I wish Yelp would allow half stars, as 3.5 fits this place for me. Staff was very friendly, from a greeting as you walk in all the way to a "thanks for coming" as you leave. I would give them a 4.5. Food was fresh tasting and quality ingredients. We had a pizza, chicken parm, and garlic knots. Chicken parm was good although the sauce was quite thin. The garlic knots really didn't have flavor. They were just bread knots that were very bland and relied totally on the marinara. The marinara was good though. Overall the pizza was good but same complaint as the knots with the pizza crust. I always eat the crust on pizza, but didn't hear, as it was just like eating plain bread. I will definitely give them another try when in the area cause I want to give them the 4 stars. read more

Found this little gem while traveling through Florida. Very polite staff. I had the haddock Francese. It was absolutely delicious. She had the ravioli carbonara with chicken which she thoroughly enjoyed. This is a really great little find that has very good food and really nice staff. read more

Party of four ordered different items. Salmon on my salad was reminiscent of cafeteria food, fishy and in desperate need of seasoning. Chicken parm sub according to dad was bland and chewy. Eggplant rigatoni with meatballs according that diner was described as a heated frozen meal. Mom ordered a burger with ketchup, mayo and onion she got a cheeseburger with tomato ketchup and mayo. Waitress apologized and only offered to bring her some onions and then had to be reminded. read more

Great food great service Pizza and salad are fantastic Never a bad meal all the staff very helpful read more

We ate the ranchero pizza Wednesday night after the movie. We love it! Always delish. Friendly helpful staff too! Always! read more

Tony & Al's Deli - Ranchero - Pizza Near Me - Starke, Florida

If you're ever in Starke, FL and you have a hankering for pizza, Tony & Al's on Call St is a solid place to fill that need. We got the Mozzarella stuffed garlic knots. These were tasty. Overstuffed with cheese for an impressive cheese pull. Could've used a bit more garlic butter, but overall, a good start. For the pizza we got the "Grandma" pizza. A 16" square thicker crust pizza topped with mozzarella, basil, oregano, and a deliciously sweet marinara. The crust was perfect. Not as thick as a Sicilian, but every bit as crispy and tasty. read more

Tony & Al's Deli - Pizza Near Me - Starke, Florida

See all

Myself and the young lady, went to this restaurant on Saturday the service was outstanding we got a greeting coming to the door we sat down had mozzarella sticks salad she had the chicken Parmesan and I had the calzone we were stuffed I would recommend restaurant to anybody in the Stark area were looking forward to going there again we want to make this our place read more

Wow what a great little restaurant. Cheese garlic knots to start were wonderful. Eggplant rollatini was the best my husband has ever had. Chicken parm was yummy. Not close to where we live but we will drive to come eat here!! read more

Service was amazing, ambiance isn't the greatest but for the quality of good and the price it's a great stop in for lunch or a quick dinner. Was also Surprised to hear when I called that even though they do not serve beer/wine you can bring your own! Overall we would definitely return on future trips to the area. read more

Tony & Al's Deli is a nice place for lunch if tou by chance find yourself in Starke, Florida and looking for a place to grab lunch. The staff was friendly and the place, while nothing fancy or high end, had a pleasant enough and comfortable enough ambiance. The food was good. We went with pizza. Overall, a good place to grab a meal in Starke, Florida read more

Amazing food and service. The restaurant is beautiful inside and very clean as are the restrooms. Our go to for anything pasta!!!

I just love the pizza here. The cheese they use is amazing! Crust is lightly browned and the marinara sauce has me coming back for more. This visit our dough knots were burnt but otherwise a great gem . Located downtown, parking on the street is convenient. Cute inside. Friendly staff. Too bad they don't deliver. Highly recommend read more

Food was delicious! Read some old reviews and decided to give it a try. Never knew it was there until I looked at the restaurants on the map and glad I did. We always stop at Sonnys and I will say I'll be returning here more now. Loved the pizza and the soup! read more

See all

Best pizza in Starke! They have gluten free too! We get their pizza almost every Friday night.

Great little Italian joint. Garlic knots and lasagna were delicious. The staff were very friendly and constantly checked in. Not much seating inside so get here early to get your spot. The to go orders were constantly coming in. read more

See all

Got take out here. Love the Cajun pasta here, nice size portion!! Take out lady was super friendly.

We met up with family that lives in Starke for lunch on a Saturday. We got right in with all 9 of us! The pizza was delicious and our server was very friendly. Definitely a place we'll go again. read more

Went to this place on Friday, June 21, 2024. Apparently the name has changed to Tony's Restaurant or something like that. Also in a different location across the street and down the block a little bit. Parking lot in the back but also street parking around the corner. Pizza was delicious but could have had a little more sauce. Stuffed garlic knots were 50/50, some had lots of cheese but some had almost none. Service wasn't bad but we had to ask for knives. Why are the utensils plastic? You're already washing dishes why not have real utensils and not add more trash to the landfills? Restrooms were very clean. Overall very good experience but not quite great. read more

I'm not sure about their Italian food, as the 4 of us had subs and a burger to takeout. All 4 came with fries - about 12-13 with less than an ounce of ketchup. when ordering the burger, they said they didn't have any mustard??? I asked for Italian dressing on the side for one sub but didn't receive. Ordered on phone with 25 minute pickup time. Had to wait on the burger when we arrived and it ended up being half-cooked, pink inside. All in all, a horrible experience. read more

Everything about this place is perfect. A friend and I got hungry driving through starke and we decided to stop at this place for lunch and I'm so happy that we did. We started with the stuffed garlic knots and they were heaven! They definitely didn't hold back on the cheese in them. For my meal I got the spaghetti with meat sauce and and it came in a huuuge portion loaded with sauce on top. Just like the garlic knots, it was simply perfect and I couldn't stop eating. Honestly for the quantity and quality of the meal I'd have paid $20 but it was only around $10! For dessert my friend and I split a cannoli and I swear I had never had better, he said the same. The filling was just so creamy and delicious we were literally scraping the plate just to finish it all. This place truly deserves 5 stars!! If I'm ever in starke again I'm absolutely dining here. read more

See all

I came back to this place again after 3yrs, and they still have amazing food with an amazing atmosphere. I got the Stuffed Garlic knots this time and a Ravioli Carbonara with chicken. The stuffed garlic knots came with 5 knots and were quite large and of a good shareable size. The marinara dipping sauce it came with was excellent and not too sweet. The Ravioli Carbonara with chicken may be the best carbonara sauce I've had in a while. It's rich without being too heavy, and I could fully taste the bacon and peas flavor. The chicken was well grilled/seared brown. Definitely recommended! read more

Tony & Al's Deli - Stuffed (with cheese) Garlic Knots with included marinara dipping sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Starke, Florida

See all

Best Pizza in town hands down! You definitely owe yourself a visit to this great little Italian restaurant. Tony, Jimmy, Sara and the rest of the Tony's staff will definitely take care of you. Their new location (across the street from their former) has been newly renovated and offers a wonderful family atmosphere for dining. I highly encourage everyone to give them a try. I'm confident you won't be disappointed! read more

Went on a Friday evening, they had the tables set up for larger parties, so that our party of 2 had to sit at a long table with another couple at the other end, so not the most private or cozy for a dinner out. We ordered a supreme Stromboli, which was pretty good, fresh baked bread stuffed with lots of tasty filling, could have used a little more marinara on the side, but overall a good dish. And then we also had an eggplant rollatini, which was supposed to be over angel hair but was served over spaghetti. The dish was sadly flavorless & mushy, and not even very hot. And one would think you would get at least a small piece of garlic bread or a knot to go with your entree, but there wasn't any. So not a great choice overall for that dish. I have been to this restaurant when they were at their older location, which was much smaller but truly the food was all around better quality. Not sure why the change of food quality in the new location. Not super excited about coming back for a dinner out, but maybe will give them another try for lunch sometime. read more

Fast, friendly and the food is always good! Hot fresh and on time. The service sizes are really big!

Great food & good atmosphere we would recommend it to everyone we are planning to go back again.

Great Place to pick up or dine in if Downtown. Always a great pie or other menu items. Friendly Staff and Area.

Excellent place to dine for pizza, salad or pasta. Today, I had the grill chicken salad the portion size is enough for 2-3 people. I also had a small (10') pepperoni pizza with Italian sausages. So delicious, fresh and hot. I arrived before 6pm, it's a small sitting area so go before the dinner evening crowd. The customer service is excellent and friendly, very attentive. Thank you guys for an excellent dinning experience read more

The pasta was like mashed potatoes. Though mashed potatoes are better. The food was unsatisfactory and I'll never go there again. It's was pointed out to the owner and he offered no resolution. Very disappointed. read more

I loved this little hole in the wall pizza spot. The pizza was delicious, I had a meat lovers and the meat was perfectly falling everywhere and sooo cheesy!! There were 7 of us and we will all definitely come back! Oh yeah and the whole staff were very friendly and accommodating. read more

Tony & Al's Deli - Meatlovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Starke, Florida

The pizza from Tony and Al's was the best we have enjoyed from the Keystone and Starke area. We will definitely be revisiting them again.

Had a yummy lunch here in early June. We were the only ones for most of our lunch but it was mid afternoon. Service was good. Tea was great. I really liked the carbonara dish. I don't live here; but if I'm in the area again, I'd choose here for a good lunch. I do wish they had lunch specials. That might help me to convince others to give it a try with me. . The garlic bread did leave a little to be desired; but overall, I liked this place. read more

Family owned and operated Tony and his wife and crew have taken this new location to a higher level of service, they are the true definition of ownership working every day to make sure customers are satisfied. The pizzas are better than anywhere else in the area, the calzones rock as well as his specials, they are just checking off all the boxes on all the food I have tried there, so go over and give them a visit. You won't leave hungry read more

Everything here was great! Very large portions. We had enough to take home for a couple of more meals. Waitress was friendly and even took pictures of us outdoors. Definitely will be back soon. read more

Went to the Grand Opening at the new location. Food, service and atmosphere was great. We are fortunate to have a quality Italian place here. read more

Great food and quick service, loved how great the area felt, it has a very cozy feel to it while also servicing great food to go along with that ambience. read more

Great Italian flavors - especially pizza and calzone- lots of cheese. Be sure to try the Roma!

I love eating here. The food is great. Their garlic knots are to die for. I like the cool little atmosphere and the downtown location. Service has always been good everything I've tried from pizzas to pasta have been cooked well and tasted great. We always have leftovers to bring home. read more

Amazing Italian restaurant and friendly service the pizzas are to die for. Sooo good worth every penny because everything is homemade..

The BEST Italian restaurant in the area! Al's cooking is as good as my Nana's. The service is excellent and the wait staff remembers us and our likes when we walk in. The ambiance is comfortable and inviting. read more

LOVE this place !!! Food is awesome, and so is the service !!! Haven't had good Italian food like this in years !! Everything is awesome!!