Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Totally Baked By Tay

    4.4 (5 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Totally Baked By Tay Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Totally Baked By Tay

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 months ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Delicious ice cream! I love how creative Taylor is with her desserts. Yummy we will come back soon to try more new stuff! 5/5

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Totally Baked By Tay

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 415 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Newberry Cafe & Bakery - To go!

    Newberry Cafe & Bakery

    4.4(124 reviews)
    10.2 mi
    $

    The strawberry donut is so good, the espresso donut is perfect if you love coffee flavors, but the…read moremaple donut deserves a standing ovation.Mini versions of all your best flavors in one box would be dangerous in the best way possible. I genuinely count down to Thursdays because that maple donut is THAT good. Newberry, please consider making it a permanent menu item because waiting all week is painful Fresh donuts, amazing flavors, and now I'm constantly craving Thursdays. Keep the creativity coming because you all don't miss

    Tik Tok made me do it and I'm glad I did it!…read more My co-worker recently had been seeing some videos about the food at Newberry Cafe so of course we had to make a lunch time stop to see what everyone was talking about. Newberry reminds me of your hometown bakery where everyone gathers in the morning for their donuts and coffee before heading off to work. Very much like many of the shops in the Bel Air area. The employees are super nice at Newberry. Really taking their time to provide great customer service to each patron that strolls through the doors. Although it was lunch time we settled on breakfast sandwiches with homefries. And I of course had to grab a donut because it's a must, and a latte. The breakfast sandwich was just what you would want to start your day, a savory piece of meat and cheese on a soft bagel. But the star of the show was the homefries. Cooked and seasoned perfectly, crispy on the outside and a soft texture on the inside. We both loved the potatoes. My glazed donut was divine, pillowy with just the right amount of glaze to not make the donut too sweet. The latte was a little to sweet for me, but I'm a little finicky with the sugar level in many caffeinated drinks. All the times I've ventured into Bel Air I never thought to stop at Newberry and I'm glad I finally did. I'll definitely be back to try more of their yummy donuts and breakfast sandwiches in the future.

    Photos
    Newberry Cafe & Bakery - Fruity Pebble Donut

    Fruity Pebble Donut

    Newberry Cafe & Bakery - Sprinkled Donut

    Sprinkled Donut

    Newberry Cafe & Bakery - To go!

    See all

    To go!

    Sweet Eats Cakes - Exterior

    Sweet Eats Cakes

    3.0(9 reviews)
    4.9 mi

    I really hate leaving negative reviews and feeling like a the negative Nellie. Just for what this…read morecake cost, I expected way more. I sent a picture as an idea of what I wanted. I assumed there would be a follow up email or phone call asking more detail what exactly I wanted. I never got a picture of the finished cake before it was delivered. There were mistakes on it and basically was told they went off the picture I sent. Shouldn't they have confirmed before making cake or AT LEAST sent me a picture confirming I liked it before delivering the expensive cake? I hope to at least be offered a partial refund. Nope. Not even an apology. The cake itself was ok. Nothing spectacular. Melted quickly in the hot sun (but that's not their fault). The cake was a little dry honestly too. Again, I hate leaving negative reviews and being THAT person. I'm sure their are better options for your cake needs in the area.

    We ordered our wedding cake and it was beautiful. However it was dry, the wrong flavor and…read moreunderwhelming. We did a tasting and the cake and flavors were delicious, so we had high expectations for the day of wedding cake. My husband was an executive chef for 25 years so he is hard to impress and when he lived this cake, as did I we were extremely happy with what we ordered. We ordered 2 tier 6" vanilla cake with blackberry between the layers and vanilla buttercream and the 10" layer was vanilla cake with strawberry layer and cheesecake buttercream. We did change the top layer to chocolate cake with hazelnut layer. It wasn't a problem and we were so excited. Day of...cake was dry, like it had sat out or was made way too early. The bottom 10" cake was some sort of citrusy lemon (?) cake. As far as the filling, it was so thin you could barely taste what it was. Even though it looked nice it was such a waste, dry, no flavor... it tasted horrible. Very disappointing and $250 basically in the garbage.

    Photos
    Sweet Eats Cakes - Sweet Eats Cakes Dessert Bar!

    Sweet Eats Cakes Dessert Bar!

    Sweet Eats Cakes - Melting cake

    See all

    Melting cake

    The Screaming Bean - Freshly-baked pastries available every day at The Screaming Bean, located just a few minutes from Havre de Grace.

    The Screaming Bean

    4.2(51 reviews)
    2.1 mi
    $

    I wish I lived closer to this coffee shop! They give out free stickers with their logo which I…read morethink is a great marketing tactic. Who doesn't love a sticker? Cashier was quick. I think we arrived before the line started up. There is a good amount of seating. Also a cute little library. Their coffee was great BUT, I think the real star is their breakfast! The Jam Slam 11/10: I would recommend this to ANYONE. Please try it. It is sweet but savory. I could eat this everyday. The Hash N Rise 8/10: More basic but still YUMMY. You can't go wrong with these breakfast options.

    We happened to stumble upon this spot while driving by and decided to stop in for breakfast with…read morethe family. I'm so glad we did. I ordered the Jam Slam breakfast sandwich, and it was amazing. It had the perfect balance of sweet and savory, my favorite kind of breakfast sandwich. I also paired it with a mango smoothie and a cold brew, which were both great additions to the meal. Another bonus: they have a drive-thru, which is perfect for those mornings when you're short on time and don't want to go inside. One of the staff informed they also have mobile ordering as an option. Overall, a great breakfast spot, and one I'll definitely be keeping in mind for future visits.

    Photos
    The Screaming Bean - Busy weekday morning at The Screaming Bean, where friends gather to catch up and business deals are made. Aberdeen, Maryland 21001

    Busy weekday morning at The Screaming Bean, where friends gather to catch up and business deals are made. Aberdeen, Maryland 21001

    The Screaming Bean - Freshly-baked pastries available every day at The Screaming Bean, located just a few minutes from Havre de Grace.

    Freshly-baked pastries available every day at The Screaming Bean, located just a few minutes from Havre de Grace.

    The Screaming Bean - Turkey cranberry sandwich available at The Screaming Bean bakery and cafe in Aberdeen, Harford County, Maryland.

    See all

    Turkey cranberry sandwich available at The Screaming Bean bakery and cafe in Aberdeen, Harford County, Maryland.

    Sweet Hearts Patisserie - Cupcakes

    Sweet Hearts Patisserie

    4.4(177 reviews)
    42.2 mi
    $$

    Sweet Hearts Patisserie is a French style pastry shop on Annapolis. They are located in a shopping…read morecenter so there is lots of parking. They offer both indoor and outdoor seating. Staff were very friendly. Inside they played French instrumental music. Store is super clean and cute on the inside. They offer an extensive selection of flavors of their pasties which includes various macaron flavors, cupcakes, and cakes. I got a cannele, hazelnut financier and a mango iced matcha. The pastries were fresh, soft and mouth watering. The mango iced matcha was a little disappointing due to the bitter after taste of the drink. Looking forward to trying other pastries and other drinks at the patisserie.

    I popped in here for an after lunch sweet treat, and this place did not disappoint. It has all of…read morethe ambience of a place I would go to for high tea with beautiful treats. There is seating available if you would like to enjoy a coffee or other heated beverage with your sweet treat. There is also the option to place orders for larger pastries, platters, cupcakes, and cakes. The staff working here was very kind and attentive. I opted for a small box that comes with two petite fours and three macarons. The macaron flavors that I tried were the salted caramel, milk chocolate amaretto, and dark chocolate. The petit four flavors that I tried were the red velvet and the triple chocolate. Everything I had here was so beautifully made and tasted fresh. I will definitely be back here again.

    Photos
    Sweet Hearts Patisserie - Seating

    Seating

    Sweet Hearts Patisserie
    Sweet Hearts Patisserie - Flavors of the month: Caramel Praline Crunch, German Chocolate, French Vanilla, Chocolate Silk. JAN2025.

    See all

    Flavors of the month: Caramel Praline Crunch, German Chocolate, French Vanilla, Chocolate Silk. JAN2025.

    Flavor Cupcakery

    Flavor Cupcakery

    3.9(184 reviews)
    10.4 mi
    $$

    Last year, I received a birthday delivery from Flavor, but the delivery arrived looking like it had…read morebeen dropped and the cupcakes were a bit of a mess. (Not sure who the delivery service was. Flavor replaced the order without *too much* of an issue.) In November, I stopped in to get something for a friend's birthday, and bought a 4-pack for them. Staff were super friendly & answered my questions easily. Feed back on the cupcakes was thumbs up all around. There were about a dozen flavor options (I think), & they all sounded good. Ended up selecting the Snickerdoodle, Cookies n Cream, & 2 of the chocolate-peanut butter because the recipient is a big fan of pb cups. I no longer work in that area but I will likely be back soon for another special occasion. I get noticed for their specials and they're so tempting. Yummmm!

    I highly do not recommend them. I ordered a cheesecake and called every single day to get some kind…read moreof status update on it and they do not answer their phones. When I went in frustrated to talk about this, an employee named Brooke smugly looked at me and rolled her eyes while I expressed frustration at not being able to get a hold of them. She shook her head and had a huge attitude with me as I explained that I just wanted an update on my cheesecake. The customer service was horrible if they can't even update regular customers on a simple cheesecake I can't imagine how nerve-racking it would be to hire these people to do a catered event like a wedding or a birthday. The front employee Brooke was smug, snide, and extremely disrespectful enough that I will never go back again after that being my very first experience there.

    Photos
    Flavor Cupcakery
    Flavor Cupcakery
    Flavor Cupcakery

    See all

    Totally Baked By Tay - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...