A few months back I received a get-well box filled with a variety of different flavored crumb cakes. They were ALL delicious! I vowed to get to this bakery that is quite a distance from my home. Sadly, I just heard that they will be permanently closing their doors on December 26, 2025. With that being said, I wanted to make sure I got there to get their rainbow cookie crumb cake for one last time! I made a special trip on my way home from work. On this late Wednesday evening, I stopped in to find the LAST piece of rainbow crumb cake for the day. While they had plenty of the regular crumb cake and red velvet crumb cake, it's the rainbow cookie crumb cake that is my favorite. BTW, I recommend going earlier in the day to ensure you get exactly what you want. Luckily they still had what I just had to have. Additionally, they have a bunch of other baked goods. In the cases there were cookies, cakes, cheese cakes, lobster claws, Napoleons, cupcakes, etc. too! The homey bakery space is roomy with a table of baked-good trays to go in the center of the store. Since I was the only person in the bakery, the girls were attentive and accommodating. read more

The Whisk Bakery - Crumb Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Last minute they helped save the day and make my birthday cake. ABSOLUTELY LOVED IT. The cake was SO GOOD and look so much like the inspo picture I sent them. It was perfect. read more

The Whisk Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Came here because of the eclectic menu and it definitely lived up to my high expectations. I got an assortment of goodies for my family to enjoy on Christmas eve and everyone loved everything they had. Showstoppers were the black and white cookie- super fresh and amazing frosting as well as the rainbow cookies- also super fresh and absolutely delicious. Will absolutely be back for more next time I need to do a bakery run. read more

The Whisk Bakery - Linzer tart, brownie with fudge and oreo, rainbow cookies, rainbow cookie crumb cake, cheesecake cone, black and white cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I called about a week and a half in advance and right from the start had an excellent experience! Friendly service and great cakes! Looking forward to working with them again in the future. read more

The Whisk Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Love this place! Best rainbow cookies on long island!! aidan and carly so sweet, such great help! read more

The Whisk Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

You are my neighbor , my closet bakery to my house . I have given this place many many tries . I wanted to love this bakery. I feel bad even saying these works , but how dare you sell me stale cookies not once but twice. And shame on me for going back. I will NEVER go again. Your workers are amazing and friendly your food sucks though read more

Let me start by saying what an adorable place! Absolutely love the vintage vibe. Also there's a really sweet girl that greets everyone as they enter with a kind smile. Nowadays you gotta love those friendly people that are kind and give a good service. I had a bagel bomb lol I hate bagels but I'm loving this one The only downside is they don't have coconut or oat milk but I'm hoping they will add soon This is my new favorite bakery and I can't wait to bring my boys read more

See all

Ordered a cake for my daughter's 16th Birthday. Provided the cake designer with a hand drawn picture of the desired cakes color and details. After conferring with Amanda she presented some ideas for the design and filling . For the end result Amanda created and designed the exact same that was requested; it was absolutely PERFECT!!!! Not only was the cake beautifully made it was super Delicious ; Vanilla cake with Raspberry filling. The birthday girl was so excited to see the amazing masterpiece and replica of her drawing. She can't wait to have another piece!!! Overall experience was excellent and highly recommended. read more

See all

Came for the first time this weekend and everything was amazing! I had to get dessert for two separate parties and everything was absolutely delicious and very fresh. I love that they play around with flavors and don't just have the standard Long Island bakery items. The service was great and I love the decorations. Will 100% be back! read more

My family purchased this Banana Cream Pie to celebrate a birthday this evening. Everyone was excited to taste what looked very good, and the banana cream filling was absolutely delicious. The problem was a completely undercooked and in certain parts, raw crust along with a whipped topping that did not have the flavor of whipped cream or butter cream; but rather had a "chemical like" aftertaste. It had "dried" bananas on top, but they were not crisp... they were brown and mushy. I am a huge proponent for mom and pop businesses, and I know she would never want anyone to get ill from her food- but to serve things undercooked or raw- can be dangerous, and sadly I will not be supporting this business again until the reviews become more positive. If during the first few weeks of opening, products were sold raw, undercooked or lacked flavor...there is NO reason for this business to STILL be serving bakery items with the same results. One would hope that all of these reviews help the owner to correct the mistakes she's making; as the lack of change makes the customer think that there is no desire to grow and become better. read more

Fantastic little bakery. Super cute inside. Very reasonable price wise. I had a decaf tea and a rainbow crumb cake for $5.25. The crumb cake was huge and I had to split it in half. The ladies behind the counter were super sweet and very accommodating. All of the desserts looked good. I have no idea why they only have 2 stars but I will definitely be back. read more

The Whisk Bakery - 1/2 of the rainbow crumb cake... I took the other half home - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

This was the cake for my daughter's baby shower. It was delicious and looked beautiful. They were easy to work with. read more

The Whisk Bakery - Baby shower cake. Delicious - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I hate to write a one star review but I had to after the cake I ate. We had the rainbow cookie cake for a party and I was so embarrassed. The cake looked nice but literally tasted like bug spray chemicals. It was so horrible that I threw it out and I'm not one to waste cake! I've had other cookies, and also the rainbow crumb cake that were also disappointing. Sorry, but I won't be coming back. read more

This has become my favorite bakery . The pastries are always fresh and delicious.You cannot beat their prices either . From coffee to cake to their gelato - AMAZING! I don't know what the bad reviews are talking about but yelp is filled with people who just like to post nasty things . Give this bakery a try - you won't regret it. read more

The Whisk Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

This is a hidden gem that deserve way more attention. (Or maybe not, only because there limit on fresh goods) if you are looking for a Whoopi Pie, take and bake cookies, or even delicious donuts, go to whisk. Their donuts are absolutely amazing. They are California stamp of approval. Their cookies are outstanding, and the cakes they offer for customization are beautiful. read more

The Whisk Bakery - Menu - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

This place always has great desserts and open later than most bakeries. It's clean and the staff are friendly whether in person or over the phone. read more

I ordered a very special birthday cake for my boyfriends 60th birthday, really just hoping for the best. When I picked it up I was shocked! It was AMAZING, there were so many compliments, we froze the " record " in Top! BTW , I also ordered cookies which by far were the nicest I've ever seen! read more

The Whisk Bakery - Custom made and designed for my boyfriends 60th birthday. - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Honestly best bakery on Long Island..and I've tried my fair share. Everything here is amazing!! I'm a tough critic with my sweets, and this place exceeds any expectation. Their butter cookies are better than any others I've ever tried. read more

Service is great. The girls are super nice. Ambiance is pretty and location is very convenience.

WOW the vibe in the bakery is "HAPPY, FRESH , Delicious " Everything I have had is absolutely amazing ! The atmosphere just makes me feel so happy walking in! They make an amazing Banana Cream Pie that I surprised my daughter with for her birthday. It didn't make it to the next day , we devoured every delicious bite ! read more

This place is adorable and amazing! Yay specially during a holiday!!! A must for cookies

The products themselves are pretty good for the most part. The professionalism and service that Whisk offers has gone completely downhill. We've been getting custom cakes and all sorts of desserts from Whisk for over 3 years, without issue. This is no longer the case. With 6 days notice (Previously always asked to submit requests with 2 days notice), we submitted our request with images and flavors for a custom cake for our daughters birthday party (15 5/6 year olds). We were asked to give a phone number for a deposit, so we went in 2 days later for snacks and to leave a deposit. We were told it's not a problem, just call back the next day so we can speak with Amanda and give our deposit. The next day we call back, and we found out she is now too busy on Saturday to make the cake for us. So now after showing our daughter the cake and bringing her in to Whisk, we have 2 days left and no cake for her party. Hoping we can find another bakery that will accommodate us, but I'm beyond disappointed at how this was handled. The cakes are great, but what good is a great cake if a lack of professionalism and service prevents it from making it to your plate? read more

Ordered a cake for my one year old's Cocomelon themed cake smash gathering. Amanda took our order and had great ideas on the cake design and texture! It came out perfect and was delicious. It was so good we ordered the same exact cake for a photoshoot later in the month! Pictures to follow!! read more

Unfortunately I was not impressed. The pumpkin crumb cake had absolutely no pumpkin flavor. The cake part was more yellow than the standard crumb but no spice flavor or pumpkin flavor at all. My son liked the macaroons The rainbow cookies were more cake like than the dense cookie I prefer. The decor was very nice but I will not be back unfortunately read more

I do not understand how this bakery only has 3.5 stars...like truly baffled. I just got their rainbow cookie crumble cake and it was the best rainbow cookie cake we have ever had!! I first tried their cakes at friends grad party & her dad's 50th. One cake was Oreo & the other was chocolate peanut butter. I was so blown away that I came home and said "We're only getting cakes from Whisk from now on." This is my new favorite bakery & my old favorite was Alpine (so I have pretty good taste) So excited for our next occasion so I can get another cake!!! read more

The Whisk Bakery - Rainbow cookie crumble cake - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Excellent pastries and cakes. Always fresh and tasty. Aidan at the counter was eager and very friendly. Have gone there many times and will continue to stop in! read more

New to the area and we were looking for a bakery with something unique. We found The Whisk and read a few reviews about their rainbow cookie crumble and we were sold. As a huge rainbow cookie fan, I must admit this is one of the most decadent rainbow cookie inspired pastries I've ever eaten. The portion was huge for the price. The girls were so sweet and helpful. I do feel like some of the cakes in the display looked like they were a day old or more. But I'm guessing business must have slowed down since COVID. I will definitely order a cake from them in the future. They had really unique flavor combos: chocolate strawberry shortcake, banana strawberry cake, Oreo cream pie. Beautiful bakery and wonderful service! read more

See all

I had been looking forward to trying this bakery for SO long and I was so disappointed. Not one thing I got was edible! I went in the morning and almost all donuts were gone, okay it's a popular place so I grabbed the last three glazed donuts - big mistake. They were rock hard! Aside from that, the flavor was just... off. I also ordered two Oreo Macaroons, and I spit it right out. Last but not least I ordered two chocolate cake pops (they look like ice cream popsicles). I will say the decor is gorgeous, it smelled heavenly inside but the taste of everything was just off. I understand if I went late in the day but it was 11 am, there's no way the sweets could be that bad! I will say I did try a sample of the chocolate chunk cookie which was absolutely delicious! I would have bought 5 but they have m&ms as well and that's just a personal preference- the sample did taste delicious. Maybe, maaaayyyyyybeeeeee one day, IF I'm in the area I'll go back and try something different. But I'm so sad to say I will not make an effort like I did today driving 40 mins JUST to come here. read more

I have to be honest I came here like three different times and all three times the cookies the cakes and the pastries was extremely stale The last time I was in here there was two girls there who had a really big attitude and a whole bunch of sarcasm every time I ask them a question I felt like they wanted to kill themselves Definitely not coming back. I got the banana Oreo bread pudding and it was like you kept the bananas outside on a summer day for about a week and then try to use them it was disgusting and it smells terrible I try to get my money back but the girl said I have to come back on Tuesday when the owner is here and this was Saturday night it was there ridiculous read more

The Whisk Bakery - Banana Oreo bread putting - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I ordered a 2 tier naked cake for my sisters baby shower. From ordering, to pickup - it was very easy. The cake was delicious!! So fresh. Nothing like a typical dense, cold, and day before prepped bakery cake usually is. It looked beautiful. I was so happy with how it turned out. Definitely recommend them & will be back to try the stuff they have in the display cases! Yum read more

Ordered pull apart cupcakes for my sister's bridal shower. The design was great and the cupcakes were delicious. I haven't had any other items from the bakery, but based on these cupcakes I would look to try other things. read more

The Whisk Bakery - Pull apart cupcakes for Bridal Shower - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

The decor is so cute! I got a SHAKE it tasted like SHAKE. The paintings are kind of weird. 10/10 would come again! Omg I forgot! I tried the cheese cake! (Mini) it was easy to eat, I will definitely be returning to sit on the Chairs and eat food. read more

See all

Just stopped in for Coffee and a muffin and I have to say this is the best muffin I've ever had! The iced coffee was delicious. Such a cute bakery with great prices. So Excited it's around the corner from my Work!! read more

Thank you to this bakery for making a wonderful custom gender reveal cake! It was beautiful and delicious and was a big hit. The cake itself was so pretty and there was even pretty glitter on it I highly recommend this bakery to anyone looking for a custom/special cake. read more

The Whisk Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

My kid love this place. The cake is really cute and it's taste really good and good favors read more

The Whisk Bakery - Cannoli cake - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

The bakery is nicely maintained and staff is very friendly and helpful. Writing was done perfectly. This is my second cake purchase and second time the filling of the cake tastes hard and stale. When I cut it, it started breaking apart. (Vanilla cake with buttercream filling).The cake itself was delicious. I asked my Family their rating from 1-10, they gave it a 3, Disappointed as it was for my daughter's birthday and she didn't eat it. read more

The Whisk Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I am SO late writing this review, but better late than never! I went in there after going to a different bakery with a Pinterest photo of a cake I wanted for my sons 1st birthday. The previous bakery looked at the picture, said it was all fondant and quoted me a ridiculously over the top price. Well, I went into Whisk as since they've opened we have gotten a few things from there and everything has been delicious. Brittany looked at the picture, and said she could do a lot of it in buttercream and that would save me a lot of money as opposed to the fondant. I was nervous because I couldn't imagine them achieving the same look, but she seemed confident. Well.... my husband went to pick up the cake and when he got home with it I was so blown away I actually started crying. My sons whole (original) party had been cancelled due to COVID and I know it sounds stupid but this perfect cake, really made it all better. Aside from the fact it was ridiculously delicious, the time, effort, skill and the over all level of care they took to make this cake was just over the top. I will DEFINITELY be a customer for life. Also, yes their rainbow cookie crumb really is that amazing. read more

The Whisk Bakery - a mickey mouse cake - Bakeries Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

We have been patrons of the local "best" bakeries for years and have been very happy with them, but Whisk is our new favorite. The cakes taste fresh, delicious, and have a home made quality to them. Sometimes, we would find cakes from other bakeries, while very good, to be too sweet. We feel that Whisk has the absolute perfect level of sweetness, where less is more. The Rainbow Cookie Crumble cake was amazing. We're looking forward to the next visit so we can try something else. One bite and you'll be hooked. Whisk will be our "go to" bakery from now on. read more

I custom ordered "The Grinch" cake pops to bring to a "Grinch" themed party & after seeing a pic of them on social media I thought I would give them a try - they came out amazing! The bakery was beautiful & smelled delicious! The cakes & bakery items on display looked so good! Def coming back here next time to try a cake! The girls working were very nice! read more

Came here two weeks ago with my wife, sister and son. The girls behind the counter were sweet and helped us choose desserts with no attitude. Looking back at these reviews, it's clear there are many people who have the keyboard warrior mentality, as well as the mentality that they can bake better products. If you can, do it. Stop bashing local businesses that put their hard earned money where there mouth is. Not every experience requires a review if you're going to be that negative. Shut the hell up. read more