Hungry for some local food, I started looking up nearby eateries. Since being in New Mexico now for several days, we still haven't had anything "green chili" on this trip. And, I was on a mission! Well, I found a little spot in Estancia, NM, (population just under 1600), that had photos of all of sorts of dishes containing green chilies. So, we drove close to 20 miles out of the way for lunch! Why? Every review about the food ranged from good to the best (except for the one guy that said "just okay")! 4.5stars on the reviews. That's great! So, with my stomach growling, we made our way to the Old Mill Restaurant. Instead of the proverbial plate of food photos, I decided that the well worn dining chair was more appropriate. These chairs have held thousands upon thousands of diners over the years - probably decades. And I'd venture to say that all of them - well, except for those prickly curmudgeons, or high-strung "Karens", enjoyed their meals here. The depth of flavor was definitely there. And the food was hot. Not lukewarm or kept under a light forever. Hot. Steaming hot. What we had, doesn't really matter. But what we experienced does. There wasn't one thing that stood out; but several. Kind people. Feeling welcomed. Delectable foods. And, that "local" vibe that we search out. We didn't get that sideways glance. You know, the look locals give an outsider. Nothing but smiles, and friendly faces. I did add a pic of my sopapilla and honey... it's one of those items that I will always order if it's on the menu; sort of like when I always order chicken fried steak for breakfast at diners. And although our meals were truly delicious, this really was not the best sopapilla that I've had; a bit thin and under done. No worries. No complaints. Just an observation. And guess what? I ate every last crumb of it. I can't even deduct a star because of it..I'm grateful it was an offering. I am so happy to have found this restaurant. And will remember it as one of those moments, where time stood still, and everything was good, and normal, for a bit... read more

See all

Stopped in for coffee and then decided to have a quick little something to eat. They just opened yet they were very accommodating and friendly. Food was fantastic and no real complaints for the small town place! The place is clean and I really have no disparaging remarks about the place at all. You definitely get a hometown feel here! Check it out if passing through or make the ride/drive out to Estancia and have some home cooked food. read more

I came in for a late lunch and was not disappointed. Got The Trailblazer, a big ol' char-broiled hamburger patty next to a plate of crispy fries, all smothered in very delicious green and red (from pods!) chile _and_ cheese. Piping hot, too - you know how sometimes they warn you the plate might be hot? This one was a branding iron. Yum. Wow, and at a reasonable price, too. Great service and great food at a reasonable price - it's worth the drive to The Old Mill in Estancia. read more

The Old Mill - a table with mustard and ketchup - Comfort Food Near Me - Estancia, New Mexico

See all

Every time I order food here it's always delicious! The service the ladies give is always perfect and helpful. The place is rustic and hometown comfortable! I highly recommend the stop. read more

Good food, quiet location. Lighting is fluorescent, which isn't great, but otherwise it's got an awesome repurposed-mill vibe going on. It's not too busy and the food is good and comes in large portions so it is a great spot to write and study. Service was a little lacking, but overall it was a good spot to stop for lunch and a much-needed break from the bright sun. read more

As a flyer, I wanted to get a review in here (Yelp) so y'all know this place still exists! We flew into the gravel strip on the east side of town where it was an easy stroll to The Old Mill. We had the standard fare -- green chile cheeseburgers and fries that were wolfed down before a topping could fall out onto the plate. The topper was a homemade Butterfingers pie for dessert. Were we worried about gross weight for takeoff? There was a patio in front with fireplace and lights strung along the ceiling ... I wonder if this place gets hopping in the evenings? By the way, I noticed there's a "Old Mill Market" listed with the same address, but the location for this "102 W. Joseph Ave." is correct. read more

The Old Mill - Front of the Old Mill - Comfort Food Near Me - Estancia, New Mexico

The bean burrito with extra cheese is amazing also everything else on the menu is bomb definitely recommend

I got the burrito with green sauce a while back and it was delicious. The cinnamon rolls are also yummy

Nice place to dine. I ordered the Navajo Taco. It was tasty, but something was missing- oh yes, the meat. It was served on a sopapilla, with beans, avocado, and garnish. No meat- or, if there was, it was such a tiny little bit it was lost in the beans and avocado. It tasted ok, but was not at all what we know to be a Navajo Taco. Nice atmosphere, friendly service. Next time I stop, I think I will stick to the burgers- read more

Super good food. Clean bathrooms. The staff is very nice. Everything you can ask for.

Omg this Was a nice surprise, we were hungry from driving for hours and stopped in here to have a burger, and beer. The staff was very friendly, and even brought us the heater to our table. That was so nice of her she could tell I was cold and the hot chocolate was amazing and I got a free refill. But the best part was the burger it was delicious cooked just right.Will definitely come back here again and try something else! thank you for such a great service! read more

Great food i recommend the country boy burrito smothered with country gravy and red chile

The Old Mill is under new ownership. It gets better every time we come in. Great authentic New Mexican food as well as delicious hamburgers and my husband's favorite, chicken fried steak. Don't forget to try the salsa and chips but don't be in a hurry. They fry their home made chips up just before serving them. read more

See all

We only had pie, coffee, and ice tea. The pie was outstanding. Service was quick and friendly.

I had the burger with green chile... delicious...the beef was very tasty. Another of us had the torta with lengua... some of the best lengua we've had. Yes we shared each other's sandwiches. And any time we are in the area, we will definitely go back. read more

What a great find the staff is so friendly and the food is really good. I had the special and the burger ad fries were very very good. If I ever come back this way it would be a must stop place. ;) read more

Outstanding! The waitstaff is friendly and the people who go there are great too. I had the pancakes and eggs, they were tasty and well-priced. This is about the best I'd expect from a diner. I know that sounds sarcastic but it's really a fine place. read more