i would 100% recommend checking out this bakery. i placed a custom cupcake order and they totally hit the mark. the decorations were superb. i gave some flexibility on what i wanted along with a few inspiration pictures, and they did an incredible job. i ordered 10 jumbo cupcakes, funfetti flavor with vanilla icing, and honestly the taste was exceptional. everyone was raving about how fresh, moist, and delicious the cupcakes were. it was really easy to order. i called about a week in advance, and they were very accommodating. service was exceptional. when i went inside, they individually boxed the cupcakes for me. overall, i couldn't recommend this bakery more. cost-wise, it was also the best deal out of the local bakeries i had looked into. read more

Benkert's Bakery - inside - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

See all

We went in to purchase a variety of donuts for our guests this evening. We were very disappointed and embarrassed when we served them. The Cheese Claw shredded as we cut into it, and as you can see from the picture, was basically empty. The Boston Cream had the consistency of bread. All the donuts that were filled only had filling one side of the donut and were dry. They weren't tender or fresh. I'm questioning how long these donuts have been sitting on the shelf. The only thing that was fresh and delicious was the Rye with seeds. Great crust and soft, fresh bread. This used to be a great bakery but over the years the quality and consistency has really gone down. read more

See all

Still a solid bakery well known to the neighborhood area. Been in the same spot on Middle Country Road for many years. Good spot to pick up a cake or cookie platter for the family gathering during the holiday season. read more

See all

I've been going here for many years on Thanksgiving morning. Each year is a little bit different but always good. The selection they have is large and they have everything; bread, rolls, cookies, cakes and even a small amount of candy. There were many people working, and the service was quick. There was also ample parking and not too many people waiting to be helped. One thing I can say about my experience this year is that the employee who helped me had a problem with numbers. I asked for a dozen rolls . 2 sesame, 2 onion, and the rest plain. She gave me the 4 rolls with toppings and then 6 plain rolls. She caught the mistake before giving me the bag and corrected it . Then I ordered 4 linzer tart cookies and she gave me two. I checked the boxes before I left thankfully and was able to go back in and get the additional two I originally ordered. I was charged correctly so it wasn't too big of a deal, just a slight inconvenience. If you've never been here, I recommend you visit but make sure to check your order before leaving. read more

Benkert's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

amazing gluten free cakes!! so careful about cross contamination. ive also had delicious cookies and a chocolate and raspberry cake. this place is delicious read more

So as you all know I ordered a lot from this bakery and most of it was made wrong. I wanted to post earlier today BUT I did not want the person who I got the cake for to see this and ruin the surprise. I don't even know if the inside flavors are rite yet. Here it is .. . I WILL NEVER GO BACK TO BENKERTS BAKERY! I ordered a simple happy 60th birthday for the same person I ordered one for 10 years ago for his 50th that they RUINED! They couldn't even get a simple cake correct. They do not care about customer service. There is nothing more upsetting then trusting a big name bakery for your special event and having it wrong more than once. The cake was supposed to say "Happy 60th birthday Mike" it came out Happy birthday Mike. They said they will fix it .. it was not fixed good at all. THEY EVEN READ IT TO ME THERE AND SAID WE WILL FIX IT. I am done. I would say go to queens to get the cake you want to have made, it may be a drive but if you want a cake made the way you ask and the price you pay is worth the trip. VERY UPSET WITH THIS BAKERY! read more

Best brownies ever! I stop by when in area to get goodies for my besties lil girls. Short and sweet review. 100% Best bakery in town and super sweet staff. P.s. Don't forget to tip. read more

Benkert's Bakery - Chocolate Brownie. - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

See all

I like their collection of delicious goodies. Always fresh. They give discounts to seniors for the asking. They used to be cheaper than other places, but now their pies and cakes are ridiculous. read more

Nice local bakery. I heard the cupcakes were really great. There is always a line. Cookies looked very old-fashioned.

Bankers Bakery is still making my ole time Favorite morning breakfast buns... Albeit the best of Long Island and not just because of there be the only 1 or 2 left that still bake and fair them availability to the underlying areas of Long Island in Ny... Thank u read more

Wow. This place place has went downhill from many years ago. It should be a 3.5 star review but that doesn't exist. We went on this store around. 12:30 pm on this Saturday The lady who helped us seemed like she would rather be at a DDS for a root canal than answer any questions we had. The customer service was really bad. Asking what each item was filled with (as they had multiple deserts side by side with different fillings) was just short of a visible eye roll As she was ringing us up we decided we wanted a log of bread. Again asking what type of bread a certain one was was met with annoyance. We pointed at the onion rye. We told her we would take it, she offered to slice it and we said yes please. We spent $26 and they wanted to add on 4% for a card. We paid cash This used to be a 5 star bakery. I highly recommend management look at their employees encounters with customers and keep in mind that some people have traveled 30 minutes or more just to come here based on previous memories. These memories were slightly shattered by the encounter of the employees which would have been a 1- 2 star review for employees, luckily their bakery items were still at solid 4-5 stars. read more

See all

Oh man we came up from Virginia and had to stop in a hometown favorite. I for got how great this place is. Everything looked so good. We just wanted to buy one of everything. I remember that they are always busy. When we came in there was a consistent flow of people in and out. There was also an employee packing a van full of deliveries. We got a bag a giant cookies, a cheese cake , and a crumb cake. Everything was as good as I remember. read more

See all

Yesterday was my daughter's baby shower. It was a mermaid theme and I brought the invitation as inspiration for the cake and I was amazed with the finished product! Not only was the cake adorable but it was also delicious at a reasonable price! Highly recommend this bakery!! read more

Benkert's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

OMG...Ordered a "naked/rustic" tiered cake for my wedding sequel celebration... the cake was beautiful AND delicious! Chris did a great job. I asked for pineapple for the smaller top layer, raspberry in the middle, and chocolate at he base/bigger layer. Guests and family loved it! some took slices home and said the cake got even better days after. Communication directly with the bakery could be better, but the caterer for the venue communicated with Benkert's directly and all worked out perfectly. read more

Benkert's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

Always a delicious treat to stop by for. I just wish they had more options when you order from delivery services. But.. fresh fresh!! I tell people calories don't count because they are delicious and they don't have long lines like other places because they are efficient while their kindness shines through! read more

Service is horrible, my sister tried to call ahead for a strawberry shortcake and was told multiple times ' we'll have it ' and they wouldn't take the order. She came in and ordered that strawberry shortcake that she needed AND WE GOT CHEESECAKE. Birthday Ruined Birthday girl hysterical read more

Benkert's Bakery - Wrong order - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

Surprised by all the negative reviews though it's my first time here. There is a constant flow of customers in this bakery. We walked in and there were some customers but not overly crowded. Came in looking for dessert to bring to a dinner. The decision came down to fruit tart or strawberry cheesecake. After an employee came to help us with our decision, we decided on strawberry. It helped to know your guests' taste buds. We also picked up a linzer cookie to snack on. Results: The cookie was a bit dry for me. The cheesecake was a hit. Will have to come back to try other items. Enjoy! read more

See all

Very bad service the ladies at from very rude . there are so much more bakeries around the area . Don't come here , I have a new born baby and I wanted to buy a short cake I call the store bc I was literally right in front of the store but my baby just felt sleep I ask them if I can order it or if they actually have short cake . She was very rude she told me " you came to come inside to see what we have " I explained to her I have a baby , she told me " okay you still have to come inside " And was very disappointed the about her service and nothing professional, I've been here before and cakes are okay but look for other bakeries . All this happened today . read more

Benkert's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

The cake came out just as the picture I have given! It was very delicious and we all enjoyed it! Lovely staff, and decent prices also! Glad I chose this bakery for my fiancés birthday cake! read more

Benkert's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

On a scale from 0 -5 Benkerts is a 6. The assortment is incredible and fresh. Staff is always cordial. Probably one of the Best Bakeries on Long Island. read more

A few weeks ago I was looking for a red velvet cake for my birthday. I had never been to Benkert's so I figured I'd give it a try. I didn't realize I had so many ways to customize my cake! I was thrown off guard but they were super patient haha. All the ladies here are so sweet. And CHECK OUT THIS CAKE!!! I was so excited, jumping up and down like a puppy. The writing was perfect, the chocolate filling was so rich, the red velvet was so tasty. Come on, who doesn't want a beautiful fabulous cake for their birthday?! Thank you so much Benkert's; I'll definitely be back for more delicious treats in the future! read more

See all

If your crumb cake sucks that's not a good sign. Consistently disappointed with this place! Alpine is Smithtown is hands down the best ever. Stale flavorless crumb cake. If you can't get make good crumb cake, don't call yourself a bakery!!! read more

Benkert's Bakery - Disgusting crumb cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

They have a nice looking selection of items. I went there today for French bread but they had none. So I bought two Napoleon's and two French macaroons. I have no idea what the macaroons taste like because I gave it to my daughter. The Napoleon wasn't flaky but burnt and crispy in the inside. Very disappointing. Couldn't enjoy it, not worth the calories. I've posted a pic of the inside. read more

See all

Got to love those bakeries. We stopped in here for some treats. The baked goods tasted ok but I could not get over the smell inside the bake shop. There was a strong smell of yeast. I know a bakery. However we frequented a lot of bake shops. The smell did infect some of the pastries we purchased. The staff were friendly. And the place looked to have an abundant amount of treats to try. Not sure if it was a fluke day we will be back to redo this review. Their rainbow crumb cake was real good but it did have a light aroma on it. :( we will stop back to redo the review hoping it was a fluke since they have been around for a long time. read more

Delicious and prices are great. Went for one item and came out with pastries, cookies, cake and danishes. Sooo yummy!

Went in to get a fresh loaf of bread and some treats for the family. What I got was fresh bread and moldy apple turnovers! Yuk. The bread is always fresh and good I thank God I cut into the giant fresh looking apple turnover in half because if not I would have consumed a moldy mess and got very sick as I am allergic to mold. The staff offered to refund my money and apologized. Will def go elsewhere for my apple turnovers. read more

The cakes taste like something that was made in a factory, frozen and then thawed out. Gross!

I grew up with Benkerts around the block in the 70s,80s, and 90s. It's been hit or miss for me lately. Definitely not as great as it used to be. Today i bought a pound of cookies and some rainbow cookies. Very disappointed as flavors were bland and nothing spectacular. Rainbows were ok but missing almond paste and chocolate on the bottom that make them great. They Seemed odd and I've bought better in Holbrook or Smithtown bakeries. I hope you guys can do better, like you used to be, we need you! read more

Great foid. Loved the cookies, the black and white cookies and eclairs. The cookie trays weregreat and fresh. Staff extremely nice.

Beautiful & very delicious wedding cake made our day extra special! Strawberries inside were fresh and ripe, frosting was perfect, cake was moist. Loved it so much. read more

Benkert's Bakery - Beautiful & so delicious cake made our wedding day extra special! - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

Definitely a great bakery ! pricey of course but what isn't now a days . But if you catch them on a fresh day best rainbow cookies and strawberry short cake cakes are the best !!!!!!! read more

I love Pretzels. not those dried out things that come in a bag at the local supermarket. Not even those super sweet things sold at the airport by someone claiming to be my uncles wife. And while a good NYC hot pretzel is a treat to savor when in the five boroughs, and they are fresh and hot (so not often). There is nothing like an honest to goodness German Brezel. I have been hard pressed to find these in the states. There is a commercial baker who puts a cellophane wrapped package of rods or buns in some supermarkets, but they can match the freshness and unpreserved quality of bakery made. Every trip I have ever made to Germany I was accompanied back home by 2lbs of added brezel weight. So imagine my surprise when I found these wonderful treats at Benkert's. I think I may have scared the girl behind the counter with my Exuberant screech. When she finally cam down off the ceiling I took a half dozen to accompany dinner that night. They did not disappoint. These were very authentic tasting so good they can be eaten without salt (as my doctor reccomends). In truth I had two with salt and one without, but let's not split hairs. So you barflies and pub crwlers can have all the pretzels you want. But when you are ready for some true German tastse, swing by Benkert's and grab a Brezel or two. read more

Walking into a bakery can always make me happy, especially at Benkert's. Boy does it smell good in here! The presentation of the desserts and baked goods is on par here, and makes you want to buy everythingggg! I was looking for a cake today to celebrate a birthday. I decided to go with the Layered Blackout cake- what a great choice. The thing that made this cake stand out was that it wasn't super sweet like I expected. Instead of icing on the outer layer it almost tasted like a pudding. I thought that made the cake taste so delicious, instead of just a sugar overload. The girl behind the counter who helped me was super friendly and was really helpful as well. I definitely will be back to try the cookies and the cupcakes and all the other goodies! read more

See all

Cake was great, but I had a special order for My Daughters communion and They asked me To write out the ticket so I could get her name spelled correctly its an unusual spelling Amalia, when I picked up the cake her named was spelled Amelia and they said well "Amalia is wrong" I said that's her name after her great grandmother form Austria. No apologies give and they tried to make the E an A and it was horrible ruined the cake. read more

Nice bakery out by my cousin's house. I've been going there for better than 30 years, usually when visiting. Yesterday I wanted to stop off before heading back to visit other friends in Westchester, so I picked up a pie and a mocha cake. Both were great and were well-liked by the party crowd. Last June my cousin bought a huge birthday sheet cake from them for her Dad's birthday. He was in a nursing home, and the staff said it was the best cake they'd ever had. So, looks like the cakes are a hit. All in all a pretty good, comprehensive bakery. read more

Benkert's Bakery - Lindy Swirl - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

Best delicious bakery as went to guest house they raved about it.Service fantastic fast Helpful But I had one set back and it was ME cause I am 60 y , brought a fruit covered cheese cake . server suggested want me to write on it is it a special occasions How asked how ? She said we put chocolate bar on top fruit and write on that I said WOW Let's do it " Girls Day'" . Now comes check out Yes 4% added cause had no cash . handed the box No string No she said haven't done that on over 6 years Felt stupid everyone looked at me Guess been a while but I will return w cash next visit read more

I've been a long time customer because the bakery was close in proximity to my house. The cakes were always just ok, a little pricey, but ok. I went in today to order a small 7" birthday cake, a small 1 lb pkg of rainbow cookies and one loaf of Italian bread. The counter girl was very pleasant. But when she wrung me up, asked if I was paying cash or card, I was confused. They charge an additional 4% if using credit card or debit! The bill came to $55 if you were wondering. I was appalled that during these times they charge NOT to handle cash! I will never go again! BUYER BEWARE! read more

Are you kidding the had no jelly donuts so the put jelly in a cruella for me $8.10 for 2 FORGETABOUTIT NEVER WILL I GO BACK THERE after 30vyears Never Keep your freaking donuts and my family's business read more

Wow! My mom used to drive from Bellport to get their rolls for years. I had family coming over and made the trek to get rolls,since I hadn't been there in a while. This place has gone really downhill. The rolls were stale and didn't tast the same AT ALL! There wasn't even a traditional bakery smell. The rolls used to have a slightly sweet taste and were always dusted in flour. read more

Wanted a heart shaped engagement cake. The baker and staff all were so accommodating. Cake was just what we ordered and delicious too. Everyone was raving over it. Will definitely we going back. read more