Had to update, food is still great, but the prices are just not justifiable anymore. Paid 14 bucks for a ham sandwich on a club roll, (they call it a baguette but it's the size of a club roll) which came with two of the smallest strips of bacon that I couldn't even taste, and not much ham either. Chicken cutlet sandwiches are now predominately bread. Shrinkflation hit this place hard, food is still bomb, they just need to actually give it to you. read more

I just had the worst tuna sandwich in my entire life. Not at the white plains location but in the new cafeteria in Tarrytown. Bread was not soft. Tuna was watery and over seasoned. read more

Delicious sandwiches! We ordered a cold sandwich and a panini for takeout for lunch one day. The sandwiches had a generous amount of meat and toppings. However, the standout was the bread utilized for each sandwich, which was soft on the inside, crispy on the outside, and full of flavor. We also ordered some freshly baked chocolate cookies, which were scrumptious and served as a perfect dessert to our lunch. The location is convenient and the service is fast, especially during the busy lunch hour. read more

This place used to be awesome till either a new management took over or the service staff was changed. The folks serving have ZERO sense of customer service and to top it off are rude, obnoxious and talk back to customers like they're doing you a favor. Used to be a regular for years.... Never going back. This place sucks snd with this behavior they will be losing more customers. read more

Just had a delicious breakfast sandwich here. I haven't been here for years..but it's still going strong!! Full Bakery and Deli with signature sandwichs, cakes, cookies, and great coffee. Could have used a sweaping, but it was Monday at 10:30 am, I'm assuming I just missed a morning rush, they are forgiven..lol Definitely a great spot for a lunch break if you work in the area. Enjoy! read more

The Iron Tomato - Delis Near Me - White Plains, New York

Literally love this place. The man that works in the Italian part that makes the pizzas and the wedges is the sweetest! And the man at the front desk is my favorite! read more

The Iron Tomato - Buttered roll with cheddar cheese - Delis Near Me - White Plains, New York

I was the only one at the counter waiting to order, with 6 people behind the counter pretending I wasn't there. Took them 5x long to simply acknowledge me than it did to make the bacon, egg, and cheese. Essentially the same think when checking out, I walked up to pay and the lady walked away from the counter, eventually came back and scanned my sandwich without a word. This review only regards the deli side, I had not tried the bakery side. Pros: they play good music Cons: bad customer service, wildly over priced, food was edible, but garbage for the price. read more

We're here from northern california and stopped in for a sandwich. Where we live, a good deli is hard to find, only a couple of good ones nearby. Great selection of sandwiches, salads, soups, pizzas, bakery. I had the Cuban panini cause it's one of my fave sandwiches. It was delish! Hubs had the chicken cutlet sandwich. It was huge and save the other half. My fave part about visiting new york are the deli's! read more

The Iron Tomato - Cuban panani, so good! - Delis Near Me - White Plains, New York

I was in town for a conference. This was a good option outside of the hotel. They have breakfast sandwiches starting at $3.50, coffee, deli items, pizza, and a huge bakery. Central location on Mamaroneck. read more

See all

I say, I was initially unsure what to think of an establishment named after a metal fruit. However after several years of patronage I can say that whatever an "Iron Tomato" is, it's good! I've tried their pizza which is decent, at best, their salads are serviceable too. However, the REAL reason you should come here are for their signature sandwiches. There are a plethora of delicious options from cold cuts to hot cutlets and more. Despite being as upscale and gentrified as it is, the sandwiches are comparatively cheap to others in the area. Despite this, the ingredients are fresh and taste better than the competition! Good show! Fare 4/5 Price $$ read more

The owners arrogant attempt of a response proves why I will not be returning here. Instead of waisting your time to try to find excuses to cover up your poor and unsanitary establishment practices, you should put that same effort and time into actually making it a pleasurable experience for your customers as it does have potential to be a great place. Bringing these concerns to your personal attention before writing a public review will not do anything but hide these concerns from people who are looking to visit this place. It is more important potential customers know what they're walking into rather then hiding it from them and bringing it up to the owner personally. If there was any care to fix these problems, they would have been fixed as I gave this place almost half a year before trying it again only to find it worse than before. The food cabinets are dirty and bug infested and the service is still slow even when no one is there. Orders should be prepared when they are placed, not upon arrival. I feel bad for the people who work in the area thinking they can come in here for a quick bite on their break. read more

***** may be a touch too generous, but I'm not going to split hairs here. The Iron Tomato is basically the most well rounded deli in town. It has sushi, pizza, salads, sandwiches, and a very well stocked bakery. Service here is decent, and the dining here is adequate. read more

This reminds me of a joke on a Nexflix show called "Comedians in Cars Getting Coffee." Will Farrell and Jerry Seinfeld are in this Greek coffee shop, and Will picks up this huge menu and sarcastically says, " I like a place with a lot of items on their menu because you know they do them all beautifully." I feel the same way about Iron Tomato and their Costco-esque approach to food - which, by the way works great for Costco, but not for breakfast, brunch, lunch, dinner, and a bakery-type place. They have a lot of items on the menu, but everything is just ok. I avoided writing this review for a long time, hoping it would get better, but last week, I got the driest chicken cutlet sandwich with almost no flavor. I have to say; they're very convenient, but convenience shouldn't be their only goal. ` BB read more

The Iron Tomato is a remarkable restaurant and bakery! They have an exceptional selection of everything from smoothies to pizza as well as salads and sandwiches. To me the greatest surprise of the Iron Tomato is that they have a fabulous bakery. I've become a huge fan of their cakes, cookies and outstanding biscotti! They are famous for their chocolate cannolis but I've yet to try any desserts that aren't fabulous! read more

See all

Well I had some of the pastries from the iron tomato in the past , we were in the area so we thought we would try there sandwiches. The meat was boars head . Note that their roast beef was home cooked which was excellent. Sandwich's we're avg for the area . They had pre made pizza that looked dry and stale . On the other side of the area they have a women making fresh salad with the ingredients that you pick . The pastries were a bit on the dry side , I guess I pick these a few pastries that were a few days old . They give you a five percent discount with the Yelp check in but when I showed the cashier the discount coupon he acted like he didn't know anything about it and read the whole coupon before giving me a discount. Sorta not good for business when they offer us a discount and act like we're scamming them ! read more

The Iron Tomato - The inside - Delis Near Me - White Plains, New York

I was "Yelping" places to get good iced coffee and breakfast food near my hotel and this place looked the most promising. My family and I walked the two blocks to The Iron Tomato and walked out happy we made the decision. Waling in the place can seem a little confusing but don't worry, someone will quickly point you in the right direction. The restaurant is divided into different areas, pastries, lunch, hot foods, breakfast, etc. Again, don't worry, the staff is awesome and will tell you what you need to know. We were there for breakfast and ordered iced coffee, a couple of bagels with locks and cream cheese and my son ordered pancakes and bacon. All were really good; definitely no complaints. read more

See all

Things have upgraded and it's tasting a lot better. Wedding cake cookies and cherry cookies are the best ever read more

See all

Super good chopped salad. Terrible baked goods though...almond cookies tasted like they'd been frozen since Christmas...the topping of raspberry jam and dark chocolate disguised but but couldn't hide it. The 'cream puffs' once again tasted like they'd come out of the freezer...and were filled with CANOLI filling instead of custard. Mini cheesecake was more like cake cake... Prices were what you'd expect to pay for fresh baked goodies...so big disappointment. Sorry for the bad review but it is what it is. read more

Came in to grab lunch and they have a lot of options which is nice. I decided on a sandwich. I got chicken cutlet with bruschetta and mozz. It wasn't terrible but not great either. The chicken was very over cooked and dried out and overall the sandwich was dry. Would need to add dressing to it to make it better. The staff were super nice and quick. I would come back and try something else and update my rating hopefully. read more

Unfortunately, this restaurant doesn't keep their hours up-to-date on ordering platforms. I would be hesitant about ordering from them in that case; even if they accept your order, you might show up to a closed restaurant and have to deal with calling GrubHub customer support to get a refund - very frustrating. read more

delicious foods and drinks٫ cool setup٫ You walk in on one side and walk out on the other to get to the registers. You walk through a gallery of food drink and snack options from sushi to smoothies to pizza. All of it made right in front of you and AMAZING salads. The service is very friendly and at the salad station they can help you decide some of your ingredients because there's so much to choose from!!! Go there today!! read more

I had been meaning to try Iron Tomato for a while now. When I first started exploring the Mamaroneck Ave strip, it was one of the first businesses that stood out to me - mainly because of its poppin' sign and all the goodies I saw when looking through the window. Today I was looking for lunch and thought it was the perfect opportunity to explore the Tomato. Iron Tomato is way more than what I had initially thought. I was kind of thinking this was a quick-stop deli-ish place with some baked goods, but in actuality the Tomato is quite large. Not only do they have a deli section, but also a bakery, sushi station, and salad station - as well as a number of boxed sandwiches, desserts, and quick snacks. They also do catering, and have a good amount of indoor seating plus more outside. Since I was in the mood for a sandwich, I headed towards the deli section in the back. There was a little bit of a line but there were a number of people working behind the counter so the line moved quickly. They have a number of paninis, salads, and wraps to choose from - I decided to go with the smoked turkey wrap. In addition to the turkey, the wrap had lettuce, crumbled feta, mayo, roasted peppers, and romaine lettuce. The wrap was good - it was a healthy size and the ingredients definitely complemented each other, though I personally didn't think the mayo was necessary; swapping it out for something a little more exotic would probably bring the wrap to another level. Service was very good - the staff was on top of it, I got my wrap quickly and was rung out promptly. I think I only scratched the surface of what Iron Tomato has to offer, but after today I look forward to returning to explore more of what they have to offer. read more

The Iron Tomato - aesthetics - Delis Near Me - White Plains, New York

See all

Simply the best chopped salad bar in White Plains. Nothing compares my big problem is there hours they close at 4 o'clock in the afternoon every day they used to be open for supper now their hours are very inconvenient for me. If they have better hours, they would get five stars, as along with the salads bar their deli sandwiches are also in the best in White Plains, shame on their hours. I know they change their hours for Covid, but could you change them back love to have dinner here or sometime not with these hours. read more

Adorable spot that came highly recommended! The pastries were heavenly. Must try when visiting

Highly not recommended - at least for desserts. Horrible desserts. Chocolate Cup cakes had very off taste to it, something very artificial flavor to it. Sarah raspberry cookies seemed days old to taste. Eclair is yet to be tried and tested. Never again would buy at least desserts from this place. Stale and not good. I agree on the sandwiches review posted below. The bread was stale as well. It was tough and chewy and you had to really pull on it. Also I realized my tshirt was covered with white flour as I ate, as the bread underside had too much loose flour stuck to it. I had to use paper napkins as a bib and on the lap to ensure It dint cover me while I ate the sandwich. Lol. read more

I've been here twice and gotten a bagel and croissant breakfast sandwich and everything was delish! It's my go to breakfast spot when I'm there! read more

This is the worst food I've ever ordered, I ordered a ceasar salad with shrimp and they forgot to give me shrimp told them i didnt want it and then they wouldn't give me the money back because"they preferred to send the 3 pieces of shrimp than to loose a whole salad" Now that the owner has responded we can all see, it its not because of the mistake as i work in custumer service i know people make mistakes, it is about the attitude i got when i got asked if i would not eat the salad because it doesnt have the shrimp i ordered, it is because the sheimp i got was disgusting, and i even tipped the delivery guy extra because i felt bad he had to go back, and please i do not waste food so do not make any assumptions about me you have no idea what i do, the whole reason i called back saying I would send back the food it is because i didnt want to just throw it out, and since you are such an advocate for feeding those in need I encourage you to not waste your left overs and give to the comunity, and how about being nice to your costumer maybe if you didnt take time veing rude here you could actually pay attentions to your orders and get them right! read more

The Iron Tomato - Ceasar salad - Delis Near Me - White Plains, New York

See all

I love it here. Food and staff is great. I've come here for breakfast sandwiches and lunch. BEC is always top tier, the cookies fire, and pizza is pretty good too. This place has lots of options for food and drinks! read more

I love this place. Tons of options from handmade salads to pizza to deli sandwiches to cannoli. Prices are on the higher side, but isn't that the norm near the WP city center? It's too bad the hours end so early as this could be a really good take away/delivery spot. read more

Only purchased from their bakery but would not do so again. Ordered 2 lbs of Italian cookies and they were absolutely horrible. Do not think of buying from their bakery. read more

A great market in White Plains with a super impressive bakery that would make the cookie monster go bananas. So this is a small Italian market with a seating area to go and enjoy those delicious baked goods/pizzas/sandwiches and salads. They have prepared salads and even a create your own salad bar (priced at per lb). I went with the gluten free pizza and at $9 was delicious and perfectly slzed. Didn't mess with their sandwiches or panini's, but was reminiscent of that Wall St. deli that literally has everything. Did I mention their extensive bakery? Literally any kind of baked good you'd want is here. Oh gelato? They have that too. Great stop on the way to CT and I most definitely would stop again. read more

The Iron Tomato - Delis Near Me - White Plains, New York

See all

3/24 This business is ridiculous. I had 3 awful experiences there. Bad food, bad service, gave it a couple tries.... It wasn't great. Was there again tonight. Waited 10 minutes for service - I spent $20 there but I won't be back. They blasted my home address on their page and this definitely is violating as a customer. I will not be back. Thanks for harassing your customers! I've been here a few times. The cookies are extremely hard - they were really hard to chew. The employees are not that friendly either - I had to look around for someone to help me for a few minutes. And, when I finally found an employee they were extremely rude. I won't be back! 1/30 I emailed the owner and he sent me an email back telling me to update my review. You definitely can't bribe me with free gift cards to update my review. If your employees and food are unfortunate, then you need to correct those problems, not my review ... 1/30 PM The owner messaged me back again shocked at my update to the review. First, no one can ever bribe me to write/change a review. I'm extremely honest about my experiences and love to share these - good or bad - with my Yelp followers, friends, family and the general public. I know lots of businesses bribe reviewers and I am very against this. This is very poor business practice. I feel extremely uncomfortable with this business and business owner. Don't attack me through emails and messages telling me to do something I don't want to do. I didn't like my experience at your establishment and I haven't met anyone else who has published a good review without being bribed. Fix your staff and food, not your reviews. That would be a much better business practice. 1/30 PM again The owner continued to message me telling me in lieu of the gift card he's sending me I should give them another star. Then he proceeded to say he's not bribing me. This is one of the many reasons I will absolutely never walk into this business again. Unprofessionalism, bribery, poor business practice - and instead of admiring his staff is rude and unfriendly and the sushi, salad, cookies, and food is not up to average par, he's attacking me as a customer - a person who dines out in downtown White Plains several times a week. You just lost another customer! read more

Nice place to have a good lunch, is place is pretty big to be only a delis they have good bakeries, a pizza spot with Italian specialties and a great salad bar. Sandwiches and wraps are awesome and the variety is nothing short of awesome. The taste is very amazing. The salad is very fresh and they charge by the pound, where you also can add fried chicken or grill chicken and shrimps. What can I say about the bakery? The words will not be enough to describe the great that they bake their cake, cookies and pastry. I can't think of anything bad to say about this place. I would very highly recommend it to anybody. read more

The Iron Tomato - Delis Near Me - White Plains, New York

This review is only for the bakery because I haven't tried anything else. Lobster Tails are excellent. (Had them twice and both times they blew me away) Red Velvet Cupcakes are decent. They are not made with a cream cheese frosting (which is why i had to take a star off) read more

The Iron Tomato - Lobster Tails - Delis Near Me - White Plains, New York

I've never written a YELP review before and delayed writing this one, but I feel this is necessary. I ordered an 8-inch cake, chocolate with cannoli filling 2 weeks in advance. The pickup was smooth. Later that evening when it's time to cut the cake, we see a yellow cake with cannoli filling. Not what was ordered. What's the recourse for that? There's nothing you can do at that point. It was just an unfortunate way to end a happy birthday. I'm only giving one star because that was a major error and unacceptable for a bakery *Update- The cake was picked up on April 21,2022. And to be clear, I've never had any other problem with this establishment. The owner has graciously replied to my post. read more

Went to Iron Tomato today to get soup while I was not feeling well. I've ordered their sandwiches and other things before, but I had never actually been in there until today. The employees were BEYOND friendly; they absolutely exceeded my expectations. I interacted with at least 6 different employees and every single one was so kind and had an amazing attitude. The employees were so accommodating and patient with their customers. The gentleman at the pizza counter gave me a generous piece of bread on the house-- which was beyond delicious and perfectly cooked. The same gentleman went out of his way to carry my hot food to the pay counter so I wouldn't burn myself. Had I had cash on me, I would have put money in his and the other employee's tip jars... but I definitely will make it a point to when I go there soon. Being as I was not feeling well and couldn't taste any of my own food at home, the chicken noodle soup I bought from Iron Tomato was literally the best I've ever had. I got generous amounts of both pasta, chicken (large, delicious chunks) and vegetables. When I asked if I could have extra crackers, the employee was so kind and very generous with the amount he gave me, and he didn't make me feel bad for asking like some restaurants do. I also ordered their rice balls, which were equivalently delicious. Their selection is huge and from what I've tried, everything in there is extremely delicious. This is an incredible establishment and the owner should be proud. I'm definitely going there at least twice a week now. read more

The Iron Tomato - Delis Near Me - White Plains, New York

$18 for an Italian Combo on a day old Bastone hero is a disgrace. Highway robbery for a terrible sandwich. Also the servers behind the counter pretend you're not standing there waiting to order for some reason. read more

Although there are reviews on-line saying they offer gluten free pastries they do NOT have GF options aside from packaged cookies. The rest of the pastries look good but were not fresh. read more

Hours are too short now, food quality has gone down, while prices have gone up. All that can be excused, except they lie about their prices. The cashier told me my total was $17.87, and I was charged $18.58. I'm glad I asked for my receipt as it states on it a non-cash adjustment. If you're now going to charge more for those paying with credit cards than cash, you need to be explicit about it and not underhanded, especially since this was never done in the past and there was no signage anywhere stating that this was a practice. I'm glad my patronage of this store has waned in recent years and I doubt I'll be back any time soon. After the owner has responded, I understand and sympathize that places are all dealing with Covid in different ways, however, I would have like to have been told what my actual total was instead of being asked to pay one number and being charged another. If they can see I'm paying by card, tell me my total is $18.58. Don't tell me it's $17.87 and then wait for me to find out on my own. Also if there is signage posted at the register, you could've fooled me. read more

$161 for bagel platter and small fruit bowl...holy robbery I happened to call back to confirm total before delivery thank goodness read more