Want the best sandwich in Sandwich? Of course you do…read more This is the spot! Love this deli! They make great sandwiches! Super friendly staff. Swing by in the morning, pick up a sandwich, some chips, and a drink before you hit the beach or go out fishing. You won't be sorry!

Hit and miss - meatball sub was average at best .... They need to step up the bread they use... the…read moremeatballs tasted like store bought and the sauce was tastless

Was looking for sandwiches and this place looked good. Menu pictures needed to be updated as prices…read morewere a little higher than expected but well worth it.

Lovely store with great food and subs . The staff is very friendly ! Makes other sun shops pale in…read moreCamparison !

Busy, busy, busy. I didn't call in my # 1 Italian and #5 that is really Italian but with mozzarella…read moreinstead of provolone. The wait was about 20 minutes so call it in. I'm from Philadelphia and know my hoagies and cheesesteaks. This is THE BEST Italian deli in this part of the cape doing BIG business on Bastille Day! Lots of workers who all were busting their butts. Great looking foods in the market to take out too, including marinating steaks and chicken, tapenade, ciabatta, amazing looking anchovies. We like to take it home...and oh so good. #5 will be for nephew coming over in a bit. They do have eat in room and exterior picnic tables. Great place! Mangia Cape Cod!

They've been our "go-to" for subs since we moved to the Cape years ago. We gladly drive 12 miles…read moreto order up some #1's fully loaded, bring back some salads, and some arancinis. Their bread distinguishes them from others. Do not skip the back room shelves and coolers! Their soups rock! We're ex-NYers. They remind us of home each and every time. We are grateful that they stay open all year. Good people too...

A generously portioned lobster roll for under $38 on Nantucket is a steal. The roll comes either…read morewarm or cold-the cold version is the standout. The bun is perfectly toasted and served warm no matter which style you choose. If you're in Nantucket, it's worth a visit.

We ordered sandwiches delivered to our hotel room in Nantucket. The Thanksgiving and the Caprese…read more The only let down was the turkey. I thought it would be real turkey it was lunch meat turkey

We went to Coletti's for our first time today. We got 2 large Italian subs The bread was so…read morefresh and the subs were outstanding!! The young man who made our subs was so polite and quick! The gentleman who rang us up was excellent also! We have found our new sub shop!! Thank you for such a great experience! We will be back!!

Good Subs definatly worth the price fresh meats and decent portions highly recommend this placeread more

I came here to grab a quick lunch before my family needed to catch the ferry. The interior and…read moreexterior of the shop itself are nothing unexpected, but the food surprised us all in the best way possible. I had the Main Street Stroll: mozzarella, tomato, arugula, and pesto on ciabatta. It was a perfect combination of ingredients. Each ingredient was fresh and in ideal proportions and flavors. I care very much about my sandwiches and this sandwich stood very high in my mental rankings. This next part is a review written by my daughter. I tried her BLT and I fully agree with everything she said: "The food here is amazing!!!!! I would especially recommend the BLT, I got mine without turkey and it was by far the best I have ever had! They put the tomato in between the lettuce so the bread wouldn't get soggy and that made it so much better than the ones I have tasted in the past. " The kebab chicken is also very nice. You rarely find grilled kebabs at a sandwich shop, but they've got them and they do a great job with the seasoning and the grilling. Thank you to the team there. You guys are doing an amazing job.

Well..... Coming off of the ferry we needed a bite to eat…read more My senses honed in on this place. Really superb sandwiches!! The family cooks right in front of you and everything is very clean. We shall return. William Perrelliphoto.com Flickr: perrelliphoto Instagram: perrelliphoto

I had heaps of respect for this places pizza, but the last few times I've ordered the (Tony…read moreburrata) with extra cheese and pepperoni. They charge you for the extras but don't actually make it to your order. I'm a sous chef and if a customer says extra cheese then there better well darn be extra cheese. Not happy at all that I don't get what I payed for but it's still better than Edgartown pizza.

Yea.... Who knew that "gas station" pizza would be a good thing! Located and situated between an…read moreintersection just leaving the town of Edgartown, MA. "Grandma " style - thick crust, fluffy dough and the pizza is so large that two people have at least two meals. Downside: limited available times that they make the pizza. Love love love!!!

Great food and great service, be prepared to wait (they move fast) but when the line is out the…read moredoor takes time to get up to front. Hint call in your order and it will be waiting for you at the cashier. Enjoy

Amazing sandwiches from the bread to the meat and toppings. Fresh and perfect. We had the…read moreprosciutto, mozzarella, peppers and basil. Phoning in our order was clutch for quick pickup. The chocolate chip cookies are amazing and freshly made.

Great atmosphere, nice people, and well run deli…read more The Marco was good, sharp cheese, great prosciutto! The hard roll was nice when it came out of the oven. The rabe was not too bitter and the chicken was cooked all the way through, but slightly on the dry side. The Italian was not the best I've had. The hard roll was on the softer side. I would recommend that you get it hot if you like a crispy outer crust. The grinder was more bread heavy on the meat to bread ratio. Toppings were onion, banana peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, oil and vinegar.

Another fantastic meal at Natale's of Friday night. We both had dinners off the specials menu, but…read moreyou can have food off any menu- sandwich boards, pizza/calzone menu, night menu, as well as the specials menu. We already know the sandwiches are fantastic, made on Buono's bread, but the dinners, oh my! Tonight I had shrimp with peppers fra diavalo. It had quite a few shrimp, green peppers and hot pepper rings in a red tomato sauce. Just enough heat and spice. This is served over capellini pasta. My husband had chicken Marsala, which comes with two sides. He chose green beans and carrots mixed, and mashed potatoes. He ate all of it except one cutlet, which he brought home. I, too, brought home half my plate. You have to try this place. The food is delicious, and the prices are very reasonable for the plate. They are only open for dinner on Friday nights.

We tried this pizza joint on the way to see the sunset while we were visiting for the week. We…read moreordered the stone wall (pepp and basil). We waited a good bit but it was well worth it. It looked like the move was to order online in advance. Highly recommend. The double chocolate sea salt cookie was also fantastic!

Just wondering when I'm going to get the rest of my chicken on my Bahn Mi sandwich??…read more I ordered the salmon bahn mi and substituted the salmon for chicken which resulted in me receiving a half piece of chicken cutlet which didn't even fill the bun. And on top of that, the price of the sandwich was the same for the chicken as it would have been for the salmon. I guess on Martha's Vineyard, the price of chicken is the same as the price of salmon. Place is a total rip off and has been going down hill for years, stay away!