Fantastic pizza! Definitely the best pizza in Avon and the baked goods are always great!

Stopped here as I was in Avon for an appointment, just grabbed a slice that was in the holding thingy as I was very hungry (thus the half-eaten slice picture). First bite was good but didn't seem hot enough, so decided to heat it up at home... well, that decision didn't last long as the deliciousness started to really sink in and I could wait no longer to continue eating. It might be my new favorite pizza place. The sauce is on the sweet side, which I love. Crust was nice and airy but not too thick. Good balance of cheese, toppings and crust. I can only imagine how good a full, fresh out of the oven pizza would be - which I will be sure to get next time as I'm definitely going back! There's no parking lot, but there is a shoulder-lane with room for a couple spots out front and a little side street right there. I didn't get a bakery item but they all looked delicious too. Friend read more

The Livingston County Pizza Co - Quick to-go slice, half eaten before I thought to take a picture. - Pizza Near Me - Avon, New York

Great location... walking distance from work so super convenient to grab and go some hot fresh made to order pizza! I'm like a little kid preferring cheese and pepperoni most days! Pizza was really good, sauce was a basic red but the cheese was the best... lots of flavor and they didn't skimp on the amount! I grabbed a to go menu, surprised they offer a lot of other options besides pizza.. burgers, sandwiches and salads.. I will be sure to try in the future. Also, a good size bakery section. read more

See all

We wanted to try another pizza spot nearby, but saw The Livingston County Pizza Company which has better ratings. We ordered 2 pizzas each with diff toppings and 10 medium wings. The pizzas were cooked perfectly, the dough was tender and fluffy, the toppings fresh and delicious!! The wings were also sauced well and cooked well. The staff were kind and helpful! We love you guys!! We'll be back! read more

P b cookies are excellent!! Yumm. I will be trying their pizza next! Ty! Very friendly & courteous! read more

They have a good dough, adequate toppings and a standard sauce neither thick nor thin, not heavy or light on seasoning, not sweet, pretty tomatoes. The Pittsburgh salad with Riviera dressing was ok covered with not to heavily breaded chicken fingers, crispy fries, mild cheddar, large chunks of celery, thin tomato. It's a melding of let's cut the celery we use with chicken wings in half, add some tomatoes we use on subs etc. The dressing is like a sweet and sour with poppy seeds? The baked good looked delicious and I bet they rock the gluten free world. With the various things they had on the walls they look like real home town supporters. read more

The Livingston County Pizza Co - Pittsburgh salad - Pizza Near Me - Avon, New York

They have vegan cheese. We got the white pizza with vegan cheese instead of ricotta. Two thumbs up. I like the puffy crust. read more

The Livingston County Pizza Co - Vegan white pizza - Pizza Near Me - Avon, New York

Love it here. We order take out all the time and always pick up something extra from the bakery. Good gluten free food can be tough to find. We feel lucky to have an option like this right in our local town! read more

Ok...ive had the pizza...a bit better than the other local spots that also have a thicker crust and sweeter sauce. I've also had a few subs...so good!! And their staff are so friendly!! Sometimes staff are reported in reviews as friendly because they are well known in the neighborhood by the reviewer. Well...i can tell you that i am not from Avon, and EVERY TIME i have been here, i have been treated well!! read more

The pizza here is good, but it is a good deal $$$ compared with other local pizza joints the area. We ordered a large with sausage and pepperoni. The crust is not a thin as the typical NY style pizza, but it is good in proportion to the toppings. The sauce carries the pizza here, it could be the best sauce in the area. I also ordered the cannoli "pie". This is a waste of cash. The sweetened ricotta cheese is pretty good, but it is topped with cheap chocolate sauce (the kind you make chocolate milk with...) Also, they make it into a pie rather than serving up the traditional pastry. The crust is bland, under done and super soggy. They have several other options for dessert to choose from. read more

The Livingston County Pizza Co - Cannoli pie - Pizza Near Me - Avon, New York

See all

We were traveling through the area for our anniversary. Absolutely delicious pizza and awesome baked goods for those with and without food allergies! Wonderful friendly and thoughtful staff. Hope to visit again! read more

Gluten-free calzone is awesome! Impressive gluten-free menu, as well as baked goods! Very knowledgeable employees! Totally impressed! read more

I love this place. I have lived here for almost 2 years and this is "my go to" for pizza. One of the best pizzas ever! They make my pizza exactly like I like it! They remember my order. They are very timely with deliveries. They are all so very nice to deal with. LOVE LCP co. read more

Got 3 calzones, 2 regular, 1 gluten free, and 2 gluten free cookies. All of the calzones came out over cooked, and charred on the outside. One of the calzones had the wrong toppings from what I ordered. The cookies were ok for gluten free, but wouldn't make it a destination for GF cookies. I've been here before, and had much better products, so hoping this is an anomaly. Will go back again for convenience, and although burnt, were still good. read more

Best pizza in town! Amazing cookies,pizza,pasta, chicken, sub's,pies,fish fry, you name it is here and delicious! Great menu as well as a large gluten free menu to choose from. Always fresh and made to order. Friendly staff, clean environment. Take out or eat in! read more

See all

Gluten-FREE!!! Taste so good!!!! It doesn't taste big difference with gluten-free food!

They have the best cheesey breadsticks of all times!!! Definitely will be going back soon!!! Recomm to all my friends and family

Great Food, DELICIOUS gluten free options. I have yet to have anything on the menu that's not yummy. Bakery items are all made in house, you can definitely taste the freshness. You would never know it was gluten free! Fish Fry's are yummy! Also available in gluten free option. Small town with a gem of a place. I would definitely stop in and order. Staff are personable any questions with the menu their pretty great with finding the answer. The Owner Paul is always there, he's a great funny guy. Family friendly for sure you can dine in as well but they do deliver. Quite the selection in food. Check it out you won't regret it. read more

They provided all of the food for a gluten-free retirement party and the food was awesome! I appreciated the individual wrapping of the 1/2 sandwiches, to allow for easy pickup. Their desserts are great! We had the carrot cake for the party and a dozen cookies. S'more cookies rocked! read more

This is by far the best pizza and wings in town! We always get the family special of a large pizza, 20 wings, and a 2ltr of soda. It's the only place we get our pizza from. read more

We were pleasantly surprised to discover this place in the middle of nowhere-ish. My daughter eats vegan and it's not always easy to find good pizza options for her. So when we read they served dairy & lactose-free cheese as an option, we decided to give them a try. Very good pizza, friendly staff, and fast service! We will definitely be back! read more