Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Painted Cookie

    5.0 (1 review)

    The Painted Cookie Desserts Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Painted Cookie

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 662 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Old Towne Bakery - Reference Photo

    Old Towne Bakery

    3.2(20 reviews)
    0.1 kmOlive Branch
    $$$

    I received a lovely strawberry cake for my birthday from Old Towne Bakery @ Sept. 28th, 2025. The…read morecake was visually appealing and inside, it had layers of cake with strawberry filling. My only complaint is that the strawberry frosting on top tasted like freezer or refrigerator taste. I'm not sure where these cakes are being stored at, but please check & correct.. I would have given the cake a ten out of a ten if it wasn't for that refrigerator taste or other that ruined it. I see that another customer had the same experience. Hopefully that issue will get resolved. Thanks

    I would like to say this first...the cake was AMAZING! To the colors, taste they did exactly what I…read morewanted done for my little baby's reveal. Cake was very sugary, but is still definitely delicious. Below I added the reference photo then the final masterpiece. I did not want sprinkles on top either. As far as the service goes and why I set my rating to 4 stars is because they lady (older lady) who was taking our order was just very hasty towards me and I felt as if I was being a bother by coming in there and having them make me a cake. Really didn't make me feel excited or happy about placing my first baby's gender reveal cake here. Would I come back here? Yeah, I didn't seem to have any issue with other workers, but will I come back to place a gender reveal cake? Well I'm not too sure about that, please get back with me some other time.

    Photos
    Old Towne Bakery - Down bag sneak shot.  The Fudge is ridiculous rich.  The Peanut Butter Cookie is great. I can't remember what was under it.  Tehehe

    Down bag sneak shot. The Fudge is ridiculous rich. The Peanut Butter Cookie is great. I can't remember what was under it. Tehehe

    Old Towne Bakery - Circular Vanilla Cake w Blue/Orange Buttercream Icing. Bluish/White filling inside cake.

    Circular Vanilla Cake w Blue/Orange Buttercream Icing. Bluish/White filling inside cake.

    Old Towne Bakery - The cheese pecan thingers are good.

    See all

    The cheese pecan thingers are good.

    The Cake Lady Bakery - What I asked for!

    The Cake Lady Bakery

    2.9(36 reviews)
    14.7 kmSouthaven
    $$$

    I am extremely disappointed with both the cake and the professionalism of this business. I called…read morethe store multiple times throughout the day and no one answered. I also never received a call letting me know the cake was ready. I eventually had to send my sister to the store to check on it. When she saw the cake, even she immediately said it did not look like the reference photo provided. When this was brought up to the owner, her response was that they didn't have the specific colors and that using different colors "wouldn't have looked good." Unfortunately, the bright/lime green that was used looks much worse and is nothing like the original design. The owner was dismissive and unprofessional and refused to remake the cake, offer a partial refund, or even provide store credit. There was no attempt to make things right for a clear mistake on their end. If you can't match a requested design or colors, that should be communicated before making the cake -- not after. I would not recommend this bakery based on the lack of communication, poor customer service, and refusal to take accountability. Requested cake: muted, earthy tones (soft sage green, tan, cream, and brown). Delivered cake: bright neon/lime green, which completely changes the look and theme. Requested cake: natural, rustic, neutral, and cohesive. Delivered cake: harsh, high-contrast, cartoonish due to the bright green frosting.

    I love this bakery. We pop in a few times a year for birthdays or other celebrations. We always get…read morethe cupcakes. They're always moist and delicious. Also, I love that they are not over-the-top ridiculous. Bakery cupcakes are often gigantic, extreme in their frosting and fillings and decorations plus add-ons like candy or candy bars...and usually dry and bland tasting. Not here! Cupcakes are reasonably sized, moist and flavorful, simple but with variety...and reasonably priced! We always get the cupcakes but this time I wanted to also try their cookies. Dang! Very good. Four cupcakes, four cookies, $20, everything was fantastic.

    Photos
    The Cake Lady Bakery - This is NOT want I ordered!!!

    This is NOT want I ordered!!!

    The Cake Lady Bakery - The groom's cake we asked for...

    The groom's cake we asked for...

    The Cake Lady Bakery - What I received!

    See all

    What I received!

    A&A Cake Factory - Tres Leches coconut cake

    A&A Cake Factory

    4.4(7 reviews)
    16.7 km

    I am so happy that I came across this gem! We needed a cake at the last minute and I was desperate…read moreto find a place in the area that provide us with what we needed. I decided to give A&A a try after coming across this business on yelp. Upon entering, I was greeted by a very friendly lady. They had a nice display case that contained cakes, cupcakes and other treats. I noticed that they had a strawberry cake and I asked to place the order. The young lady informed me that the cake was a tres leche cake, which was something I wasn't familiar with. She explained the process to me and I decided to order a slice first. She gave me a fork and I was able to taste the slice I purchased. Oh my goodness, it was so good!!!! She told me that it would be moist and that it would probably come across as "wet" to some, but I thought it was excellent! The flavor was great and I loved the fact that the icing wasn't extremely sweet. It was not like the typical buttercream icing. I purchased the cake and did not tell others that it was a tres leche cake. (I wanted to see how they would feel about the slightly different texture.) Everyone at the gathering absolutely loved the cake!! I am so thankful that I decided to drop in to this place. We now have a go-to bakery that we will use for all occasions! Highly recommend!!

    No update phone number and they don't sell cakes. I visited the address. It is own by Latino's.read more

    Photos
    A&A Cake Factory - Tres Leches caramel with pecan cake.

    Tres Leches caramel with pecan cake.

    A&A Cake Factory
    A&A Cake Factory - Tres Leches strawberry cake slice

    See all

    Tres Leches strawberry cake slice

    Miss Muff'n - Clearly buttercream in between the layers meanwhile this was ordered as a strictly all over cream cheese icing cake.

    Miss Muff'n

    3.6(52 reviews)
    14.4 km
    $$

    My husband ordered a cake here for my birthday. He specifically ordered everything to not include…read moreor be done with any sort of buttercream because on top of buttercream making me very sick, it also does not agree with my body and then I have numerous days of torture ahead. The cake was decorated decently, however, the inside of the cake layers is buttercream. I found this out after I already took a generous bite and I have been struggling with my stomach since then. The cream cheese icing used was almost unbearably sweet, so unfortunately, a good portion of the cake slices were thrown away and the remainder of the cake will have to be disposed of. I worked in an Italian bakery in NYC for a few years and have never tasted an icing that was THIS sweet. On top of everything else, the cake was supposed to be lemon flavored. I'm assuming they "baste" their cakes either a lemon flavoring because the only area that had any lemon flavoring was the immediately part touching the buttercream that I threw away after the first bite. Overall, I am beyond thankful that my husband wanted to gift me a beautiful and delicious cake, even remembering that I have intolerances to buttercream and my love for lemons, unfortunately, Miss Muff'n did not deliver a good product. We won't be returning customers.

    Miss Muff'n is a wonderful bakery! They are always very kind and very helpful! They have even…read morehelped me to the car with an order. Their strawberry cake is our family's favorite!! The strawberry cake is a large 3 layer cake with a strawberry jam and icing on the inside layers. Their cakes taste like your grandmother made each and every one with love. Delicious and perfectly made! They do custom cakes, wedding cakes, cookies, cake balls, etc. Once entering the small store, you will see a display of bakery sweets that you can buy. I usually buy myself a cake ball or cookie when I'm picking up my order. I definitely recommend Miss Muff'n! Go check them out in Germantown near saddle creek!

    Photos
    Miss Muff'n - Buttercream in the center layers which rendered it inedible.

    Buttercream in the center layers which rendered it inedible.

    Miss Muff'n - Strawberry cake!

    Strawberry cake!

    Miss Muff'n

    See all

    The Painted Cookie - desserts - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...