It's been years since I've been to a Turonis and never this one in Newburgh. We decided to have lunch there recently. We started out with Garlic Cheez Toast - lots of cheese and crispy bread. Yummy. Then we each had a 9-inch pizza. I built my own with beef, mild pepper rings, spinach and mushrooms. I love the thin crust and it was crispy all over - no soggy crust here. I really couldn't taste the spinach or the sauce but it was good. I looked at the menu later and there is a 7-inch lunch pizza which I would have liked to have since this 9-inch was too much for me. I wish the staff would have mentioned that to us. Next time! It also was really dark in the restaurant. We had a hard time reading the menu. But I'm sure we'll be back. read more

Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery - Garlic Cheez Toast - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

See all

I am in town for work and sat in the bar area. I had the Bearded Bulldog American IPA and the 9" Lots a Meat pizza. The pizza came out hot and the crust had a slight crunch to it, which was great. Pizza had a good flavor with plenty of meat. The service was very good. The bar area is 21 and over so it was couples in the booths/seating area and a few guys at the bar top. Cool decorations and lighting. I have been here a few times and will be back on my next visit. read more

See all

I grew up in town, but never actually ate here until I had long since moved away. We stopped by on a weekend afternoon, so it wasn't super busy. Good service, kept our drinks filled, didn't have to wait long for food. Interesting interior, seemed like a "we found it at a yard sale" vibe for the wall art. The food was fine - mostly it's good to have a non chain option in the area. read more

Turoni's pizza hit the spot! My party of four ordered the house special which was overloaded with toppings and cheese. The waitress was courteous and attentive. Our order came out promptly and piping hot. The only flaw that stood out and that many family restaurants have difficulty to rectify is the sticky menus. read more

Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery - We placed an order to go. - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

See all

My God! We paid $30 for a medium 12" pizza. It would have been more if we used our debit card. Pizza was great but way too expensive.

Never disappointed !! 5 worth our drive to Newburgh for Our favorite Pizza ......House Special

Great food, great service, great atmosphere. I like the design of the restaurant as well, the service is phenomenal. Pizza is great, epically with the cheese sauce, best cheese sauce I've ever tasted. Highly recommend Turoni's. read more

I prefer to have dinner in the bar area. Their amber ale is really GOOD!! We had the mozzarella sticks to start, I had the Lots-A-Meat pizza and my daughter had the stromboli. The stromboli is in a sandwich form and not rolled like traditional stromboli. Just a fun tidbit. Overall, very good. read more

I may look like a troller but in all seriousness, I take hour-long flights from across America just to try your pizza! bread sticks perfect! pizza and the pizza is a beacon of hope shining bright in the vast ocean of pizza restaurants a hidden gem a masterpiece service is wonderful all the employees are super nice the restaurant itself has a wonderful layout what all restaurants should be the seating Is like a 5 star plane trip comfy minimum gum under the tables! 5 stars I would commit atrocities for this pizza! read more

Turoni's is the best pizza in Evansville, hands down! Try any location and you won't be disappointed! We love it and frequent often when we are in town. This location is on the outskirts of Evansville in a wonderful little town known as Newburgh. We have family there and love to meet up for food and drinks. Turoni's has a full bar area where you can seat yourself if everyone in your party is over 21. If not, they will get you seated quickly in the other side of the restaurant. Service is always fast and friendly. The food is always delicious. We had the special without olives and tomatoes, cheese bread with pizza sauce, and jalapeño poppers with ranch this visit. We also had beer, wine, and martinis at our table and all was great! read more

Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery - Turonis House Special Pizza (no olive or tomato) - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Up charge for removing pepperoni and bacon and replacing with only sausage. Lost my business for life. Also a good sign it's probably premade. In hindsight the pizza gods were looking out for me. read more

Great selection of pizza with locally brewed beverages and apps to go with your pizza. The turoni beer selections are above the best in town. Can't go wrong with Thunderbolt red. Pizza with vegi toppings are amazing read more

We came here on a recommendation. The atmosphere/ambiance had cool vibes The pizzas were very pricey and many of the appetizers charge you 1.83 for any sauce. Service was extremely SLOW and our waitress was busy cleaning tables and getting ready to close her duties for the night. Mind you, it was 2 hours before closing time. For the entire 1.5 hrs we were there we hardly saw her. Service sucked! Maybe don't spend your time cleaning and actually taking care of customers! Pizza was way overpriced and didn't have much flavor or spice. I was really disappointed. My frozen cauliflower crust biggie pizza at home was better! I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND! Our bill was $90 for two adults and two children. Pizza and appetizer!! read more

Service was marginal at best. Server seemed to be preoccupied. I had to get up to ask for a drink and had trouble getting our check in a timely fashion. Cheesy bread appetizer was just cheese barely melted on bread. It should have been toasted. No place on the tables for the pizzas for our large group. Pizza was just warm. Beer selection is limited to their house brews. Only seem like to be interested in profits. read more

Best Pizza in Evansville Metro. Classic cracker style crust, great sauce. The Buffalo Chicken pizza is also excellent, Get the Brownies for dessert. read more

We just returned from eating lunch today at the Newburgh restaurant. We ordered a meat pizza, with mushrooms and onions on half for my wife. All they have is thin crust, I saw no option for pan or hand tossed. $43, water to drink, barely any leftovers. It did taste good, but nowhere near $43 worth of good. Will probably never return. read more

The best pizza in Evansville. First time at the Newburgh location and it was just as good as the others. Service was quick and attentive. I'll definitely be back. read more

Best Pizza in Evansville , top 3 in Indiana. High quality ingredients cooked to perfection read more

Visited the Newburgh location and my oh my!!! I'm struggling finding a positive thing to review. We visited on a Thursday at 3pm. There were only 3 tables seated in addition to ours. We were greeted by a waitress who said sit anywhere and she walked off. We ordered fairly quickly. A large house pizza, meatballs and bruschetta. The waitress dropped (literally) our food in the table. Never said a word. Food was ice cold. Pizza was placed directly on the table. No pan underneath. (See pic). Finally flagged our waitress down and asked if the food could be warmed up. 29 minutes later the meatballs returned - hot but very bland. No apologies. No refills of drinks. Turoni's may be considered the best in Evansville, however it's the worst in Newburgh. I'd visit the two Evansville locations before this one ever again. read more

Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

See all

Turoni's is always a hometown favorite of mine, service is always good, the pizza is good and I love the environment!!

Came home for Christmas from San Diego, CA, and I was looking forward to getting Turonis. My Grandmother worked at the Forget me not in Evansville and I grew up on Turonis pizza. Chloe in Newburgh made sure I wasn't disappointed with my visit. The pizza was fresh and delicious. Thank you Chloe! read more

Near garbage level quality, lying managers and owners who should be ashamed of their product No remake, no refund, have to spend more money to get a coupon is the best offer, so spend more money and get ripped off more ..sure crooked?. Place is ran by idiots read more

I really enjoy this Turoni's location. My meals are always hot and fresh. Turoni's has some of the best pizzas in this area! My favorite is either the Turoni's House Special or Vinny's Pepper Planet. read more

See all

This place is a complete joke. When we first walk in we are created by two young women which one was a server and one was what I can assume is the hostess. We were told there was a 15 minute wait but there were open tables. We were told we could sit in the bar though. My 96 year old grandma did not want to sit in the bar. After watching the server and hostess talk about my family in front of us for five minutes they chose to seat us two tables back. My mother who is recovering and we are trying to help her by bringing a bottle of alcohol free wine to which we were told that we can not bring anything into the restaurant at all. The serve said he would go ask his manager only for the manager to come and ask us if we had a question. I understand if it was an alcoholic beverage but the "manager" said it could not even be water. Then to make matters worse our serve came by the table to ask my mother how she was doing on her merlot. I had already told the waiter she was an alcoholic that we had brought her alcohol free wine. This location I am not from Newburgh or even Evansville but I can tell you that I will not be coming back and will do everything to refer anyone to dominos over this place. This place is operated by middle aged rejects who do not know customer service. This place has no morals or values all for a buck with no realization that this community is what keeps them e read more

Bad experience on carry out. First person on phone was curt/ rude. Second order was incorrect. Ordered house special and got a pepperoni. Charged for house special Food quality is not like it used to be. Won't be back. Too many other places that have good service and food. read more

Excellent place!! The pizza was fantastic, the staff were great. He suggested one of their own IPA's and my husband loved it!! Probably the best pizza in our opinion. read more

Tried this for first time last week. Pizza had practically no sauce or cheese. Called and complained. Was told "we have teenagers working here and that is just the way it is. Please try us again." Our response to trying again is NO THANKS. I'll go to Pizza king. read more

Celebrated a milestone birthday on 2/4/23 with around 30 guests. Planned ahead and had a room to ourselves. Our server Ricky was flipping amazing, personable, accurate and accommodating. Two thumbs up Everyone had an amazing time. Pizza and appetizers were amazing! read more

We live in Louisville, and we always ensure we go to Turoni's every time we visit the Evansville are as it's always delicious, and this location is no exception. Service was good and courteous, hand crafted beer was delicious, and the pizza and garlic toast were phenomenal. What more can you want than great beer and great pizza? read more

See all

We frequently visit the Turoni's in Newburgh. Went there for my bday dinner. Kudos to the staff working in the bar they loaded that pizza up with all the toppings and I got a candle on it they treat you like family there. There is no other pizza place in town I would rather go... read more

Bussin lol. My dad and I devour Turonis at any given opportunity. All appetizers are delicious, and I'm personally on a quest to eat everything on the menu. Great vegetarian options, along with an incredibly friendly staff. read more

Yummy pizza just wish they would bring back the veggie dream! They use to be the only place we would go for pizza when they had Veggie Dream

Excellent pizza and service. If you like thin crust pizza, the house special is their version of a supreme. I highly recommend.

We went to Turoni's on the advice of some locals. They said that Turoni's was the best pizza in town. Service was about average, and the restaurant decor was old-school sports memorabilia. I ordered a medium pizza for myself which was a big mistake. This pizza was massive. I only finished about half, and had to box the rest. The specialty pizza I ordered had quite a bit of toppings on it and whereas the outside pieces had a nice crispy texture, the middle pieces were a little soggy. I also didn't care for their checkerboard cut of the pizza... I would have preferred a traditional pie-cut (it just seems more natural). Next time I try this place, I will order a pizza with less toppings and probably get a more crisp and consistent crust. read more

Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

It was pretty pricey for okay pizza. The pizza wasn't great enough for me to want to come back, especially for the price.

Really happy that Turoni's built a location in Newburgh! Nice location near the main highway, but far enough away that it's not right on top of the traffic. It's always pretty busy when we drive by, but we usually just order takeout and pick it up. They have a great drive-up window where you can just pick up your order. Pizza is always great - thin crust and delicious! My wife isn't too adventurous with her toppings, so I haven't tried too much - but we've enjoyed everything so far! read more

See all

We come here alot, but the last 2 times we have had pizza the outer crust was burnt not the pizza that you normally get here.

If you want pizza go to Turoni's. They have a large and extensive menu that can cater to many. They even also Gluten free ! Everyone claims they have the best. For me Turoni's is the best. They offer a fun and casual family friendly environment. The staff was helpful and made accommodations for our large work group. Service was quick and pizzas were delish! read more

See all

we were at Turoni's in Newburgh Friday night order was taken in a timely manor.This is where our experience goes bad after waiting for about 50 min. We watch as our pizza is delivered to the table behind us a few min later they came and picked up the pizza took it to the kitchen,a few more minutes go by and here comes our pizza.We asked the waitress if it was the pizza just taken from the table behind us, she replied that yes it was but it was okay they did not touch it!!!!!! We left. Could not believe they thought it would be ok to eat food that was taken to the wrong table this is not okay I wonder just how many times this actually happens? Will not be going back read more

We had a party of 6 and we had a pretty long wait for a table to open up. The wait staff was very friendly and attentative. We ordered the breadsticks and jalapeno poppers as appetizers and they were delicious, especially the poppers. Really good. The crust on their pizza here is thin and crispy. I ordered pepperoni on half and Italian sausage and mushroom on the other half, extra cheese. The sausage I didn't really care for. The pepperoni was good. Alittle pricey. Good pizza. read more