I visited Coterie on Saturday, November 15th. The primary reason was to listen to the Straight up Chumps, an alternative rock band. The band was incredible, as expected! The added bonus was the atmosphere, service, food and fun of Coterie Kokomo is a mid-sized city about an hour north of Indy. The venue is a local favorite for music and great burgers. They did not disappoint this out of town visitor! The staff was welcoming. The menu, while limited, had a great variety of sandwiches and salads. I chose the Coterie burger which is served with fries. It was fire . The music venue is next door to the primary bar and is full service for food and drinks. The entire evening was so much fun - I highly recommend Coterie for an evening out! read more

See all

This place is amazing!!!! Kyle is super cool and nice. Sure he cursed at us but what the heck the food was Amazing!!!!! The Feeling was pretty cool dude!!!!! read more

The Coterie - A picture of me - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

Apparently, we couldn't bring our baby in to sit and eat with us. They have booster seats for children up in front by the doors/windows. Their website has no indication that they are a bar or don't allow people/children under the age of 21.... Don't advertise that you are a burger joint if you're not... read more

A great local bar with great burgers. Service is always good. Food is great, even better after a few drinks ahah. A great spot in downtown Kokomo. Vibes are always good too. The fried pickles were alright, the batter is like a sweet and thick similar to funnel cake. The burger creations are always spot on and delicious. We will be back soon. read more

See all

Very very amazing food and service. Everyone is so nice and accommodating, the ambiance was new and vintage mixed well. The Cookie butter burger although sounds different tastes amazing! Must try read more

This is one of my least favorite bars in Kokomo. First, the good: this place has the most live music in town. I've seen all kinds of different bands play in their upstairs. And the food admittedly tastes pretty good, but in my opinion it's too expensive and portion sizes aren't really worth it. But it does taste good. The bad: I'll start with the door fee. I've seen them charge a $10 cover to get into the downstairs when there's not even a band playing upstairs, it's just a regular Friday night or whatever. Door charges are never cool, but especially not when the bar has nothing going on and it's just a room full of snobby 23 year olds. Which brings me to the Ugly: the vibe at this bar is trash. Very cliquey, mostly stuck up hipsters. All the way down to the beer list. Call me old fashioned, but I don't really like a bar where I can't get a Budweiser, especially not a bar where the cheapest drink available is like a $7 10oz draft of some craft stuff that smells like an actual armpit (not hating on IPAs). Also the bartenders don't let you access the jukebox so... That's great or whatever. Now you gotta just sit there listening to "stomp clap hey" kinda stuff while the 35 year old wearing a bowtie and suspenders stares at you like you got a problem. If there's not a band playing, 9 times outta 10 you're better off hitting Soupleys and staying home read more

Been here a few times while in town on business. Nice selection of bourbon and other spirits. Old fashioned I had was great. The staff is friendly and helpful in helping to pick drinks and food. The food was standard pub food with some twists. Friendly crowd and definitely a local fave. Would totally recommend and will go back. read more

You have to go to The Coterie for the burgers and cheese curds! I'm not sure I've had a better burger in my life. The portions are also very generous. We didn't need an appetizer, but the cheeseburger did not disappoint. The atmosphere isn't my taste but that's not what I was there for. So glad it's close to home- We will be back! read more

Amazing food, service, staff, and hard to find bourbon for a great price. Very nice vibe.

My review is a little overdue as I was here in April of 2022. I chose The Coterie online because they had a Beyond burger on the menu, and the person I dined with didn't want to eat at the other places I found with vegan options. This was a bit of a dive bar more than a restaurant, which was fine, but it wasn't quite what I was expecting for a birthday meal. It'd be a cool place to visit on a date or with friends on a weekend though. The Beyond burger was good. I just didn't realize it came with cheese, as I didn't see that on the menu, and asked for it without. I also left off the aioli and asked for mustard. A little strange to me that a Beyond burger would come with dairy. Server didn't understand my request exactly. It seemed a little overpriced at the time, but now in 2023, it costs the same as going to BK but tastes much better. (Dang inflation is killing me.) Food in baskets. Nothing fancy. Pretty good fries. I can't remember the name of it now, but I had a beer from NW Indiana which I chose just because it was from "Da Region." Decent selection of draft beers as I recall with several from different parts of the state. My dining companion had a Moscow Mule but didn't really care for how it was made. The ambience and decor were interesting. I especially liked the neon state of Indiana which changed colors. The bar glasses and plastic water cups had far out there and funny sayings on them. I remember the restroom being small and having a line. I believe they had a whiskey bar upstairs which I did not check out. In a pretty convenient location in downtown Kokomo. Easy walk to street parking and other establishments. I don't mind divey. It wasn't bad. It just didn't particularly stand out as a favorite. I might return at some point for the beer and the sandwich as well as the sign. I'd rather sit at the bar next time instead of the tall table we had. They had a long booth toward the front underneath the Indiana sign as well. read more

See all

All I can say is if you love a great smash burger. This is your place!! Best smash I've ever had. It was so juicy and crispy around the edges. Makes my mouth water just thinking about it. We had the fun guy burger. It had sautéed mushrooms and provolone cheese. We also had the shrooms appetizer which was also very tasty. They were different than most deep fried mushrooms. They were more like sliced breaded mushrooms, which made them very tasty. We also got an amaretto sour from the bar. That was also amazing. I will definitely be back. read more

We love this place. We come for lunch, dinner, live music and just to hang out. The burgers are my favorite in Kokomo. And now the bigger menu with that new burger "Double Double Prairie Dog Style". I'm from San Diego and the bartender said "it's like an In n Out burger, animal style" I knew that's the one I had to have. It was amazing!! Pretty damn close to the real thing. The bartenders are always friendly, good selection of beer and liquors and a fun atmosphere. read more

The Coterie - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

See all

The best cocktail bar in Kokomo! Mixes tend to be freshly made. Large variety of base alcohol to either make something off the menu or a classic favorite. While there, you will want to have a fabulous burger (Won 5th best in town! Not sure how it wasn't #1) or sandwich that is not based on something frozen. AND they frequently have a dessert that is fine-dining quality. But those cocktails.... read more

Cheap drinks, good food, and a vibrant crowd. This felt like a cool bar in a college town or larger city. Not what I was expecting in Kokomo, but well worth the drive. We will be coming back for sure. The burgers were amazing. Also can't beat a $7 Old Fashioned. read more

Went on a Sunday afternoon for some burgers and drinks. Our server was super nice and attentive. The burgers were half off and so delicious. Fries and burger sauce were really yummy too! The burger patties and buns are delicious, so you really can't go wrong with any of the burgers. Cocktails were yummy too! Vibes inside were very chill and welcoming. Will 100% be returning for more! read more

Good food, good service and chill atmosphere. Our bartender, Damon, killed it. He made our drinks with perfection and set off a good vibe. Will return when in the area again. Hopefully he is working when we do. Great place, check it out! read more

Great burger, good drink specials. Fun vibe, good service. if i ever end up in Kokomo again I'd definitely go back.

The Coterie has the best food in Kokomo by a lot. The burgers, brunch, tacos on Tuesdays, drinks, and the staff are all amazing! It's more of a laid back and chill bar except during events and parties which are very cool! Can't beat half price burgers from 5-7 either! read more

This is our favorite spot in Kokomo. Hidden gem dive bar. AMAZING beer and impressive cocktail selection. Best burgers in Indiana (especially on Wednesday's). The only thing I wish for is that some of their fun events started around 7pm for us old folks! (Especially the drag shows!) The staff are great. If they could get a hood and fryer in this place, their next step would be world domination!! read more

The Coterie - New menu - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

See all

Don't believe the rigged polls, the Coterie has the best burgers in town. In a three way tie, I'm not sure what's better: their burgers, the curds, or their amazing drinks. I recommend the Mouth Cuddles or they make the best damn sour on the planet. The service is always wonderful too. You also can't go wrong with brunch here on a Sunday. And for those of you who usually have kiddos like me, they've done curbside for me too. Once you go, you'll understand... sometimes you just need a Coterie burger. read more

You can't beat this place . Good atmosphere, live entertainment, good food, amazing staff!

Food was great! Bartender's were extraordinary! But there was a redhead waitress who was the upmost rudest person I have ever met! She wouldn't even acknowledge our table! Maybe had to do with our skin color! read more

Enjoyed Friendsgiving Had fabulous bacon bacon bacon burger while sharing the pimento grilled cheese. Had swell fries. Bar keeps were friendly and engaging But had hoped for Mexican wrestling on TV and only got to watch the Yule log and a bunch of pussies (felines) read more

Very welcoming environment. I have met many people from all walks of life and have always enjoyed my experiences there. Acceptance is a key note from all employees, and have always been met with kindness and professionalism in the field. A fun environment to be in with great music and excellent food choices. Very laid-back atmosphere. read more

Tired Bud Light? Annoyed that the bartender doesn't know what a saison is? Try the Coterie. Want a real cocktail menu? Wonder about what great whiskey you're missing out on? Try the Coterie. Need a good burger? Try the Coterie. AND DEMAND THEY FIGURE OUT HOW TO BRING BACK CHEESECURDS. read more

Fantastic find in Kokomo. We stumbled upon this place and so glad we did! Right in downtown, which is really being built up nicely I must say. Up a flight of fairly steep stairs awaits a super bar, great atmosphere, and choice craft cocktails. The bartender/beverage manager (I think) was super helpful in navigating spirit options and libations. Really love the use of small batch and/or local suppliers. We arrived on a Tuesday evening and had unfortunately missed the Tacos, got the tail end of Trivia, and did not bring our vinyl for the Turntable portion of the evening. We will definitely be back. Watch out for those stairs after a few drinks though! read more

Great place to check out!! Food and services are top notch. Very chill atmosphere! Right on town square.

Great food in a bar! Appys, burgers, sandwiches served with interesting beers or hand-crafted cocktails at reasonable prices. It is an over 21 place but well worth one's time if hungry or thirsty! read more

Great place to get some really nice cocktails. The owners were very nice & so was food. read more

The Coterie - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

The Coterie has absolutely the BEST bartenders to be found without driving to Chicago or Indy. They have specialty burgers on Wednesday that are always interesting and tasty. 2 thumbs way up! read more

racist took everyone else but order(Mexican) never asked what drink we wanted we had to go to bar to get drink

First, $3 drafts on excellent craft beer was great. Also, venue was great. And drinks were made very well. Negatives: TV was showing a women giving birth, along with several other vulgar scenes that I did not think were appropriate for a classy bar. Also, bartender both was drinking and eating Taco Bell behind the bar. Also was responding to drink orders with "what the F*** is that?" Bartender also was swearing a lot and giving indication he did not want me and my friend drinking in the bar because we were young (of-age of course). read more

best atmosphere you'll find in town great staff and food i would recommend everyone check them out

Visiting my boyfriend's family here and this is his favorite bar. I can see why. The owner for one, is so nice and greeted me at the door. There's a really cool cocktail menu and excellent live music (I'm here on a Saturday night). Bar staff is very friendly and quick! It truly is a hidden gem in Kokomo! read more

While the ambiance is very nice, The Coterie likes to blast their PAYING customers for leaving a review on their business Instagram page. They're very unprofessional, rude, and their cocktails are exorbitantly overpriced. 2 stars. Will not go again. read more

Great bar and we had never been here. Can't wait for The Wildcat to open. The bar tender Levi was super. Great recommendation on an Indiana IPA. read more

The Coterie - Great service by Levi and great Indiana beer. - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

Great hidden gem in downtown, if you haven't been before and have trouble finding them, keep looking, (though a storefront door and up the stairs) you wont be sorry! Cool dudes working there with great drinks and great prices. I will be back the next time I'm in town! And if you stop in on a night when the burger is the special, get one (or two) read more

Great atmosphere! Best burger I've ever had recommend The Mexicali burger plus beacon. For drinks the Bees Knees great lavender taste also best drink I've tasted for my palette. Will return in the future. From San Diego and Indiana worth the trip. read more

Amazing craft drinks, local beers and food well above standard. You can't go wrong with anything served here. Better yet, the guys at the bar know the art of making drinks. Don't miss! read more

Overpriced liquor. Even the cans of PBR were over $4. I made the mistake of ordering a Gin Martini and was charged $11. My girl ordered a Moscow Mule and they brought it in a glass instead of a copper mug. Hipster staff has an attitude and took too long to take our orders. Never again. On a lighter note, this is a great place to take a dump. read more