Pulled up to this cool quaint place , very nice staff , sat outside on patio , very nice views . Food was really good , server he was chill , informative, and attentive. Thank you for an enjoyable experience . Gluten free friendly enjoyed the mussels, Pittsburgh salad , gluten free Margherita! Team THT well done read more

Very good service, the calzone and pizza were excellent. Outdoor seating setting was enjoyable.

We ordered food, two calzones were wrong. We mentioned it, and for one they stuffed the missing ingredients inside and brought it back out. Then the waiter said "well, that's a traditional calzone which doesn't come with that." Yet last time I checked, when you add something extra it comes with the thing you requested. read more

The Humble Tomato has a nice atmosphere, and the service was exceptional. The food was pretty good as well, making for an overall enjoyable dining experience. read more

The Humble Tomato - Italian Near Me - Lewisburg, West Virginia

At the edge of a charming downtown, this place offers outdoor seating, which the weather invited me to on the day I stopped by. They're open seven days, and there was quite a lot of business for a small town on Monday night. The menu is pretty straightforward Italian, and is marked for vegetarian needs. Their smaller size pizza was a bit light for a meal (I suspect the larger one would be plenty), so getting a salad and garlic bread turned out to be a good decision. The basil lemonade I got didn't really deliver much more than a lemonade flavor. There is indeed something humble about tomatoes, but the setting here in addition to capable renditions of staple foods made stopping to sample some tomato-based cuisine a worthwhile decision for me. read more

See all

I picked The Humble Tomato because they allow pets. They have a beautiful outdoor dining space that feels like eating in a quiet garden. They even have some tables in a grassy area. I dined outside wiith my dog. They offered a dog bowl of water for my pup. They had some wonderful sounding seasonal cocktails. I didn't try any but definitely would have if I wasn't dehydrated for water. The dish of the day was a chicken piccata. I went in wanting something else and changed my mind to the piccata. The server let me know how much it cost which was nice. The dish was delicious and I had enough leftover for lunch the next day. My server was attentive and had my water refilled throughout the meal. I was appreciative of this on a hot day. read more

The food was delicious, the service was great, the ambiance was great. Highly recommend this restaurant.

Oh my goodness! 5 stars! This place is delicious! The atmosphere is cozy. The service is great and the food is to die for like drop dead delicious! So we got the cheese sticks, soft and cheesy deliciousness. We got a cheese pizza and my brother got a Forest Gump inspired pizza. Unfortunately it only came with like 2 shrimp, that was the only flaw though. I got the Steak n mushroom calzone and it was also delicious. Their marinara sauce is so good. Definitely recommend The Humble Tomato to any and everyone! read more

The Humble Tomato - Cheese Sticks - Italian Near Me - Lewisburg, West Virginia

See all

Awful place!! look at my review on Google Maps. Absolutely horrific. They seat who they know on the inside. The regular customers tossed outside like dogs in the heat. read more

Was in town for a few weeks. Visited a couple times. Pizza is amazing ! Salad are good. Wasn't my favorite chicken Parm. Atmosphere is great! Service was great had friendly service with each visit. read more

The Humble Tomato - Side saled Balsamic vinegarette - Italian Near Me - Lewisburg, West Virginia

See all

I stopped by here with my brother + my friend last spring-ish and the food was super tasty! Service was friendly and attentive without being intrusive. They offer all kinds of different appetizers, soups/salads, pasta, sandwiches, and artisinal pizzas -- it was honestly kinda difficult to decide on what we wanted, but I think it'd be hard to go wrong. We enjoyed everything we ordered. :] The bread they use from their sandwiches are from a local bakery, as is the meat that they use (Swift Level steak + bacon). Hoping to go back to visit my friend again + try more of their menu next time! read more

The Humble Tomato - Italian Near Me - Lewisburg, West Virginia

See all

Such a great find! This awesome restaurant is set in a cool, unique building that adds to the atmosphere. I was excited to see gluten-free pasta and pizza options right on the menu -- and they were delicious! The service was genuinely friendly and helpful from start to finish. Can't wait to come back! read more

We were a group with 4 checks, 2 different tables. Service wasn't good, refills sucked, had to ask multiple times. We get back home to Ansted, WV from being at Cass WV. The following day I looked at my receipt and was charged for a steak sandwich that our table did not order! NO problem, I'll call and fix they will fix it tomorrow. I called on Sunday, the same day I looked at my receipt, we ate on Saturday I called on Sunday. I was told to call Monday it could be fixed then, ask for Emily she would be working and answering phone calls. No problem I'll call and I did MULTIPLE times and no answer so without a doubt she was screening calls. Benefit of the doubt I called 2 other days and wasn't answered, the one time I was answered Emily just walked out of the door. So I'm out of approximately $17 and I'd never recommend this place. No one in our group was pleased and we are all plain country folks‼ read more

Highly recommend!!! Super cute historic building. Food was delicious. We shared a ceasar salad...next time would ask for extra Brussel sprout .. they were charred and shaved on top. Small pepperoni mushroom . Very good. Liked the crust. Best meal we ever found in west virginia ... would come back. The town was cool ... looked historic and artsy. Interesting. Be aware the curbs are really high .. so be careful. read more

The Humble Tomato - Italian Near Me - Lewisburg, West Virginia

The chicken parm had a weird tang like sauce, I didn't like it, and I eat chicken parm at multiple places. Wasn't a fan. Also couldn't substitute the lenguini pasta. Not a fan of that either. read more

I absolutely loved this quaint diner. 5 big stars! My brother took me to it when he was in town taking me to a doctor's appointment. The food is excellent. The atmosphere is rustic and great. Service was good and not intrusive, just right. Beer was good. I can hardly wait to go back when I have my next appointment in Maxwelton. read more

My Human took me to a place called The Humble Tomato. It turned out it was Dogfest 2024! Lots of other dogs and lots of petting all around! Somebody said it was because of TOOT, but it wasn't me, I didn't even smell it. My Person ordered what he said is his usual, the Magnum P.I., but I didn't try it, those red things that grow outside make my stomach hurt. He says "no", they aren't good for me - he says that a lot. He seemed to really like it though. He said the pizza was perfect. The outdoor area is beautiful, lots of great smells, from people who have dropped stuff to squirrels and chipmunks, I will definitely be back! read more

The Humble Tomato - Italian Near Me - Lewisburg, West Virginia

Great food, neat atmosphere, and service was on point. Had the Margherita Pizza and a beer on tap.. delicious read more

The Humble Tomato - Margarita Pizza - Italian Near Me - Lewisburg, West Virginia

The cutest historical place and we had the light lemonade with basil - so awesome and the Brussels with bacon and goat cheese and hot honey was to die for! Our server was so friendly , all in all a fantastic experience! read more

The food was good. Not great but above average. What makes this place special is the atmosphere. Great old house. This is the kind of place you can bring the family or have an intimate dinner. read more

We've dined here a few times and haven't had any real issues, but our most recent visit wasn't very good. Slow service isn't surprising but you better have good food to back it up, and that simply wasn't the case. The garlic knots were just terrible - hard, dry gobs of over baked dough with almost no butter or garlic. Seriously, the worst appetizer I've had anywhere. The rest of the meal was ok, the drinks were chincy and it was expensive for what we got. We're going to put this place on tbe back burner for a while. read more

Cute little place in Lewisburg! Open on Mondays! Patio seating is the perfect relaxing setting! Best pasta and priced for half portions! Katelyn is the best server! Awesome dinner! read more

Beware!! Prior to August 2, The Humble Tomato was my favorite restaurant in Lewisburg - good food and good service in addition to a great atmosphere. Unfortunately, however, I experienced firsthand that the service at this restaurant is totally unpredictable. Our group of 8 had an early reservation and arrived right on time. However, things began to deteriorate upon waiting an hour for our food. After raising the issue with the waitress and the manager, our food arrived in spurts, orders were incomplete, and the situation became a comedy of errors. The ineptness of the staff was blazing, which is when the manager should have stepped in and practiced the basics of customer service - correct the mistake and make amends. Unfortunately, she did not. And therefore, there are 8 of us who have a really bad taste in our mouths for The Humble Tomato now and will not be returning. read more

1st time for us. Very impressed. We had pasta with meatballs and salad with grilled chicken and soup. The fresh made pasta with 2 large delicious meat balls with marina sauce was delicious. Their house made tomato vinaigrette dressing was terrific. Would have bought some to take home if available. The old house the restaurant is in is a treat in itself. Can't wait to return. read more

The Humble Tomato - Soup and salad - Italian Near Me - Lewisburg, West Virginia

See all

Absolutely delicious. Great pizza and some tasty local beer selections. Eat here not food and friends across the street.

Food was good, service was acceptable, 1 star because the proprietor does not post an up charge for using a card. Stealing from customers is not a good business practice. Will not return to support a nefarious business owner. Look like Hill and Holler for pizza in Lewisburg. read more

The Humble Tomato - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Lewisburg, West Virginia

Food was amazing. Service was good. We had the chicken parm, lemon chicken pasta and the salmon. All were delicious!

Normally this place is amazing. I will continue to visit. Unfortunately, we reserved a table for 13 for an engagement party on a Saturday evening and it was average at best. Long wait for dinner, room upstairs was so hot a couple had to leave, and the gluten free pasta was mush. I think it was just a bad night. When I have visited with a Smaller party everything was fantastic. read more

Let me start by saying that my husband and I are NOT hard to please, especially when it comes to Italian food. When looking through the reviews for this restaurant you might think 'Wow, this place seems great!!' or at least that's what we thought. We ordered takeout on a Friday night. There was a 40 minute wait, which is fine, but we went in after 40 minutes and had to wait an additional 10. We ordered chicken alfredo and chicken parmesan. At $20+ per entree you would think the food would at least be up to par with Olive Garden, which has similar pricing. That was not the case. Truly, you could make it at home and get better results. In the chicken parmesan the chicken was not crispy, it was soggy (which is funny considering it should've been extremely fresh since we had to wait so long) it was also extremely bland and had a burnt oil taste. It was also a very small amount of chicken considering the price. The red sauce tasted like it was just a jarred sauce, comparable to Ragu or another cheap brand. The noodles were overcooked and mushy. The chicken alfredo was "blackened" but it was more charred than blackened. It was also very dry and a small portion, at that. The sauce was ridiculously underwhelming and also tasted like jarred sauce. The noodles were mushy and gross. It also had sun dried tomatoes, which my husband liked but I thought were grossly out of place. My husband wanted to return the food and ask for at least a partial refund because it was so terrible. I was starving though and didn't want to wait around for another takeout order from another place so we did eat it. I don't think I've ever been so disappointed by a restaurant in my entire life. If I could give a 0/5 stars I would. read more

Our waiter was fantastic. We waited a few minutes to be seated but the food was well worth the wait. The mussels were tender and delicious and the veggie pizza was piled high with toppings. read more

Well just the facts. Stopped for brunch once. Out of eggs. Stopped by last night. Not seating at 8pm. Closing at 9pm. Asked to just have drinks, dish washer had left. So told to leave. I feel these were lame excuses. Eggs are commonly available at any grocery store located within one mile of this restaurant. If you close at 9pm. Then close at 9pm, don't leave the door open at 8pm and advertise that your business is open until 9pm. Perhaps change your hours to reflect you actual operating practices. If you cannot serve drinks because the dish washer left, I am severely concerned about his work load the following morning. Perhaps consider switching to disposal-able dish ware, because if your business model is dependent on a dish washer then I believe there is a fundamental flaw. Or perhaps ask patrons to bring their own dish ware or wash their own dishes. Just suggestions. Thanks Unhumble Turnip. Appreciate your disservice. Great food. Terrible place. Get it together. read more

My bride and I came to Lewisburg today, for the day, prior to heading to the Greenbrier tomorrow. This town is so great! So many great shops and locally owned restaurants. Today, we met my Aunt and Uncle at the Humble Tomato. First, great choices on menu. Second, incredible ambience with exposed wood, clearly old house, well maintained. Third, very friendly staff. Last, food was so delicious. Spaghetti, Chicken wrap and calzones. #yummo! Definitely recommend!! read more

See all

Fantastic waiter and fantastic food! We had lasagna, cauliflower crust pizza, fried Brussel sprouts, and cheesy bread. Everything was perfect. read more

Good pizza. Servers too few, but mine was nice and helpful. Would recommend. They sell the Izzy sauce, yummy.

Very good service with a friendly staff. Food is really good. They make the dough on site and that makes a difference. Huge selection of pasta and pizzas. They also have salads and other main dishes. Save room for the tiramisu read more

The Humble Tomato - Cow portrait on the mantle - Italian Near Me - Lewisburg, West Virginia

So bad. Hostile hostess,completely in-ept bartender/waitress. Couldn't get bill. Bartender told us she was too busy to get to us and there was only 4 people at the bar. We had already sat at a table for 30 min. Obviously none of waitresses staff could handle more than one table read more

Nestled in a gorgeous small town in Lewisburg, WV is this quaint adorable spot. Pretty menu of beer on Tap but food was nothing to write home about. I got the bruschetta, tomato soup and grilled cheese. The soup was okay. Grilled cheese was a grilled cheese.... Bread and cheese. Lol. The bruschetta was more like pico de gallo which was odd. On a fun note.... They have a beer called Devils Anse. Anse is NOT pronounced anus. Thankfully the couple next to us did not pronounce it correctly which gave us a good laugh. The waitress didn't even flinch. True professional. I, on the other hand, almost covered my dinner date with partially chewed grilled cheese as I immediately lol'd the moment I heard the couple order the devil ANUS. Back on track..... so food...ehhh, ambience great. I would definitely go back and recommend this place. Pricing was fair. read more

Staying in Lewisburg for a Winter Storm weekend. Once we got settled into our AirB&B we walked over to this fantastic gem of a pizza place. "Pizza Place" feels like an understatement. The sign says "Humble" but the food "Boasts" of culinary creativity and exciting flavors. We started with the brussel sprout appetizer. That could have been all we ate and I would still give this place 5 stars. Crisp little leafy bundles of joy covered in goat cheese, hot honey drizzle, and crispy pork fat goodness. Just stop what you're doing and get some of these immediately. Even your pickiest veggie eater will buckle under the phenomenal flavor of these bad boys. Next up we're the pizzas. We ventured Down the Rabbit Hole (DRH) and ran into Magnum PI (MPI). Not literally mind you, those were the interesting names of our pizzas. The DRH was insanely good with roasted cloves of garlic, ricotta sauce, mushrooms, and chili oil. This is a must for garlic lovers! The creamy ricotta balances the garlic while the chili oil gives a subtle kick. The MPI is a savory adventure for your tastebuds. Spicy capicola and rich thick cut bacon cubes find balance with sweet juicy pineapple on this pizza. Careful! You won't look at simple ole "Hawaiian Pizza" the same way again. If your visiting Lewisburg this place needs to be at the top of your list. Heck, even if you're passing through on 64, take the damn exit and get yourself a good meal here now! read more

See all

Excited to try this place. Turned away at door after hostess told she didn't have a table for us since we didn't have a reservation. It was busy but we had 4 people and were not given the option to wait. The website says "The Humble Tomato accepts both reservations and walk-ins. Please use the number below to reach us for reservations". Would have made a reservation if it was strongly suggested/mandatory to even eat there or would have been happy to wait until something opened. read more

The Humble Tomato - Website photo. - Italian Near Me - Lewisburg, West Virginia

Not sure why this happened or why it matters, but we took a later seating for our dinner....and everything except for our drinks and our waitress were underwhelming. Some of the dishes we ordered seemed like they had been reheated in a microwave, the pizza crust was too doughy, etc. Hard to believe this place has been given the stars it has. I'm hoping it was just because we were the last diners of the evening and we got what we got....otherwise, I can't see this place making it as it is. In a town with so many great options, this place needs to step up their game!!! read more