Order The Cake Don Takeout or Delivery
The Cake Don Photos
The Cake Don Popular Desserts
You might also consider
More like The Cake Don
Recommended Reviews - The Cake Don
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
I stopped by here not realizing this was the cake store and not the cupcakes store which is in Huntington. It was my sisters bday and after rushing out of work I wanted to grab something quick. I arrived here at 4:10 pm which is pretty close to their closing time. I was immediately greeted by Kathy who was super friendly and welcoming. Unfortunately I realized this was more of a place to order cakes and they didn't have an actual display of cupcakes. I mentioned that I just wanted some cupcakes but realized this place didn't have them. She said she would see what she can do for me. 2 minutes she offered me a few options. I agreed to it all 5 minutes later Kathy came out with the prettiest cupcakes. I'm was so grateful that she took the time to make them for me. The cupcakes are delicious and fresh and they are just soooo pretty! I would give the customer service here and A+++ and would definitely be coming back here for our regular came orders. I'm so happy to have found a decent cake/cupcake place around. :-)
A few short weeks ago, I had the idea to order a custom cake for my friend's retirement dinner. I dealt with the Cake Don only to purchase his (fabulous) cupcakes during the lockdown and beyond. He is my go-to for a quick treat or item to bring to a BBQ/gathering. This time, I called, spoke with them about my thoughts, and how I really didn't have an idea. Before I knew it, we decided on something with the scales of justice. I then Googled some images and found a stack of law books with the scales of justice atop. The dinner would be for 12 people, so they recommended a cake for 12-15 people. There were several options for the cake and filling, so I opted for chocolate cake with chocolate ganache. I gave them my credit card, they asked me what time I wanted to pick it up, and they gave guidance for keeping it cold before serving. On the day of pickup, they produced a box large enough to fit a microwave! They helped load it into the car and again reminded us of to keep it safe and fresh for the unveiling later on that evening. Every single person we dealt with was lovelier than the next. The restaurant we had the dinner at (the legendary King Umberto's!) took special care with the extremely large box and kept it safe until they presented it on a rolling cart to our table. Fellow diners are nearby tables were in awe of the cake. This cake look exactly like the photo I submitted with gold fasteners (edible) and binding on the book that look so real! The scales of justice sat prominently on top and the ribbon with "Happy Retirement" was perfect finish. The server told me he felt bad cutting it. Now for the flavor: the cake was moist and fresh. The ganache was among the best I have ever had. The icing was not overly sweet, and despite the coloring used for the exterior of the "book", none of us had discolored teeth after eating. The cake was easily at minimum a foot wide, and definitely about 6-7" high. Slices were generous and we still had plenty enough left over to take home. This cake was worth more than what I paid for it--I can only imagine the hours of labor to produce this work of art. Patronize the Cake Don, either for cupcakes at his Huntington store, or by ordering a cake for your next event. You will not be disappointed. And when an owner and his whole staff are lovely? Even better!
Beautiful custom cake made for a surprise party I threw for my girlfriend. My girlfriend actually thought I got her a dior bag for a second. Nah just the cake baby! Everybody loved the cake as well! I got red velvet with cream cheese filling on the inside. Thank you very much! The lady I worked with (Chrissy) was extremely helpful throughout the process of getting this order together. Highly recommend.
Honestly I don't even like cake (I do like frosting lol). Yes I am a weirdo. Anyway despite that, I do like my cakes to look awesome, and taste amazing for others. After looking at most places all over the island I finally checked out the cake don and he does absolutely amazing work. We first used him for our baby shower cake. My cousins still talk about that cake being one of the best ever. The taste and how adorable it was. We also used him for our son's first birthday party which again everyone loved. My one girl loved it so much she had to get his 4th of July cupcakes for our little party and my son literally lived his best life that day. Those cupcakes were my son's dream, cuteness overload as he had red/white and blue icing all over him lol. Anyway I'd 100% recommend him for cakes, cupcakes, etc. He's the best on long island.
I ordered cake for my baby shower, I paid extra money for safe delivery, as I was told by bakery.they told me if I pay extra for delivery that's guarantee for safe Delivery! unfortunately this is how I got the cake at the time of delivery ! I attached the picture below , which is marked with red circle. As u see The bow is dropped!! I also attached picture of cake which I ordered. I don't recommend this bakery for any event!!!!!
The most amazing cupcakes ever!!!! I highly recommend The Cake Don for all your cake needs... Don is so nice and his cupcakes are delicious! Many flavors to choose from and my favorites were the Samoa and the S'mores! I've seen his work online and in store and his cakes are unbelievable! He can create almost any specialty cake! I'll be going to Don for all my cake needs in the future! Definitely check him out!!!
I recently celebrated my birthday with a custom cake from "The Cake Don" . I was so excited with the outcome of our cake. Don is so talented and will truly bring any vision of yours to life! He created a masterpiece based just from my inspiration. Not to mention the cake, itself, was DELICIOUS! Several fabulous options of fillings and frostings to pair and choose from. I appreciated the teams communication prior to the big day as well as a seamless delivery to the venue. Thanks again for making my celebration extra special. Highly recommend treating yourself or loved ones to a custom Cake Don creation!!
I don't know where to begin. I am so so so so glad someone close recommended me this place for my sons first birthday cake. Don greeted us so warmly and quickly showed us the designs for the ideal cake we wanted. The attention to detail, the flavoring , the quality is all 5 stars. This place is a must try for whatever your special occasion is. You will not be disappointed!! Thank you so much Don!!
Our daughter had her 100th day celebration and we decided to go with Cake Don after reading the reviews on yelp. We called Don and setup an appointment with him. We sat down and showed him some pictures online of what we had in mind. He was receptive to our wishes and gave a few helpful suggestions too. We then chose the flavor of the cake; and that was pretty much it. We got the cake on our scheduled date and time. The cake came out as we had designed. Our family members were impressed and thought we had bought it at a Chinese bakery since the Chinese character, colors and design were authentic in appearance. In terms of taste, the cake is really delicious. It's not overly sweet and fairly light (excluding the fondant). We chose vanilla cake with strawberry filling which ends up as a mousse with pieces of macerated strawberries. It's easy to have more than one piece. We will definitely be going back to Cake Don in the future for our cake needs and recommend him to family and friends. We're glad we found someone in this area for our custom cake needs.
Let me first say when you're dealing with a theme-styled cake, details are everything (and of course flavor). I ordered this cake for my husband's 50th birthday party and being that this is my first husband's favorite movie of all time it just seemed appropriate. The details on the cake I received were very good and the cake itself tasted very good as well and overall my cake looked almost like the one posted on Pinterest (which, along with the great reviews, is what helped me decide to order from The Cake Don in the first place). I was just a little disappointed that 3 details were missing from the cake: 1) the cigar 2) the handkerchief and 3) blood from the horses head - but again, like I mentioned, the cake tasted very good and still the artistry was excellent and I would deal with them again, but I think next time I would make a concerted effort to take the trip out there (they're located in Long Island I live in New Jersey) before the date of an event to make sure to cross all my T's and dot all of my i's in person. I'm still a big believer in dealing with people in person.... For certain things a.k.a. special orders, as opposed to dealing with people by text or over the phone just because things like this can happen and I was a little worried Something like this would happen. With that said, again I would order from them again- they did a great job.
Had these cupcakes delivered to my mom in Greenlawn for her birthday! Each flavor was better than the next. My personal favorite was the red velvet. The cupcakes are stunning and the buttercream was rich and delicious. The most moist and flavorful textures and lasted in the fridge until they were all gone ! Perfect addition to our celebration
5 months ago
4 years ago
I stopped by here not realizing this was the cake store and not the cupcakes store which is in Huntington. It was my sisters bday and after rushing out of work I wanted to grab something quick. I arrived here at 4:10 pm which is pretty close to their closing time. I was immediately greeted by Kathy who was super friendly and welcoming. Unfortunately I realized this was more of a place to order cakes and they didn't have an actual display of cupcakes. I mentioned that I just wanted some cupcakes but realized this place didn't have them. She said she would see what she can do for me. 2 minutes she offered me a few options. I agreed to it all 5 minutes later Kathy came out with the prettiest cupcakes. I'm was so grateful that she took the time to make them for me. The cupcakes are delicious and fresh and they are just soooo pretty! I would give the customer service here and A+++ and would definitely be coming back here for our regular came orders. I'm so happy to have found a decent cake/cupcake place around. :-) read more
A few short weeks ago, I had the idea to order a custom cake for my friend's retirement dinner. I dealt with the Cake Don only to purchase his (fabulous) cupcakes during the lockdown and beyond. He is my go-to for a quick treat or item to bring to a BBQ/gathering. This time, I called, spoke with them about my thoughts, and how I really didn't have an idea. Before I knew it, we decided on something with the scales of justice. I then Googled some images and found a stack of law books with the scales of justice atop. The dinner would be for 12 people, so they recommended a cake for 12-15 people. There were several options for the cake and filling, so I opted for chocolate cake with chocolate ganache. I gave them my credit card, they asked me what time I wanted to pick it up, and they gave guidance for keeping it cold before serving. On the day of pickup, they produced a box large enough to fit a microwave! They helped load it into the car and again reminded us of to keep it safe and fresh for the unveiling later on that evening. Every single person we dealt with was lovelier than the next. The restaurant we had the dinner at (the legendary King Umberto's!) took special care with the extremely large box and kept it safe until they presented it on a rolling cart to our table. Fellow diners are nearby tables were in awe of the cake. This cake look exactly like the photo I submitted with gold fasteners (edible) and binding on the book that look so real! The scales of justice sat prominently on top and the ribbon with "Happy Retirement" was perfect finish. The server told me he felt bad cutting it. Now for the flavor: the cake was moist and fresh. The ganache was among the best I have ever had. The icing was not overly sweet, and despite the coloring used for the exterior of the "book", none of us had discolored teeth after eating. The cake was easily at minimum a foot wide, and definitely about 6-7" high. Slices were generous and we still had plenty enough left over to take home. This cake was worth more than what I paid for it--I can only imagine the hours of labor to produce this work of art. Patronize the Cake Don, either for cupcakes at his Huntington store, or by ordering a cake for your next event. You will not be disappointed. And when an owner and his whole staff are lovely? Even better! read more
1 year ago
3 years ago
1 year ago
4 years ago
Thank you Cake Don for making my beautiful and delicious retirement cake in short notice. Someone other then me ordered it. It was delicious. None left to take home. Also the Cake Don Cupcakes in Huntington is amazing. Fresh and delicious! read more
Beautiful custom cake made for a surprise party I threw for my girlfriend. My girlfriend actually thought I got her a dior bag for a second. Nah just the cake baby! Everybody loved the cake as well! I got red velvet with cream cheese filling on the inside. Thank you very much! The lady I worked with (Chrissy) was extremely helpful throughout the process of getting this order together. Highly recommend. read more
1 year ago
6 years ago
Honestly I don't even like cake (I do like frosting lol). Yes I am a weirdo. Anyway despite that, I do like my cakes to look awesome, and taste amazing for others. After looking at most places all over the island I finally checked out the cake don and he does absolutely amazing work. We first used him for our baby shower cake. My cousins still talk about that cake being one of the best ever. The taste and how adorable it was. We also used him for our son's first birthday party which again everyone loved. My one girl loved it so much she had to get his 4th of July cupcakes for our little party and my son literally lived his best life that day. Those cupcakes were my son's dream, cuteness overload as he had red/white and blue icing all over him lol. Anyway I'd 100% recommend him for cakes, cupcakes, etc. He's the best on long island. read more
4 years ago
I ordered cake for my baby shower, I paid extra money for safe delivery, as I was told by bakery.they told me if I pay extra for delivery that's guarantee for safe Delivery! unfortunately this is how I got the cake at the time of delivery ! I attached the picture below , which is marked with red circle. As u see The bow is dropped!! I also attached picture of cake which I ordered. I don't recommend this bakery for any event!!!!! read more
2 years ago
I tried the new S'mUDGE cupcake today... OMG, the chocolatey goodness of the s'mores and fudge cupcakes combined is incredible and a new fave! read more
The most amazing cupcakes ever!!!! I highly recommend The Cake Don for all your cake needs... Don is so nice and his cupcakes are delicious! Many flavors to choose from and my favorites were the Samoa and the S'mores! I've seen his work online and in store and his cakes are unbelievable! He can create almost any specialty cake! I'll be going to Don for all my cake needs in the future! Definitely check him out!!! read more
4 years ago
I recently celebrated my birthday with a custom cake from "The Cake Don" . I was so excited with the outcome of our cake. Don is so talented and will truly bring any vision of yours to life! He created a masterpiece based just from my inspiration. Not to mention the cake, itself, was DELICIOUS! Several fabulous options of fillings and frostings to pair and choose from. I appreciated the teams communication prior to the big day as well as a seamless delivery to the venue. Thanks again for making my celebration extra special. Highly recommend treating yourself or loved ones to a custom Cake Don creation!! read more
I don't know where to begin. I am so so so so glad someone close recommended me this place for my sons first birthday cake. Don greeted us so warmly and quickly showed us the designs for the ideal cake we wanted. The attention to detail, the flavoring , the quality is all 5 stars. This place is a must try for whatever your special occasion is. You will not be disappointed!! Thank you so much Don!! read more
7 years ago
Our daughter had her 100th day celebration and we decided to go with Cake Don after reading the reviews on yelp. We called Don and setup an appointment with him. We sat down and showed him some pictures online of what we had in mind. He was receptive to our wishes and gave a few helpful suggestions too. We then chose the flavor of the cake; and that was pretty much it. We got the cake on our scheduled date and time. The cake came out as we had designed. Our family members were impressed and thought we had bought it at a Chinese bakery since the Chinese character, colors and design were authentic in appearance. In terms of taste, the cake is really delicious. It's not overly sweet and fairly light (excluding the fondant). We chose vanilla cake with strawberry filling which ends up as a mousse with pieces of macerated strawberries. It's easy to have more than one piece. We will definitely be going back to Cake Don in the future for our cake needs and recommend him to family and friends. We're glad we found someone in this area for our custom cake needs. read more
3 years ago
6 years ago
Let me first say when you're dealing with a theme-styled cake, details are everything (and of course flavor). I ordered this cake for my husband's 50th birthday party and being that this is my first husband's favorite movie of all time it just seemed appropriate. The details on the cake I received were very good and the cake itself tasted very good as well and overall my cake looked almost like the one posted on Pinterest (which, along with the great reviews, is what helped me decide to order from The Cake Don in the first place). I was just a little disappointed that 3 details were missing from the cake: 1) the cigar 2) the handkerchief and 3) blood from the horses head - but again, like I mentioned, the cake tasted very good and still the artistry was excellent and I would deal with them again, but I think next time I would make a concerted effort to take the trip out there (they're located in Long Island I live in New Jersey) before the date of an event to make sure to cross all my T's and dot all of my i's in person. I'm still a big believer in dealing with people in person.... For certain things a.k.a. special orders, as opposed to dealing with people by text or over the phone just because things like this can happen and I was a little worried Something like this would happen. With that said, again I would order from them again- they did a great job. read more
Had these cupcakes delivered to my mom in Greenlawn for her birthday! Each flavor was better than the next. My personal favorite was the red velvet. The cupcakes are stunning and the buttercream was rich and delicious. The most moist and flavorful textures and lasted in the fridge until they were all gone ! Perfect addition to our celebration read more
5 years ago
The Cake Don made a beautiful cake for my husband's 50th birthday, I showed them the picture of the cake I wanted and they made it exactly the same! It came out so nice, my husband and the guests at our party loved it! read more
5 years ago
I tried the cupcakes from here and they were excellent!! Cake is super moist and not boring like in most cupcakes. The caramel mocha was my favorite! Would definitely pick these up again. read more
5 years ago
6 years ago
Ordered a cake for my 40th birthday party. The cake was not only beautiful but it tasted delicious also. Everyone at the party stated that the cake was amazing! Highly recommend The Cake Don! read more
8 years ago
7 years ago
Just had my baby shower cake done by the cake don and he gave me exactly what we described to him! The consultation was easy and very comfortable, and included a tasting of all the cakes and flavors. He was very nice and gave us is a clear picture as far as direction of the cake after we explained what we wanted. I thought the price was fair for the kind of cake I got and am extremely happy. I will be a return customer, you cannot get better on long island period! read more
3 years ago
3 years ago
6 years ago
First time customer and a very happy one. I order two cakes for my son's birthday. Both looked amazing as you can see in the pics, and also very important, they were scrumptious! The service at the shop was very friendly as well. Overall a 5 star cake shop, I'll be ordering more cakes in future from here. So thank u cake don!! read more
5 years ago
5 years ago
6 years ago
Definitely didn't look like the cake I wanted for my daughter 1 year birthday party the butterflies didn't even look like I wanted and I messaged and never got a reply read more
5 years ago
This was my first time ordering from The Cake Don. It was a birthday cake for my moms 70th birthday. Omg!! I was speechless. I've never in my life have seen a more beautiful cake. The staff was incredible. I worked with Chrissy and she was a doll. I felt like I knew her my whole life. When I picked up the cake I met the owner and he was the most down to earth nice guy. I can't say enough good things about this place. If you want a spectacular cake this is where you want to go!! read more
5 years ago
5 years ago
I don't even know where to start. Cake Don, you are amazing, you live up to your name and have now gained a forever customer. We went with a vanilla cake and chocolate mousse filling. The cake was ordered 1 week before my party and he made it work. I said I needed the cake for about 30 ppl and this cake fed alot more than that. People were coming back for 2nd and 3rds lol The taste and the smell of this cake, omggg I cannot even describe it. The artwork and detail that was put into this cake was phenomenal. I cannot wait to order my next cake for you. read more
8 years ago
This guy does AMAZING work. This place was not cheap, but it was worth every penny. Not only does Don and his staff do beautiful work, but they made the best tasting cake I have ever eaten. I will only order special occasion cakes from this guy. I can't recommend him enough. The Star Wars cake he created was awesome. read more
5 years ago
7 years ago
Page 1 of 2
More info about The Cake Don
Ask the Community - The Cake Don
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
5 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
8 years ago
9 years ago
2 years ago
5 years ago
3 years ago
The Cake Don - bakeries - Updated July 2026
Best of Huntington
People found The Cake Don by searching for…
Bakery Birthday Cake in Huntington, NY
Dubai Chocolate in Huntington, NY
Nut Free Bakery in Huntington, NY
Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies in Huntington, NY
Personalized Cookies in Huntington, NY
Birthday Cake Delivery in Huntington, NY
Custom Cookies in Huntington, NY
Red Velvet Cake in Huntington, NY
Strawberry Shortcake in Huntington, NY
Cookie Delivery in Huntington, NY
Bakeries That Deliver in Huntington, NY
Cannoli Cake in Huntington, NY
Baby Shower Cake in Huntington, NY
Fondant Cakes in Huntington, NY
Jewish Bakery in Huntington, NY
Trending Searches in Huntington, NY
Blueberry Pie near The Cake Don
Breakfast Pastries near The Cake Don
Breakfast To Go near The Cake Don
Brownie Sundae near The Cake Don
Chocolate Chip Cookies near The Cake Don
Chocolate Croissant near The Cake Don
Cinnamon Roll near The Cake Don
Cold Noodles near The Cake Don
Cupcake Delivery near The Cake Don
Custom Birthday Cakes near The Cake Don
Dairy Free Bakery near The Cake Don
Egg Salad Sandwich near The Cake Don
Fresh Produce near The Cake Don
Gourmet Cookies near The Cake Don
Ham And Cheese Croissant near The Cake Don
Ice Cream Cake near The Cake Don
Ice Cream Sundae near The Cake Don
Juices And Smoothies near The Cake Don
Lemon Meringue Pie near The Cake Don
Mexican Dessert near The Cake Don
Pastries And Coffee near The Cake Don
Romantic Restaurants With A View near The Cake Don
Sports Bar With Tv near The Cake Don
Steamed Crabs near The Cake Don
Strawberry Shortcake near The Cake Don
Sugar Free Desserts near The Cake Don
Vegan Desserts near The Cake Don
Browse Nearby
BEST of Huntington, New York Restaurants near The Cake Don
BEST of Huntington, New York Coffee near The Cake Don
BEST of Huntington, New York Things to Do near The Cake Don
BEST of Huntington, New York Parking near The Cake Don
BEST of Huntington, New York Desserts near The Cake Don
BEST of Huntington, New York Breakfast near The Cake Don
BEST of Huntington, New York Cake near The Cake Don
BEST of Huntington, New York Cupcakes near The Cake Don
BEST of Huntington, New York Thrift Stores near The Cake Don
Browse Brands
Related Searches in Huntington, NY
Bakeries That Deliver in Huntington, New York
Bakery Birthday Cake Choices in Huntington, New York
Best Bagels Available in Huntington, New York
Best Donuts to Try in Huntington, New York Near You
Best Filipino Bakery Options Near Huntington, New York
Best French Bakery Options Available in Huntington, New York
Best German Chocolate Cake Bakeries in Huntington, New York
Best Keto Bakery Treats in Huntington, New York
Best Mexican Bakery Options in Huntington, New York
Best Mini Cakes Available in Huntington, New York
Best Panaderia Bakery Treats in Huntington, New York
Browse Popular Pastry Shops Around Huntington, New York
Delicious Carrot Cake Bakeries Near Huntington, New York
Delicious Cookie Cake Options Available in Huntington, New York
Delicious Cookies You Can Find in Huntington, New York
Delicious Croissant Options in Huntington, New York
Delicious Custom Cookies Baked in Huntington, New York
Discover Authentic Italian Food in Huntington, New York
Discover Authentic Italian in Huntington, New York
Discover Popular Iced Coffee Spots in Huntington, New York
Discover Tasty Cookie Treats in Huntington, New York
Discover Top Baked Goods Shops in Huntington, New York
Discover Top Mediterranean Food in Huntington, New York
Discover Top-Rated Cheesecakes Near Huntington, New York
Discover Vegan Desserts Near Huntington, New York
Discover the Best Macarons Available in Huntington, New York
Enjoy Classic Strawberry Shortcake in Huntington, New York
Enjoy Delicious Crepes in Huntington, New York
Enjoy Fresh Cinnamon Rolls in Huntington, New York
Enjoy Fresh Doughnuts Made Daily in Huntington, New York
Enjoy Pastries and Coffee Near You in Huntington, New York
Explore Custom Cakes Crafted in Huntington, New York
Explore Cute Coffee Shops Around Huntington, New York
Explore Dessert Places Around Huntington, New York
Explore Popular Tea Rooms in Huntington, New York
Explore the Best Cakes in Huntington, New York
Explore the Best Sugar Free Cakes Available in Huntington, New York
Fast Birthday Cake Delivery Services in Huntington, New York
Fast Cupcake Delivery Services in Huntington, New York
Find Chocolatiers & Shops Around Huntington, New York
Find Custom Birthday Cakes Made Fresh in Huntington, New York
Find Delicious Chocolate Cake in Huntington, New York
Find Delicious Pies and Cakes in Huntington, New York
Find Delicious Sheet Cakes Available in Huntington, New York
Find Delicious Sourdough Bread in Huntington, New York
Find Top Tres Leches Cake Bakeries in Huntington, New York
Find the Best Black Forest Cake in Huntington, New York
Find the Best Coconut Cake in Huntington, New York
Browse Articles
People who viewed The Cake Don also viewed
Sweet Karma Desserts
176 reviews
$$
Pure Sugar
3 reviews
Fiorello Dolce
98 reviews
$$$
Smallcakes - Syosset
89 reviews
Baking My Heart Out
15 reviews
$$
Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bakery
141 reviews
$$
The Dirty Cheesecake By Lilis
108 reviews
A & G Bakery
89 reviews
$$
Nikkie's Devine Desserts
7 reviews
Jonathan Lord Cheesecake
9 reviews