This place is under looked at because of the place next door, the Bagel Emporium, which it's overhyped and overpriced. The atmosphere was great, small but cozy, the staff is very helpful and friendly. I ordered a Chipotle chicken sandwich with mouster cheese, LTM, jalapeños, and a Turkey wrap with mixed greens, honey mustard and Swiss cheese. A side of macaroni salad and a sour pickle. To say the least, everything was absolutely delicious! A solid 10/10 and definitely coming back! read more

Food is average, also tried breakfast, scrambled eggs on a roll with bacon just didn't have a real taste to it. The eggs didn't seem natural and the bacon not too fresh. read more

Giving this 5 stars to increase the overall rating. It's really more like 3.5. Looking at the reviews here convinced me for a long while to avoid this place like the plague, even though I live around the corner. Went in randomly 1 day to get a drink, and contrary to what's written here they couldn't have been friendlier. That convinced me to come back and try the food. They were mobbed when I came the next time between people waiting and also to go orders. Even so they took care of my order quickly. Drink and chip options were solid. I got a Reuben and my wife got the Virginia. My Reuben was solid, with a decent amount of meat, and it was very well balanced with not too much thousand island or cheese. My wife liked her sandwich even though it had Mayo on it which she normally hates. Pricing was cheap so that made it even better. Why the disparity in reviews? Not sure if they changed owners or something. More over, it's a case of what my wife described as people complaining about 'deli sushi'. That's not to say they have sushi, it's to make the point that you should never order things in a deli (like sushi) which have no prayer of a chance of being good. It's a fucking deli. Buy a sandwich. Not everything in the display case looked amazing, but that's always the case. Judging a deli like a Michelin star restaurant doesn't make an ounce of sense. As much as these guys are a totally normal and solid deli, they made a believer of me. I will be back. read more

So I go in and order some thing and then some people come in behind me and there was actually a lot of people behind me and they got their orders and I'm still waiting for mine. I ordered a spinach wrap with egg and hash brown. The hashbrowns was so crunchy and oily. I couldn't even finish it. I threw it out, let's just say I won't be going back there again read more

This place has a hot lunch menu and different specials every day of the week but they make amazing sandwiches I love the roast beef and Swiss with less tomato mayo salt pepper olive oil and vinegar. But I see everyone coming here for amazing sandwiches and ordering food to go for lunch it's always fresh always delicious and a wonderful staff read more

Tarrytown Delicatessen - Roast beef in a roll - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

Again... mistook my order after I repeated my order 3 times. This is my third time I get to my desk to discover It's something that I do not want. This deli sucks. read more

Old school breakfast sandwich, coffee, quick service, perfect for a pit stop when about to cross the bridge

Pretty much where the Saw Mill River Parkway hits I-87/287, you'll find the fifty year old Tarrytown Deli. It was on our direct route to MetLife Stadium, which made it a convenient stop to pick up sandwiches for the game. What an impressive place! It has just about everything you could possibly want for a meal -custom cooked breakfasts, twenty four kinds of cold and twelve kinds of hot sandwiches, paninis, wraps, over twenty homemade salads, hot lunch specials, bakery goods, soups, chips and snacks, etc. My turkey sub for the game, and a croissant for the car ran $10.74 and I was very happy with both. The croissant was delicious and still warm! The turkey sandwich had a generous portion of super fresh deli turkey and the shredded lettuce, provolone cheese, sliced tomatoes and spicy mustard I asked for turned this into one helluva great lunch. If I lived nearby, I'd be here a lot read more

See all

If I could give a half star, I would. I literally am around this area DAILY, and am ALWAYS hungry...They lost a loyal customer and an outspoken foodie who loves to share new places to eat.. I walked in here, almost salivating because of how hungry I was. I expected to be greeted, helped, tended, asked "What would you like to order?", to which I would respond "Hi its my first time here, and then ask the person helping me what they would recommend, or what dish the place is known for.. I was actually visibly profiled, and a person who just walked in was greeted and tended to by the same lady who was supposed to finally (after a good amount of time had passed and I was standing at the counter and walking to and from one end to the other hoping someone would acknowledge me and help me. Unfortunate. But before the food, comes the service and I recommend the bagel shop thats right next door, I ordered the meatiest bagel ive had in a while, and that says plenty since im a native New Yorker. read more

Stay away!!! I was working in the area today and headed over to the bagel place next door but the line was long and the seats were taken so I opted for the deli next door. BIG MISTAKE!! I ordered a Philly cheesesteak which was listed as one of their daily specials. About halfway through the sandwich I bit into something rock hard. I spit it out and can only assume and hope that it was a piece of bone?! I've NEVER encountered a piece of bone in a Philly. EVER. I took one more bite and tasted something off. Almost sour. I didn't finish eating and within minutes my stomach was RUMBLING!! It's now 4pm and I've been on and off the toilette with serious bloating, gas and diarrhea. The last thing on my mind was to take picture because I dont ever leave reviews but I created a YELP account today, specifically to let you all know about this place. On top of all this as I was eating the sandwich all I could think was "wow, this sandwich is not at all good. No flavor and not made with care. Eat at your own risk. read more

Not sure what's up with Asian lady who had us waiting to pay for ready made soup and coffee. No eye contact - with me or my mom, but with Jekyll and Hyde like hospitality, was discriminatory friendly with three people who arrived after us and placed deli orders. Thank God for the polite gentlemen who came to our rescue and checked us out after completing deli orders. The sign in the window reads "Established in 1960"... We definitely felt like she treated us like it was circa 1950. C'est La Vie .... even in 2018. Not a big deal. The coffee was good. Made it myself so I was confident in drinking it. read more

Wish I read the reviews before coming here. Basically everything is already premade. This isn't like a deli at all, it's more like a gas station. I asked for a grilled vegetable wrap with no mushrooms and the woman told me, "I'm sorry it is already made and we can't remove any items." Are you kidding me? It's a deli! It was a cold vegetable wrap mostly made of lettuce. Disappointing read more

Tarrytown Delicatessen - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

I really like this place. I was a little hesitant to try it due to the many negative reviews. I especially love it for the coffee and friendly responsive crew. Only Dominick's further down the street has a coffee that matches here. They also have a pretty good egg and cheese with hash brown sandwich. There's also a sandwich called SEX which I find funny. That's all I've tried so far. Their deli in case offerings tend to look old, but one day this week I went in mid morning and everything was super fresh. I'll need to try their prepared foods soon. Now if you want a bagel, croissants or muffins try someplace else. I initially came here seeking refuge from the similarly awful bagels and coffee and service of Bagel Emporium next door. However no dice on that front. Their old expired dried up stuff is plain awful. They do other things better. A lot of people also say the Korean couple who own the deli and the stationery story next door are rude. That hasn't been my experience at all. In fact I find them professional and very friendly with their regulars. What I've noticed is that in these affluent areas...white privilege is on full display, and if you're not bowing to them they get nasty. read more

Tarrytown Delicatessen - Front of Tarrytown Deli. - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

If you like cold cut sandwiches that are 75% lettuce and tomato, then this is the place for you. Never been to a deli that makes sandwiches this cheap! I had the same experience on two different visits. Clearly they think everyone is stupid. All bread, tomato and lettuce, embarrassing. Do not go. read more

It's been around forever & I've been here over 30+ years. Great selection of sandwiches (hot/cold), salads & hot foods. Breakfast & lunch only + catering. They did picnic lunches/baskets way back, not sure they do that any more but hey you could just order some salads (health, German potato, red potato, German cucumber), sandwich or wrap & make your own basket. Be prepared to wait on line during peak breakfast & lunch periods. You can place phone orders. read more

ugh, update. so i went a few weeks ago and treated myself to the usual, the pastrami was so fatty i chucked it and didnt eat that day, part lazy, but mostly pissed off they sent this out the door. pathetic on rye. read more

This deli reminds me of the deli's we had in The Bronx when I was growing up. Large selection of salads and cooked item in addition to wedges or heroes as we called them back in the day. Old school charm and worth a trip. When places like this are gone we will shake our heads in disbelief and pine for the old days. read more

Nice deli with a long counter on one side and a long drink cooler on the other. The Italian combo hero was delicious. I haven't had a really good Italian sub since I moved to NY 10 years ago. This may be my new sandwich spot. It's a Boars Head meat place, so the quality is pretty good. They also have salads and desserts. The rice pudding was great. Really good spot in a mini mall type setting. read more

This place is SO inconsistent with their prices AND the quality of their sandwiches depending upon who helps you... Just ordered honey turkey and Swiss with lettuce/tomato and avocado on a roll and it cost me $8.10... At the deli close to my home in Ossining I could have gotten a wedge for that price... I made a comment to the woman at the register that the price seemed a little high for a turkey sandwich even WITH the avocado and she said it was extra for the honey turkey... Got back to my office and there was no cheese on my sandwich and BARELY any turkey, especially for the price I paid... I called the deli to complain and she told me to bring the sandwich back so she can see that there was no cheese on it and she would refund me 50 cents... UNBELIEVABLE!!! I will NEVER get food from this deli again... read more

Tarrytown Delicatessen - All toppings, hardly any turkey, and no cheese (which they charged me for)... I will NEVER eat here again... - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

This deli is horrible. I'm not going to waste time with what this place used to be because it hasn't been in awhile. Four customers lined up 1-2-3-4 to get served in that order, not here. Poor guy behind me who got service before I did, ordered an Italian combo on a roll. Deli slicer wasn't used once, not once. All the cold cuts and cheese were pre sliced, gross. I could get that at a Subway and it'd probably be better because the rolls here aren't very good either...think they get them from Sam's Club or Stop n Shop.. If you were to order a 1/2 pound of American, I'd guarantee they'd go to that pre sliced pile and load you up with that stale thick cut cheese. Because who doesn't like thick cut cheese and deli meats? Interested in hot food? Beef brisket & corned beef are easily 50% fat. Maybe get some soupy stuffing and wet mashed potatoes as a side. I'm done with this place. When a business is this consistent at being bad, it's time to go elsewhere. Just a heads up to the out of towners or to the tourists that may be visiting, this isn't what a NY deli is, it just looks the part. read more

The first time I got a sandwich there it was actually pretty good. The guy who made it was not a talker, but that's cool. Lady at the counter wasn't either but that's cool. Second time I went, I brought my Dad, who was visiting from out of town, telling him this place makes a pretty decent sandwich. When we walked in, the dude was visibly annoyed that he had to tear himself away from the football game on in the back to make my sandwich. Then when I paid the lady, I said, "Mind if I give you some change?". She nodded while I counted a few coins, then 5 seconds later went, "C'mon. C'mon." No one else in the place, by the way. Wow, business owners that don't seem to want to own a business. Bummer. A little courtesy goes a long way. I won't be returning. Plenty other good sandwiches in Tarrytown. read more

Just got an egg and cheese, and it's delicious! Definitely my favorite on yet. Make sure you stop by at this place if you want a quality meal! read more

Food is pretty good. It is apparently owned by a husband and wife. The husband is hard working and respectful. The wife who often is at the register is rude and fake. I will never go back. read more

Ok so I really hate to do this but their sandwiches and prices are very very inconsistent! I actually went back to the store to have them fix it. And when i called to speak with the manager, they said she wasn't there! I just left the deli and knew she was there. She rung me up! I always get the same thing...the only person that can make a good sandwich there is the Caucasian gentleman who wears a baseball cap and T-shirt. He actually puts meat in the sandwich. And at $9 a pop there should be! Everyone makes their sandwiches differently, including the owner. Which makes me crazy till no end. Just make it good the same way every time and charge me the same please! I even took a picture of my $9 sandwich. I could have gone to subway if I just wanted tomatoes and lettuce on my huge loaf of bread! read more

Tarrytown Delicatessen - My $9 sandwich with no meat! Really unacceptable! - Delis Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

Really good food and they've been here since I was a college student (20 + years ago!).

Ok, what is going on with this deli? 2nd time here and again it was disappointing. This time the owner made our roast beef sandwich himself and it was awful! It seemed like the bread was a day old and the meat didn't even cover the bread. I think he put 4 (if i was lucky) slices on the sandwich and it tasted like it had gone bad. Won't be going back... ever! read more

Absolutely Love this Deli! Was working in the area and went here all week for breakfast and lunch. Great sandwiches!! I did notice the price was a bit different everyday but if you're worried about a few cents or even a couple dollars one way or the other, you should budget for Subway or McD's. read more

Unless you are a regular and can make nice with someone this is the pace that will let you stand there for 3 Minutes and not make eye contact with you when there is no one in the store. When you finally get your hero. This is the pace that will fill your hero with lettuce and cheese and tomato then the little bit of space left is where your meet goes. Open the sandwich and your eating mostly bread and toppings and the the meat is the topping. Sometimes a good hero, most of the time, Where is the meat. I boycott this place for a year at a time. Today I start another year for the next time I forget to bring my lunch. BTW, tell the lady behind the counter she looks great and you get a reaction. Stand there like you need something, dead air. read more

One of the worst delis in the tri-state area. 10 credit card minimum strictly enforced even if your lunch comes out to $9.95. Owners wife is very rude. The food is bland and over-priced. read more