I wanted to like this but couldn't. At the moment I walked in the door, I was met by a surly woman…read moreat the counter. It must have been a bad day for her. She was just gruff and mean. The place looks cute inside. I saw a lot of food that probably was good but I decided to have their specialty, the pasty. I've had them at many places and have enjoyed them. This is by far the worst one I've ever had in my life. Everything about it was bad. I would give this place another try but I'd never order that again. And I hope I would never see that woman again. Other people in the place were nice and the other food did look good. And as I said, It's a cute place, old fashioned.

We enjoyed our stop at Red Rooster. We started with coffees, the strawberry-rhubarb pie (for my…read morewife), and the saffron bread, which was kind of a soda bread but really loaded with saffron - great! Then we got figgyhobbin, pecan pie, and pasties to go. The pasties were bland but tastier than Sheboygan-style, and their robust crust is truly indestructible, great for microwave re-heating. We had a nice repartee with the counter lady.

Jim does a great job. Food is fixed your way. He is always pleasant, knowledgeable about what's…read morehappening in and around town.

Terrible service, slow taking orders, sl0w receiving food. People who came after got food before usread more

This diner is the real deal! Hearty breakfast, fantastic pies, and a friendly atmosphere…read more Their cinnamon rolls are huge and delicious. Don't forget to ask for their homemade strawberry rhubarb jam for your toast!

Take the eggs Benedict off the menu. That is not eggs Benedict!…read moreCheese wiz is not a substitute for hollandaise sauce.

My family loves diners. We dont know why we haven't tried this place sooner. It is quaint and…read morerustic, almost kitchy. But that is the charm of this place. You gotta love the tufted leather 'office' chairs at the tables (on wheels.) Although small, there seems to be a good turnover; we didn't have to wait. Our server was prompt, courteous, and friendly. In true diner fashion, there's a lot to choose from on the menu. We went for the breakfast menu. The French toast was fluffy with a tasty egg coating with hints of cinnamon and sugar. The hashbrowns were the way I like them: crunchy on the outside with soft potato warmth on the inside. And they weren't jazzed up with peppers or onions. Just pure hash. My salmon Benedict had eggs poached with soft white and a perfect runny yolk. Complemented niicely with salmon and creamy avocados. The salmon was a bit overcooked; I was expecting lox, but that's my bad. The jalapeños were too hot for me, I had to remove most of them. Regardless, it was still a satisfying dish. My daughter's banana-Nutella crepe was wonderful. The crepes were made just right, thin but still a bit fluffy, not paper-like or like a tortilla. It was loaded with warm, lightly cooked banana and covered with plenty of Nutella and, of course, whipped cream. I was jealous.of her dish. Overall, we really liked this place for brunch. The food is well prepared do they give you plenty of it. And the staff was friendly and professional. Like MacArthur: I shall return!

Really cozy, classic, cute brunch place with kind staff. I felt bold and went for a lunch menu…read moreoption, and it was pretty solid. The bread was a bit disappointing, a bit soft and cheap. The rest was good, portion size not bad, and the fries were crunchy and great with ketchup and salt. Overall solid place and I wouldn't mind coming back again.

Great homemade pies, nice locally owned biz. Had the roast…read morebeef special and was very good and reasonably priced.

Susie and her staff offer a great place to eat at affordable prices…read more The quality of food is the best in the area. Her pies, desserts, and ice cream are a must, and we order to go for many of our family occasions. Water Street Market brings a nostalgic feeling, and you can't go wrong ordering anything on the menu Breakfast, Lunch, or Dinner. There aren't many places like this. Support a Small Local Business and stop by.

Very solid, had a nice meal here. My wife had breakfast and the hash browns were very good. I…read morereally enjoyed the fries, they were solidly above average. Burger was very basic, service was nice and friendly. Reasonable prices, overall a good experience.

This is not a pastie! Mostly potatoes and cut from a large pan, not individual. But liver and…read moreonions was good, as well as coffee and iced tea. Service acceptable. Do not go for Cornish pasties. ​

New owners since March 2026. We were greeted right when we walked in and was offered coffee…read more Friendly service to the max. The dining room was extremely clean and had a cute farm theme. We ordered crepes and a Philly beef sandwich. The crepes were tender and light. Next time I'd likely order three instead of two. The beef sandwich was OK, nothing special. We upgraded to cheese curds for only $2 and they were great! Friendly place to grab breakfast or a quick lunch.

I've been to Fink's many times over the last 10 years, and even with ownership changes, it remains…read morea top breakfast spot in Mount Horeb. The seating can be a bit cramped as it is a small place. The service is usually good, but there can be waits when they get swamped, which makes sense because I don't think I've ever seen more than a cook and one server in the place. If you want a good, greasy breakfast, this is the spot.

Came through from Milwaukee to galena and stopped for a great grilled cheese and creamy potato soup…read more Great customer service

Great place and Amazing soup along with cabana sandwidge. Best desserts on our road trip to…read moreNebraska.