I've lived in Rockland since 2019 and no one has ever told me about this place! Can't believe I've missed out on their pizza all this time! I don't have any pictures because I eat the food before I thinnk to take pictures when it comes to this pizzeria lol The VadkaRita is absolutely amazing especially with some hot pepper flakes and a side of Riesling. Salivating right now just writing about it. The salad pizza, plain and grandma slices are delicious too! Ambience is the old school pizzeria feel... With the square pizza boxes piled up on the counter shelves, chef in his white apron working hard, gumball machine, and the Italian ice box full of Good Humor ice cream bars ... No bells and whistles but just the way we like it! Special thanks to Mikey who always hooks us up with the best recs and conversations! Will be going back there probably on a weekly basis. read more

We love going to Nicky's after boxing! Always freshly made slices!! The staff are all very nice and welcoming

All roads lead back to Nicky's--and for good reason! The pizza is delicious, the service is always top-notch, and the dinners are 5-star. If you haven't tried the Chicken Francese, you're missing out--it's the best around. Whether it's a casual slice or a full dining experience, Nicky's never disappoints. Fabulousness, guaranteed! read more

Nicky's II Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Congers, New York

Ask my son if he wants Pizza and he will reply...can we get Nicky's! We love the plain and pepperoni pizza. Chicken Parm is good for two people. Top it off they have Mexican coke and Ice cream. read more

Decent plain slices but I prefer toppings. I got the buffalo chicken and while it wasn't bad by any means, there are other local options that provide far more chicken on their slice. I'm local so I'm sure I'll be back at some point. read more

Nicky's II Pizza - a slice of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Congers, New York

The new owners are great. I got a gluten free white pizza and they were so careful with my food. It even comes with a plastic pizza cutter so you can be sure the food wasn't touched with anything contaminating! I love their pizza and everyone is very friendly and easygoing. read more

Nicky's II Pizza - Gluten free white pizza - Pizza Near Me - Congers, New York

See all

Best pizza in rockland county, had a great lunch. Salad slice and a pepperoni slice, both were really good. Will be back.

First time there for a take out order that took 20 minutes longer than they said for hamburgers and a salad. Food was ok nothing special and not worth the wait. read more

I had heard great reviews of this place and was looking forward to the pizza, to my dismay, I was thoroughly disappointed. The pizza was subpar at best and the wings were burnt. Definitely not going back there! Honestly speaking no self respecting Restaurant would serve a customer this! read more

Nicky's II Pizza - Burnt wings- don't go here - Pizza Near Me - Congers, New York

Very disappointed tonight. Although this place almost always has great food and the service is wonderful, tonight was another disappointment. This makes the second time an order of wings has been unacceptable. These things were definitely cooked at least a day ago. They were dry, tasteless, and just old, like you had them in your fridge for a week and then threw them in an oven to reheat the f out of them! And as stated, this makes strike two. I don't recommend the wings. The pizza is usually decent tho. And the staff is generally younger and quite pleasant. Sorry guys, this is a management issue, not a service one. read more

Honestly the best pizza I have ever had in my life! As someone who doesn't like pizza this pizza changed my my mind. I highly recommend the Sicilian roni! Please do not miss out. read more

People are great; place is always clean; food is USUALLY good. Not always- received wings that MUST HAVE BEEN AT LEAST 5 DAYS OLD!! Just nuke them right out of the fridge and BANG! High quality left overs nuked to death!!! Never again read more

Ordered pie. After waiting an hour called them to see where my order was. Told me driver just left. We live 2 miles from pizza place. 20 minutes later we called again and they said he had multiple deliveries. 15 minutes later we cancelled order . They seemed not to care because they NEVER MADE the order. read more

This place is delicious their staff is so nice and the food comes quick I really recommend their bbq blast they make it to perfection every time! read more

Nicky's 2 is absolutely my favorite pizza place in Rockland County. I constantly order from them because the food is amazing and the staff is really nice( something other pizza places in Congers don't have). I had ordered an extra large pizza, which was ready when they said it would be and was delicious. They never disappoint when I order from them. Their chicken Marsala roll is absolute bliss and their sweet Marion sandwich is really good too. If you're ever in Congers, I would defiantly stop at Nicky's 2! read more

Nicky's II Pizza - Extra large cheese pie. Yum!! - Pizza Near Me - Congers, New York

I came after being recommended from someone at Bounce Trampoline Sports. I had ordered a Cheese burger. Not only did it take 20 minutes, it wasn't medium rare like I asked. Also, the person I was with got their food is unreasonably late. The burger was more than well over done. I don't think I will ever be visiting this place again, maybe it was just a bad day. However still bad service and food. read more

Nicky's II Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Congers, New York

I'd say 5 star , I'm a Bronx guy , turned into a rockland county guy . First off I walked in and it was a polite atmosphere, guys made sure they used my name and welcomed me to the town . Secondly they have gluten free pizza for my wife , and she loved it The pizza and all the food this far is great Great job guys read more

I was happy this restaurant stayed open through Covid-19, however their food is inconsistent, on 3 occasions I made the mistake of ordering heros and each time they were served on stale and burnt bread. This tells me that this pizza place, doesn't take much pride in their food. read more

OK so I did a meatball parm hero comparison from the 3 pizza places in Congers. Nicky's & the one across the street were neck in neck. Here, the meatballs were large but a tad tough. The 3rd place on 303 was not even close. Then I did an eggplant parm comparison between the 2 pizza places & Nicky's WINS! Non-breaded eggplant (the way Mom did it) , a nice crusty bread & topped with a good amount of gooey mozzarella. Everywhere needs to add another ladle of sauce please or ask for it on the side. read more

Seriously the BEST penne vodka pizza I have ever eaten in my whole life. When I decide to have my cheat meals. I choose their pizza every time. YUMMMM!!!!!!!! read more

Love this place. The kids love their pizza and I enjoy their salad slice. They have tables outside so we usually sit outside and people watch. The kids can also eat their pizza and run around and watch the train that comes by once in a while. They also love this place because they have Italian ice. Staff is friendly and the place is always clean. read more

We order from here a lot !! Their pizza is so good compared to everywhere else around here. I come from the city and of course I can't find pizza that good around here but Nicky's is fairly close. Their grandma pie is really delicious also. Wherever you're ordering a slice or a pie you won't be disappointed! They also have an eat in option.. on a nice day you can sit outside but I would suggest for them to hose it down daily as the bees can be an issue during the summer.. otherwise it's great! read more

This is my favorite pizza place in Congers... actually, probably in all of Rockland. I've ordered from here multiple times and have never had a problem - the pizza is delicious every time. The sauce is flavorful and generous with toppings without it overpowering the pizza. Really love this place! read more

My friends and I order from here at least twice a week due to the stellar service and delicious food. They are always polite on the phone (especially the young lady that works the phone!!) and rarely ever make errors with my orders. The pizza is awesome and the fries are always crunchy and great! Don't forget to try their soups!! Oh and they deliver quite fast compared to all the other places in town. You won't be dissapointed here! read more

Best pizza I've ever had in my life. Seriously, they are magic pizza makers and if you live in the area, consider yourself lucky. They do this wonderful type of layering with their toppings. Imagine a regular pie with whatever topping, now imagine that same pie with a little more cheese on top and a slight touch more toppings on top of that as well. The end result is perfection, the absolute perfect combination of topping, cheese, sauce, and dough. Still a New York style pie with slices that hold up. I've never had a better pepperoni pizza and I'm not sure if I ever will. read more

Great local pizza place. Super clean, friendly staff, fresh offerings. Treat yourself to a slice of the margarita pizza.

For delivery in congers this is a great place! I have had both the pizza and the chicken and pasta dishes and it is the best I have had in Rockland so far. It has be compared to authentic Italian places in the Bronx. read more

Always our favorite pizza spot in town!! Great pizza! We love the veal parmigiana too! And delivery is quick so you don't have to wait forever for awesome pizza! read more

My favorite pizza place in congers. Great attitude and service. Been going here for years. Awesome pizza!!!

Food has been good in the past, even better now under new ownership. Good pizza and chicken parm.

Our favorite pizza place in Congers. My go to slices are the vodkarita and the chicken caesar slice; delicious! White slices are excellent, my son loves the meatballs and chicken fingers. Andrew and the rest of the staff are very nice and make you feel like family. read more

I called in an order to pick up a normal cheese pizza and was told it would take 30 minutes. Thought that was a little long to wait for a pie at a not so busy time, so I went in after 15 minutes. Like I suspected, my pizza was done and seemed like it was sitting there for a while. Imagine if I waited the full 30 minutes, my pizza would have been cold. On top of that, the pizza was burned. read more

Love love love the pizza here. The chicken vodka square slice is my favorite slice in rockland. I usually get some fresh garlic on top for a little kick. I gave them four stars because I haven't been crazy about any of the pastas I've had, but as far as pizza goes this place is fantastic! Also, the service is great. The guys over there are super friendly. read more