We grabbed a couple pizzas and garlic knots to bring back to our little shore house while on…read morevacation and this place was terrific. Heidi took care of me when I went in to grab the order and she did terrific and was fast, friendly and efficient. The buffalo chicken pizza was amazing, I subbed out blue cheese for ranch and added pepperoncinis and it was REALLY good. My wife opted for a margherita pizza and it was terrific as well, the pesto drizzle added a little pop of flavor. It wouldn't be a trip to NJ without grabbing a piece of plain pie so we also added a last minute slice they warmed up for us and it was my wife's fave. The crust is amazing! The garlic knots were just ok, not a show stopper but I think that's because everything else was so amazing.

Phone ordered a Philly cheese steak sicilian pizza, told me 30 mins. Jumped in car and drove over…read moreto pick it up. Place was empty. Talked to nasty counter person and after hitting a gazillion buttons on a screen I couldnt see, and asking me 3 times what I ordered was unable to find my order. Why would you have a front of house person like that? Good job! You know where I wont be going again. You may want to keep your employees checked.

10/10 experience! Everyone was incredibly kind and even took the time to answer our questions about…read morestreet parking with the storm coming in. You can tell this place is run by people who genuinely care AND the pizza was fantastic. We ordered the Meat Lovers pizza slices (and honestly would've gone for a whole pizza if we were hungrier). I loved the wonderfully thin, crispy crust and how the toppings were packed with flavor. The restaurant itself is cozy, decorated with Cape May artwork, and has a charming diner-style vibe that feels both local and welcoming. Would recommend to anyone visiting!

Awesome!!!!! I expected average boardwalk pizza.... What a got was some really well made pizza;…read moregreat crispy crust, fresh ingredients on the "works" pizza (see picture) and high quality cheese. My guess is grande cheese, the best of the best .if it's not, I'd be shocked. Anyway, highly recommend!!! ‼

Great pizza! Friendly and helpful staff. Very accommodating. They were nice enough to make us a…read morecouple pies very close to closing, saving the day for my hungry family. Thank you!

9/20/2026. I took a chance on Mangia after reading some reviews. I was on a mission to feed 6…read moreadults and two hungry young ladies. Although I stay in Stone Harbor- I do not enjoy the substandard food and the insanely high prices. Wildwood and Rio Grande are way better options for me. I called at around 3:55 pm on Saturday and the phone was promptly answered- I ordered a cheese pizza, sausage pizza, and a steak Stromboli. I was quoted 25-30 minutes and it's around an 18 minute drive. Easy peasy drive down the parkway exit 4b then a right at the very first light. Nice generous parking lot with awesome stores to boot!! I also spotted ARC Thrift too. Definitely a place I may investigate further as the week goes by. When I arrived my order was promptly ready and the young man at the cash register offered me paper plates after I paid. My order was around 66$. Very reasonable. The steak Stromboli was loaded with steak- absolutely delicious! The mozzarella they used in it was fantastic too! The pizza was fantastic made with high quality ingredients and a generous amount of cheese. I really liked how the restaurant punched a hole in the top of the Stromboli box with a very generous cup of sauce- none of these tiny one ounce stingy ramekins I get elsewhere. I would definitely go back and try one of their dinners. The restaurant was cozy and nicely laid out. They had a case of desserts that looked great too. Definitely try this place if you are fed up with crazy prices, if you are disgusted fighting for parking, paying for parking or tired of the games the in town ritzy shore places play. This is the REAL DEAL!!! I was very thankful I tried this place. ********One very good important thing I forgot to mention*********** the young man at the register offered to assist me to my car. I declined, but he walked me to the door, held the door for me and personally thanked me. THAT, my friends, is STELLAR customer service which is nearly nonexistent today.

Ordered seafood, pasta, pizza + apps ALL were great!…read more This has become one of our go to who places in the are

Sicilian pizza with extra cheese and peperoni $35!! Most I ever paid in my life…read more Said pizza was $25 and topping were $5 each.

I saw this place opened up a few months back and all my friends kept telling me I had to try it so…read moreI figured I would give it a try. I'm glad I did. It's awesome. I go there at least 2-3 times a week now. They have really good wings cooked fresh. They also have daily specials with food that you generally don't get in a pizza shop. I dined in many 5 star restaurants when I lived in New York and some of the daily specials are on par with those expect at a cheap price. Their pizza is also very good and you can't beat it when you catch their $5.99 large 1 topping pie. I highly recommend!

Pizza is outstanding always fresh and hot. Excellent service. Staff very friendly and nice. Been…read morecoming for years best ever.

Let tell you something if you're looking for a the greatest pizza in my opinion around the Jersey…read moreShore I might even say the Tri State area. Ever Pizza I have have had is Fn awesome my fav

A BBQ pizza joint? We had to check it out. We ordered take out and it was ready when they said it…read morewould be. We got a pizza and some BBQ. Pizza was just OK. Sauce was not very flavorful and crust was little too thick for my liking. We also order a BBQ pulled pork platter. The pork was tender and had some flavor but not covered in sauce. The baked beans were dry - like they had sat out all day. The creamed corn was also dry and tasted canned. The corn bread was tender and had a flavor of jalapeños (maybe) but wasn't spicy. We ordered late afternoon during the week so maybe things would be better/fresher tasting during a peak time.

My family and I visit Cape May, NJ annually and always want to try a new place. Looked online for…read moreanything local and found a bbq spot which we were very excited for. All I can say is we were extremely disappointed with the outcome. The photos from online are clearly not the same as what you would get.

I've stopped here during work and a great deal for a slice and a drink…read more Can add toppings to a regular slice. It's the perfect portion for a lunch on the go where I'm not starving all day until dinner. It's small and locally run so have a little patience if you hit it during the lunch rush. He takes phone orders to have it ready if you need. Place is a bit small so be prepared to take it to go. Great place to grab a slice or a whole pie and take it out to the beach at the end of Sunset for a little car side picnic and watch the sunset.

Great unpretentious pizza place in West Cape May on the way to Cape May point. They offer slices…read morethat are reasonably priced. Quality, tasty pizza.

I absolutely love this gem of a place! The food is incredible. I've never had focaccia that good…read morebefore, and I wish I could eat it every day. Friendly quick service, and a kinda dark industrial vibe to the place

My wife and I visited The Boiler Room. We had visited a few times in the past also. Always have…read moregreat food (especially that fireside pizza!!). And great staff & service. We were having a few beers and had the best bartender. A shout out to Zach. He was professional, so friendly and gave us superb service. He made our visit there so enjoyable. We look forward to visiting again. Hope to see you then Zach. There was another staff member there (forgot his name) and we met the manager also. All so great to talk to. All professional. Also, the atmosphere is so nice there also. Kudos to Congress Hall / Boiler Room on the staff they hire. Thank you for such a great time!!

Classic cheese pizza, nice crispy crust, good cheese to sauce ratio and great lunch special…read morepricing. $5.99 gets you two cheese slices & a can of soda or bottled water. I also ordered a side of pizza sauce, which was also good. A friendly staff, plenty of inside seating and parking in the lot. This is a definite stop if you are on the way in/out of the Cape May, NJ Ferry terminal area.

Just wanted a Sicilian extra cheese pepperoni and received a flat extremely over priced "thick…read morecrust" pizza at a whopping $31!! Please look at the pics and tell me that is a Sicilian. Seriously debating to get visa involved.