Disappointed after so many years of great pizza. Don't like to give bad reviews but come on. Several times I've ordered food from turonis main St or forget me not and it's always the same story the past few years - Good pizza but had to start ordering a side of pizza sauce because it's so dry. I just ordered stromboli for lunch,it was pathetic. No sauce just ground meat,a couple slices of banana peppers,and cheese. Doesn't stromboli come with sauce,onions and green peppers? Time to find another pizza shop read more

You all know that you don't HAVE to eat here just because you live in Evansville, right? Like there's good pizza elsewhere and you don't have to gaslight those of us not from here to think this is palatable. Terrible service, dirty place, and I am not sure you can legally call this food. read more

Best pizza in the Evansville Indiana area. I don't know if I like the crisp crust or the cheese and toppings the best. Amazing taste. If you're a beer drinker, they brew their own beer with a variety to choose from. The atmosphere is great. If you have a large party, they accommodate with putting tables together but the booths are big enough to seat 6. Always a friendly staff. read more

I got a half stromboli with very little meat. Usley strombolis from most places the meat is falling out. Not there it was mostly bread. Flavor was ok but it wasn't enough to make up for being so skimpy. They think just there name is enough. No I was hungry and very disappointed in what I received. read more

Probably the best pizza within 500 miles. Prices are crazy portions have shrunk but still good been a weekly regular since 1986.

Made a reservation for 10 people. 20 came and they were accommodating and nice. Been going here for a lot of birthdays. Incredible food and staff read more

I enjoy Turoni's pizza, it is my go to spot for pizza on Main St. in Evansville, IN. I go with the 'Turoni's House Special' or the 'Vincenzios Masterpiece A' Pizza...both are outstanding choices. I usually like to start with their 'Jalapeno Poppers'...let them cool before you bite into the poppers, or it will take a few days for the skin to grow back on the roof of your mouth...definitely have a cold beer standing by before you bite in. Nice older interior which is very pizza-like, if there is such a thing. I also enjoy their beers on tap, if I am eating in house. The Drive-Thru is also very convenient if you want to pick up your meal and take home or to your hotel. The staff is also very helpful. The only thing that would make it more enjoyable for me, would be if they had military veteran discounts...but they have nothing like that. read more

I really want to love this place. I love the atmosphere and the cheesy bread. That's it. I haven't tried their pizza, and it looks pretty good. But, my Stromboli I ate a few bites and brought the rest home for my daughter. read more

Turoni's Forget-Me-Not Inn - Cheese bread - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

First of all. I have been coming years since I was a child. This specific location period. What can I tell you. They change the crust. It's some sort of cheap white cracker crust that has no flavor and it's like a saltine cracker. This is not the same crust the butter crust that had a little bit of body to it from the past. This is a completely different sheen recipe and it's likely no wonder people aren't sitting around waiting to get tables to this place anymore. The pizza is three times what it used to cost and the crust is total garbage. The pizza isn't filling so they keep in the crust to try to get you to order more pizza. It doesn't make any sense to me. read more

This is our go to for pizza. Food and service are always top notch when we dine in. However, their takeout is quick and convenient too when watching a game at home. read more

The atmosphere here is very odd and has a very weird energy, the food here is very not worth the wait. Speaking of the wait we sat here for a hour and twenty minutes waiting for our food to come out, the lady serving us seemed kind at first but just kept telling us that our order would be out soon. She then told us that our food got "lost" whatever that means. Over all not a place I would eat at again. 1/10 read more

Always love coming here when we are in town. Cheesy bread and pizza, yummy! Our server was great and the Doomsday IPR was awesome read more

See all

It was great once we finally received our food, but the service was beyond disappointing. After waiting 1 hour and 10 minutes (and 4 drink refills), our meals finally arrived. While the waitress was not entirely at fault, she didn't handle the situation well. Instead of being honest, she repeatedly told us "soon." It was clear she hadn't been properly trained, and unfortunately, we never saw a manager check in at any point. Come on we wre a $100 table and have spent 100's thru out the years. you can do better!! read more

Whenever we have out of town guests, we try to make it to Turoni's! The pizza is amazing and the staff is always friendly and attentive.

Everything is absolutely perfect here food service and ambiance Definitely our GO-TO anytime!! read more

My friend & I sat at the bar, bartender ws very nice & attentive we split the Mediterranean salad & cheesy garlic bread it ws very good , will definitely go back read more

I've been to both Turoni's in Evansville and both are equally worthy of praise as they serve incredible food and drink. The pizza here is something special and is if it's own unique style - I've never had anything quite like it before elsewhere. There isn't much for me to do in Evansville, but whenever I visit, a stop at Turoni's for pizza and a cold draft of beer is always a must. On this particular occasion I had the "House Special" which is made up of: "Homemade pizza sauce, italian sausage, pepperoni, onion, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, pepperoncinis & tomatoes". The flavor is great. If you come to Evansville and don't stop at Turoni's, you are missing something special! read more

Visiting Evansville after 30 years away, Hubby wanted to go back to one of his favorite college hang out spots. We had the spicy chicken sausage Stromboli sandwich. I loved it - it had just the right amount of kick to the sausage that made my taste buds stand up and say, hey that's no regular Italian sausage. It has a home style pizzeria feel. I really liked hanging there with the man while he told me stories of college. (heart eyes) read more

Turoni's Forget-Me-Not Inn - Menu cover - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

I have been coming to this place since it was still the Forget-Me-Not-Inn in the 70's. This has always been a great bar and when they became part of Turoni's and their pizza and sandwiches it became even better. The place has both a bar area and a family room to eat. They do enforce the over 21 in the bar because a family came in with a newborn to meet some folks and they had to leave the bar area. My wife and I always split a spinach salad. One salad can easily feed two people. The homemade bacon dressing is very good and goes well with the spinach, eggs, and red onion. We split a small pizza that was plenty with the big salad. They have their own beer, craft beer and a full bar. This is a great casual dining experience. read more

I've always loved Turoni's. I live in Louisville, but my grandparents live here. Whenever we visit, we always go to Turoni's! The pizza is some of the best ultra thin crust I've had as it's cracker thin and is always perfectly browned! The toppings are always phenomenal, and the Supreme is absolutely excellent. Their appetizers are also great especially their garlic bread! The beers are just the icing on the cake! They have their own brewery and their stuff never disappoints! I especially love their stouts and seasonal offerings! Service is always on point! read more

Turoni's is one of those community pizza places that has been around forever. They have been making pizza for over three decades, and once you walk in, it totally has that feel. Although built for families - nice big tables, heavy wooden chairs, and large family sized booths - it's dimly lit, and generations of local sports and community memorabilia adorn the walls. The food is good - pizza, sandwiches, and soups. On this visit, I had the chili. Thick and rich, with just a kick of the spicy hot stuff on the end. This was a great appetizer for my favorite - the loaded strom. I added tons of cheese, mushrooms, cheese, peperoncinis, cheese, onions, cheese, and cheeeeeeese. Now what makes this place special is it doubles as a brewery. While they have some nice house selections, I have an affinity for Rudolph's Revenge, a nice red Belgian strong ale; it achieves lots of complexity with its coriander, Belgian candi-sugar, and malted barley flavors. It comes in a smaller portion, due to its 10 ABV, but with a larger price tag. It is worth the extra cost - I usually end up leaving with a growler of the red stuff. The wait staff is nice and attentive, but you definitely want to beat the lunch and dinner crowds. Since it is family-oriented, I typically avoid dining there at dinner time or after a local sporting event, to avoid all the children; during those hours, this place is chocked full of the rascally little Devil's sprog, wall-to-wall. read more

See all

I grew up eating turonis, it was the only pizza we ordered. Known for its thin crust pizza, my family would order it when we came back and friends would suggest it when I was back in town. Last time I had a veggie personal pizza. It came with peppercinis even! read more

Turoni's Forget-Me-Not Inn - Veggie House Special - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

I've been eating this pizza since I came out of the womb. If you're looking for a starter, my go to is the garlic cheez toast! Dunk that cheesy goodness into some pizza sauce and NOM, you've got the perfect start to your pizza adventure. Now onto the pizza. I'm a sucker for the Turoni's House Special loaded with Italian sausage, pepperoni, onion, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, pepperoncini's & tomatoes. Their pizza's are served on-a some thin-a crust-a. It's delish! Don't forget to check out their beer menu because HEYO they brew their own beer! read more

Never been here before. On business from St. Louis. Sat at the bar. Great woodwork and greeted nicely. Asked for a double and the bartender Rob F. made sure I knew how much it would cost me. Totally impressed. Aniya, the bar back, waiting to get her license to tend. she's a hard worker and will be great. i like a crispy pizza crust and Rob told me how to order. came out perfectly if business brings me back, I'll be back. read more

I loved the garlic cheese toast! Nice cold beer and glasses. Our server was friendly. It was a little chilly, so bring a jacket if you think you need it. It was also was a little dark inside. Pizza was good as well. The cookies weren't as good as we remembered. I don't think I'll get those again. They were (below) average on the cookies. Other than that, I'll be back! read more

Turoni's Forget-Me-Not Inn - Garlic cheese toast - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Turoni's is a brewpub pizzeria offering a handful of homemade brews and speciality pizzas (See menu above). The beers being mostly of the IPA or red type. They do have a honey blonde which is a little too sweet in my humble opinion. For an appetizer, I tried their bruschetta. If you are expecting traditional Italian, skip it. It's more of a garlic bread creation with a melted blend of cheeses over red onions and tomatoes. Not very Italian at all. I also decided to try a small Vinny's Pepper Planet Pizza consisting of a variety of different pepper species, mushrooms, bacon bits, ham, and a blend of cheeses all spread over a Chicago thin style crust. Again, not very Italian, but it was quite tasty. In closing, I'll say this: Italian, it certainly isn't. Tasty it certainly is. The great and friendly service was very much welcomed. Give it a shot. read more

Turoni's Forget-Me-Not Inn - The not-so-Italian bruschetta. (Properly pronounced, brew-sketta and NOT, brew-shetta.) - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

Good food, high priced but take the family a few times each year. Fast service.......

Turoni's has the BEST pizza I have ever had - thin crust, perfect sauce, and generous toppings - reasonably priced and excellent quality - Ask for a small house special pizza with a flight of their home-made brews read more

Turoni's Forget-Me-Not Inn - Turoni's small house special pizza with a flight of their home-made brews - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

THE BEST PIZZA ON PLANET EARTH. Pizza is always quality when eating in at Turoni's. Highly recommend the Pepper Planet pizza. Beer is always ice cold and served in a frosted mug/pitcher. Definitely one of the better pizza places I have been to and will consistently visit. read more

Turoni's Forget-Me-Not Inn - Unreal pizza and coldest house brews on Earth. - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

BEST pizza and beer within a 50 mile radius!! And not only that, the atmosphere of this place is not only hoppin' but reminds you of one of the good ole pizza parlors with the dark wood and feel of the place. I love everything about this restaurant!! We've been here a couple of times but this last time we were really able to experience it. The service was excellent and we were seated almost immediately, much to our surprise, since the place was packed (and always is). Note: it's usually the larger parties waiting, so don't let the lines fool you...if it's just 2 or 3 of you, make sure you check before driving away. We ended up ordering cheesy breadsticks, which I abstained from but the 12 year old son gobbled down faster than I could return from a bathroom visit, as well as a 1/2 meatball and 1/2 house thin crust pizza. HOLY MOLY I was in pizza heaven!! Both were good but the meatball was exceptional and it was such a wonderful surprise to get anything but cardboard for pizza crust for once!!! PERFECTION!!! Our server was great with my bi-polar beer choices...ended up bringing me several samples before I chose. The beer is always good especially since they brew it themselves...I'm SO sick of the normal Busch/Bud Light options!! Microbrew heaven here. The topper for us was the magician that came around...yea, these guys can be over-the-top annoying sometimes, but he put a huge smile on my son's face and put us all in awe! Great addition. Know before you go: Two entrances. One is the family side and one is the over 21 bar/restaurant side. Both croweded. read more

Turoni's Forget-Me-Not Inn - 1/2 meatball, 1/2 house special - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

I was going to give them a three star but the server who just brought me my pizza was very rude. I ordered a spinach salad and asked for a container to take half home since the waitress said it was huge, like a meal in itself. Well I am attaching a picture of this meal in itself. It barely had a layer of spinach and it had not had the long stems pulled off. There was barely any egg . The egg was chopped really fine and may have been a tablespoon full. Could not find much bacon maybe 2 tsps. And well I am not sure if it even had mushroom slices. Needless to say it was NOT a meal in itself. When the person from the kitchen brought my pizza I started to tell her that I wanted to have the spinach salad taken off my bill because and she grabbed it and started off. Did not bother to listen to my explanation. It was not worth 10 dollars. I just asked my waitress who was awesome who the person was that brought my pizza. It was the manager Sharon. Wow hope the owner realizes his manager is rude to customers. Great way to lose customers. I live out of town but always get Turonis pizza each month I visit but won't be back at this one ever. Main street Turonis or Newburgh will be my choice. read more

Turoni's Forget-Me-Not Inn - All the stems I had to pull off - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

Every year at a minimum we make a trek from North Carolina to Kansas to visit my family. Most often over Christmas but also sometimes in the summer. We discovered this place (and its sister location) because my kids are picky as heck and 'pizza' is an easy win. Not wanting to do the usual chain place as most are delivery only these days we looked up pizza in the phone book and found this place. Since about 2006 we now make this part of the tradition of the drive to Kansas. I'm a big fan of pizza done right or done uniquely, and Turoni's has a unique style. They have an extremely thin crust. Some would say 'cracker' except it's not dried out like a cracker. It's crisp and thin, but the center retains a bit of chewiness that I like a lot. They have several specialty pizzas and we tend to go with the 'all meat' one for my wife and I while the kids do their traditional half cheese/half pepperoni. We've been to both locations now, usually we went to the other one but I got turned around and found this one first so we tried it. This one has more room/parking than the other location but the food was just as good. read more

Whenever I'm in Evansville, I always make it a point to hit Turoni's. It's a real gem of a joint in a city that is pretty devoid of good, locally-owned restaurants. The menu is limited to a vast array of pizzas and a few sandwiches, which is a good thing. They have obviously focused their efforts in creating a great pizza. As an added bonus, everything is very inexpensive. The building itself is also pretty cool. It's very dark and woody inside and there's a decent sized patio facing Weinbach that isn't too bad. read more

Not even sure if this place is open an longer - this review was started in 2012, I am just trying to catch up on my reviews from out of state - I had the 9"turonis house special pizza... Cracker type crust, fresh toppings, nice servers but if you are from anywhere near the North East you might want to pass read more

Dont go to this location Holy Terrible service! how could how could you let somebody sit in that line. They have this nutso drivethru you cant get out of and takes Forever... literally add an additional 20-25 min. No take out offered. Unfortunately take out or delivery is out if you have the time, pizza is good inside read more

First time at this location in probably 30 years, and not even sure if it was turonis yet at that time . I have just ordered, and the first thing i got was water and the waitress went right up to the bar and grabbed a glass (plastic) and jammed it down into the ice bin. Isnt that like super unsanitary? Other than that, this place is super cute and clean as far as i can tell. The waitress is saying to another customer that the newburgh and main st locations have switched to a brick oven style oven and this location still uses a pizza pan. She is saying the locations have many different things and she doesnt know why they are different. I love the food at the main street location so in about 30 min i will rate this locations pizza. .... So, i like the crust here better than main st. But the top has less flavor. I still like the pizza alot. Id definetly come here again. read more

Turoni's Forget-Me-Not Inn - Green pepper and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

The go to place for pizza in Evansville. Great beer choices also. They have seasonal rotational beers that are worth a try.

Ordered a veggie pizza and all it is...is a house special without meat. The price isn't even lower! I'll be getting pizza elsewhere for sure! read more

Hadn't been here in 20+ years (back when I was a student at UE), toured the university today with our oldest and dropped by an old favorite ....... and it's every bit as good as I had remembered. Cracker thin and crispy crust. Perfect sauce. The pictures on the walls and the seating hasn't changed, and that's just perfect. We were there for lunch, so no beer for us, but looked like a nice selection some of which are their own. An Evansville landmark that's not to be missed. read more

My parents and I are from the Evansville area and I'm currently a Milwaukee transplant. I came in town to celebrate my birthday and IMMEDIATELY requested we drive to Turoni's for lunch! It has been one of my favorite places for 20 years and things have never been better! We were one of the first people in the door, sat in the bar area, and our server took our order sooooo quickly! The wings and breadsticks were phenomenal and the pizza was hot and delicious. Server was the best I've had in YEARS at any concept. She was was courteous, quick, and very pleasant throughout the whole visit! Turoni's, thank you for making the start of my visit here in Evansville one of the best ever! Happy birthday to ME! read more