lbs of jumbo shrimp for 25 dollars and after cleaning I was sure the package was "Lite" (missing product) I let it go being I was in a hurry. This Friday July 5th again I bought 2 Lbs jumbo shrimp and took them to the cleaning station I sat in the car / my wife came with the cleaned shrimp and immediately I knew I was robbed ! I told her to go back in the "front to have it put on the scale again" on the way in one of the workers said what is wrong? She explained and handed him the bag he said you're write this is not 2 Lbs. then the "big guy" white hair / mustache who sits behind the register says lets weigh it. From 2.04 Lbs it weighed 1.6 Lbs almost 1/2 lbs "disappeared into thin air" he then tells her the most bogus story about how cleaning them the "heads, poop, and shells" is why almost half a pound was missing. I went back into the Fish market myself and he tried the same bogus excuse on me , except I'm a fishing fanatic and am good at sizing up weight. I put the cleaned shrimp on the scale and told him "these are shrimp tails, no heads and that shells are paper thin weighing nothing" if anyone has ever cleaned shrimp, I have and use the shells to make stock they are almost weightless ! So I told him at this rate your employees go home with pounds of everyone elses products. I made it clear I was disappointed, furious and would find another vendor. Don't get robbed, either stand In the cleaning area or just go to another vendor. His seafood is just as fresh as any other vendor. It is NOT Brought in by boat "fresh daily" is bogus I know I live in Freeport . Sincerely disappointed and robbed, Fishbonz !!! read more

This place is amazing. Probably the only place outside of Africa that has tilapia caught in the wild. Their selection of wild, not farmed, fish is so remarkable. What a jewel! read more

Two cousins fish market is one of the most amazing places to get your fish in all of Freeport and Long Island. The staff is wonderful and courteous and know their stuff incredibly in all areas of fish and seafood knowledge. The man in the front Kevin is wonderful and always courteous to the customers. This market has some of the best clams in all of New York let alone East Coast. Go there once and you'll be going there forever!!!!!! read more

Fresh fish and shellfish. Excellent service. And plenty of ingredients to help you prepare your dishes. Simply, the best seafood market in Freeport. Easily, four and a half stars. read more

Best place on Long Island to get the freshest seafood imo. I've seen the men get off the boat and sell or bring fish to the market. They also have a part in the back where the guys sell scraps of fish I buy for my dog. Small family owned business. Very friendly. Highly recommend. read more

Good variety. They offer military discount. I like the marinated squid. The lobster bisque not bad flavor but to current I like it chunkier. Prices are okay but I found side places with cheaper big size lobsters. I just moved from dc we have a huge fish market there nothing compared to this. But its all good. read more

The fish is always fresh. I have bought salmon, red snapper and bass. I also bought crab legs and shrimp and when I cook them, they always come out tender and juicy. The employees are always so pleasant and helpful. They are a little pricey but for the most part worth it. read more

These guys are great! Made a large purchase on Sunday unfortunately my flounder fillet was not added in the bag after it was paid for, went in the next days everyone in the front was super nice and accommodating! Will continue to do business with them. Have to appreciate great customer service during times like these. read more

I have been going here for years and recently Danny and Kevin have been doing a great job. The fish and shellfish are just as fresh as they always were. Their selection is second to none and their prices are very reasonable. There's nothing better than fresh, high quality seafood and there's no better place to get it than here. read more

the fish is always fresh . and the guys there are always helpful . I always come here for my crab legs

I love the selection and the fish but what's up with the grumpy old guy at the counter - he seems pissed at the world. I walked in with my baby who is two months old in a stroller and he orders me to put the baby on the side with no politeness or courtesy. I wouldn't mind keeping the stroller aside but I'm giving you money and increasing your business so have some manners and fake a smile. Other than that it's great! read more

I can't say enough about this place! We love fresh fish but it wasn't always the easiest to find or trust in our previous home. "Fresh" fish was only found at the supermarket... uggh!! Two Cousins is different. They are the seafood purveyors to many of the local restaurants.They're always busy, constantly replenishing their stock so you know their fish is always the freshest...much of it from local waters. They will fillet your fish or shuck your clams for free. The guys in there know their product & can answer your questions including cooking suggestions... read more

Best quality of seafood The fish is always fresh, and the guys are very helpful. Kevin is the best!!!!!! read more

Today as my first time buying fish from this place ,due to the reviews and ratings on here. When I first walked in everything was going well. The older gentleman gave me a warm welcome and even offered me free samples of the seafood salads they had available. He was incredibly helpful. He's the only reason I even gave this place 2 stars. Things went down hill when we went to the back where they clean and filet the fish. BE PREPARED TO HAVE THE GUYS RUDELY BEG FOR TIPS. One of them also claimed they work for tips like they don't get paid any other way. The other man implied that them cutting ans cleaning the fish isn't free like the man at the register told us. The men who works in the back are no where near as gracious as the older gentleman. The guy that was working on our fish kept offering to sell us fish scraps left over from previous customers for a really "good price". I wonder if the man in the front is aware of this hustle that's going on in the back. Overall the workers in the back were extremely rude and left a really bad taste in my mouth. They have no sense of customer service. They also were talking about us in Spanish not knowing I understood ever word!!!!! Next time I need fish I'm going down the street instead. read more

I remember waddling up to the fish and poking their eyes when my parents would take me here to pick up seafood for Christmas Eve dinner as a baby. 20 years later I know that if I need friendly service and quality ocean-fare at a reasonable price, two cousins is my go-to. Located right on the Nautical Mile Two Cousins has been servicing the Village and surrounding areas for years. Parking can be a bit of a pain and if their lot is full you can utilize the metered parking provided by the municipality. read more

Do yourself a favor and go to the neighboring fish markets. Years ago, we loved this place, however, something must have changed. The place literally stinks (as in smells, something you dont expect from a clean fishmonger), and the service is terrible. They close up shop before the posted hours and they are not friendly. And their prices arent even that good. As paying customers, we have choice, and don't need to be treated like we are being a nusance when trying to spend money. read more

Fantastic selection of the freshest fish available in the area. Add the facts that the people are always willing to help you to selection the correct fish when you want to try something new and advise you on the proper way to cook, makes this overall the best Fish Market around. read more