Still love this place. We come here for trivia almost every time they have it. Vibes are always immaculate. We always run into the owner and his family, and he's super nice. The patio is incredible. Last night we lost (after winning the previous time, but it's good to be humbled on occasion lol). But, I thoroughly enjoyed my free grilled cheese sandwich that I won as our previous trivia night prize. Sandwiches really are their specialty. Perfectly greasy, and the caramlized onions and spinach really elevated it. Another person in our group had the turkey on a pretzel bun and said it was amazing. Also, a great range of drink options. Always a good time, and I'm excited to come to one of their mahjong gatherings, since I recently learned how to play. read more

The Fat Shallot -Evanston - Grilled cheese. - Sandwiches Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

See all

We stopped by the Fat Shallot on a whim. I had the turkey sandwich, which came on a very fresh, soft pretzel roll bun with lots of greens. The fish tacos were very good too and had two large pieces of fish! Worth trying if you're debating between options. The staff at the counter gave great recommendations. We went on a weekday afternoon and there were few people there. It's a good spot to hang out and relax without feeling rushed. The decor is fun and cutesy, with dried flowers at the tables. Would definitely go back if I'm in the area again. read more

See all

I got to attend a graduation party at The Fat Shallot and it was really nice. The catered food made by the restaurant was good. I had the fries and chicken tenders. All were very tasty. There were also burgers I didn't have one but everyone that had a burger or chicken sandwich said they were good and tasty. The open bar was nice the Tito's was smooth and I had a good time. There was a DJ and enough room on the bar floor for dancing and there was a television with sports on for the sports watchers. I also saw patio outdoors seating out back. They had two restrooms and they appeared clean for patrons. The waitstaff and bartender were all friendly and just very nice. read more

The Fat Shallot -Evanston - Shots were drank (Tito's) - Sandwiches Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

So good! I definitely will be back! Really really great lunch and late night food. Simple menu means that everything served ironed out the details is delicious and works together. The BLT was the highlight for me, with the chipotle aioli that came with the cheese curds also standing out. Grilled cheese was also great, and the Arnold Palmer was fantastic on the hot day. Staff was super nice and love how bright and modern the inside was as well. Great place I definitely will be returning to. read more

The Fat Shallot -Evanston - Truffle BLT, House Fries, Grilled Cheese, Cheese Curds, Arnold Palmer - Sandwiches Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

Definitely my favorite sandwich shop in the area. The staff if very friendly and they have a great menu of items. My go to is the turkey sandwich with avocado and a side of fries. The staff is very friendly and there's enough seating for the entire crew. Highly recommended! read more

The Fat Shallot -Evanston - Sandwiches Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

See all

Definitely one of the best burger spots in Evanston. You have to get the cheeseburger but add grilled onions and bacon. The truffle fries and cheese curds are worth mentioning. I'd probably get the sauce on the side the next time I order truffle fries. My daughters like their grilled cheese sandwiches. read more

See all

I've been here a few times. I really enjoy their food. Everyone is friendly the location is clean. read more

See all

Not a place to eat late, it's just a bar with no food and only one bartender. Never even noticed us. read more

The Fat Shallot -Evanston - Sandwiches Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

See all

The service was excellent. They were so nice and friendly so A+ for that, but the food was disgusting. Turkey sandwich, BLT, truffle fries, soup. The sandwiches and fries were *swimming* in mayo and the truffle taste and smell was overwhelming - just awful. We threw away most of it because it was completely inedible. I really don't understand the great reviews. So disappointing. read more

I had the hot chicken sandwich with truffle fries. Absolutely delish and the sandwich is HUGE, crispy and tangy. The fries were very tasty and the sauce was perfect for dipping. Very cozy atmosphere with inside and outside seating. Friendly staff. The menu is not overpowering which I appreciated. Six sandwiches on the menu from what I recall which I think is a smart move. read more

Ambiance: I'd say this is a trendy kind of place. Sort of shabby chic deco, getting a coastal vibe meets the 50s. Very clean environment. Everything looks pretty new. There is a bar in the back which we didn't go to, large screen TVs. Service: Very quick service. You have to take your own menu and then order at the register. They don't take 100s though, Even though my order was $88. So no large bills here. Super friendly employees, positive attitudes all around. Food. Truffle BLT 4.0 stars. The bacon was a little too crispy. I've never said that before about bacon but it was. Needs a sauce with a little more flavor. The bread was spot on. Super crispy not soggy at all, fresh ingredients. It was nice. Truffle fries: 5.0 stars. Very good. Perfectly cooked. Chicken fingers: 4.5 stars. Cookie: 3.5 stars. My kid says it would be better if it was warmed. read more

See all

So friendly, good food, great service , fun neighborhood feel, with generous open play Mahjong on the first Saturday of the month.

Stopped in for lunch on a whim. The service was friendly, attentive, and patient. Focused menu and very well curated selection of beers. I ordered the truffle BLT and the ingredients were fresh, with generous bacon and the right amount of truffle flavor. The back patio is a true oasis in Evanston. I am looking forward to returning! read more

The Fat Shallot -Evanston - Truffle BLT - Sandwiches Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

I finally made it to their brick and mortar in Evanston today. I had my usual, the BLT. My son had the burger with cheese. Both sandwiches were delicious the burger had great grill flavor and was juicy; it came with two patties. For drinks I had the ginger lemonade, which was so good with a ginger aftertaste. If you like ginger, you'll like this. My son had a fountain soda. We also ordered the truffle fries. I thought there was more to the truffle than sauce. I would've liked some shaved truffles over top, especially for the upcharge. I paid $48 for our two sandwiches, an order of fries and drinks. This was an expensive lunch. I see this as a special occasion place for lunch and not a regular spot for food. The restaurant was light and attractive. They also had outdoor seating. Very fitting for a place in Evanston. read more

See all

We ordered from DoorDash. Everything was so salty. Sesame fries and grilled cheeses were inedible. Salty and greasy. Too much truffle flavor. read more

We brought a group of about 30 people here for a summer work outing. There was a bit of a hiccup with seating when we arrived, but the staff handled it quickly and got us settled on the patio. Grace and the team were kind, responsive, and made it work, which I really appreciated. The food was fantastic. The sliders, fries, and apps were all crowd-pleasers. Everything came out hot and fresh, and the pacing was solid given the size of our group. The vibe was fun and low-key, which was exactly what we were hoping for. If you're planning a casual event or just looking for a reliable spot to eat and hang out, I'd definitely recommend The Fat Shallot. We'd absolutely come back. read more

Great neighborhood spot. Didn't realize we needed this and don't know how we did without it. Love doing a casual meet up with friends. Two suggestions though: 1) Why not add a turkey burger to the menu? 2) Would be great to make the bar area a kids-free zone, move the games, and add a few more tables. read more

While very busy on a Friday night (and very kid-friendly), we luckily were able to snag the last T able up front when the back room was very loud and the outdoor patio was full. The food was solid, with very generous portions, and priced fairly. We'd definitely return or place an order for carry-out! read more

I loved this place when I lived closer to the Revival Food Hall location, so now that this is near our current place, I'm elated! If you like BLTs, you MUST try the Truffle BLT. It's insane...I crave it! I look forward to going back to try other items like the burger and the turkey. The fries are good, too, but the sauce we got with the black sesame seeds is one we'll skip next time. Also looking forward to attending one of their trivia nights! The space is really light and airy up front and the back room has a full bar with windows overlooking the outdoor space. Excited to try that out next summer! Service was good and the food didn't take long at all to be prepared and brought out to us. Plus, this location has beer if you want to imbibe. (Probably more but I wasn't looking to drink that day.) read more

See all

Awesome, family and kid-friendly spot! Same menu of delicious sandwiches you expect from the Fat Shallot after over a decade as a food truck. Turkey and buffalo chicken were chefs kiss favorites and the salad is really good as well. Tons of stuff for the little ones to do and always other kids to play with as well. Trevor was a super friendly bartender and big thanks to him for turning us into the frozen gin and tonic which was an instant classic on such a hot day. Only suggestion to the owners is some signage that says there's a bar in the back as we passed it over when walking by because from the sidewalk it only seems like a sandwich shop. read more

The Fat Shallot -Evanston - Pretty sure he was pooping near connect 4 - Sandwiches Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

I got the cheese curds and the truffle BLT to go. I wanted to love this place because I'm such a big fan of truffle mayo but the BLT did not live up to the expectations. They didn't put enough truffle mayo and the avocado was so brown it turned me off to eating it. The cheese curds were okay, wasn't melty as I like them usually to be. Maybe I didn't choose the right items. I'll eventually give them another try but it won't be a first choice read more

Great neighborhood place. We came for lunch on a hot summer Saturday. Got the truffle BLT (which I had tried at their satellite shop at Sterling Food Hall downtown and Food truck!), but also got the Buffalo chicken sandwich and cheese curds!! All delish! Best part is the cute lil bar in the back where we got some ice cold beers to go with our food - great space! Staff was friendly and quick! Will come back soon! read more

Quality sandwiches in a cute space. Burger needed a little salt. Friendly folks handling carryout.

I have been eating Fat Shallot on and off for years, starting at their Revival location. Back in the day, they were on Mealpal so I was getting truffle BLTs every week! Well anyway, let's just say I have a physical dependence on them now. I now rarely go downtown, which is why I was so happy to see this place open near my new home on the north side. The space is clean and beautiful and quite big. The eating area in the front is cute, and the big room in the back has the bar. I got my usual BLT and a beer and enjoyed them there. Meanwhile, we noticed that they have trivia, so we'll be back for that. I really hope this location does well and Fat Shallot continues to thrive. Next time I'm in, I plan to try the burger to see if it can even compare in deliciousness to the BLT. I'll update when I do! read more

I just had the same experience as another reviewer with the restaurant closing ahead of the posted time and turned me away at 7:55pm. Very rude and unacceptable. No apology or excuse was offered. read more

We love the Fat Shallot! It is so fun in the summer to bike to for Neighborhood hangs. Sarah and Sam are the best. The food is amazing. 10/10 for good vibes and food! read more

Very nice space. Fast casual food that is elevated with some unique sides and sauces and an impressive wine/beer list. This used to be the Old Neighborhood Grill but now it has a bright, clean, beach-y vibe. I brought my teenager and his friends here for an early Friday night dinner, but will come back for a night out with my friends as this is a friendly and casual place to just relax, eat and catch up. No TVs in the front space, there was a low pitched (you could hear yourself and your companions speaking) mix playing and there was no overspill from the bar area. It kind of feels like a big living room. The grilled cheese was fantastic (get it with the bacon!) and they make a really good french fry. Hamburgers were praised by the teenagers in my group. There is a delicious truffle aioli sauce that you can eat with anything there. It's especially good on the cheese curds. There is a bar area in the back and a patio where there is live music in the warmer weather. Order at the counter and they bring your food out. Be sure and try to the Ginger Lemonade. And shout out to the front of house manager, who is really glad you are there and so warm and friendly. We will be back because I am very curious about the Spicy Sesame Fries and actually really want to have a burger myself and the ones the kids ordered looked delightful. read more

Holy crap this food is good! However, then you thrown in the bar tending skills of TC???=!my new favorite Evanston place!! read more

See all

My new favorite restaurant in Evanston and an awesome addition to the neighborhood. They've completely redesigned the old dark space into a warm, welcoming scene. The front is the main dining area, with a cozy bar in the back and an awesome patio that has live music. I've been there a bunch of times since it opened and every item on the menu is excellent. It's tasty comfort food - think sandwiches, fries, Brussel sprouts. My favorite items are the truffle BLT and the homemade slaw, but it's a hard choice because it's all so good. Major bonus for this turning into a neighborhood spot that's super kid-friendly. I love coming here on Friday night and running into family friends! read more

See all

First timer, used carry out service and it was good. Selections are great and the food is very tasty.

$10 for a 6 ounce cup of beer Everything on the website was not on the menu Brought the wrong food and had to wait 12 more minutes No receipts Trash on the ground Very rude Brought a BLT but forgot about the lettuce and tomato No Sprite No Coke No ice tea They were out of their special Yeah, they're fat Only reason that they're getting people is because they're in a fantastic spot I had a bellyache for six days after that and I went to the doctors and they said that I possibly got a food poisoning from them read more

Excellent food, fantastic staff and perfect for groups! This restaurant is a local gem!

The Fat Shallot is phenomenal for hosting special celebrations! For the past few years we have organized the New Trier Cheerleaders Holiday party here and we will continue to do so each and every year! They are so easy to work with and have guided us perfectly on the menu both times. The food is beyond awesome and the staff is the same. They are always so gracious and friendly with all of our families- it's like they're part of the team! Guests who have never been here love the trendy atmosphere and laid-back, friendly vibe. I highly recommend considering the Fat Shallot for private gatherings - you won't be disappointed! read more

Stellar local restaurant. We were visiting friends who live in the area and frequent The Fat Shallot (amazing name). You order at the counter, then they bring out to you. I had the truffle BLT. Chef's kiss. What a lovely sandwich! I added caramelized onions to mine, and I recommend it. As a self-proclaimed connoisseur of brussel sprouts, I believe they could've used at minimum a lemon/lime wedge for a squirt and at max a balsamic drizzle as they read a little dry. Regardless, the mains, the drinks, the service, and the vibe were all on point. I would not hesitate to come back. read more

I was looking forward to an exceptional sandwich. But, it was just average. The menu wasn't that interesting either. too bad

Cute sandwich shop with some tasty food. I tried the shrimp po' boy and my daughter had the turkey sandwich. We tried the spicy sesame fries which were tasty but the heat kept building so we were unable to finish them. The ginger lemonade was really interesting. Will definitely be back again. read more

The Fat Shallot -Evanston - Turkey sandwich with avocado and arugula - Sandwiches Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

See all

We had a 50th birthday party with about 90 people and a band at the Fat Shallot, the restaurant providing food and libations. Sarah was on hand and was incredible, as was Trevor, the bartender, and the rest of staff too. The food and the drinks were on point and I would not hesitate to recommend the Fat Shallot to celebrate your event. read more

My wife and I really enjoyed this place. Very cool atmosphere with a cool little bar in the back and a cool looking patio. They have games for the kids to play so it's kid friendly. The service was really good and everyone was extremely nice. I got the po boy and sandwich and my wife got the blt. Both were very good. There was great flavor and everything was cool great. This is definitely a place that we will return to and would highly recommend this place to anyone that is in the area or anyone looking for a fun and tasty experience. read more

The Fat Shallot -Evanston - Truffle BLT - Sandwiches Near Me - Evanston, Illinois

See all

Just went back for an eat-in visit. I just couldn't help myself. I carried-out only a week ago, but wanted to go back and try some more of their delicious food, so I took my daughter to lunch. I ordered their Truffle BLT, and an order of Spicy Sesame Fries with Aioli and a Ginger Lemonade to cool things down. The truffle BLT was amazing, with more bacon than I could shake a stick at (who's shaking sticks at bacon?)... the bacon was thick and crunchy, the bread was wonderful and everything was super flavourful. The fries were spicy and the aioli had a nice kick to it. And if I was expecting the Ginger lemonade to cool things off I was nicely surprised, because the ginger had its own kick. Sarah, one of the owners, came over and to say "hi" (she is so nice and friendly), and my visit was just so pleasant and I'm just so pleased that have become a new member of the Central street family. Try it, you'll like it! read more

The staff is so patient and so cool. We had a work party there and I highly highly highly recommend the fat shallot. Everyone loved it. Everyone loved the food. There wasn't one complaint and the drinks were amazing. If you ever want to have a work party, the owners are so so easy to work with. They respond almost immediately with all questions answered. It is obvious they care about customer service, which I appreciate being from New Orleans and so many places don't make that a priority. Who wants to go spend money to eat where people are rude and not happy? This place really knows how to treat people and on top of that the food is wonderful- get cheese curds! Some of my coworkers told me the following week that they were still thinking about the cheese curds. read more