Extremely Dirty, Chef has an Extremely Bad Attitude, And the Food is some of the Worst food I've…read moreEver Seen Anywhere, Overall just a Bad Experience, I Would Never This Place Recommend Anyone

Dearest people that may want to venture here. Do not say or do the wrong thing, especially ask…read morewhat the meal comes with. He will find a way to be a jerk to you. Had two encounters with the guy in 7 years and he was a complete jerk on both occasions. He will never get my money, but he may catch the bird on occasion while I venture by.

The Owner is Extremely Rude!!!…read more We stopped in to get fish dinners recently. After looking at their menu, my husband had a question. He asked the owner his question, and the owner replied, "Can't you read?". My husband said, "Excuse me!". The owner tried to change his tune, but it was too late, and we just walked out. There are so many places to go to for a great fish dinner (The Winfield Grill, Chick'n Out, Bill Gray's, Palmers,...), where you'll not only get great food, but far superior services and get treated with respect. In addition to this owner's terrible attitude, this place has a "Very Fishy Odor", and that's never a good sign when purchasing fish from a "Fish Market". We will never go back to Captain Jim's, and strongly suggest that others do the same.

I got a hot buttered lobster roll ($30) and fried clams. The clams were mostly breading. One of…read morethem had sand. The lobster roll was weird. Rather than chunks of soft white and red meat and visible claw meat, it was cut up big squarish chunks of white, brown, and rubbery meat. I'm sure it was lobster, but the preparation/composition was very different from other places. The lobster was overcooked and rubbery. There was not enough butter. It was in a plain hotdog bun rather than a toasted brioche bun. I had to add more butter. I think you should try a warm buttered lobster roll from Nolan's on Canandaigua ($25), the restaurant or the snack shack, to know what it should look and taste like. For this price the quality has to improve... I won't be back unless I see pictures that it's better. I was really really really looking forward to having a go-to lobster roll spot.

This place has Authentic English Fish and Chips! It's the go to every-time! If you are in the mood…read morefor fish and chips, there is no other place. Portion size is huge and its good value for your money

Camera didn't eat first. We were looking for a local fish and chips spot and ended up at…read moreChurchills. My husband, toddler and I got the King's Platter which was perfect - two pieces of halibut, three shrimps and 3 scallops with a huge amount of fries, coleslaw, with what I assume was house made tartar sauce and seafood sauce. We were the only customers - we went in the Sunday of a long weekend shortly before closing - and had our food in front of us within ten minutes of entering. It all tasted fresh and delicious and "light" considering it was deep fried. The batter had good crunch. We loved all of it...our toddler loved the fries and the decor, especially the murals. We will absolutely be back.

Ordered early for Good Friday along with hundreds of other people! The fish was good, not overly…read moregreasy, and didn't leave that heavy feeling in your gut after. Service was slower than expected...even considering the rush, and a little unorganized. If someone was going the payment only, not trying to also manage everything else, it would have gone much smoother. Staff were almost cordial, as much as expected. Looks like a strip mall fish and chips joint, not much to the decor or ambiance...but it is what you'd expect. I would get the fish again.

We ordered the light and fluffy battered halibut with a side of thick cut fries with a side of…read morecoleslaw and gravy. The gravy was a great add-on to the fries we had! The coleslaw was fine (does anyone realllllly like coleslaw? Haha) It was $41 for two boxes of fish and chips (1 piece of halibut each) + the gravy + the coleslaw. A little pricey, but I would go again :)

My husband and I live in Buffalo. When we are in Rochester we stop at the Old Toad. It is an…read moreauthentic British pub experience. We have been going to this establishment for many years. Last evening we stopped for dinner and a beer. We had an excellent British beer, Speckled Hen. We shared the Chicken Korma and Fish and chips (with the peas). The chips were very crisp and the fish was fresh. The curry was mildly spiced. We meet a couple from England. The man in the couple did an internship at the Old Toad years ago. He stopped in when traveling in the area because The Old Toad is the kind of place that you remember. You should stop in soon.

Rochester staple for beer and whiskey. Decent menu and…read moreeclectic crowd. If looking for chill spot and just simple service ... it's an old standby

Food is great it reminds me of my childhood back in Michigan…read moremy parents would take us to one a couple of miles from our home

The worst fish and chips ever. The fish is just frozen pre-battered unknown fish species.read more

We love Doug's and have been coming for years. It's simple and consistent and comforting. The fish…read moredinners are fresh and tasty. The service is efficient and friendly. The dining area can get busy and crowded but it's a warm and friendly environment

We got a lobster roll, fish, fried clams and all were AMAZING. The clams were absolutely the star…read moreof the show. Fried clams are a favorite when dining at a good seafood restaurant but these were the best we have ever had!