Had the reviews said this is your typical 50's type hangout with cheap well done burgers then I would have thought it was good. This is not a foodie place by any means and I despise well done beef so to me it was ok. I would not go back or go 12 miles out of the way for it again read more

Rude service and low quality food. My "deluxe" ham and swiss sandwich came with 2 pieces of deli ham and a piece of cheese. My $4 side of jalapeño poppers came with 4 lukewarm poppers that tasted like they were straight out of the freezer. I ordered cottage cheese as well and never received it after reminding the lady who took my order twice. Very dissatisfied read more

Fantastic, friendly service with great food and a fun family atmosphere - amazing sides (especially the sweet corn nuggets and cheese curds) Highly recommend for anyone driving through! read more

Probably one of the best turkey burgers I've had. It was thin and delicious and the staff was super sweet. And it was quick to get food so it was the perfect break between our animal adventures on sat. read more

What a neat little place. Their sign says they raise the beef they cook, and I believe them. Their burgers are tasty and grilled to perfection. I got mine with bacon and unlike a lot of places they made sure the bacon was nice and crisp. Also love the chedder cheese balls. I know that they're probably just frozen, but dang they're good. Burger, balls, and a shake, and I'm a happy camper. Décor is lots of pictures from the local High School basketball team, just like a good Hoosier spot should have. And I really appreciate how they're open on Sundays which is a rarity down here. read more

Great burger place right down the road from Paoli Peaks! We will be stopping again. The fries were perfect. Lots of options for kiddos.

When you're in the middle of nowhere Indiana, this is a standout option. Not burgers you'll necessarily write home about but you won't be mad you stopped in. Fries are average, burgers are above average and of course the price is right. read more

Super Burger has the best burgers in town...or actually the best I have ever had! I love that the beef is local and the service is friendly. We visit here often! My husband has them on speed dial. read more

I've been going to this place for as long as I can remember. It's been through several owners and the quality has always been up there. Since Mr Scott bought it the decor has been upgraded but the food is still great. There are still a few old pictures of Paoli ball teams which are cool to check out. My uncle is even in one of them! The fries have always been a favorite of mine and the burgers are awesome! Prices are really good also. It's worth a visit! read more

Nice local place! Fresh beef burgers that are huge for the price and quite delicious. We tried fries, onion rings, and mushrooms for sides - rings were the clear winner. Lots of local basketball memorabilia. read more

Making our way from Indianapolis to Paoli Peaks stop in for lunch and the food & serves was excellent!

Yesterday we went there and I Had the super tenderloin and it was thin as card board and mostly breading that was over cooked.. very dark brown . Was brought too us by a lady who I believed to be the owner, not one of the mostly teenagers working. Was not a good value (especially since I could only choke down half) of tenderloin, Order came to $17 for tenderloin, small cheeseburger, order of small onion rings and two very small milkshakes. Second time there, both times dining room was freezing. read more

Pretty good food and not over-priced. This is exactly the sort of restaurant it appears to be from the street. Lots of character here. There are pictures of the Paoli sports teams for 60+ years. A neat place to check out for a tasty burger. read more

Really good food and as the sign says they grow there own beef.

This place is grease-burger heaven. It is just off the town square and on your way to the French Lick casino if coming from the north.

Super burger, coming from Bloomington, IN friendly, works very hard.. great food. easy. The way it should be. Going there again tonight to meet the hard working Emily. (and say thank you to the cooks.) read more

Was just here today with family from out of state . None of us are from the area . Found superbuger on yelp and we decided to try it . We were all very disappointed in the quality in the food. Dry buns on all our food , sides more breading then mushrooms or onion rings . When u ask for chicken u don't want hamburger mixed in w it . When u ask for a bacon cheese burger u shouldn't need to wonder where's the bacon or beef . Have had much better. read more

Made from cows grown right here in Orange County!

Good home made food. The beef is from their own cows. Taste great! Nice lunch if your tired of fast food had have time to just hang out.

Excellent place to eat. I have never been disappointed in a sandwich here and highly recommend the cheeseburger (made with their own grass-raised beef), pork BBQ, and ribeye sandwiches. Cheese curds are wonderful too! read more

Cool locally owned joint!! Beef is locally raised! Yum! My 4 year old and 2 year old who are picky eaters loved it. Finished off with ice cream! read more

Went by here for a quick meal while driving down to Tennesee, and wow, was it good. I got a double with fries and a milkshake, and after a couple minutes. Not too much around the place to look at, decor sub-par. I didn't have to spend to much time looking at the walls, however. They served all 10 of us in a matter of minutes. Delicious, my go-to lunch place when heading down south! read more

The burger i ordered was so tendee it seemed to fall abart. Customers staff was very friendly with recommendations. While they do not deliver which is the only draw back i also did not expect it from a restaurant this Size. read more

The food is "super" overpriced and not even that good. If you order shakes you are guaranteed to wake at least 15 minutes in the store.

Superburger is a great burger place! Love that you can get grass-fed, local beef here. The Triple Newk is a beast! If you're looking for a good burger, don't hesitate to stop by. read more

When we travel we try not to eat at chain restaurants. While traveling back from zip lining west of frenchlick we stopped here for a quick bite. We had the dbl bacon cheeseburgers which were very good the curly fries were hot but nothing special. I would definitely stop here again as the staff was friendly and if your looking for simple meal this place works. read more

Supper burger?!? With a name as such I imagine a large burger, not the case here! Patties a very thin, bacon is pre-cooked, and I did not even receive fresh fries with my meal! read more