Although I have a ton of family in and from New York and pizza is my favorite food, somehow I've never actually had true New York pizza. On our most recent visit, that had to be fixed. In true NY fashion and true to its name, The Pizza Place is very straightforward. We ordered to go, and the pizza was made fresh and they were able to accommodate my husband's dietary restriction. I'm glad I finally had authentic NY pizza-it definitely didn't disappoint! read more

The Pizza Place - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

Had dinner brought in from Pizza Place. The food was amazing! We ordered chicken Bruschetta, eggplant Parmesan , linguine with white clams and penne a la vodka. The focaccia bread was delicious! I highly recommend The Pizza Place!! read more

They consistently have great pizza and Italian cuisine with a friendly atmosphere and good customer service. The place is always very clean and welcoming. I highly recommend them. read more

Enjoy coming to the pizza place have my family come here as well Ty much don't change I appreciate the service n the workers the girls always very pleasant over the phone to a great new year's Ty again read more

The Pizza Place - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

Terrible experience. I went to meet my boyfriend for lunch, we ended up taking the food in instead of carry-out. The white haired guy goes, "if I knew you were eating here I'd put a plate out". My boyfriend goes, "I'm sorry we changed our minds". The guy scoffs loudly and goes, "women". As my boyfriend pulls out a chicken Cesar wrap that's literally falling apart, I ask him to leave because I refuse to be disrespected especially on the day after Christmas. read more

Melanie was lovely great service great food. The garlic knots were a little dry, but the service made up for it.

I had missed lunch so I stopped at this pizzeria to buy a plain cheese slice. The slices all looked good, different types but I like plain. Plain slice should have a good blend of Italian cheeses, sauce should taste of fresh tomatoes and herbs but not candy sweet! The crust should be crispy to the fold as such to hold it up well. When I got my slice, ! It was well cooked! I was helped immediately soon as walked in and my slice came out nice and hot that the cheese stretched so good!!! Mouthwatering!!! Great location, easy parking! Hope to bring my family over soon! read more

The Pizza Place - Crispy crust held up pizza beautifully - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

See all

The old guy behind the counter was the rudest person I ever encountered in a restaurant and then proceeded that with getting my order completely wrong. Don't go here they do not care about their customers and they make sure you know it. read more

Im a pizza lover! By far this place is my favorite for a regular or pepperoni slice . They have it all nailed down. From the cheese to the sauce & especially the crust. Love the service here . & the ambiance is great aswell. read more

I've come to this pizza establishment a few times in the last 3 years. Sadly, every visit I leave thinking the customer service could be better. I don't know if it's racial or just plain rude. A combo perhaps. This last visit is definitely the last. Not only is the place not inviting but they are now charging $3.95 for a bland tasteless small slice of pizza. Pass. read more

Solid pizzeria with offering up the standard pizza and Italian food. A local spot amongst the many options in the area. It's near the local High School so be aware it can get really crowded during lunch hours when schools in session. Enjoyed the Grandmas and the regular slice. Haven't had the food but it looked yummy. read more

The Pizza Place - The interior - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

See all

I take a trip from the North Shore of Nassau just for their Avocado Salad (gotta be chopped) topped with buffalo chicken. Their creamy balsamic and Caesar salad dressings are killer! Rigatoni Fiorentina. Chicken roll. Spinach pinwheel. All Glorious. Restaurant quality, huge portions at pizzeria prices. Highly efficient/ proficient phone order-takers, too. Never a mistake. Guys behind the counter are pros, and are usually lovely. I've yet to find a place that even comes close --anywhere. read more

amazing food, nicest staff, and management, cozy environment. I have 20 plus pizza places nearby me, yet I drive to this place and I don't mind the drive. try it and find out for yourself. read more

I come here every Sunday with my family to eat. The young waitress who works every Sunday is the best! We have so many allergy's and she carefully wrote all of them down to tell the cooks in the back. Whenever the food comes out it is unbelievable. The place has very chill vibes. Every time we come in the waitress greats us with nothing but love. She is why I keep coming back. Thank you so much to her!! read more

This morning I witness staff working the oven and handling garbage at the same time. He did not wash his hands. He then proceeded to take extra garbage bags out the bottom of the bin and placed it on the table that mix the pizza dough and make other dishes. I was absolutely disgusted and threw my food out. Other staff were present and didn't blink a lash. This appears to be common practice. read more

Driving north had Bigelow's in my GPS, knew it was ten minutes away etc... then saw this cute looking storefront for The Pizza Place... and knew I should check it out. Looked at the Neapolitan/round pizza and thought naa.. needs reheating and looks skimpy.. etc.. but then took a good look at the Sicilian and Grandmas and knew that was their thing. In the car instead of having one and saving one for the person I got if for.. had both! Cancelled my trip to Bigelows... Sicilian pizza is so good here... like you would get in Brooklyn. In the front a very helpful nice guy from El Salvador.. coming out of the kitchen I saw an authentic Italian must have been the owner. Will stop over any time I'm near this way .. for perfect Sicilian.... sauce is perfect! cheese is perfect, crust is crunchy...... no need to go to Brooklyn.. this is the real deal.. perfect. Try it. read more

The Pizza Place - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

WHY AREN'T THE EMPLOYEES BEHIND THE COUNTER WEARING MASKS? Also, they were rather rude. I almost walked out without paying for my order yesterday, if I wasn't so hungry I may have. When I finally got home I noticed that the portion size had been reduced. I won't be going back. read more

I am on Long Island at least once a week and I love to try different pizza places for lunch. (Shout out to Gino's in Lawrence and in Long Beach for some delicious pizza!). I stopped here and I usually would get a plain slice but I've had delicious broccoli slices in another places so I tried their broccoli and spinach slice. Truly mediocre, no flavor. I honestly feel bad about wasting calories on this.But the best part was the cost - drumroll please - $6.95! Congratulations pizza place on the most expensive and mediocre pizza slice I've ever had read more

Ugh lol I'm just so disappointed in my meal. I ordered through doordash.. while the pizza is warm the bottom is burnt and has the nasty burnt taste and hard! I got the 12 inch margherita pizza it's under seasoned, there's no basil like on the picture.. and idk how the crust cooked like that one side is really thick and one side is thin I've never had a thick Margherita pizza. It just totally missed the mark completely and it's just pizza lol read more

The Pizza Place - a hand holding a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

See all

Called to make an order. Person that picked up the phone was a little rude and claimed he could not hear me. After several attempts of me trying to give him my information he just hanged up. read more

Disclaimer: I'm from the west coast. I know NY is known for thin crust, but I'm legitimately a fan of how thick and soft the crust was. My cousin took me here while I was visiting and I easily fell in love with this sweet spot in Hewlett. I didn't even know chicken marsala pizza was a thing. Also baked zitti pizza, whaaaaaat?! The workers and I both knew there was one slice of chicken marsala pizza left on the pan, so they asked me to wait an extra minute to bring out a fresh one. From that, I knew this pizza place cared about their customers. They also suggested my cousin pay for my slice, ayyyye. read more

Love the grandma slice! Cheap and saucy and delicious. The homemade focaccia is great too!

I came here once, and the Pizza here was awful. I thought that it was hard to mess up a simple tomato, mozzarella, basil pie, but I couldn't finish eating it because it was so terrible. The tomatoes were dehydrated and tasted like cardboard, the pizza itself was unseasoned and really lacking in any sort of flavor. The dough didn't taste fresh, and tasted worse than a Costco flatbread. On top of that, the person handling my pizza putting basil on the pizza was also operating the register simultaneously without gloves so it was very unsanitary. For almost $40 for a pie, I expected much better than this. I do not recommend this place and I will not be coming here again. read more

Have tried pretty much all the pizzas around the neighborhood and towns next to Hewlett and this is by far the best you can get. It's always fresh and crusty. read more

Always amazing, tonight is the best meatballs in the sauce was over the top amazing. Even went out of the normal way and delivered a little further than their usual. Their avocado salads are just awesome incredible as are their soups. I wish I could order from them every night. read more

"The Pizza Place" was recommended to my brother from one of his work friends. Thank goodness he recommended this place. I met my brother for a late lunch. Parking lot is packed because they share it with a couple of popular stores. "Pizza Place" is on the corner of the shopping center and it is definitely noticeable. Heading inside I was impressed with the modern looking space with bright colors to make it stand out. They played light music in the background, and dining to the song "Soul Man" made the atmosphere very relaxing. They have two beautiful waitress if you choose to dine in or you can head to the counter and order with the friendly staff. The line was long, but worth the wait. Once my brother and I went over our options, we grabbed two slices each. They don't have a lot of specialty slices out but they make food to order. Once we sat down they put silverware and napkins out for us. The food was ready and piping hot. It was time to eat. The bacon, chicken, ranch slice was phenomenal. It had too much bacon and too much cheese. I fell head over heels in love with it. Next was the buffalo slice. Upon asking, the owner was kind enough to bring blue cheese over. This slice was the slice I never knew I was looking for. It was the benchmark of buffalo pizza. I couldn't believe how cheesy, juicy, and spicy it was. They used two types of cheese that worked very well with a crust that stood out on its own. I will definitely recommend this place to all Yelpers and return again. Trust me, drive there, wait on line and grab a slice. Trust me you will also become a regular. read more

See all

Best Italian food I've ever had. I grew up in Hewlett and moved to NYC and am still searching for better Italian food than here. The pizza and chicken rolls are to die for and every pasta dish is amazing. Also - their creamy balsamic dressing should be bottled and sold. Love this place!! Need an outpost in NYC! read more

the service was terrible. the old guy that works here is a complete prick he tells me to come get my pizza than doesn't give it to me so I go sit down and he calls me out infront of the whole place asking if I was expecting my friend to give it to me read more

This is perhaps the most overpriced pizza in five towns... unless they flew it in this morning from Italy. Then the prices would make sense... it tasted alright enough but prob not a repeat based on taste alone. Also, hearing the owner and his friends repeatedly calling someone they were talking about an a-hole and d*** on full volume while I waited for my pizza i could of done without. read more

I used to like their pizza but I noticed that recently the quality deteriorated. They put a lot less cheese on the pizza now. However, the most disconcerting fact is that they are not health conscious. The same person who makes and handle the food also handles the money. A few days ago, I went there to order pizza with pepperoni. The person grabbed the pepperoni with his bare hands and then took the money from me. This is not the first time that I saw the same person handling the food and money. Additionally, no one wears masks here. read more

Excellent pizza and incredibly respectful employees who take care of you. Bonus points because they hire teens (which is never easy), and I've witnessed them both discipline them but also defend them from j*rkoff customers. read more

Extremely disappointed! Ordered delivery yesterday and whom ever answered the phone had absolutely no personality.The order was wrong (I paid over 40 dollars for two pizzas).They got the address wrong as well.I won't be ordering from here again as I was hosting a bday party. read more

New in area. Highly disappointed. Just received my delivery the pizza was barely cut the bottom of my chicken roll was burnt. The cheese slid off the pizza, the back of the box had a giant glob and now has grease there to show where it was. read more

The Pizza Place - Cheese pie and burnt chicken roll. Cheese everywhere. Pieces barely cut. - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

The food it's okay but too pricey!! Been ordering there for a few yrs now but the quality has decreased!!

Ordered a Sicilian pie and 2 cheese calzones. Pizza was amazing. Calzones looked a little flat in shape vs from other places i've had. read more

The Pizza Place - Sicilian slices - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

See all

absolutely heaven sent try the avocado salad, chicken roll, rigatoni Florentino and everything else its all amazing do it alllllllll i love ittttttttttt read more

Heard this place was "the best ever". After of years of people raving I finally tried it. I had the buffalo chicken and a grandma slice. I'm not a huge fan of buffalo chicken so I didn't like it. Too much bleu cheese and the chicken was too spicy. They forgot about my grandma slice so everyone around me was eating and I was waiting for one slice for over 15 minutes. It finally came out after having to remind them and it was pretty good. Except for the last bite. It tasted like earwax Or something had contaminated it. I had to spit it out. Staff was very friendly however. read more

Obnoxious people, overpriced food. They think they're doing you a favor selling you for top dollar their "ok" food. Spend your money someplace else where they appreciate your business. Not here. read more

Pizza was good, hot and fresh..Buffalo slice was big and delicious...prices are great..only negative is no posted menu to see what else they offer when you walk in...I'll be back..food was great! read more

The Pizza Place - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York

If you're in the mood for the absolute best chicken Caesar salad you've ever had please come to pizza place. Tip: order fresh mozzarella, and fried chicken instead of grilled chicken to expand on your wonderful experience. Have been coming here for years for this salad and will continue to come. The service is absolutely amazing! All the workers are so sweet and it's simply a pleasure to go there. read more

The Pizza Place - The best chicken Cesar salad you'll ever have! - Pizza Near Me - Hewlett, New York