Horrible attitude from new owner (Luigi) - this place is just not the same without Andy running it day to day. I will have to support Luigi's pizza in Hockessin now, better pizza and food, and that owner actually cares about this customers. food quality has gone downhill quickly also. read more

Ordered the cheesesteak there was so little meat I ended up taking half of the sandwich and putting the meat on the other half just to make it a sandwich wouldn't order cheesesteak again read more

I gave Tony's a bad review the last time and it has not changed. I stopped in tonight to place an order and I was ignore. I went to the counter to place my order and the man behind the counter was on a personal phone call. Really?? Is that how you do business? Well I will not be back. read more

By far my favorite place to get a pizza! I've been coming here since I worked at MBNA (long time ago lol) cuz it's the best! I've never ordered something that I didn't like, the prices are great, and customer service is always on point. read more

Tony's was recommended to us by family who live in the area so we stopped in for a quick lunch. The place was hopping the whole time we were there. It is situated on the inside of a 3-4 store front. Parking was available in front of the store but I believe there is also parking behind and over to the side in front of some other stores. When you walk in, you'll probably run right into the line of customers either waiting for an order or about to give an order because the cash register is right up front. Standing room is tight there. Off to the right are a line of tables that go to the back of the store. In any event, the line moves quickly and the orders are worked on immediately. The time from ordering to getting our food was about 10 minutes. We shared a italian sausage sub, fries and cokes. The coke machine is right up front to the left. The sub was very good, hot and crispy, with just enough sauce to make it a finger licking event. The fries were great. The owner has a crew of workers behind the counter and lets them know in italian if they're missing something. read more

So happy to get to eat homemade gluten free Ravioli !! Thank you Tonys! Delicious marinara sauce.

I work across the street, and many times on lunch, I just don't want what I've brought with me that day, and I know I will always be happy with what I've ordered from Tony's. I love the atmosphere, and the owners and employees are always very nice and quick. I have tried everything from their plain cheese and specialty pizzas, to their penne pasta a la vodka or garlic oil spaghetti (which is AMAZING, btw), to my "I'm pregnant, and need low-carb stuff!" Flacco wrap. I have never had a bad item there, and I doubt I ever will. read more

Best tomato pie ever!! Warm or cold it is delicious. Whenever I want Pizza, Tony's is my go to on my way home from work. Margherita, cheese, white or loaded with toppings, you will not be disappointed. You will be in heaven! read more

This is my favorite kind of eating experience. I had about 20 minutes to grab a quick bite and I was in the right place at the right time. The staff here is super friendly. You get the full sit down treatment even if you are getting a quick reheated slice. By the way you won't need more than one. These slices are big and heavy on the toppings. You also get free garlic bread and tomato pie while you wait. The dining area is not very big, not a lot of seating (think NYC) but I could tell it had happy regulars. This place bustled at dinner time. There are a ton of slices ready to go in a lot of different varieties and you can tell it's fresh. Very reasonable pricing too, two of us ate for $10.00 and we took food home. I am looking forward to going back and trying the rest of the menu. A definite recommend. read more

Pretty good pizza joint that falls short of the standards of its competitor five minutes down the road- Cacciatori's. Still, the restaurant provides enough good food to stand on its own merits. The regular pizza is pretty good (not as good as Cacciatori's- just saying) and they have a ton of speciality pizzas- the only one I've ever tried is the white pizza which isn't very good. But if you want a pizzeria that has more than your standard cheese/pepperoni/olive pizza, this is definitely your place to go. The strombolis are great, and they also have one of the better dessert offerings of all Delaware restaurants. The "zippoli's" as they call them- which are basically sugary dough, are great, and the cannoli's are out of this world. The facility is a little dirty, but not too bad, and all the staff are very friendly. I would definitely recommend Tony's to you. read more

As a New Yorker transplanted to Delaware, Tony's is a taste of home!!

Love Tony's! Catered for my grad party this past weekend and everyone could not stop raving about the food. 6 trays including, chicken parm, sausage and peppers, meatballs, baked ziti, penne alla vodka, antipasto salad, and a lasagna. They even included a box of bread! Pricing was very reasonable for the amount we got. We have a ton of leftovers which is great honestly. We will be calling again if we need anything else! read more

Best pizza and service! The bruschetta is awesome too! Andy & Kim are super!

Really good Pizza, as close to NY style as you can get around here......I've only done take out, so cant speak for the table service.............. read more

Hands down the best pizza in Newark. The only pizza place that rivals it is its sister restaurant, Amalfi's. The cannoli are delicious, too. read more

Live nearby and have ordered pizza, which we think is good but not the best dish on the menu. (The tomato pie is great) . However, antipasto salad - incredible! Lobster ravioli - unbelievable. My sister-in-law and I split a dinner (6 HUGE raviolis) and I still had enough sauce left over to warm up and put it over angel hair the next night. People have remarked the service is bad, well, it takes some getting used to. The folks who run the place are usually right out straight and kind of abrupt, but we usually get take out so who cares. Oh, the bruschetta is also crazy good. read more

I'm disabled and unable to stand and cook, so I order here three times a week. I've never eaten such delicious food outside of a private Italian kitchen. And everyone is so kind not only to me, but as soon as the door opens a greeting is forthcoming. The pizza is outstanding, the dinner portions can last two meals, and I love the variety. Try a crab slice...no fake crab here! Delicious! My favorite dinner is eggplant parmesan. Affordable too. read more

It is in the suburbs but it has the feel of a city neighborhood. After buying a few dinners Tony recognized me and would know what my family liked. The place always smells so good it makes my head spin and is busy with patrons who give respect to everyone in the place. They have deserts that are superb! It is an experience of joy. read more

Food is always amazing. I stopped this past Tuesday after a funeral on the way to the family's house for dinner. Ordered 4 large pizzas and they went above and beyond to have gracious, fast service. They knew I had my hands full and even helped me carry everything to my car and secured it in the back seat. Food never disappoints, but the service is above and beyond. Looking forward to my next visit. read more

Horrible experience. I have loved the crab pizza for months. They sold me a runny disaster today. Not worth the bread it was baked on. This pizza disaster should never been sold. There is no pride in what they sell. If they had any, such a pizza would never have been sold. Got my money back. Go to another place that values your experience and takes pride in what they serve. Tony's Cafe is not that place. read more

I have been a customer here since it first opened, and it is just as great today as it was then. Tony's provides amazing Italian food for a great price. Large portions of excellent food. They are almost always busy and crowded due to their relatively small size, but they never fail to provide excellent customer service that makes you feel like part of the family. Tony's is a great member of the Newark community. Fast, friendly service, amazing food! read more

Absolutely delicious! Every single thing that I have ever gotten here is incredible. I highly recommend the eggplant parm and the lobster ravioli... YUM! read more

When saw the reviews for this place I had to try it out. Every time I ordered take out. The pizza is delicious the food is always good. The only reason I gave it three stars is because I got sick after eating here once and never returned. I had a salad and pizza not sure which gave me food poisoning. The people there are nice and we made sure to let them know. I do recommend it because it might have been a one time thing. read more

Only giving Tony's 2 stars....I've eaten here many times both dine in and take out and I find the food allright but it doesn't knock my socks off. The pizza is decent, not great. The tomato pie is disgraceful- bland- stale crust. The subs/steaks are about on par with average. The calamari is one bright spot- it was pretty good. The lobster ravioli had no lobster meat in it, just an over-abundance of the pre-packaged frozen mini shrimp.The chicken marsala was really dry and tasteless. And I noticed that the kitchen cooks and food prep people were not wearing hats or hair nets, nor were they wearing any cooks attire. They were all in street clothes. WTF? Sorry I don't want any hair in my food!! Tony's needs to get it together. They also need to expand that place, it is wayyyy too small. But with established businesses on either side of them it'll probably never happen. On a recent visit, their "special" that night was Shrimp Scampi over Penne Pasta, decided to give it a try. It was NOT Shrimp Scampi, it was not the garlicky/buttery scampi...it was a lemon and capers sauce.... so it was actually Shrimp Picatta over penne pasta. I ate it....it was edible...but not what I wanted. Sure the server was bright and cheerful but the food really was lacking. We are not going to come back to Tony's Cafe for a long time; they really need to get their act together or lose us for good. Also, they should make a decision on whether to watch the soccer game or listen to the music. Both were too noisy. read more

Some of the best pizza you'll find in Delaware. Great calzones, stromboli's, and pasta dishes. Friendly family run restaurant, but limited seating at this location. Our favorite pizza place! read more

I am giving 4 stars .I have been a customer since 2008.I love their pizza but recently they stoped making their own bread I think.Sandwich didn't taste like it used to be.White pizza is perfect.I love their menu.Friendly people.... read more

Ordered a pizza from here one evening when I hadn't eaten all day and was starving. Waited 10 mins at the shop to find out they gave my pizza to another customer. Offer me her crappy pizza which I would not take. Ended up waiting another 20 mins as I had already paid. They offered no refund or extras to make up for the mistake. Heard one of the men making pizza say he didn't care. Horrible customer service. I can also say the pizza is decent but as a nyer that move here 6 months ago it is not comparable. It's just better then the other crap around. Now going to make from home as I do a better job and it don't have to deal with incompetent employees. read more

Tonys is a great choice if your looking for a pizza place to attend. There food is quickly made and tastes great. Also there prices are reasonable. However the building is tiny and crammed and you don't have a lot of space. Overall though, good prices and great food read more

I will not go back there....I placed the order over the phone...the girl was rude...the food was awful!! The roll was so hard I could not eat my cheesesteak. There was hardly any meat on it...terrible terrible food and terrible service!!! Save your money...do m ot go there read more

The best Italian Meatballs and Penne Al Vodka anywhere!!! Tony's catered our party and everyone enjoyed the meatballs and pasta. They couldn't get enough. Service was awesome too. Will definitely be going back to Tony's!! read more

I have had many items from Tony's menu and everything that I have eaten has been delicious! We recently had Tony's cater a business party and all of my fellow employees were extremely impressed. Did I mention their customer service is excellent. My friends and I love this place! read more

This was our first time there, and we will definitely return. Four of us ate outside at the picnic tables, although there is plenty of seating inside. Finally- a restaurant with great food and generous portions!!!! I had a Dante salad with craisins, roasted sweet walnuts and mandarin oranges and cheese; it was absolutely delicious. Our party had generous bags of fries and onion rings and great subs on fresh quality rolls. What a feast! The folks behind the counter couldn't have been friendlier. The outside looks very, very plain, but the food and service are the best! read more

Went to the newest Tony's location for lunch with a coworker. This location isnt on yelp but I am pretty sure it's the same owners. We called ahead and placed our orders over the phone. They brought our entrees out right away which was great since we were on our lunch break. I really have a hard time going to Tony's and not getting Grandma pizza. But since we were sitting down I decided to try something different. I got the lasagna. Fantastic! It could use a little more sauce but other than that top notch. It was 2 huge slices with salad and bread for 12.95. I am a huge eater and still had to take half home! They brought me a soup container of sauce to go with my leftovers! My friend had the calamari with a garlic olive oil sauce. He enjoyed his as well. The sauce was so good on his we were dunking our bread it it. Tony's never disappoints and the staff is extra friendly. read more

Just moved here from NYC. My first stop? Pizza of course. Judging from all the positive reviews on yelp and them advertising as NYC style pizza, I decided to give this a try. Ordered 2 plain slices and 2 pepperoni for my brother. While we were waiting , my brother went to the bathroom. I saw him come right back out because he said it was filthy disgusting without any soap. Ok then. Waited about 5 minutes. Then 10. I see a customer walk in, order 2 slices, and walk right out. Ok then. 15 minutes later, I go up to the counter trying to figure out what is going on. The waitress apologizes. Ok, no big deal. They actually throw in an extra slice and cannolis for the trouble. Love it! We get home and dig in. This is not in any way shape or form NYC quality. Tasted like ketchup on a wet dish rag. Sauce was bland. Crust was almost inedible. Got through a slice and dumped the rest. I don't get all the quality ratings for the pizza but this is one of the worst I've ever had. 2 stars for the apology and freebies thrown in, 0 for the pizza. read more