So yummy! We had the cheese curds with hot berry sauce as an appetizer, pulled pork baked Mac and cheese, and a buffalo chicken sandwich. Servings were very generous sized, will prob be eating for a few (happy) days LOL read more

The Cottage Inn - Pubs Near Me - Copenhagen, New York

Stayed in Tug Hill for riding. Rode here for lunch. Sat at the bar and enjoyed it. Nice staff. Good drinks and food. Honestly one of the best Chicken Caesar wrap and cheese curds I've had. The croutons in the wrap were a good crunch factor. 10/10 would return when back in the area. read more

The Cottage Inn - Chicken Caesar wrap - Pubs Near Me - Copenhagen, New York

Steak salad with Maple Vinaigrette dressing was outstanding! Excellent service. Will definitely stop back when in the area

Decided to update my review since it has been a year. We popped in over the weekend to try out their chili for the chili cook-off and try some of their wings. Their chili is so good! It is my favorite so far, and we have tried about 13. I wish I lived closer so I would be able to get at their chili more often! The wings were good. I wish they were more meaty but loved their sauces. Our waitress was great and let us have dry wings because I wanted different sauces than my husband. The sweet Buffalo and butter maple are amazing!!! Such good flavor! read more

See all

Great food! We got the buffalo chicken and the hamburger Mac and Cheese. It's a cute little place. Our server is absolutely new and seems a little all over the place but she is a nice girl. I will definitely come back. read more

See all

Lovely waitress/bartender great recommendations the cheese curds wings were crispy sauces were delicious... seems like they have great following the only horse is beautiful. I'd love to go again. read more

The Cottage Inn - Pubs Near Me - Copenhagen, New York

See all

Stopped in at 3:45 today for prime rib. The waitress told us it didn't start until 4:00. No biggie... ordered some fried cheese curds and two beers. When 3:55 rolled around she took our orders . I ordered rare prime rib and my boyfriend ordered medium well. When the dinners came out, mine was well done and his was perfect. I asked the waitress if they had any rare cuts and she said 'he said medium well.' I said yes he did, but I ordered mine rare. From that point on, the waitress was MISERABLE. I wish I'd caught her name , but she was like 21 yrs old and long blonde hair. She never brought the horseradish that she said she would and we practically had to beg for more beers. I've been going there for years (like at least the last 9 years) but I doubt I'll honestly be back. I spent 93 bucks and got treated like crap. read more

Environment- was a little chilly inside. Sports bar environment which was enjoyable. The area was clean, just was a little outdated for seating. The music was my style (80s hair bands). The waitress didn't reach out but once to fill up our drinks however, and didn't help with information (it was our first time). Drinks- water was smooth and not limey. Arnold Palmer was lacking in the lemonade, tasted mainly of watered down tea. Husband was upset the didn't serve sweet tea. Appetizers- clams were a little too garlicky for my husbands taste, but I enjoyed them, however ever steamed clam plate NEEDS crusty bread and this didn't come with unfortunately. The cheese curds were on the smaller side comparing portion to price. The Thai chili sauce was great addition to the curds but you could tell that it was store bought sadly. Main courses - came here because was told the mac and cheese is the claim to fame. The noodle choice for both dishes was the perfect compliment to sauce and chicken. The noodles and chicken were cooked to the right doneness. The Alfredo "mac and cheese" I wouldn't claim as Mac n cheese. But the flavor is some of the best Alfredo I've had . The sauce to noodle ratio was what it should be. The sauce stayed in the noodle which was superb. The chicken on top was favorable and cooked great and held moisture. Issue was they put a blanket on cheese on top of the chicken and not under it so the cheese clumped the chicken from the noodles. The portion was decent size as well. The Buffalo mac was extremely greasy, there was orange all over the bottom of the dish and unfortunately caused the sauce to not stay on the noodle. But the sauce flavor was the best mac Buffalo flavor we've had ! The chicken was moist! Also it said blue cheese or ranch flavored cheese sauce - I didn't detect any flavor of those besides cheese and buffalo. If the sauce was thicker and not as greasy so it didn't fall off the noodles this would be unbeatable. read more

See all

Stopped in for lunch. Very quiet in the dining room. After reading reviews I ordered the Mac and cheese topped with Pork BBQ. OMG! It was hot and fresh. No gloppy Mac and cheese. The BBQ was sweet the way I like it, and cheddar cheese was melted over the top. It was sinfully good! It was a large portion, so yay, I have leftovers for later! Highly recommend this place!!! read more

The Cottage Inn - BBQ Mac and cheese bake - Pubs Near Me - Copenhagen, New York

Best macaroni and cheese I've had in a restaurant in a long time! Plan to come back to try the pulled pork Mac n cheese. The service was pretty quick and very friendly. Bbq chicken salad special was yummy. Ambiance was ok, not too loud. read more

This was a fantastic local place with some great food. Our table started out with two orders of the cheese curds, one with the sweet thai chili sauce and the other was a blueberry sauce (I'm like 75% certain but I could be wrong on exactly what it was my memory isn't working today). The cheese curds themselves had a nice light batter and were delicious on their own. I'm pretty sure the thai chili sauce is just from a bottle, Thai kitchen brand. Even with that said the sauce is good and works well with the cheese curds. The blueberry sauce is very sweet but still really good. My husband ordered the sandwich that had both a piece of fried chicken and a burger on one bun. The actual name is escaping me (that memory issue again) at the moment but I do remember it was delicious and if you're debating if you want a burger or chicken sandwich, go with this and have both. It is a very good sandwich. Now the mac and cheese oh soooo good! I had the philly cheese stake mac and cheese. There was so much mac and cheese for about $8. This turned into about 3 meals for me. The noodles were cooked great, an awesome amount of wonderful cheese and a generous amount of philly steak, peppers and onions. It seems like you cannot go wrong here. Great food, generous portions at amazing prices. I'm 100% a fan of the Cottage Inn! read more

The Cottage Inn - Cheese curd partially eaten - Pubs Near Me - Copenhagen, New York

See all

Fantastic place! Food and service were amazing. Would definitely recommend the hot wings, cheese curds with chili sauce. My husband loved their pot roast. Our server was Olivia and she was the best! read more

Service is friendly and welcoming. Food is delicious and you won't leave hungry and I love the cozy and comfy environment.

Great food at a fair price and excellent service. Nice cold beer too. Friendly and fun atmosphere.

So the problem isn't the food, the chef back there is awesome! Everything tasted great. The problem is the service. Our waitress, Sarah was the worse. Told us the wait would be 30 mins, there were empty tables everywhere! Didn't show me to a table, basically directed me where to sit, "Take that table in the back on the left!". 4 people at a small square high top table with no room. Ordered wings with ranch as an app, she forgot the ranch and then proceeded to ignore me for about 15 mins, never came to check on how the food was. By the time I got ranch, I had cold chicken. Then when my main food came, I basically had to drink my saliva because Sarah didn't think liquid should be served with food apparently. When I was finished, didn't see her, had to wait for 20 mins for a check... Long story short, order food to go to avoid Sarah's piss poor service. read more

Had to try the poutine appetizer. Probably as good as it gets, and the gooey melted cheese curds...superb. Wait staff kept hopping by a full house on a pleasant April spring evening. Beer cold, and sandwiches hot. No complaints, here! Good spot. read more

Just moved to the village, thought we'd give it a try and OH MY HOLY GRAVY POUTINE PIZZA WITH THIN CRUST and then I died from joy. Husband had something boring like bacon burger. Don't care. Too busy crying with joy over poutine pizza. He said his was delicious. Still don't care. I want to eat this every day of my life. Clean place, quick service, locals all over the place. I want to watch baseball and drown in poutine every night. read more

Must have been an off night for this place based off the other reviews. Wilted lettuce, stale roll, dehydrated fried chicken breast, over cooked fries and pickles... seriously just left this place, barely got home before getting sick to my stomach. Like the kinda sick you don't post about. Cutting this short, round two. Ugh. FML. read more

This restaurant has served my family great meals with good service, our server remembered us from a previous visit. Wish they could make more from scratch so the fried pickles and cauliflower would taste as individual as the fried cheese curd. The macaroni and cheese is great comfort food and theirs is made fresh and to order. Thank you. read more

Best wings ever! Very nice place I go here everytime I'm in the area. Owners are great peoples!

Local restaurant with amazing food! We went there after seeing other yelp reviews and loved it. Waitresses were so sweet and attentive and the food......we got poutine fries for appetizer and Bbq pulled pork Mac and cheese bake. Couldn't finish it all but really tried because it was so good. One side was a small bar with classic rock playing and the other a dining room with comfy chairs at each table so these out of towners were made to feel right at home. We will definitely be back next time in town. read more

The Cottage Inn - Pubs Near Me - Copenhagen, New York

Takes a while to get your food but it's worth it because it is so good!! Service is great!

I have eaten here twice and look forward to eating again soon! The menu is bizarre but delicious. The atmosphere is small-town Northern New York nice. The staff is very friendly too! If you're in need of comfort food go there tonight! read more

Huge portions, excellent wings, and friendly people. Food is fast, service sorta slow.

Hands down some of the best wings in a long time. Sweet mild sauce is so gooood!! Baked dishes are plentiful, I'd recommend you get the half! The desert special was a homemade triple berry cake and it was very delicious. I've also have had there soups and burgers, you won't be disappointed here! Service was quick! read more

Stopped in for a late lunch and was very pleasantly surprised by the wonderful selections and unique dishes! Everything was well prepared. Service was friendly and efficient. Hope it continues to do well. Stop in and check it out! read more