Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Treasure Bay Restaurant

    4.3 (10 reviews)
    Closed 3:30 pm - 8:30 PM

    Treasure Bay Restaurant Photos

    Treasure Bay Restaurant - Puerto Rican Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico
    Treasure Bay Restaurant - Garlic mojo fish - Puerto Rican Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico
    Treasure Bay Restaurant - Puerto Rican Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico
    Treasure Bay Restaurant - Puerto Rican Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico
    Treasure Bay Restaurant - The counter - Puerto Rican Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico
    Treasure Bay Restaurant - Menu Item: Filet de Mero Ajillo con Arepa y Amarillos (filet of grouper in garlic sauce with arepa and fried plantain) - Puerto Rican Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico
    Treasure Bay Restaurant - Menu - Puerto Rican Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico
    Treasure Bay Restaurant - Red snapper with sweet plantains and salad. - Puerto Rican Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico
    Treasure Bay Restaurant - Pechuga a la plancha y pescado blanco frito - Puerto Rican Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico
    Treasure Bay Restaurant - Alcapurrias - Puerto Rican Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico
    Treasure Bay Restaurant - Menu Item: Filet de Mero Ajillo con Ensalada Verde y Amarillos (filet of grouper in garlic sauce with green salad and fried plantain) - Puerto Rican Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico

    +12

    Treasure Bay Restaurant - Menu Item: Costilla en Salsa de Guayaba con Papas Fritas y Amarillos (ribs in guayaba BBQ sauce with fries and fried plantain) - Puerto Rican Near Me - Culebra, Puerto Rico

    TREASURE BAY RESTAURANT ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Treasure Bay Restaurant

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Garlic mojo fish

    Food here was fireeeee! Would highly recommend! Also the service was so friendly which I found kind of a rarity on Culebra/ PR in general. Seriously worth the stop, super authentic and very affordable. Can't wait to go back.

    Menu
    Eukaryote J.

    Bbq place for night owls/snowbirds. We ordered two dinners consecutively and it was the best available option when we were there. - chick salad: good size with tender meat - chicken wing (Alitas frita): tender chicken wings - cordon blue and sorullitos de maiz are great local appetizers. they are fried ham cheese ball wrapped with chicken meat, and fried corn dough. - grill ribs with guava sauce: guava sauce is on the sweet side. I would prefer their regular bbq sauce.

    Menu Item: Costilla en Salsa de Guayaba con Papas Fritas y Amarillos (ribs in guayaba BBQ sauce with fries and fried plantain)
    Paul F.

    Couldn't find this place on Yelp so I added it. We tried out the restaurant but they also have a bar, which can be seen in pictures on their Facebook page. Our waiter was a little impatient but was friendly and attentive. The staff and everyone behind the counter was welcoming and cheerful. Seating for the restaurant may be small for large groups but capacity is around twenty. The atmosphere is café-style with some seaside decor. They also have an ice cream selection available in the restaurant. We ordered the ribs in guayaba BBQ sauce and the grouper filet in a garlic sauce. The grouper was flakey and moist and was garnished with sautéed peppers and onions. The garlic sauce over the filet was a bit salty for one of us but not bad. The ribs were pork spare ribs, cooked perfectly, and were outstanding. The meat fell off the bone and was tender and juicy. The guayaba BBQ sauce was fantastic. It had a traditional BBQ flavor with a Caribbean twist. Also worth noting, the fries, fried plantain, and arepa were also really good. The arepa reminded us of Native American frybread. This place may not look like much on the outside but the food was definitely worth the stop. The staff was nice, the food was plentiful and delicious, and the price was right. I definitely recommend checking this place out for a hearty, flavorful meal.

    ribs with guava sauce
    Noel C.

    We came after COVID restrictions had been lifted but the island is still feeling the effects of the hurricane and covid. Most restaurants aren't open and the ones that are close early. Luckily this place was open past 6 pm. We waited in line to place our order and they got our number so they could call us once it was ready. We had the ribs with guava sauce which was really good. The ribs were really tender. The arepas were also good. I also enjoyed the fried sweet plantains. My friend enjoyed his grouper filet. He also got fried pork (carne frita?) and it was soooo dry and had no flavor. It came on top of plain white rice which didn't help. The chicken wings were basically chicken nuggets and I don't think we would order those again. Overall we enjoyed it.

    Grouper fillet
    Jean Luis C.

    We were driving into town looking for a place to eat and this jumped out at us with its homey front patio. Even though it didn't have many Yelp reviews, we decided to give it a try and were happy we did. The owner Victor was super friendly and attentive, and the food was really good at reasonable prices. Victor spent some time telling us about Culebra including off the beaten path beach recommendations. Would highly recommend this restaurant if you want to go to a less touristy place where locals eat.

    Pechuga a la plancha y pescado blanco frito

    See all

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Noel C.
    3
    36
    10

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Review Highlights - Treasure Bay Restaurant

    We ordered the ribs in guayaba BBQ sauce and the grouper filet in a garlic sauce.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Susie's Restaurant - Escargot

    Susie's Restaurant

    4.2(79 reviews)
    1.4 km
    $$$

    Susie's was a lovely dinner with a casual but beautiful open air garden/patio setting. We loved the…read moreambiance; especially the sweet cats that would wander around very politely asking for pets! The owner apparently feeds a good number of street cats and we loved the additional company. Our waitress (Heather maybe?) was incredible, giving us menu suggestions as well as tips for our visit to Culebritas we had planned for the next day. She was super friendly and we enjoyed chatting with her and learning a little of the history of the restaurant. The food was mostly amazing- we loved the escargot, it was a different preparation than I've had before with a sort of buttery herby sauce. Also loved the sides, the beans and rice were top notch and the mixed mash was very fun and interesting though a little dry without sauce- delicious with some sauce from other dishes. I heard very good things about the chicken and shrimp; unfortunately one star off as my husband and I bought got the Mahi-mahi and it was rather chewy and tough. The flavor was there but didn't really enjoy the texture. I would 100% go back and get the shrimp though!

    Susies is the best known restaurant on Culebra Island. They…read moreusually open on Thanksgiving but this year decided to open in October. Great idea? Wait to find out... We started with a bottle of wine similar to a Chardonnay. But let's talk food. I ordered the escargot. If you know anything about me it's that I absolutely love escargot. I will order them any where I can. I have tried them everywhere from NY to Ca and even Spain and Italy. Susies hands down wins in this category. The butter garlic combination is amazingly delicious. And they don't skimp on the escargot. There's plenty of them unlike other places that count them. The service at Susie's? As friendly and as personable as you want. Every one is happy and pleasant but then again you live on the best island that has the #3 best beach (Flamenco). I had the machi machi. Excellent choice! Plus the rice and beans which I grew up on, however they did not make them with sofrito which is really the secret ingredient to making them. But still delicious nonetheless. Over all, I'll continue to visit Susies each day every time I'm here. Since it was my birthday we ordered the Carmel cheese cake to go. Because some things need to be eaten in private. Shhh....

    Photos
    Susie's Restaurant - Your choice on the menu.

    Your choice on the menu.

    Susie's Restaurant - Escargot to die for. Award winning!

    Escargot to die for. Award winning!

    Susie's Restaurant - The beautiful open air interior of the dining area.

    See all

    The beautiful open air interior of the dining area.

    Azul

    Azul

    3.7(7 reviews)
    1.9 km
    $$

    Very nice quiet venue. Lovely service and tasty food with comparable prices. A must go if you are…read morestaying at Club Seaborne and even if you're not. We shared the cod fritters to start.5 thin & crispy fried flat fritters in an order came with a side of shredded crab mixed with olives and red peppers (that would have been a great dip on its own). Ask for extra lime on the side. For dinner we had the churasco -- perfectly cooked to order skirt steak with rice (comes mixed with habichuelas/red beans and bits of ham) and a whole fried snapper which was huge and delicious. For dessert we shared the individual ramekin of key lime "pie" which was a layer of graham crust top with key lime pudding. Slightly tart filling and a sweet topping. Overall a very good experience and would highly recommend.

    Wow! I have been coming to Culebra for 17 years and now own a house here. We eat mostly at home…read moreand when we do go into town for dinner, we don't make it much farther than the city center. This time, we branched out and drove a little further to get to Azul. I swear the last time we ate at Seabourne must have been 10-12 years ago. Waiting for so long to return was well worth it. What a fabulous meal! We are mostly vegetarian/pescatarian so we ordered the tuna and shrimp dishes. We also had the Jibaro nachos. All three dishes were beyond our expectations. How you get that much flavor in nachos is impressive. For the shrimp, we were expecting, in usual Puertorican style, a couple of lettuce leaves as a side. It was a heaping arugula salad with six spicy shrimp on top! Such a nice treat on this island where true greens are hard to come by. The tuna was served with a mango salsa and was also excellent. Now let's turn to the wine list. On this island, its Tempranillo, Malbec or Rioja (gets boring fast!) or crappy California swill. Azul has a very nice selection of wines by the bottle which include a lovely Spanish wine from Priorat. Wines from Priorat are some of my favorite - inky, dark and smoky. We enjoyed the heck out of the Gine Gine and at only $25, it was an amazing bargain. The atmosphere was tropical romantic and service was perfect.

    Photos
    Azul - Great food, clean, and friendly staff.

    Great food, clean, and friendly staff.

    Azul - Jibaro nachos. Malanga chips paired with black beans, guacamole and salsa in a dip format. ¡Muy delicioso!

    Jibaro nachos. Malanga chips paired with black beans, guacamole and salsa in a dip format. ¡Muy delicioso!

    Azul - Don't be scared off; he was tasty!

    See all

    Don't be scared off; he was tasty!

    Treasure Bay Restaurant - puertorican - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...